
it was 2008 and I was planning what
seemed like the first vacation I had
taken since starting my last company
everyday health calm in 2002 so without
enough time to plan the epic disconnect
I so badly needed I went to amazon.com
and I bought the wallpaper magazine
guide to the city of Marrakech where I
was planning on going the guide arrived
I planned my trip and basically verbatim
I took the recommendations of the
editors of wallpaper magazine
and boy did I have a great time each
recommendation was better than the last
so much so that at the end of my trip
when I was sitting in the airport lounge
waiting for my flight back to JFK I went
back to Amazon and I bought ten more
wallpaper city guides to cities that I
was planning on going to in the future
and so it’s like I’m gonna get a little
personal here I’m going to share a
little bit of a personal quirk some
could call it an idiosyncrasy or
defining characteristic I tend to need
to know the math and statistics of
everything going on around me and so
there’s a lot of numbers flying around
in my head at all times and so I knew
enough about publishing to know that the
editors of wallpaper had probably made a
dollar 50 in me purchasing this $10 book
I also knew enough about the travel
agency or online travel agency business
to know that Expedia had made about
$1,500 as I booked this $10,000 trip
wait a second so the people who actually
helped curate the experience and give me
a fabulous week made a dollar fifty and
this compares to the people who simply
took my credit card and they made $1,500
so as a marketer at heart kind of took a
step back and said in what marketing
ecosystem is that a reality where were
the people who inspire the transaction
make one one-thousandth in this case of
the people who simply process the
payment and I as I felt this sort of
Jerry Maguire moment sweeping over me I
landed in JFK back to life and back to
reality
fast forward to 2014 we had just taken
every day health public on the New York
Stock Exchange which I used as my
curtain call to exit and I was again in
need of another epic disconnect this
time I took what I’ll call the 30 day
March Madness sabbatical and that
basically it’s very much what it sounds
like i sat on my couch for about 30 days
and I watched every single March Madness
game as my wife watched on horrified at
the end of the tournament she turned to
me and said I really hope this isn’t
what your everyday health life post
everyday health life is gonna look like
I said don’t worry honey
I have this I had this Jerry Maguire
moment years ago I’m going to go back
and revisit it and I’m going to see if
there’s something there so you know I’d
reached out to my friends who ran
different travel publishing businesses I
networked and met some c-suite Hotel
executives I met some hotel general
managers and I started doing research I
tripped across the Greenwich Hotel which
is literally around the corner from
where I live in Tribeca and their
story’s a little different you know
they’re at ninety five percent occupancy
and they by policy will never be on an
OTA so how do they do it well Robert De
Niro’s one of the owners he’s also one
of the founders of the Tribeca Film
Festival and so every year his posse or
crew or entourage descends on the hotel
as part of the Tribeca Film Festival and
that gets picked up in Hollywood
Reporter and travel and leisure and
Conde Nast Traveler and all sorts of
blogs and and they really know that
every year they have this reliable PR
engine and so the hotels complete is is
is is completely full and really a case
study in a successful independent hotel
and then I came across another hotel
that’ll talk about the Gladstone Hotel
in Toronto it’s a small 37 room hotel
where each of the rooms was designed by
a local artist and on a monthly basis
one of those artists does a major
installation throughout the hotel
and I would categorize their guests as
as falling into one of two buckets those
who knew that they were going to an art
hotel with a very avant-garde Flair
maybe they read in Conde Nast traveler’s
list of 10 best places to stay for
Toronto Pride Week maybe they had read
about the hotel and then other guests
who had booked on Expedia and didn’t
really know they were just looking for a
four-star hotel on Queen West to stay at
in Toronto and those guests when I was
there there was a plant art installation
that kind of made the hotel feel like a
jungle and you could sort of almost pick
out who had booked through an OTA and
didn’t know what they were getting they
kind of looked terrified
they’re going to walk around the corner
and there might be a tiger there or
something so the the point that I’m
making is is you know we all wish we
could be in the enviable position of a
Greenwich Hotel where every year there’s
this huge PR shot and that lasts the
whole year and then there’s but but but
it content and publishers you know new
things don’t happen all the time and so
how does how do so so that’s why I
believe publishers haven’t really found
their way into a core part of the
economic engine of a hotel in the same
way that an Expedia has and does it have
to stay that way
well I’ll take a step back and share a
case study I think it’s going to be one
of the most important case studies in
sort of marketing and advertising go
back to 2007 MySpace and Facebook are
both about the same size each of them
are each about a hundred million people
and they’re both cool in different ways
MySpace more music and Facebook a little
bit more personal communities and
myspace is owned by Fox and Fox is used
to making money by selling TV ads or a
spot you buy the sod and whatever
happens happens and that was their
business model Facebook on the other
hand took a little bit different a
different approach they engaged in the
conversation with the largest marketers
in the world and and I’m going to dig
into how they work with Procter and
Gamble they basically said we’ve built a
big audience we really like to work with
you guys you guys have been doing some
testing
you know one of your brands let’s say
tide spent a million dollars getting
more people to like the brands we want
you to you know what will it take for
you guys to spend more and the brand
managers answer was very logical if you
can show those million people who liked
our brand you know now spends there are
now buying more tide and their ROI is
good then of course we’ll spend more
money and so Facebook instead of just
saying oh we’re growing we’re exploding
we’re so big they actually engage in the
conversation and they enabled the credit
environment where they could share their
data in an anonymized way with research
with a research company that PNG was
working with and basically the research
company got the data here’s the million
people who now like tied because of the
Facebook of the of the Facebook
marketing and they the research company
pulled down customer loyalty data 70% of
drug store and grocery transactions even
though they’re not happening online
where it’s easy to measure their
customer loyalty programs allow
marketers to measure them so the
research company pulled that data in and
so then they were able to add the
correlation they said okay well here’s
these million people and here they are
they’re buying a lot more tied so you
know fast forward Facebook has
flourished myspace is a little bit of
history and what does this have to do
with with publishing and hotels well
with all due respect to most travel
publishers I’m going to say that I think
they’ve acted a little bit like MySpace
whereby they’ve said here’s a beautiful
odd page it’ll be in the beach issue
it’ll be thirty thousand dollars and
when hotel says well what am I going to
get for that you’re going to get this
beautiful page in the beach issue and
well what about the revenue because I’m
accountable for that it’s going to look
really great you know you’re amongst
Lexus and some of the best advertisers
in the world and really the publishers
don’t know how to engage in that in in
that question and this is kind of the
culmination of my Jerry Maguire moment
from 2008 my new company curiosity is
actually in the middle of the largest
study
ever been conducted I’m going to fathom
that it would cost five million dollars
to hire McKinsey to do this research but
you basically we have 15 hotels who are
sharing their primary booking files with
us we have five publishers who we’ve
embedded with tracking codes that allow
us to see which users are reading about
which hotels and we’re actually
measuring on a one to one user basis
okay this user read about this hotel and
here they are they stayed at the hotel
90 days later that publisher deserves
some credit if we create some incentives
something good might happen and so while
the study is not yet finished we’re you
know it’s been running for almost a year
now I will be publishing it in the fall
and I’ll give you a little snapshot
though I’ll tell you some data out now
our first publishing partner we actually
co-created surface hotels calm with the
editors of surface magazine and with on
surface hotels calm we took a hotel that
had two properties one in Miami and one
in New York and we we divided the
surface audience into two we said okay
we’re going to market these hotels very
heavily and have all of this side read
about the hotels we’re not going to
market the content about about these
hotels to this other side and to create
a test and control group and basically
for the people who were exposed to the
content repetitively for every thousand
people about nine of them ended up
staying at one of these two properties
in the next six months for the
non-controlled or for the group that was
not exposed only one of the in a
thousand people stayed at that Hotel in
the next six months
so we deduce that to 95% statistical
significance that 8 out of a thousand
people were impacted by the content that
was on the site – then therefore stay at
the hotel so there you have it you know
you can actually measure the point of
inspiration and and and publishers can
actually do this if they want to and
hotels can work with publishers in this
way if they want to engage with
in this way and so while I’m not I’m not
really suggesting that Expedia and
Priceline are going to go away or not be
relevant in the ecosystem I’m just
saying that maybe hotels should consider
instead of spending ninety five percent
of their resources and focus trying to
close the deal maybe they should be
spending 5050 and trying to try to
create more demand where they where if
they weren’t even on those platforms
some of the time
it wouldn’t hurt their businesses so
much like the Greenwich hotel but
obviously without balance is what is is
what we think where we think the
pendulum will end up and so we’re
excited to pave the way to reshape the
conversation that publishers and hotels
are having and I think the result will
be more profitable hotels happier guests
who find the right hotels and more money
for travel publishers to produce content
that creates further inspiration in the
future a truly virtuous circle thank you
[Applause]
seemed like the first vacation I had
taken since starting my last company
everyday health calm in 2002 so without
enough time to plan the epic disconnect
I so badly needed I went to amazon.com
and I bought the wallpaper magazine
guide to the city of Marrakech where I
was planning on going the guide arrived
I planned my trip and basically verbatim
I took the recommendations of the
editors of wallpaper magazine
and boy did I have a great time each
recommendation was better than the last
so much so that at the end of my trip
when I was sitting in the airport lounge
waiting for my flight back to JFK I went
back to Amazon and I bought ten more
wallpaper city guides to cities that I
was planning on going to in the future
and so it’s like I’m gonna get a little
personal here I’m going to share a
little bit of a personal quirk some
could call it an idiosyncrasy or
defining characteristic I tend to need
to know the math and statistics of
everything going on around me and so
there’s a lot of numbers flying around
in my head at all times and so I knew
enough about publishing to know that the
editors of wallpaper had probably made a
dollar 50 in me purchasing this $10 book
I also knew enough about the travel
agency or online travel agency business
to know that Expedia had made about
$1,500 as I booked this $10,000 trip
wait a second so the people who actually
helped curate the experience and give me
a fabulous week made a dollar fifty and
this compares to the people who simply
took my credit card and they made $1,500
so as a marketer at heart kind of took a
step back and said in what marketing
ecosystem is that a reality where were
the people who inspire the transaction
make one one-thousandth in this case of
the people who simply process the
payment and I as I felt this sort of
Jerry Maguire moment sweeping over me I
landed in JFK back to life and back to
reality
fast forward to 2014 we had just taken
every day health public on the New York
Stock Exchange which I used as my
curtain call to exit and I was again in
need of another epic disconnect this
time I took what I’ll call the 30 day
March Madness sabbatical and that
basically it’s very much what it sounds
like i sat on my couch for about 30 days
and I watched every single March Madness
game as my wife watched on horrified at
the end of the tournament she turned to
me and said I really hope this isn’t
what your everyday health life post
everyday health life is gonna look like
I said don’t worry honey
I have this I had this Jerry Maguire
moment years ago I’m going to go back
and revisit it and I’m going to see if
there’s something there so you know I’d
reached out to my friends who ran
different travel publishing businesses I
networked and met some c-suite Hotel
executives I met some hotel general
managers and I started doing research I
tripped across the Greenwich Hotel which
is literally around the corner from
where I live in Tribeca and their
story’s a little different you know
they’re at ninety five percent occupancy
and they by policy will never be on an
OTA so how do they do it well Robert De
Niro’s one of the owners he’s also one
of the founders of the Tribeca Film
Festival and so every year his posse or
crew or entourage descends on the hotel
as part of the Tribeca Film Festival and
that gets picked up in Hollywood
Reporter and travel and leisure and
Conde Nast Traveler and all sorts of
blogs and and they really know that
every year they have this reliable PR
engine and so the hotels complete is is
is is completely full and really a case
study in a successful independent hotel
and then I came across another hotel
that’ll talk about the Gladstone Hotel
in Toronto it’s a small 37 room hotel
where each of the rooms was designed by
a local artist and on a monthly basis
one of those artists does a major
installation throughout the hotel
and I would categorize their guests as
as falling into one of two buckets those
who knew that they were going to an art
hotel with a very avant-garde Flair
maybe they read in Conde Nast traveler’s
list of 10 best places to stay for
Toronto Pride Week maybe they had read
about the hotel and then other guests
who had booked on Expedia and didn’t
really know they were just looking for a
four-star hotel on Queen West to stay at
in Toronto and those guests when I was
there there was a plant art installation
that kind of made the hotel feel like a
jungle and you could sort of almost pick
out who had booked through an OTA and
didn’t know what they were getting they
kind of looked terrified
they’re going to walk around the corner
and there might be a tiger there or
something so the the point that I’m
making is is you know we all wish we
could be in the enviable position of a
Greenwich Hotel where every year there’s
this huge PR shot and that lasts the
whole year and then there’s but but but
it content and publishers you know new
things don’t happen all the time and so
how does how do so so that’s why I
believe publishers haven’t really found
their way into a core part of the
economic engine of a hotel in the same
way that an Expedia has and does it have
to stay that way
well I’ll take a step back and share a
case study I think it’s going to be one
of the most important case studies in
sort of marketing and advertising go
back to 2007 MySpace and Facebook are
both about the same size each of them
are each about a hundred million people
and they’re both cool in different ways
MySpace more music and Facebook a little
bit more personal communities and
myspace is owned by Fox and Fox is used
to making money by selling TV ads or a
spot you buy the sod and whatever
happens happens and that was their
business model Facebook on the other
hand took a little bit different a
different approach they engaged in the
conversation with the largest marketers
in the world and and I’m going to dig
into how they work with Procter and
Gamble they basically said we’ve built a
big audience we really like to work with
you guys you guys have been doing some
testing
you know one of your brands let’s say
tide spent a million dollars getting
more people to like the brands we want
you to you know what will it take for
you guys to spend more and the brand
managers answer was very logical if you
can show those million people who liked
our brand you know now spends there are
now buying more tide and their ROI is
good then of course we’ll spend more
money and so Facebook instead of just
saying oh we’re growing we’re exploding
we’re so big they actually engage in the
conversation and they enabled the credit
environment where they could share their
data in an anonymized way with research
with a research company that PNG was
working with and basically the research
company got the data here’s the million
people who now like tied because of the
Facebook of the of the Facebook
marketing and they the research company
pulled down customer loyalty data 70% of
drug store and grocery transactions even
though they’re not happening online
where it’s easy to measure their
customer loyalty programs allow
marketers to measure them so the
research company pulled that data in and
so then they were able to add the
correlation they said okay well here’s
these million people and here they are
they’re buying a lot more tied so you
know fast forward Facebook has
flourished myspace is a little bit of
history and what does this have to do
with with publishing and hotels well
with all due respect to most travel
publishers I’m going to say that I think
they’ve acted a little bit like MySpace
whereby they’ve said here’s a beautiful
odd page it’ll be in the beach issue
it’ll be thirty thousand dollars and
when hotel says well what am I going to
get for that you’re going to get this
beautiful page in the beach issue and
well what about the revenue because I’m
accountable for that it’s going to look
really great you know you’re amongst
Lexus and some of the best advertisers
in the world and really the publishers
don’t know how to engage in that in in
that question and this is kind of the
culmination of my Jerry Maguire moment
from 2008 my new company curiosity is
actually in the middle of the largest
study
ever been conducted I’m going to fathom
that it would cost five million dollars
to hire McKinsey to do this research but
you basically we have 15 hotels who are
sharing their primary booking files with
us we have five publishers who we’ve
embedded with tracking codes that allow
us to see which users are reading about
which hotels and we’re actually
measuring on a one to one user basis
okay this user read about this hotel and
here they are they stayed at the hotel
90 days later that publisher deserves
some credit if we create some incentives
something good might happen and so while
the study is not yet finished we’re you
know it’s been running for almost a year
now I will be publishing it in the fall
and I’ll give you a little snapshot
though I’ll tell you some data out now
our first publishing partner we actually
co-created surface hotels calm with the
editors of surface magazine and with on
surface hotels calm we took a hotel that
had two properties one in Miami and one
in New York and we we divided the
surface audience into two we said okay
we’re going to market these hotels very
heavily and have all of this side read
about the hotels we’re not going to
market the content about about these
hotels to this other side and to create
a test and control group and basically
for the people who were exposed to the
content repetitively for every thousand
people about nine of them ended up
staying at one of these two properties
in the next six months for the
non-controlled or for the group that was
not exposed only one of the in a
thousand people stayed at that Hotel in
the next six months
so we deduce that to 95% statistical
significance that 8 out of a thousand
people were impacted by the content that
was on the site – then therefore stay at
the hotel so there you have it you know
you can actually measure the point of
inspiration and and and publishers can
actually do this if they want to and
hotels can work with publishers in this
way if they want to engage with
in this way and so while I’m not I’m not
really suggesting that Expedia and
Priceline are going to go away or not be
relevant in the ecosystem I’m just
saying that maybe hotels should consider
instead of spending ninety five percent
of their resources and focus trying to
close the deal maybe they should be
spending 5050 and trying to try to
create more demand where they where if
they weren’t even on those platforms
some of the time
it wouldn’t hurt their businesses so
much like the Greenwich hotel but
obviously without balance is what is is
what we think where we think the
pendulum will end up and so we’re
excited to pave the way to reshape the
conversation that publishers and hotels
are having and I think the result will
be more profitable hotels happier guests
who find the right hotels and more money
for travel publishers to produce content
that creates further inspiration in the
future a truly virtuous circle thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: