Press "Enter" to skip to content

Why Indian Children Are Malnourished | Pavitra Mohan | TEDxShivNadarUniversity


good morning everyone

if all of us in this room were

malnourished and we grew up we may not

have been here some of us may not have

survived the childhood and most others

would have an intelligence that is lower

than what is required to see us through

the school and surely not to get into

another university but we escaped and

millions of children in this world but

are not so fortunate when I was younger

I was I was really family I wasn’t like

what I am today and on seeing me I’m one

of my earlier photographs that you see

here somebody said you know you really

look scrawny and famished did you grow

up in Ethiopia and I said you know

growing up in India would have been a

more appropriate explanation because the

malnutrition levels in India are much

higher than that in Ethiopia of course

children in Africa are malnourished very

large number of children in Africa or

malaria this is one of the better

photographs but if you google you will

see large number of starving children in

Africa that’s pretty well known but what

is not well known is that in India the

numbers of children who are malnourished

are much much higher the levels of

malnutrition are almost twice that in

Africa for example 15% of children in

India wasted in the first three years of

their life as compared to seven percent

in Ethiopia or Nigeria now but why does

this happen

India is a one of the fastest growing

economies in the world we are a food

replete nation we have very very stable

government’s and democracy that we are

very proud of as opposed to that many

countries in Africa have unstable

governments struggling economies HIV has

wiped off large populations there

how does India pull off this dubious

distinction still to have higher levels

of children’s and the nutrition this is

something that had bothered us for a

long time and like other health care

professionals earlier in life I went

with the belief that it is largely a

problem of ignorance of families right

families do not know what to feed their

children because in general the

countries has enough food and once they

know what they what the children need to

be fed how to feed and how many times

you feed etcetera

problem will be solved and I was

involved in large-scale programs that

intended to do just that to inform

families on what to feed how to feed and

how to care for children didn’t really

work last few years then we started our

clinics and surgeons southern Rajasthan

we were really frustrated by this whole

nutrition education approach there

wasn’t enough nutritious food in the

households mothers just didn’t have

enough time to take care of the children

with all the back-breaking tasks that

they were doing and as a result you

could see that the mothers and children

but also Malorie we saw a large number

of women who came to a clinics but

themselves malnourished and that’s when

we started this exploration that I’m

going to share with you a bit today in

the year of 2006 in the last decade

World Health Organization assessed

growth patterns of almost 8500 children

across six cities in five continents of

the world they measured the growth and

weights of children across the first

three years and what they found this is

what they found that the child whether

is born in Accra in Ghana or city of

Davis in USA or Oslo in Norway or

muscadine Oman the growth patterns were

similar absolutely similar which means

that there is absolutely no difference

between the growth potential that

children have children everywhere in the

world have similar growth potential

provided certain conditions are met and

what are those conditions one needs to

better understand it’s definitely not

the genes that is restricting Indian

so can India produce a Magic Johnson you

know who this guy is

Satnam Singh the first NBA player who is

in fact a few inches taller than Magic

Johnson so yes

India can have people who grow as well

who are taller who are stronger than

children anywhere else in the world then

what is it that explains the differences

the first thing that comes to the mind

is

as you know the mothers who are better

nourished themselves are likely to

produce better nourished babies and

poorly nourished mothers are likely to

give birth to pool in a rich babies

so some facts rural Indian women in

general do eat much less than what is

required to stay nourished and healthy

they eat on an average 550 calories

lower and 13 grams lesser protein is it

different in sub-saharan Africa on the

surface it looks similar the amount of

calories that they ingest is largely

similar but whether women are in

sub-saharan Africa or in India but when

it comes to protein there is a huge

difference sub-saharan African women

tend to eat much larger amounts of

protein and that’s largely because of

her much higher consumption of meat and

fish which not only provides better

quality protein but also does so at a

much lower cost and that makes a huge

difference and that’s what results in

African women being almost 6 centimeters

taller than their Indian sisters and

almost 2 points higher in their body

mass index what does this really

translate into it translates into almost

30 percent of Indian children almost one

in every three children were born in

India are born undernourished at Birth

has compared to almost 14 percent in

Africa so that’s what really explains

the difference it’s really a bad start

in life that accounts for these

differences in undernutrition levels but

hold on it’s not the only thing because

a large number of children also become

malnourished after they are born in the

first few years of life it is the care

that makes a use difference and the care

depends quite a bit on the caregiver

mother in most cases and it’s the

mother’s own ability to care for their

children and for themselves that makes a

huge difference in the first few years

of life are Indian women less empowered

than African women to take care of

themselves and their children

it seems so three very eminent gentlemen

dr. ramalinga swamy doctor urban johnson

and dr. john roading representing

different continents but combined by

their interest in children and their

experience of having worked in

India and Africa try to answer this

question in the last decade and what did

they conclude they said that women in

sub-saharan Africa in general enjoy much

greater opportunity and freedom than

women in South Asia they said that

subordinated millions of women in South

Asia neither have the knowledge not the

freedom nor means to take care of

themselves and to act in the best

self-interest of themselves and their

children since then there has been much

more empirical evidence on this issue

world economic forum analysis repeatedly

year after year puts Indian women much

lower than sub-saharan on equality is an

opportunity to education and for

opportunities to work and earn so to sum

up children everywhere in the world have

similar opportunities to grow they have

similar potential but what really

matters is whether their mothers are

equally well nourished do they receive a

nurturing and caring environment in the

first few years of life and their own

ability to go out in the world and to

work earn and to get educated that’s

what really makes the difference so at

this stage people often ask that what is

it that we can do and to you as young

students I would say that just go out in

the world go stop by at the nearest

construction site look at the child of a

woman laborer who is there and check

what has he eaten who cares for her when

the mother is working and constructing

homes what does the mother herself eaten

in the past 24 hours go to a village if

you have time and see what care does the

child receive them when the mother is

out collecting firewood go also see

places where there is a nurturing

environment and children are well cared

for why is it that all disadvantaged

children who require such care are not

in such places and then if somebody

tells you that undernutrition can be

treated by a pill or a magic bullet

tell them that you know better and if

somebody says that economy can grow when

half of Indian children and one-third of

adults are malnourished tell them that

you know better go out in the world go

discover it for yourself and find your own moorings good luck

Please follow and like us: