Press "Enter" to skip to content

Why Investing in Public Education is So Risky | Atnre Alleyne | TEDxWilmingtonSalon


there’s so much need in America’s public

education system but I probably should

warn you that investing in education is

an incredibly risky endeavor but that’s

only because there are so many smart and

well-intentioned people that are

investing in all the wrong things and

they don’t even know it

but they probably shouldn’t feel too bad

this isn’t the first time or the first

industry where folks were investing in

the wrong things and had no clue let’s

look at the energy industry hundreds of

millions of dollars were invested in the

solar panel company Solyndra only to see

that company go bankrupt and have to

layoff over a thousand employees now who

would have thought that a innovative

solar panel company like Solyndra would

be such a colossal failure and a blanket

with sleeves called the Snuggie would be

a multimillion-dollar success and I know

some of you guys ordered the Snuggie and

we can look at major league baseball for

other instructive examples about

investing in the in the wrong things and

some of those examples are really well

depicted in the movie Moneyball and

since that’s one of my favorite movies

and I imagine some of you guys have not

seen that movie I’m gonna take some

liberties here and and reenact a really

important scene from that movie for you

guys

and so in this scene Billy Beane who’s

the general manager of the Oakland A’s

he’s talking to his team of and his

played by Brad Pitt he’s talking to his

team of Scouts about how they’re gonna

replace some key players okay so bear

with my acting skills here for a second

guys you’re just talking talking la la

la la la like this is business as usual

it’s not we’re trying to solve the

problem here Billy not like this you’re

not you’re not even looking at the

problem we’re very well aware of the

problem I mean okay good what’s the

problem look Billy we understand what

the problem is

we have to okay good what’s the problem

the problem is we need to replace these

players with what we have Billy says and

the problem is there are rich teams and

there are poor teams and then there’s 50

feet of crap and then there’s us

baseball is an unfair game and now we’ve

been gutted

we’re like organ donors for the rich

Boston has taken our kidneys the Yankees

have taken our heart and you guys are

just sitting around here talking that

same old good body nonsense like we’re

selling genes like we’re looking for

Fabio we’ve got to think differently you

see I’ve been working in education for

over a decade as the founder of a

college prep organization I later worked

in education policy and now I’m leading

an education advocacy organization and

there is no doubt in my mind that

education is also an unfair game and

deeply inequitable and if we’re ever

going to help kids win we also have to

think differently about our approach and

our investments about a year before I

was born

a famous report was released and was

called a nation at risk and it sounded

the alarm about the declining quality of

America’s public education system and it

talked about the impact that that would

have on this country’s prospects and

future and now more than 30 years has

passed and America is still struggling

to provide excellent learning

opportunities for all of its kids let’s

just look at some of the data we can

start at the earliest ages in preschool

black preschool students are four times

more likely than white preschool

students to be suspended suspended let’s

think about that we’re talking about

Elmo loving Dora the Explorer watching

Swiper no swiping

three and four-year-olds getting

suspended we have an inequitable system

let’s go to fourth grade on a national

session of reading only 21% of

low-income students were able to achieve

proficiency compared to 52

scent of their non low-income

counterparts it’s a deeply inequitable

system but this isn’t just a problem for

low-income students or for students of

color nationally families are spending

1.5 billion dollars annually for their

kids in college to take remedial courses

and this is not just for lack of effort

there are a number of really smart

people that are working every day to try

to make this education system better and

a ton of money is spent trying to

educate kids in America nationally we

spent about six hundred billion dollars

annually of public money on pre-k

through secondary education and another

fifty four billion dollars of private

philanthropy is invested annually in

education I mean that’s more than a GDPs

of some countries Poland Sweden Saudi

Arabia but our education system is not

just inequitable because certain

students are not getting the quality of

education they deserve our system is

also inequitable because the folks who

are most impacted by public education or

the primary customers of public

education are the ones who are the least

likely to have an influence on the

decisions that ultimately affect them

let me put that into context I got to

take you guys back a little bit when I

was a teen I worked for the movie

theater and I worked in the concessions

concession stand and they would

encourage us and incentivize us to to

sell combos to customers and just in

case there any doubts about my

credibility and why I’m on this stage I

was an award winning combo seller at the

movie theater seriously I had to let you

guys know and when we were pushing these

combos to customers in any given week if

our box a bunch of crunch if our box a

bunch of crunch was not selling well

with the large popcorn and the three

medium drinks that you could get they’ll

replace it with something like Raisinets

or or Twizzlers and if a given movie

that was not doing well in the box

office office with customers

would not be in the theater for too long

so let’s contrast that with education

there are schools there are classrooms

and their policies that have not been

working well for students and their

families for decades and nothing changes

nothing

so I contend that if we’re ever going to

see lasting and meaningful change in

public education we have to

fundamentally disrupt this inequitable

system now I’m not gonna stand here like

I’m the smartest guy in the room here I

also got this very wrong before too

see I used to work for the Department of

Education in Delaware for four years and

I led a research work and policy efforts

and I got to see the good the bad and

the ugly of the education policy process

and for those of you who might not know

that much about Delaware it’s a small

state less than a million people

somewhere in the midpoint between

Washington DC and New York City and I

came to the state at a really great time

in 2012 the state had just received 120

million dollars of federal funds to

implement a whole slew of education

reforms that would change the quality

that Delaware’s 130,000 public school

students will receive and it was like a

education reform buffet you had

increased academic standards here we had

more professional development for

teachers here yet coaches for principals

here with stronger accountability here

and we had more data better data

research we had it all we did a lot and

there were some great successes but far

too often great ideas and great

initiatives would succumb to the

stubborn inertia of adults enter

politics now I could be here for a long

time telling you about the types of

stories that depict the type of inertia

and adults enter politics that I’m

referring to I mean you wouldn’t believe

the amount of energy that it takes

sometimes to do certain small things I

mean there was one year

when we worked for months and negotiated

for months to pass a regulation that

said a school principal could go and

observe and evaluate a teacher

unannounced that’s it that was it that

was the wind that year no warning

unannounced observation but I think no

story really captures what I think is

wrong with this system more than a time

that I broke the unspoken rule of

education insiders so let me tell you

little about that as I work the

department i sat in countless meetings

but we were making important decisions

that would affect all of Delaware’s

public school students and I was the

only person of color in the room and

this is an education system in Delaware

where a little over half of Delaware

public school students are students of

color and I was sit in these meetings

and I would see the voice of parents the

voice of students the voice of

communities was never represented at the

table it was just the usual suspects

you’d see interest groups representing

superintendents school principals

teachers higher education always also in

the room as well different times so we

saw all these folks at the table but one

can only tolerate and stomach this

unfortunate reality for so long so at

some point I decided to mix things up a

little bit as is custom for me so as one

important meeting was coming up where

the state was going to be deciding and

discussing how it would assess and

evaluate teacher quality I decided to do

something different I invited dozens of

parents to a public meeting the team I

was working on had garnered a list of

parents as they engaged in what’s called

in the bureaucracy stakeholder

engagement at some point so I took this

list and I just blasted the meeting

invitation to the entire list it was

about 50 people and then something

really interesting happened a few days

later after I sent out my invite the

Secretary of Education received a call

from the state’s teachers union and they

interrogated him like what is your team

doing inviting all these parents to

policy meeting so the secretary

education met with my manager and the

secretary expressed his concern with my

rolled parrot outreach but the so called

damage was already done the invite was

out and so we waited so on the day of

the meeting we all convened and four

parents showed up only four out of the

50 or so that I invited

so I guess my experiment failed well not

so fast

with only four parents in the room the

decision-makers at a table could not

proceed with business as usual where

they breeze through the agenda and

rubber-stamp things you know they

actually had to explain their policy

positions they had to answer

common-sense questions they had to

receive pressure and pushback from the

folks who were going to be most impacts

but impacted by the decisions that they

were making and that’s when it became

abundantly clear to me what if we

empowered parents students and

communities to participate in the

education policy process and push for

policies that are truly student-centered

what if education was a true partnership

with those who know the policy and the

parents and the communities that know

their needs intimately you know research

would tell us that this works but it’s

also just common sense

and if this is a type of system that we

like to see there are some clear things

that we can do for starters we can show

up we can find out when that next school

board meeting is taking place or that

state board meeting is taking place or

whatever the venue we’re important

policy decisions are being made we can

show up and not just show up alone

invite someone or maybe invite 50 people

like I did and pressure the system and

it doesn’t matter if you’re a parent of

students and public schools or not it

doesn’t matter if you are a parent

we need our country our communities our

corporations to understand that we are

all we are all paying the price right

now for an education system that

systematically under prepares so many

students for their potential the second

thing we could do is change how we

approach philanthropy in education and

I’m talking about our individual

philanthropy but also the flan to be

coming out of our corporations and our

foundations we need to invest in efforts

to disrupt the stubborn inertia that I

referred to and this means we don’t

always focus on organic organizations

but we need to focus on organizing as

well so our communities can

underrepresented communities to a place

of excellence we need to move our

investments beyond its expenses on

pricey consultants and elaborate plans

to expenses on the public pressure to

push past the politics that have

advantage adults for so long and

disadvantage so many students you see I

have to close with another quote from

Moneyball because it’s my favorite movie

where Billy Beane or Brad Pitt said if

we play like the Yankees in here we are

going to lose to the Yankees out there

you see simply put we cannot continue to

approach an inequitable system as if

it’s business as usual and expect to see

any success but I know that we can

create a winning system a winning

education system for all kids when we

think and invests differently thank you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: