Press "Enter" to skip to content

Why the patent system should look more like Indiana and less like Kentucky | Alan Marco | TEDxTysons


I want to tell you the story of the Land
of Lincoln so I’m not gonna tell you
about this guy I’m not gonna talk about
Illinois I’m going to talk about Thomas
Lincoln hashtag the other Land of
Lincoln
Thomas was Abraham’s father and his land
was Kentucky may bruh ham in fact was
born there in 1809 but after a few years
Thomas Lincoln up and moved his family
to Indiana looking back on this Abraham
Lincoln said that the primary reason for
this move was a difficulty with land
titles in Kentucky you see over the
course of a few years Thomas Lincoln was
involved in multiple disputes he had to
move he lost land by 1816 he’d had
enough why invests in the land
if you risk losing it now at the time
Kentucky was the frontier and war
veterans and others in earlier years had
been granted something called land
patents in order to encourage settlement
and part of the responsibility of
claiming the land was it you had to
provide a survey a meets and bounds
survey a verbal description of your
property lines using the physical
features of the land like this survey of
Abraham Lincoln’s boyhood home as it
read in 1986 when it was sold to the
National Park Service it refers to 36
trees three fences a bridge a drain a
stump so you can imagine this kind of
verbal description of the land could
lead to problems see the early pioneers
they were not professional surveyors and
sometimes intentionally or
unintentionally they would describe the
same property
using different features different trees
and you get overlapping property lines
and they gave it a name for this in
Kentucky they called it shingling
because it looked like roofing shingles
overlapping each other now
why were things so much better in
Indiana well in Indiana the land with
government owned to begin with and prior
to sale it was professionally surveyed
into rectangular townships and
rectangular Lots and it’s one of these
Lots
the Thomas Lincoln bought in 1817 when
he moved it’s the southwest quarter of
section 32 it’s pretty simple isn’t it
and to start contrast to the survey that
we saw in Kentucky the certainty of
these boundaries the clarity of these
rights gave people the confidence to
invest in the land
it’s a why did Lincoln move because
people prefer certainty to uncertainty
they prefer Indiana to Kentucky and no
offense to anyone from Kentucky out
there it’s a lovely place but it
provides a cautionary tale for
discussing the patent system
technological change and economic growth
see just as land patents encourage
settlement patents on inventions our
government writes that encourage
innovation so if you have a patent than
for a period of years no one else can
use your invention without your
permission and if it’s useful in the
marketplace you can make some money
but the patent is not a reward it’s the
incentive to develop the technology to
begin with and to tell people about how
it works it’s a twofer we get the
technology and we get the information
that we need to build on so this is part
of what we call the market for
technology and if there’s one thing that
economists like it’s a market we love
markets
my wife doesn’t like it when I spend too
much time alone with the market they’re
beautiful they bring people together
usually buyers and sellers and they
trade and the key is that voluntary
trade makes both parties better off and
it literally creates wealth so suppose I
want to sell you my car well okay this
isn’t my car I’m not sure who told you
that but let’s pretend this is a 1972
Ferrari Dino and let’s say it’s my car
and then I value it for $100,000 but you
value it for $150,000 so you can imagine
that be fairly easy for us to agree on a
price that would make both of us better
off and if we can do that then
regardless of the price we’ve just
created $50,000 worth of wealth in the
economy because we’ve taken an asset
that was worth $100,000 and we’ve
transformed it into one what’s worth a
hundred and fifty thousand dollars just
through trade alone that’s incredible
it’s simple it’s beautiful its elegant
and it works except when it doesn’t like
when there’s a lot of uncertainty in the
market like when people flee Kentucky
for the certainty of Indiana so when I
was a student we would shop at a grocery
outlet this was a literal outlet for
groceries overstocks discontinued
products they had a scratch and dent
section where some of the cans were
missing their labels entirely we would
call these maybe beans like they baby
beans we’d get them home
nope not beans it’s cream of something
but we didn’t care because we were poor
and no one can charge full price for
these cans these are Kentucky cans
people prefer certainty to uncertainty
they prefer Indiana cans to Kentucky
cans and it’s the same in every market
certainty makes the market work better
but this is particularly important in
the market for technology because
historically and globally technology is
the primary driver of economic growth it
is a single thing that most
distinguishes our lives today from those
of our ancestors think just about how
you got here today now imagine doing
that trip with Archimedes or Joan of Arc
or da Vinci or Thomas Lincoln you’d blow
their minds well maybe not da Vinci he’d
say yeah I thought of that but
Archimedes be running around going
Eureka Eureka Eureka think about my
favorite underappreciated technology
refrigeration and cooling obviously this
makes our lives more comfortable as it
is today but it goes way beyond that
because refrigeration actually radically
transformed our economy because it
enabled the long distance hauling of
perishable goods you know what it says
store in a cool dry place yeah well
there weren’t any except at the top of a
mountain which was inconvenient so it
now enabled this cross-country trade in
food and what that did was enabled
regions to specialize and take advantage
of economies of scale that led to
further advancements in planting and
harvesting nationwide we got higher
quality food we got more variety and
lower prices which made everybody better
off so let’s think a little bit about
how this technology developed
the first refrigeration units were these
big beastly things that had the tendency
to occasionally explode so they were
first used to produce the ice that was
used for shipping because you didn’t
want one of these things blowing up your
train but eventually the unit’s got
smaller and safer and we could have
refrigerated rail cars because we could
combine refrigeration technology
reliable power supply insulated
containers rail cars dense technology
got smaller got safer we can get
refrigerated delivery trucks it got
smaller and safer and we could put them
in our homes and now gamers like my kids
are putting them in their computers to
cool down their video cards what will
these kids think of next
which is kind of the point because it’s
their generation that will develop the
next advances if they can pull
themselves away from their video games
it’s the market for technology though
that makes this happen because this
pattern of innovation is common to all
technological change we combine previous
technologies into something new and then
we improve it but the market for
technology works best with more
certainty in it which is why we want
well-defined patent rights so patent
examiner’s inventors together they
define the boundaries patents inventors
describe their technology and how to put
it into practice patent examiner’s look
it over and they make sure that the
claims of the patent are clear and
accurate they comply with the law but
obviously this can be very challenging
especially in emerging technologies
because when something is truly new we
may not even have the words for it
so really inventors and patent
examiner’s are like surveyors in a
technological frontier
imagine trying to define a complicated
space in this landscape using meets and
bounds
a verbal description when you can’t even
see the entire picture because you’re on
the frontier this is complicated
you see in the patent system there are
no neat little rectangles because we
can’t survey the land ahead of time like
we could in Indiana so because of this
there is some inherent uncertainty and
that leads a lot of people to argue that
the patent system looks a lot like
Lincoln’s Kentucky with overlapping
property lines confusion and a market
for technology that doesn’t work but
there are others that suggest that
despite done uncertainty the market for
technology works more like Indiana so
which is it
Kentucky your Indiana well I’m an
economist so I’m gonna say it depends
because it can be either or both it
depends on the technology and really
maybe it doesn’t matter so much where we
are as where we’re going see the people
of Kentucky didn’t just throw up their
hands and give up private property they
were dealt a bad hand but they did what
they could to mitigate so for them
that meant professional surveyors
permanent boundary markers better
record-keeping these things reduced the
uncertainty helped them to clean up the
shingling from the Frontier Days
so really regardless of where we start
the policy goal is the same we should
make the patent system more like Indiana
now when it comes to policy I’m a big
fan of what we call evidence-based
policymaking but some policy questions
are hard and evidence is often hard to
get sometimes we come up against what I
like to call policy based evidence
making
which is neither good policy nor good
evidence but sometimes things are a
little easier you see we know that
people prefer certainty to uncertainty
and it makes the market work better and
the patent system that means high
quality patent examination well-defined
rights an easy way to fix mistakes
transparency in the system especially
transparency in ownership these things
reduce uncertainty in the system as a
whole for all technologies see the
parable of the Land of Lincoln tells us
how important it is to create certainty
in the market for technology because it
has the potential to create real and
meaningful change and that brings
economic opportunities to everybody it
puts us on the road to Indiana and
that’s where we want to be thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: