Press "Enter" to skip to content

Why Public Health should support the decriminalisation of Sex Work | Georgina Perry | TEDxLSHTM


[Music]
what does Public Health do for sex
workers I mean what do we really do sure
we recognize sex workers to be a
marginalized group of people with
greater vulnerabilities and access needs
we run sex worker friendly clinics we
give out condoms we test for sti’s we
prevent and we manage communica
infection we design studies we collect
the data and we write up our findings
and if we really understand our
epidemiology we recognize the high
incidence of violence both sexual and
general violence amongst the sex worker
population and we might design and
implement strategies for safety and
support and then we give out more
condoms and we test for more sti’s and
we design more studies and I think you
get the picture now I’m not saying that
there’s no value in this pretty much
every sex worker I’ve ever met has been
thankful that such services exist when
they need them but there’s a bigger
conversation one that needs to take
place and it moves beyond the sex
workers as vectors and victims trope and
we as public health professionals need
to be part of it because to remain
silent
means that we become complicit and if we
are complicit it means that we
contribute to the harm and the stigma
faced by sex workers all over the world
I want to talk to you about why if we
are truly serious about tackling health
inequality the full decriminalization of
sex work should be a topic for public
health then you’ll be armed with the
knowledge that you need to go back to
your public faculties your hospitals
your commissioning roles your
educational establishments and you’ll be
able to have these conversations and you
will cede the ideas that will make you
part of
change now that’s the contagious idea
and what is it we want to change just
the law to be precise it’s the current
set of laws that criminalize sex workers
and criminalize the cha create the
climate in which their health and
well-being is harmed every day the law
that prevents them from taking the
condoms that we provide in case the
police find them and arrest them because
condoms can be used as evidence the
condoms that prevents them from
accessing the clinics that we run
because they’re fearful of giving over
their personal details to people that
they perceive to be part of authority
and the law that prevents them from
reporting crime that’s happened to them
because they are fearful that if they
try to seek justice they will be
criminalized instead the sale of sex and
the UK law is not illegal but everything
else associated with it
advertising organizing working together
it is illegal we see versions of this
sort of criminalization all over the
globe and it’s very disingenuous because
it puts sex workers in a situation where
is virtually impossible for them not to
break the law
once sex workers so these are
individuals who live complex lives
within grey areas of the law have become
victims and they seek redress for this
the police often struggle to make an
appropriate response they move towards
an examination of the sex workers lives
and a judgement about what they do
rather than the crime that’s actually
happened the message that sex workers
take away from this is that they are not
deserving of protection of the law and
as a consequence they are fearful to
report the authorities so fear of
judgment and prosecution and it also
means that they distrust other services
fearing that the authoritarianism of the
law is likely to bleed into other
professionals now for 13 years I ran a
large NHS service in East London and
I’ve seen at firsthand the barriers
created by criminalization facing many
sex workers when they try to access our
support by providing free
and confidential access to healthcare
advocacy and support the service Iran
was able to assist people when they
needed it sex workers could come knowing
that they wouldn’t face moral judgments
or anti prostitution ideology and where
they knew that if they came to us they’d
have a team who would be working hard on
their behalf to navigate the complex set
of laws that they needed to get through
in order to access public services in
the UK one of the first questions we
would be asked by sex workers getting
migrant sex workers was how did they
know they could trust us because in
their home country health services are
always linked to the police and it
didn’t matter how hard we tried to
reassure them if the woman that we were
meeting had been part of a police raid
that brothel had been raided and they’d
been had their ID taken and they’d been
told if we find you and you’re working
as a prostitute again in the UK then
you’re going to be criminalized and
deported no matter how much we impressed
upon them that we were different and we
weren’t the police they couldn’t trust
us and no wonder they couldn’t use our
service without absolute proof that we
were a safe and confidential entity they
were too fearful of their details being
treasurer shared by the police in a
large borough elsewhere in East London
my team would give out condoms to sex
workers and they would refuse to take
more than 6 and we would see them
running off and hiding the condoms in
bushes and behind walls and we’d say why
are you doing that and they’d say
because when the police arrest us they
use the condoms that we have on them as
evidence for prosecution national ugly
monks is the organization that I work
with and we promote safety and access to
justice for sex workers who are often
targeted by dangerous individuals and
they’re reluctant to report to the
police because they’re fearful that if
they do so they that that the police
will disregard what what they’re saying
to them we make reports we produce
anonymous reports that go out to other
sex workers and we then enable sex
workers to also get in contact with the
police and make a full criminal report
we also put them in touch with
frontline support services with their
consent we share that intelligence now
the fact that national ugly mugs exist
is a testament to the basket case that
is the UK law what other group of people
require an interface between themselves
and the criminal justice in order to be
taken seriously in order to make a
report because they’ve been victims of
crime as statutory funding for Public
Health dries up in the Northern
Hemisphere and the neoliberal market
takes its place partnerships between
NGOs and faith-based organizations and
the police emerge now these alliances
are not new phenomenon if you’re a sex
worker in Southeast Asia you will long
have been used to the brothel raids that
pull you out of the place that you’re
working put you somewhere that’s deemed
more suitable for you as a woman in the
UK were increasingly seeing the language
and the actions of enforcement supported
by helpers offensively there to rescue
and rehabilitate sex workers across
happening across the UK and regularly
these brothel raids and these street
arrests happen would be helpers in tow
with the police and what they tend to do
is ask that the sex workers work with
them and engage with them they see the
problem of social workers of sex workers
and social and the sex workers
themselves are characterized as deviant
and they’re what they do is conflated
with either victims of trafficking or
they’re told that they need to accept
the support otherwise they’ll face
criminal sanctions now the reasons that
we should care about this as public
health professionals is that sex workers
think that we’re all the same they don’t
differentiate between public health
services that operate within the
boundaries of confidentiality and
impartiality and we would never sanction
all or hand people over to the police if
they did disengage with our service so
it becomes increasingly more difficult
for public health professionals to press
home the point that we’re here to listen
and not to tell because why would sex
workers believe us
any form of criminalization drives sex
workers underground
it’s what I’ve seen
year after year of running sex worker
services sex workers in need of help and
support you come late to services or not
at all to seek treatment for health
problems but would have been simple to
sort out if they’d have come to us
earlier but they’re hiding from
authorities the trend towards
authoritarianism and the creeping
enforcement helps us to really
understand why how it’s trying to have
this the system is trying to manage what
they see as undesirable behavior and
this particularly looms large if you’re
working in public health in the UK today
our Commission is a part of local
governor e-government machinery and
their objectives are set by elected
representatives who in turn over to Dinn
by members of the general public and the
understanding of risks inherent of
pushing sex workers away from services
and treatment is of little interest
what counts is gentrification
enforcement targets and
cost-effectiveness what’s simple a way
to deal with sex workers then enforce
them out of sight when it comes to
developing services for people who are
marginalized we like to think as public
health professionals that we are
creative the move towards
authoritarianism in public health now
sees reductionist reductionist thinking
we recognize the connectivity between
mental health and physical health we
recognize the integral relatedness
between structural and environmental
factors and we try hard to reflect the
lived experience of sex workers when we
design services with them and on their
behalf the new breed of authoritarian
helpers lack the passion they lack the
training they lack the knowledge they
lack the skills to calibrate the level
of emotional support and practical
support that’s needed by sex workers and
they pushes their remit requests their
own targets their own target driven
initiatives the structural changes in
health and community based services
means that there’s a high staff turnover
and there’s stigmatization very often
because services are amalgamated and a
one size for service is meant to fit all
sex workers specialist understanding is
not there and so sex workers simply stop
using services in discussion recently
with a colleague she was describing some
of these developments and she said I was
talking to a woman who was working for
one of these helper organizations and
she said that a sex worker had come to
her who’d been raped and I apparently
the colleague had said to her I don’t
understand why you still do this job why
don’t you just go out and beg now
there’s a perverse consequence to all of
this
the further sex workers move away from
support and services then the more
unwell they become and when they
eventually come to clinics with acute
care needs this requires and it
legitimizes our treatment of STI is our
management about breaks handing out of
condoms ever felt like you were part of
a system that was perpetuating the ill
health of people because I know that I
did start to feel like that my point is
that if as health professionals we
aspire to offer meaningful protection
for sex workers around the world then we
must marshal our arguments and we must
use our professional status to advocate
for full decriminalization it’s not good
enough for us to think that just giving
out condoms and promoting safer sex
should be the limit of our involvement
we have to speak out about the fact that
the law creates appalling barriers to
health and criminal justice redoubtable
institutions such as the UN the World
Health Organization and Amnesty all call
for decriminalization but change starts
with us the little people it starts when
we’re sitting in meetings when we’re
talking to our commissioning colleagues
when we’re talking to our medical
colleagues and we have to keep in mind
how these terrible laws impact on the
poor health outcomes and the better
health outcomes that we would like to
see it’s not good enough to produce data
that simply reflects back the might
biomedical harms that we really see we
need to grapple with the context and the
politics we need to create a climate for
sex workers in which poor health and
discrimination and stigma is not the
norm my aspiration is that all health
professionals come become empowered
enough to challenge the authoritarian
say
King that criminalisation is the answer
to sex work increasingly and thankfully
sex workers across the globe are
campaigning and devising their own
services they want to see sex worker
criminalized and they know that it will
make them healthier and they know it
will make them safer and public health
needs to join forces with them on the
front line because if we support the
policy of the the principle of policy
made through evidence then the
decriminalization of sex work is a
contagious idea but we need to see
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: