Press "Enter" to skip to content

Why Our Conversation About Rural America is Incomplete | Ellie Dupler | TEDxColumbiaUniversity


if you followed the 2016 presidential
election you’ve probably seen this map
this map shows the states that Hillary
Clinton won in blue and the states the
Donald Trump won in red and if you
followed the election particularly
closely you’ve probably seen this map
now this map shows the same data but at
the county level and as you can see many
of the blue counties are clustered
around big cities and many of the red
counties are spread across rural America
now these maps have been used to support
the now widely accepted idea that rural
communities are synonymous with two
things whiteness and redness where
whiteness refers to the color of their
skin and redness to their politics but
it isn’t necessarily the case that rural
communities are all white or all red in
this narrative that’s been perpetuated
by both the left and the right obscures
a deeper truth rural communities are
more diverse than we realize and our
failure to recognize the diversity of
experiences and beliefs within them is
widening the urban world divided our
Commission of what I’ll call rural
homogenize ation that is ignoring that
rural diversity is exacerbating and
expanding the disconnect and the lack of
understanding that these two groups have
for one another now I grew up in
Thompson Ville a rural community located
in northern Michigan with more than a
little luck I received a scholarship to
obtain my bachelor’s degree at Yale and
as a first-generation college student
coming from the rural Midwest I met a
kind of person that Yale that I had
never met before they thought that all
country music sounded the same growing
up and particularly in my later years of
high school I loved riding around in my
95 Ford Ranger pickup listening to Luke
Bryan on the speakers I was driving down
an empty back road my peers in college
also thought that the silence of night
but kindly you only get when you’re out
in the middle of the woods away from the
city sounds was eerie and
as a child and even to this day I loved
taking late night or early morning walks
with my mom hearing nothing but it could
cost me of crickets and spring peepers
in the background but our differences
didn’t end there now I love where I grew
up I think northern Michigan is the most
beautiful place in the country but
during my junior year of Yale I
desperately wanted one of my friends to
come and visit me in my hometown he grew
up in the suburbs of Boston and had
never visited northern Michigan before I
said you’ll love it but he was being
very hesitant about organizing a trip
and finally revealed the reason for his
hesitation to me I just think small
towns breed hate he said your people are
just so provincial
now that word provincial it dripped with
the stain and the way that he said it
and for the first time in my life it
made me feel a tinge of shame for where
I came from and this wasn’t the first or
the last time that I would be taunted
for growing up in rural America during
my time in college but it was the most
direct in the most illuminating the
current conversation hammers home this
idea that rural communities are backward
self-interested and resistant to change
in progress it asserts that the
oppression of liberalism comes not from
politicians and campaigns that
disenfranchise rural voters but instead
from the so called provincial people
themselves as long as we keep having
this conversation in this capacity we’ll
only grow more polarized as a nation and
the truth it turns out is that America
looks less like this and more like this
this map shows what the United States
would look like if all of the red boats
and all of the blue votes were overlaid
onto one another so the more purple an
area is the more ideologically diverse
it is that is the more equal the number
of red and blue votes in that community
and as you can see from looking at this
many of America’s rural communities are
not all red or all blue but purple now
let’s zoom in on one of those purple
communities
this is benzy county the county that i
grew up in now the US government has a
system of ranking counties according to
how rural or how urban they are called
the rural urban continuum where the are
you see a 1 on the are you see is the
most urban a county can be and a 9 is
the most rural a company can be Benzie
county is a nine on the RUC and in
addition to being very rural
Benzi county is 95% white only 25% of
its residents hold college degrees as
opposed to 35% in the nation as a whole
and many of its residents fall below the
national median household income so when
we look at the county level map we’re
not necessarily surprised if we take the
media’s portrayal of rural communities
to be true that it looks deeply red but
here’s what the voter data actually
shows us for Benzi County now as you can
see this is for 2016 and as you can see
in 2016 while there were a significant
number of red boats
there were also a significant number of
blue votes so when we talk about rural
communities as though they’re
ideologically homogeneous we’re missing
a whole piece of the conversation we’re
erasing this whole subsection of rural
voters and this distinction between
popular cultures characterization of
rural communities and the reality of
rural diversity becomes even more stark
when we look at two additional groups
people of color who live in rural
communities and white people who live in
rural progressive states examining the
2016 voter data can help to elucidate
those distinctions now this is Green
County Alabama Green County is an 8 on
the RTC so again very rural and 81
percent of its residents are black and
in 2016 82 percent of the vote in Green
County went to Hillary Clinton despite
it being an extremely rural County among
the most rural in America and what we’re
seeing here may not surprise you given
the high rate at which black voters tend
to choose Democratic candidates but what
it does reveal is that our discussions
about who gets to claim rural what
rurals colors are what rural looks like
privileges a certain narrative
and one that is not inclusive of
everyone living in rural America and we
see these results replicated in other
counties as well so here we have Todd
County South Dakota which is entirely
encompassed within the Rosebud Indian
Reservation now Todd County is a nine on
the RUC and 88% of its residents
identify as native and in 2016 71% of
the vote in Todd County went to Hillary
Clinton but you never see people from
Todd County and stories about rural
America and in fact you never see Native
communities being profiled in these
stories at all despite the fact that
many rural can many reservations are
among the most remote and rural places
in our country now at this point you
might argue that that’s because rural
America is overwhelmingly white and
these are you know one-off instances of
counties where there are more people of
color than white people but the truth is
that one in four people living in a
rural community identifies as a person
of color and when we look at the country
as a whole we’re just over one in three
people identify as people of color we
can see the significance of that number
and now you might argue that that’s
because we’re interested in rural white
people and their voting patterns to
begin with and everyone knows that
people of color would still choose
Democratic candidates regardless of
whether they’re living in rural or urban
communities but even rural white
communities are not as homogeneous as
our current conversation portrays them
to be so let’s have a look at Lamoille
County Vermont
now Lamoille county is an 8 on the are
you see again very rural and 96% of its
residents are white but in 2016 Hillary
Clinton won Lamoille County by 31
percentage points over Donald Trump and
when we look at the rep at the results
from 2012 and 2008 we see an even
greater distinction between the vote for
the Democratic candidate and for the
Republican candidate up to 50%
discrepancy in those votes and so what
this shows us is that even rural white
communities aren’t inherently conforming
to some voting patterns
customs and ideologies that are laid out
for us and the choice to portray and to
study only a small sector of rural
communities is a deliberate decision and
not one that is inherent to the study
and understanding of rural politics
rural diversity in both race and
ethnicity as well as ideology is alive
and well in America
Amuro modernization is not just a
semantic issue but one that has real
practical implications for national
unity and cohesion when we commit rural
homogenize ation we’re more likely to
bring to our conversations assumptions
about our peers and colleagues who come
from rural communities that they’re
backward and Hillbillies who don’t
deserve our attention or who worse
require our reeducation we’re less
likely to believe that we can find
common ground and we’re more likely to
carry out our distaste for these groups
in insidious ways and importantly we’re
less likely to consider
intersectionality in the search for
solutions to rural problems like
rebuilding critical infrastructure and
expanding access to medical and legal
resources and when I told one of my
friends that I would be giving a talk
about politics of rural communities he
said oh so basically hillbilly elegy and
for those who aren’t familiar with it
hillbilly elegy is a popular memoir
published in 2016 about life in rural
Ohio and while it does touch on some
important issues facing rural America it
also plays directly into this narrative
that rural communities have a singular
identity and I think that my friends
comments demonstrate that even the most
well-read and educated among us often
failed to see rural America as anything
but a red and blue issue I’m really it’s
so much more when groups are left out of
the conversation they rightly resent
those who have excluded them and in the
context of rural politics this means
that rural communities will continue to
harbor resentment towards urban
communities who are often seen as the
paternalistic and righteous
decision-makers over matters of national
importance a 20-17 poll by the
Washington Post
to reveal that 70% of Americans think
that our country is today more divided
than it was during the Vietnam War and
much of that divide exists along
urban-rural lines and we today in this
moment have the power to change that
ultimately it isn’t the president who
will divide or unite the country
regardless of who she or he may be it’s
us every one of us in this room and
every person you meet on the street we
can stop real homogenization and start
developing a nuanced understanding of
our country’s rural landscape when we
stop homogenizing and whitewashing and
boiling these communities down to
worn-out stereotypes that no longer
represent them and maybe never did when
we start understanding that even rural
America is pluralistic diverse and
complicated the face of rural America is
in truth the face of America not just
white but also brown and black and not
walls of red and blue but blankets
purple [Applause]
Please follow and like us: