Press "Enter" to skip to content

Why we draw | James Prosek | TEDxYale


[Music]

drawing is one of the most powerful

tools of human expression it’s not only

an aid to help us think but perhaps the

most direct way of manifesting a thought

of getting something out of our heads

and onto a surface so that it can be

recorded about ten years ago

I began working on a book about how and

why we named an order nature about why

and how language has failed me the basic

thesis is that nature is an

interconnected and constantly changing

system but in order to communicate that

interconnected system through language

we have to language being possibly the

most powerful tool humans have ever

invented we have to take that holistic

system and chop it up and label the

pieces and soon the holistic world

becomes fragmented into a series of

units that fit into boxes and boundaries

are placed between ourselves and things

in nature it took me a while to realize

but it’s actually the failure of words

and language that helped bring richness

and purpose to my life

that helped spark the urge to be

creative to find a way to fill the

spaces in-between where words couldn’t

go and it was in part knowledge of an

older form of communication that I’d

been doing since childhood that brought

this inquiry about in my head a form of

communication that could be considered

almost a window into a more elemental

human self and that’s drawing I’d like

to start with this image it’s possibly

the most iconic image ever drawn by a

scientist if not the most important

it’s Darwin’s drawing the first drawing

he ever made of the evolutionary tree of

life he just returned from a five-year

trip around the world on the boat known

as the

egle and he sat down at his desk and he

was trying to synthesize his thoughts

about this big idea evolution that all

animals in all life on Earth was

descended from common ancestry on a

great evolutionary timeline it looks

kind of like a stick figure gone wrong

but it’s it’s actually such a simple but

such an important idea perhaps that

simplicity is what makes it so beautiful

it turned all ideas about why we are

here and how we got here on our heads

and he did it through a drawing he may

as well have said in a version of de

cartes I think therefore I am I think

therefore I draw if you can see he wrote

I think up there or I draw therefore I

think or I can’t think unless I draw or

maybe I draw therefore I am which I

think will be a theme of this talk going

forward the idea that the first time

humans make mark made marks consciously

was the first time that they became or

help them become sentient self-aware

animals I thought about calling this

talk why we draw but then I realized

that not everybody does draw although

most of us start drawing his children

and then stop and I’d like to explore

that a little bit later then I thought

maybe I would call it why I draw as

there’s nothing I’ve been doing longer

in my life and drawing I drew before I

could write my own name and before I

could form complete sentences but then I

what I really wanted to be about was

more about why I think we should draw

drawing as a tool for helping us develop

ideas for helping us internalize our

environments helping us slow down and

pay attention almost like a form of

meditation in this hyper technological

age that we live in to slow down to help

us observe our surroundings I grew up in

southwestern Connecticut not far from

here and I was introduced to nature

through my father

love of birds I began drawing birds as a

child copying the works of John James

Audubon and Louis Agassiz suertes and

Roger Tory Peterson so I was drawing

from nature already processed by other

individuals through through the through

their minds but then I also had access

to raw nature itself in this case a

magnolia Warbler that had flown into the

window of our home and died and my

father wasn’t afraid to pick it up and

put in my hand and you know that was a

very formative moment for me holding

this beautiful unfortunately dead thing

in my hand but it filled me with a sense

of wonder

this is an early drawing of a Warbler

soon after that my around the age of

nine my drawings morphed from birds into

fish when I fell in love with fishing

and in particular a beautiful fish of

cold water streams called the trout in

particular even more so the brook trout

which is the native trout of Connecticut

that has lived in our streams since the

last glaciation they’re some of the most

beautiful creatures in my opinion that

I’ve certainly ever seen and I wanted to

capture them through drawing because

that’s what I did my passion for trout

was so intense it’s hard for me to

describe it resulted in two books of

paintings of trout of North America and

Europe Asia North Africa I spent at

seven years traveling around the world

looking for native trout that was much

later but typically what I would do in

any spare moment was go out on the

stream near my home catch a fish make

sketches of the fish and usually take

photographs too because I like to let

the fish go alive and the colors fade

very quickly after you take the fish out

of the water so because I wanted to draw

them these were very good aides to me

for looking at the colors then I’d go

back to my home and I typically sit at

the desk in my bedroom I draw the

outline of the fish and graphite and

then start filling it in with

watercolors and at that point I realized

something strange started to happen I

again to have these almost visions like

lucid dreaming where I was reliving a

moment on the stream even though I

wasn’t there that somehow drawing had

had brought about this resurrection of a

very vivid memory I could feel the the

warmth of the Sun I could see the the

stream going by feel the or hear the

buzz of a fly by my face smell the

flowers in the air and I began to think

about why this happened because I also

would write about my experiences in my

journal since I was 11 years old I was

so intensely into fishing that on days I

didn’t go fishing I wrote no fishing

there were more days that I fished and

didn’t fish but in any case when I wrote

in my journal about the experiences the

same thing didn’t happen so it was

something unique to drawing and then

when I went back out on the stream I

felt like the experience of drawing the

trout had made me more efficient at

catching them a more efficient predator

so to speak even though I didn’t kill

the fish but that that somehow drawing

the trout had made it exist in my body

and my brain had integrated myself with

the environment in a way that was almost

kind of magical and then when I first

encountered these drawings of animals on

cave walls I don’t know in some

publications somewhere and read how old

they were and France and Spain at sites

like Glasgow and Cha they made they

think 40,000 years ago I felt like I had

some idea we have no idea why they were

made of course because the people have

been long dead many many people have

speculated but I felt like I had some

idea about why perhaps they were drawn

and why perhaps people still drew

because if I’d had this experience where

I was drawing the animal I was pursuing

and it had such a profound effect on me

and it made me a better observer of my

surroundings had helped hone my skills

of observation that maybe drawing was a

tool that

these people get to know their

surroundings better and then once they

made a drawing of the creature even if

you weren’t the person who made the

drawing it gave a a platform for other

people to communicate that thing when it

wasn’t even in the room think about how

powerful that is if you have a drawing

of a cow or something like these or

whatever kind of cow like creature they

they were made possibly extinct

creatures now if you have a drawing you

have a platform through which you can

communicate that thing a drawing in this

sense is almost like a word and and

because drawing predates written

language drawing is the ancient ancestor

of written language written language

came out of drawing and drawing possibly

even predates complex spoken language

then drawing may have been the first

word essentially the first way to

communicate it’s it’s like saying the

word cow if I say the word cow you can

all close your eyes and conjure up a cow

and your heads and that’s a pretty

pretty powerful thing it’s almost like

sorcery you can bring the animal into

the context of the room without it even

being there or some imaginary semblance

of it so I felt like you know the

drawing was this perhaps first most

powerful way of communication and then

that way maybe the writers of the Bible

had it wrong in the beginning wasn’t the

word I think in the context of human

evolution and the beginning was the

drawing I’ve seen some of these rock

drawings in person this is in Zimbabwe

people were very resourceful in how they

were made we were told that these were

made by using sometimes antelope blood

or semen or the urine as a binder of the

pigment the ochre pigments or the urine

of a ancestor of an elephant called the

hyrax but they’re extremely beautiful

these giraffe drawings in Zimbabwe this

is a drawing from Thermopolis Wyoming

where they used a rock to pack out the

drawing on the rock with another two

rocks and these are thought to be

thousands of years old

going to these sites and standing in

front of them has filled me with great

wonder like like you do standing in

front of a great work of art like a van

Gogh or a DaVinci because I believe that

that when you stand in front of a work

of art you are that the energy of the

person who made it is still sort of part

of that work and when you stand in front

of it even thousands of years later

you’re engaged in a kind of time machine

of the mind and this led me to think

about or to ask what were the first

marks that we made consciously as humans

and why and and I thought what we must

have definitely taken our cues from

nature perhaps what inspired us to draw

originally were the footprints of

animals in the snow like these Fox

prints in my backyard or the lines drawn

by blade of grass as the wind blows it

over a dune and the sand and Cape Cod or

maybe it was the afterimage of the Sun

when you gaze at that the Sun which you

shouldn’t do for too long ago burn your

eyeballs and then you close your eyes

and you have that beautiful after image

of the Sun on your eyes perhaps that

gave us some indication of you know

making a mark or maybe it was the power

of a reflection on a lake because we

don’t think about how amazing and unique

an idea that is or a thing that nature

does it takes a three-dimensional world

and it converts it to a two-dimensional

surface for you which is what artists

try to do they take they take the

three-dimensional world and they convert

it to a two-dimensional surface whether

it’s a piece of paper or canvas or a

piece of rock another reflection on the

pond across the street from my home or

maybe it was some other mark made by

animals in nature they’re certainly

abundant these are eggs laid by

different sea birds and other kinds of

birds when an egg starts in the body of

a female bird it’s white and then as it

passes out of the oviduct of the bird

little essentially inkjet printers in

the oviduct make these little marks on

the eggs and they’re beautiful there’s

some speckled and

you know squiggly ones and you could or

I at least think they’re quite

remarkable and beautiful and I consider

them a kind of drawing if you do then

you would say that these eggs were drawn

on by a female grackle the bird that

laid them and these in particular bear a

remarkable resemblance to the work of a

little-known artist named Jackson

Pollock and you wonder you know Pollock

lived in eastern Long Island near the

beach he undoubtedly took a lot of walks

along the beach and he probably saw the

the eggs of different sea birds so you

know whether it may be coincidence this

resemblance but whether Pollock was

inspired by the bird or the bird was

inspired by Pollock I’m not so sure but

I’d venture to say that if I had to

guess which came first Pollock or the

egg that it was the bird so nature we

can be pretty sure was the first scribe

so what first humanoid was it that first

saw the power realized the power and

imitating these things that happen in

nature whether it was the courtship of

birds that we mimicked in our dances or

birdsong in our speech when we had first

made a mark as a human on a wall or

wherever we had not only sorted we

weren’t just copying a gesture made by

Nature we discovered a method and this

method was a revelatory method it’s so

simple but I think it was one of the

biggest ideas of all time think about

what that does it’s it it’s a way of

pausing in recording time all these

gestures left behind by animals you know

Fox prints in the snow or lines in the

sand drawn by grass they’re ephemeral

they’re slippery just like thoughts and

memories they’re washed away by the rain

and the wind but if we can make a mark

that actually lasted in a place that was

protected by the elements and that that

mark could be

communicated to another human being that

was extremely powerful it was it was a

way of acknowledging our own existence

on the planet and and probably these

people liked doing that too because they

may have acknowledged that they died and

it was a way of leaving a piece of

themselves behind the first drawings I

would imagine probably looked something

like this

this is a an image of a hand on a cave

wall in Sulawesi Indonesia thought to be

about 40,000 years old made probably by

somebody taking some pigment in their

mouth and blowing it through a straw

around their hand to leave a negative

image and again this this kind of image

I find it very haunting looking but it

was it was a way of kind of saying I am

here or Here I am this is a cave in

Argentina they call the quavo de Manos I

think the cave of hands it’s it’s a it’s

a really arresting image and it’s like

they’re shouting out Here I am Here I am

I’m here I’m on the planet and it’s it’s

very much now looking back on it like

Darwin’s little simple image of the Tree

of Life an acknowledgement of where

humans came from and in this great

ancestral lineage that were part of

contemporary artists still use this

simple imagery to this day this is a

work by the British artist Richard long

handprints in a circle and this is an

image by an artist named Joel Shapiro

made by with fingerprints it almost

looks like a digital drawing this is a

close-up of that image these are the

footprints of my son four month old son

Cody minutes after he was born these

marks are sometimes called by academics

indexical marks their individual – every

human being and that’s partly what makes

a drawing powerful that it’s a mark of a

single person and even if we all you

know drew a straight line on a piece of

paper and we handed them out to

everybody you would see the differences

that’s why I kind of lament the fading

away of

cursive handwriting in other ways of

handwriting because it’s so special to

get like a letter in the mail or

something like that as opposed to a text

email which is also great and efficient

but but I lament the sort of end of

those individualistic beautiful ways of

communicating I still draw to this day

this is me in the studio I draw at home

and I draw on trips around the world in

the midst of different enquiries this is

was on a trip to CERN him as part of

this project I’m working on about naming

and ordering nature a collecting trip to

CERN him with the Peabody Museum at at

Yale this is a snake that we collected

and there’s me drawing the snake and

this is a toucan I sometimes wonder how

it is that these tools that I use to

communicate are still relevant being

that they’re so ancient and really

haven’t changed in thousands of years a

pencil with graphite something that’s

mined from the ground an animal

hairbrush with a wood handle or a piece

of charcoal from the fire pit in my

backyard can still make a very wonderful

drawing how has this technology

persisted to this day in the face of all

the alternative technologies we have

photography type written Lang Britain

language excuse me or or the you know

all the other things we have iPhones and

things I still draw because it’s a way

for me to connect with my surroundings

this drawing I made on a trip to the

Scottish Highlands and if I hadn’t sat

down in this landscape to draw this

picture if I just taken a picture with

my iPhone and walked away I wouldn’t

remember the landscape it wouldn’t be as

internalized in myself as it was because

I sat there and I can still remember

looking at this drawing the the sound of

the stream and the the trout jumping in

the stream the midges biting the crap

out of me the Sheep you know roaming by

and smelling their dung this is me at

around two years old drawing but just as

a way to sort of start wrapping up the

talk we all start drawing as children

and then we stop and I wonder why that

is is it is it because we’re told by our

teachers that a drawing has to look like

something and then if it doesn’t they

take it and tear it up and throw it away

that would be a pretty bad teacher but I

think I’m not just selling drawing here

as a means to an end as a way of having

something a result that looks like

something obviously abstract

expressionism threw out the idea that a

drawing has to resemble something in our

in our worlds I’m selling drawing more

as a process that helps us connect with

nature to slow down to pay attention as

I mentioned before as a kind of

meditation I’ve been working on a body

of work I’ll end with this image where I

do these murals of bird silhouettes on

walls and they’re kind of like the

images that the early people painted on

cave walls just silhouettes of animals

on a surface and the point of these

pieces is that the source material are

these old field guides where there’s

silhouettes of birds or animals with

numbers and the numbers match up to a

list of names to help us identify things

in the field so when I paint them I

paint the animals and the numbers but I

leave out the key so there’s no way that

people can satisfy their urge to know

what the names are and then they get

frustrated and that’s because I feel

that sometimes we live too much in the

world of language in labels and it’s

just an acknowledgement there’s other

forms of communication that can be just

you [Music]

Please follow and like us: