Press "Enter" to skip to content

Why good people do bad things | Einar Øverenget | TEDxOslo


okay let me start out with a question

after all I’m a philosopher that’s what

we do have you ever done anything wrong

even when you knew it was wrong at the

why’d you do that now I sound like your

parents do you remember how you answered

your parents I don’t know do you

remember how mused everybody’s answer

and how amuse they are when your

children answer the same way there’s a

philosophical question error why do we

do what we do why don’t we do something

else

the obvious answer because it made a

choice we don’t have to do what we do

we can choose let me make hundreds

thousands of choices every day in the

sense of doing this rather than that but

making a choice is not just a matter of

doing that but is also my road being the

one setting the direction for your life

and by will do this rather than that

because you think that’s the right thing

to do our rationality enable us to

reflect on our impulses and decide

whether or not to act on those and

historically the view has been that if

you do that we will over time develop

deep-rooted stable moral beliefs virtues

that will guide us to life and help us

make good decisions and withstand social

pressure whatever other people wants you

to do and internal pressure your own

temptations that’s really what freedom

is all about however say that you are a

good person

you have good virtues you have good

moral beliefs you have a good character

that does not though automatically

produce good behavior because human

beings we’re also able to act against

their own principles and even to do so

without having a conscience kick in and

stop us or bad bottles afterwards and we

do that by neutralizing our own roaches

not rejecting them but just saying that

well in general I think this is wrong

but right now I think it’s right for

some wild reason but in general so I

morale neutralization usually starts

with the experiencing what we can call

moral dissonance you are tempted to do

something you shouldn’t do ever been

we don’t like to be in the dissonance we

like to solve dissonance one way to

solve the distance is not to do it of

course but we would like to do it what

now say you walk down the street and

there cell in front of you there’s a $20

bill laying on the ground obviously

somebody lost it but there’s no one

around so you cannot see the rightful

owner

so we have two options now you can pick

her up or not if you pick it up you get

two other options you can keep it or not

I’m not keeping it that would be trying

to give it back to the rightful owner

but there isn’t want to see there of

course you can make the detour to the

police station hand it in and say I

found this and hopefully the rightful

owner will come and claim it but you

know that’s going to take time you don’t

really have the time it’s a detour and

after all you get this little gift from

the universe in your hand it could be a

nice lunch but you’re not a thief you

don’t steal money you think it’s wrong

to keep money that isn’t yours so if you

keep it

even without knowing it you start this

in a dialogue we try to find a good

reason for this before we really make up

your mind and what will you say to

yourself now you think you know

everybody else would do this wouldn’t

they

and after all no harm is done or the

harm is already occurred somebody lost

it I’m sure they’re sorry about that but

I’m not going to add any add any harm to

the universe by keeping it so what

you’re doing now you starting to

neutralize your virtues I’m going to

describe seven different ways in which

we neutralize our virtues or moral

beliefs one for each day of the week so

then you can do it afterwards or maybe

not number one we have used already the

denial of responsibility everybody else

would do it it could be the business

person saying that I’m against

corruption but if you’re going to win

this bid we have to bribe someone but in

general I’m against corruption it could

be the athletes saying I’m against

taking illegal drugs in order to succeed

in order to win but I’m going to win

this race I have to do it because

everybody else is doing it so that’s

just how it is I don’t like it but you

know that’s how it is denial the

responsibility number two there is a

denying that you really are producing

any harm you know you keep this money

nobody is harmed by that or you lose

your suitcase somebody stole it maybe

you have two cameras you have one cheap

and one very expensive the cheap one is

in the suitcase

and expensive is at home but what if you

kind of do a little bit like this before

you make your claim to the insurance

company and put the expensive one in the

suitcase

you know no harm done really insurance

companies don’t they make very much

money you know really and everybody else

would do it wouldn’t ya and then we have

to denial the victim you heard somebody

you’re not a person doing that really

you’re a nice person but you did it said

something and then you tell JIT but you

know if he hadn’t said that if she

hadn’t dressed like that she had done

that you know really he asked for it she

had it coming

not my fault number four metaphor of the

ledger

I found this money I deserve this money

I’ve done so much good for people lately

so this is just what I deserve I keep it

you know rewarded by the universe I’ll

have this launch number five the claim

of necessity I had no choice it’s a very

interesting to justify a choice isn’t it

I had no choice if we are gonna win this

race I had no choice I had to take these

drugs because everybody else was doing

it if we were in a win this bid I had no

choice because everybody else was doing

really had no choice

number six justification by comparison

one my favorites really other people are

doing things that I’ve worse

and you know so much bad has been done

in the world so that one is always open

it is always possible to find somebody’s

done something worse I grew up with my

father he was a police officer he’s

retired now when and people then tend to

think that when I grew up I had a very

strict upbringing not so really because

he in his line of work he experienced

and saw and met you know extreme

violence brutality homicide really bad

things so when I got back home from

school having done my more or less

innocent pranks I was just kind of

almost reading his mind then he was

thinking did he kill anybody it could be

that bad and the seventh one

postponement I see this might be wrong

let’s use not to think about that right

now

I wanna reflect on that you know when I

retire I’m going to spend the last 10

years of my life and then I reflect on

all those things that were wrong I’ll do

it then not now don’t have the time so

here we have seven different ways of

neutralizing your own roaches no you

don’t reject them you keep them in a

very nice place I have him here but they

don’t apply right now because and they

do this so why should we focus on this

phenomena really ways to learn from it I

think we should focus on this phenomena

in order to understand the true meaning

of human freedom freedom is not just a

matter of acting a lot you know doing

this right all the time

and it’s not just a matter of having

good virtues I’m a great character I’m a

nice person I hope it beliefs it is

trying to connect the two that’s the

important thing and that’s the nature of

human freedom not doing whatever you

want you shouldn’t do that really really

think about it all the things you want

don’t do it especially at home no I do

technical training for professionals I’m

often asked then you know very effective

people they’re very practical people and

you know we’re operative and they ask me

what is philosophy really all about and

my definition now is trying to

understand what you already know but you

know it so well so we have become

unaware of it is trying to reflect upon

established practice and that’s

important and I invite them to become

philosophers because in their daily work

in dealing sort of with the world and

the job they’re very effective it’s fast

and I said well that’s good but you must

also think

because why do you actually do what you

do are you you think you’re choosing

here but aren’t you really just keep you

know giving in to social pressure do

whatever other people want to do or

aren’t you just giving in to the you

know your own once and so forth your own

temptations are you really making

choices try to pay attention to how you

justify your actions that really at the

center of ethics how do you go about

justifying your actions so I invite them

to become philosophers because I think

that’s important in the professional

world for your reputation for building

trust for the nature of your relations

it’s important to do it I think is

important in our private lives too to do

the same thing at this building trust so

now I invite you to become philosophers

from now on look at your justifications

thank you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: