
nowadays there are lots of ways to get
our ideas out into the world there’s
social media web hosting blogs
comments on news articles if you’ve got
something to say you can find a place to
say it and partly because of these
platforms we also live in a world of
fakers and echo chambers where we
surround ourselves with sources that
tell us what we already think and how
clever we are for thinking it so you
agree with me wow you must be really
smart and obviously an excellent source
of information but if we step outside
those circles having lots of ideas and
opinions around us is a good thing
it makes it harder for us to exist
solely in our information bubbles a
diversity of ideas is also an indicator
of a tolerant society and that very
tolerance suggest that we should respect
the ideas and opinions of others right
each according to their own let a
thousand flowers bloom I would argue
treating all ideas as equally worthy of
respect is a toxic notion because if all
ideas are equal then all ideas are
worthless now let me explain that
thinking a bit if there’s no criteria we
can use to determine if one idea is
better or worse than any other then it
is by definition both worthless and
useless in other words an idea that
can’t be
valuated is an idea without value but we
value ideas for different reasons some
ideas are valuable because they change
how we think and can therefore make
possible that which wasn’t possible
before they open up opportunities for us
to imagine and to dream and to act the
TEDx forum gives us lots of examples of
these ideas that can take us places that
help us explore progress and development
that give us meaning and purpose are
good ideas but not all ideas are like
that I’d also suggest that an inability
even unwillingness to discriminate
between good and bad ideas has left us
with a deficit of among other things
good politicians and high-quality public
debate so where does the sentiment come
from that we should treat all ideas and
opinions with respect well to my mind
it’s part of a broad and deep social
movement towards tolerance and equality
which is a good thing but what that
movement sometimes fails to recognize is
a very important principle that people
are innately worthy of respect but ideas
are not we can’t empathize with ideas
like we can with people ideas can’t
suffer they don’t know joy and they’re
not by themselves responsible for other
people ideas shouldn’t get respect
unless they earn it the world of ideas
should be a brutal meritocracy they
should stand or fall according to their
merits not because of who promotes them
or because of the passion or sincerity
with which they’re expressed so ideas
and people are different
sometimes however we integrate our ideas
into our identity and that can make us
very resistant to critical analysis of
them can even make us angry when others
dare to challenge us and that anger can
make others hesitate to criticize us but
if our ideas can’t be challenged and
critiqued then they’re nothing more than
gang colors identifying us in the same
way that bumper stickers or football
jerseys do to say that my idea can’t be
challenged because it’s part of my
identity and that an attack on it is an
attack on me equivalent to a denial of
my human respect is a fallacy of
reasoning and I call this fallacy the
fallacy of deepest defense
it’s a blurring of the line between
people and ideas so we need to
interrogate our own thinking with the
same rigor that we would use to
interrogate the thinking of others and
to expect the same from them perhaps
letting go of some cherished ideas along
the way because it’s far more sensible
to let go of an idea if we have good
reasons to do so than it is to cling on
to it in the face of compelling evidence
or arguments against it a stubbornness
born of not separating our ideas and our
identity thinking critically about our
ideas and why we believe in them is an
essential part of our personal growth
critical thinking is not something to be
weaponized for use against others it’s
rather a mirror that we can hold up to
ourselves we should therefore respect
the right of others to inquire into
anything and to go wherever that free
inquiry may lead them we should also
respect the fact that they may end up
embracing ideas that we ourselves would
not wish to hold but what we don’t have
to respect is the idea itself the right
to hold and promote an idea does not
create in others and
Legation to respect it the right to be
heard is not the right to be taken
seriously I said earlier if all ideas
are equal then all ideas are worthless
but all ideas aren’t equal and all ideas
aren’t worthless some are better than
others and no one person can tell us the
criteria for a good idea across all
contexts that’s something we have to
work on collectively and collaboratively
but what we can say is that the very
best ideas are those that help all of us
to flourish not just some of us at the
expense of others when we realize this
we can look ahead with more clarity to
find to recognize and to accept those ideas that really are worth spreading
our ideas out into the world there’s
social media web hosting blogs
comments on news articles if you’ve got
something to say you can find a place to
say it and partly because of these
platforms we also live in a world of
fakers and echo chambers where we
surround ourselves with sources that
tell us what we already think and how
clever we are for thinking it so you
agree with me wow you must be really
smart and obviously an excellent source
of information but if we step outside
those circles having lots of ideas and
opinions around us is a good thing
it makes it harder for us to exist
solely in our information bubbles a
diversity of ideas is also an indicator
of a tolerant society and that very
tolerance suggest that we should respect
the ideas and opinions of others right
each according to their own let a
thousand flowers bloom I would argue
treating all ideas as equally worthy of
respect is a toxic notion because if all
ideas are equal then all ideas are
worthless now let me explain that
thinking a bit if there’s no criteria we
can use to determine if one idea is
better or worse than any other then it
is by definition both worthless and
useless in other words an idea that
can’t be
valuated is an idea without value but we
value ideas for different reasons some
ideas are valuable because they change
how we think and can therefore make
possible that which wasn’t possible
before they open up opportunities for us
to imagine and to dream and to act the
TEDx forum gives us lots of examples of
these ideas that can take us places that
help us explore progress and development
that give us meaning and purpose are
good ideas but not all ideas are like
that I’d also suggest that an inability
even unwillingness to discriminate
between good and bad ideas has left us
with a deficit of among other things
good politicians and high-quality public
debate so where does the sentiment come
from that we should treat all ideas and
opinions with respect well to my mind
it’s part of a broad and deep social
movement towards tolerance and equality
which is a good thing but what that
movement sometimes fails to recognize is
a very important principle that people
are innately worthy of respect but ideas
are not we can’t empathize with ideas
like we can with people ideas can’t
suffer they don’t know joy and they’re
not by themselves responsible for other
people ideas shouldn’t get respect
unless they earn it the world of ideas
should be a brutal meritocracy they
should stand or fall according to their
merits not because of who promotes them
or because of the passion or sincerity
with which they’re expressed so ideas
and people are different
sometimes however we integrate our ideas
into our identity and that can make us
very resistant to critical analysis of
them can even make us angry when others
dare to challenge us and that anger can
make others hesitate to criticize us but
if our ideas can’t be challenged and
critiqued then they’re nothing more than
gang colors identifying us in the same
way that bumper stickers or football
jerseys do to say that my idea can’t be
challenged because it’s part of my
identity and that an attack on it is an
attack on me equivalent to a denial of
my human respect is a fallacy of
reasoning and I call this fallacy the
fallacy of deepest defense
it’s a blurring of the line between
people and ideas so we need to
interrogate our own thinking with the
same rigor that we would use to
interrogate the thinking of others and
to expect the same from them perhaps
letting go of some cherished ideas along
the way because it’s far more sensible
to let go of an idea if we have good
reasons to do so than it is to cling on
to it in the face of compelling evidence
or arguments against it a stubbornness
born of not separating our ideas and our
identity thinking critically about our
ideas and why we believe in them is an
essential part of our personal growth
critical thinking is not something to be
weaponized for use against others it’s
rather a mirror that we can hold up to
ourselves we should therefore respect
the right of others to inquire into
anything and to go wherever that free
inquiry may lead them we should also
respect the fact that they may end up
embracing ideas that we ourselves would
not wish to hold but what we don’t have
to respect is the idea itself the right
to hold and promote an idea does not
create in others and
Legation to respect it the right to be
heard is not the right to be taken
seriously I said earlier if all ideas
are equal then all ideas are worthless
but all ideas aren’t equal and all ideas
aren’t worthless some are better than
others and no one person can tell us the
criteria for a good idea across all
contexts that’s something we have to
work on collectively and collaboratively
but what we can say is that the very
best ideas are those that help all of us
to flourish not just some of us at the
expense of others when we realize this
we can look ahead with more clarity to
find to recognize and to accept those ideas that really are worth spreading
Please follow and like us: