Press "Enter" to skip to content

Why this world needs pessimism | Darren MacIean | TEDxPearsonCollegeUWC


so are you an optimist do you expect

that good things will happen are you at

the last half-full kind of person the

pressure to be positive has never been

greater positive psychology has become a

happy smiling juggernaut spawning

billion dollar group sales and a

lucrative coaching industry aimed at

making the world more optimistic and

it’s working major corporations no

higher happiness experts the US Army

currently trains its soldiers in

positive thinking in the UK they teach

optimism in schools and talk across the

world government policy advisors however

done talking about the happiness index

as a rival to GDP the unquestioned view

is that optimism is good pessimism is

bad if you search amazon for roots or

negative thinking almost all of them are

negative assuming the pessimism is

something to be cured of like a disease

but whatever our assumptions of our

optimism are wrong last week my daughter

took this photograph in the forest near

our home as you can see it’s beautiful

at this time of the year the snow is

crisp air is pure but should I be afraid

that hiding somewhere in these woods

is a dangerous bear woken early from

hibernation or is this just a negative

thought spoiling another one’s pleasant

walk in the woods faced with this exact

scenario our ancestors could meet one of

two mistakes

mistake number one they could think that

there was a beer in the woods when

actually the

or mystique number two they could think

of it there wasn’t a bearded once when

actually there was one the cost of

making the first mistake was needless

anxiety endless hours of unnecessary

stress the cost of making the second

mistake was death this is why when you

study history you never ever read of the

tribal optimists they died being

pessimistic expecting the worst was what

gave our ancestors an edge they kept

them alive and give them a 1% over their

happy soon to be extinct friends we know

that when we feel happy we get a kick of

the brains happy drug oxytocin this is

why feeling happy feels happy however

studies have shown that the downside of

oxytocin is that it reduces our ability

to identify threads in 2011 the social

psychologist Joseph poorgrass conducted

an experiment at the University of New

South Wales in which people were divided

into two groups according to whether

they were in a good mood or a bad mood

whether their glass was half full or

half empty they were then asked to judge

the truth of certain elements such as

two parallels cause cancer did the CIA

murder Kennedy and they discovered that

the happy people were far more gullible

than their gloomy counterparts and that

in contrast those unencumbered by

happiness and optimism were far less

likely to meet errors of judgment it

seems that the happier and more

optimistic are the less evil humor to

identify threats to spot dangers and to

pick up more falsehoods this is why when

you Netflix and

an innocent cuddle that makes you feel

happy sometimes these to begin here that

you major regret and a totally wasn’t

your fault it was just the oxytocin if

you were in a bad mood it would never

have happened in 2006 two professors of

Finance from Duke University Matthew

Premium David Robertson studied to the

they discovered that optimists are more

prone to reckless behavior than there

has been more slightly more pessimistic

friends they concluded that optimists

work fewer hours save less money and are

less likely to pay their credit cards

and then they said check this out a

little optimist of me beneficial but too

much can lead to some really bad

economic choices so here you have two I

would imagine normally circumspect

professors over let’s face it boring a

subject like finance using some rather

flowery vocabulary we’re noticing that

optimism can lead to not just bad but

really bad economic choices so should it

concern us then that the happiness

industry’s number one customer is

corporate North America given that an

often underreported cause of the

financial meltdown and youth

was the business culture was overly

optimistic and key decision-makers were

far too positive in a culture where

negativity and failure were taboo

subjects no one stole or is allowed to

see the beer eating in the woods think

about it if the culture that you work is

aggressively positive and if optimism

and happiness are mandatory and

negativity is forbidden and you’re not

allowed to be the proverbial rain cloud

you dare not in that environment put up

your hand and see has got a really bad

feeling about this

I don’t think it’ll work and we probably

shouldn’t do it well sometimes that’s

exactly what you should do however many

hundreds of billions of dollars has been

wiped off the value of major

corporations because these

decision-makers insisted on positivity

and forbid negativity

how many major corporations have a

ceased to exist because that was so how

many new startups have been unsuccessful

because the entrepreneurs were rearing

rose-tinted spectacles and didn’t see

the danger we know the only three out of

every ten new businesses survived the

first five years and yet curiously 81%

of entrepreneurs give themselves a

better than seven in ten chance of

success it seems that too many people

are feeling too happy but they’re too

positive and the positive optimism is

making them blind to danger and this is

a problem

take show me as an example this was the

field attempts by the two Canadian media

giants Rodgers and Shaw to compete with

Netflix bald world movie when they

finally admitted defeat in 2016 the

general manager of Xiaomi said

fascinating he said the business was

more challenging to operate than we

expected this makes me wonder what

exactly was it they expected and the

thing that fascinates me about this guy

is his super-smart long track record of

success degree in finance from Stanford

and MBA from Harvard and yet in less

than five minutes my 12 year old son saw

a bear hiding in the woods that the

teams of smart media savvy geniuses a

two of Canada’s most successful

when she launched in 2014 my son like

everyone else took a look to see if it

was any good and after literally minutes

of painstakingly detailed research

emphatically declared dad this is

rubbish no way this is gonna work I said

why not he said look it’s got less

content than Netflix it doesn’t have any

of the good shows why would we pay for

this when we’re already paying for

Netflix big question but an even bigger

question is why did any of the super

smart

Chintan people a two of Canada’s biggest

was successful companies seriously think

that a streaming service that hit the

market seven years after the competitor

with less content for the same price was

going to work when obviously it wasn’t

this was one beer that wasn’t even

hiding in the woods it was there in all

it’s scary detail for the world to see

and yet they didn’t see it why not one

possible explanation is that optimism

made them over estimates their chances

of success and underestimate at best the

possibilities of the dangers of failure

and here’s the thing the more success

you’ve had in the past the more proven

your track record is the more wins

you’ve got under your belt

the world likely you are to fall into

this trap this is why the hugely

successful North American auto industry

didn’t take the threat of small cheap

import

from Japan seriously until it was too

late this is why when the hugely

successful blockbuster video were

offered the chance to buy Netflix they

laughed it out of the room

they actually laughed and in this much

time they went from being a global

player in the movie rental business

where thousands of stores worldwide with

a market share that was so big that

going to Blockbuster was a key part of

every family’s Friday and Saturday night

they went from that in this much time to

extinction optimists draw way too much

confidence and lead too much security

from yesterday’s successes the

pessimists are wired differently they

were always worrying about what went

wrong next about the dangers of the next

challenge and they never led the vision

of standing on the mountaintop make them

lose sight of the dangers involved in

getting there so let’s see that you’re

invited to give an important

presentation at your work and it matters

to you your boss will be there the

directors will be there you needed to go

well now let’s see you approach that

presentation with optimism applying a

few of the tricks you learned from

positive psychology so you visualize

yourself doing an amazing job in your

imagination you can picture your

audience hanging up on your every word

in your mind’s eye you can hear the

thunderous applause when they finish and

you can almost feel your boss’s hand pat

you on the show

as she says good job let’s have lunch

and talk about their promotion if you

approach your presentation with that

level of optimism immediately confidence

that is true but it is equally true that

it may give you overconfidence and your

overconfidence because you too under

prepare and take success for granted and

over loot many of the things that true

to go wrong and as be pessimists will

tell you there are not many things that

could go wrong you can lose the USB

that’s got their slaves five minutes

before your presentation you could spill

coffee on your nose your battery could

run out of power of a laptop could crash

it’s a nightmare but none of that

matters to the pessimist because he saw

those fears hiding in the woods a long

time ago and he didn’t just prepared he

over prepared when he was putting the

slides on a USB he made two extra copies

one for his briefcase one for Setar

pocket when he printed out his notes he

made a spare copy and he put the sphere

copy then a plastic folder coffee no

problem

he makes sure that after he was charged

and just to be extra sure he brought a

backup laptop because you can never over

prepare and that’s the edge that’s the

advantage that pessimism gives you and

that sly pessimists are often still

standing still surviving and still

thriving long after their happy

counterparts have gone into extinction

to speak in praise of pessimism is not

to say that it’s going to read it’s just

to say that this is love and it can read

and it quite often does and umbrellas

are a lot cheaper than ammonia and

that’s why the world needs more

pessimists I thank you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: