Press "Enter" to skip to content

Whose shame is it anyway? | Minh Dang | TEDxBerkeley


we have fallen down again tonight in

this world it’s hard to get it right

trying to make your heart fit like a

glove Oh what it needs is love love love

in the words of a dear friend this is my

love song to you okay technically that

was incurred mikaelsons saw but the next

15 minutes and 29 seconds are my song

they’re part of my love story and now

each of you play a role 11 years ago to

this very day I severed ties with two

sexual predators unfortunately those two

predators were also my parents tomorrow

is what I call my freedom day the day

where I celebrate my sovereignty and

mourn the losses I have suffered as I

mourn my losses I’ve created space to

gain so much I’ve gained clarity about

Who I am and what it means to be free I

want to share with you one of the most

important lessons I’ve learned in

freedom if you’re willing please close

your eyes I want you to think about your

story the terms and labels that you

identify with for me they are Bay Area

native a woman a backpacker a survivor

of child abuse and incest a survivor of

slavery and human trafficking now with

your eyes still closed

please raise your hand if you identify

with anything I just shared about myself

all right

thank you now raise your hand if you

identify as a prostitute okay raise your

hand if you’d like to be called a

prostitute

and lastly raise your hand if you’ve

alright go ahead and open your eyes one

of the most important lessons I’ve

learned in freedom is that there is no

such thing as a prostitute as you can

imagine no one raised their hand to

state that they were a prostitute and no

one raised their hand to say that they

wanted to be called one and no one I’m

pretty sure

despite the blinding lights raise their

hand to identify that they use the

services of a prostitute in an audience

this large that is highly unlikely so

why is it that so few people raise their

hands

shame in our collective consciousness we

believe that prostitutes are pariahs

that they are inherently shameful there

is something wrong with them for what

they do with their bodies and they do

not deserve our association they along

with pedophiles are among the lowest

status of our humanity what we have

failed to recognize is that they are not

inherently shameful we have assigned

this shame we have assigned this low

status and we use this low status in

order to justify the way that we treat

the people we call prostitutes now what

is a prostitute anyway I’ve traveled the

country training and speaking and I’ve

asked people what do you think about

when you hear the word prostitute two

things come up one a woman – someone who

sells sex now let’s set aside the fact

that there are men and children who sell

sex and let’s interrogate the stereotype

so yes there are women who sell sex but

what is inherently shameful about that

for the most part in our society we

believe that people who sell sex are

disgusting there’s something wrong with

them I mean it’s okay to like sex but

they like it a little too much and they

like it so much they want to do it all

the time that’s not normal right and if

I go by them it’s because I’m doing them

a favor that’s all they’re good for

they’re not smart enough to do something

else

some of you anti trafficking activists

or others might think no no no

no one there has any choice to be there

they’re forced to be there they have no

agency those poor pitiful prostitutes

we just need to save them and help teach

them are clean dignified pure ways of

living all right some of you might be

thinking men you’re being a little harsh

I might have thought some of those

things but I don’t really believe

they’re shameful I’m a progressive

Berkeley grad I mean everyone can be

whoever they want and Berkeley right and

if you really have never thought any of

those thoughts that I shared or

something similar can you please

introduce yourself to me after because

you are a rare species now what does

that mean for the rest of us that means

that we have and we continue to

contribute to a signing shame to the

people we call prostitutes now before

you cut your pearls and write yourself

off as an exception I want to tell you

that I am one of the most complicit

people that I know

I believe that prostitutes are shameful

since I was little I mean this little I

know I’m really cute and it’s kind of a

low blow to put a child picture in there

it was that or cat videos but it’s a

serious family photo so you had to put

that in there um

despite my cuteness my father was raping

me at this age and it was this age that

I began to believe that I was a

prostitute see I was too young to know

the word for prostitute or sex but I

knew that my mother felt about me the

way she felt about the other women and

children my father was using and I knew

she felt that I was a mistress that he

was using to cheat on her – my mother I

was the sexual predator my father wasn’t

the pedophile I was making my father do

this to me with my disgusting sluttiness

my mother wasn’t harming me I was

harming her we call this projection my

mother did not feel shamed she made me

feel ashamed and that I felt in spades

and

enact my therapist calls purifying the

parents I took the shame out of my

parents and I put it in me

I took the badness out of them and I put

it in me because if I was bad then I

gained hope I could do something about

it and everybody else who was doing what

I was doing was also bad and they could

fix themselves to see at this age you’re

in what we call the magic years kids

believe in Superman and superheroes I

believe that a prostitute was just like

one of those superheroes an identity

that we created the thing is is that we

tell children or they figure out that

Superman and Santa Claus and superheroes

don’t exist we don’t tell people that

about prostitutes we don’t say to them

that there’s no such thing as a

prostitute we don’t say there’s no such

thing as good people who have good sex

and bad people who have bad sex we don’t

tell them the truth which is that

there’s no such thing as sexual virtue

because it is not the act of having sex

selling sex or even buying sex that is

the problem predation is the problem

sexual predation is one form of

predation one way that we prey on

another human being but sexual predation

is not about sex

it is about power it is about dominating

another human being and this is where

projection and shame come back in in

order to dominate another human being we

need to make them less than we are we

project our shame onto them and say I am

NOT disgusting you’re disgusting you are

not worthy of the same rights and

dignity that I am worthy of and I can

use any excuse to make that so we use

this projection in shame to justify our

violence towards one another whether

that violence is a microaggression

or complete enslavement our shame

unfettered can do harm we try to pass it

on to someone else I don’t want to feel

bad you feel bad so I mentioned I’m

complicit right

in college a friend of mine told me that

she was molested by her father I said I

don’t believe you I don’t recommend

doing that it was pretty awful the truth

is is I didn’t believe myself

and I could not admit that I felt so

ashamed of the fact that in college my

father was still raping me and my mother

and father were selling me while I went

to this University I didn’t want to feel

bad I wanted her to feel bad and her to

feel bad for making me feel bad I tried

to give her my shame luckily I evolve

and I went back and I apologized to this

friend a few years later and she was

gracious and accepting but I still feel

sad and bad about the ways that I did

harm to that relationship every day

there are people like me who try and

pass on the pain and shame of what was

done to them because they cannot deal

with it my parents did this dayvid this

to an extreme but predators are people

people who cannot love any longer but

they weren’t born this way their

capacity to love was destroyed every day

we can destroy our capacity to love or

I’m asking you to stretch your capacity

to love a little bit further I want you

to think about the people to whom you

give your shame

whether that’s someone who sells sex a

trans person a Republican someone who

has high heels someone who for me it

used to be someone who highlighted their

hair think about the people who you need

to be bad and ask yourself why do I need

them to be in the shameful category why

do I need them to be bad and think about

now ask yourself what do I feel bad

it is time that we release the people we

call prostitutes from our moral

indictment from passing on our shame

what if people who sell sex willingly

are not prostitutes but sex workers who

have rights and who also need our

support and who have probably been

through trauma as well what if people

who were forced to sell sex are

brilliant and clever and smart and

enterprising and traumatised and need

our help

but don’t need us to save them if your

social justice work is rooted in

soothing your own shame by trying to be

good enough and saving everyone well

unfortunately join the club but join me

in also transforming our motivations

join me in healing ourselves and our

communities not other people’s

communities over their anti-trafficking

work isn’t just about ending sexual

violence we need to think about how each

of us play a role in dehumanizing

someone this journey is not just about

healing our own pain and shame but

thinking about the ways that we can pass

it on that we have the capacity to do

harm as well you’re going to walk away

from this talk asking and wondering

what’s an action step how do I help

people who went through what men went

through how do I take action and join

the anti-trafficking movement dealing

with your projected shame is the action

step that I’m giving you

it is a hard one but anti-trafficking

work like any other social justice work

is about how we can de hue minh eyes

someone make someone less than we are

and justify how they deserve less than

we do I’ve learned that as I deal with

my shame my social justice work becomes

more about walking doing speaking with

this is a group of women who have walked

with me my understanding of freedom has

been profoundly affected by them and

many others who are not pictured here

these smiles are hard-won

they were fought for with tears they

were fought for through hard

conversations about how we want to pass

our shame on to other people you know

those people who don’t deal with their

childhood stuff and how we try to pass

our shame to one another these women and

many others helped me believe and

understand that there is no such thing

as a prostitute they helped me

understand that I was never am not and

will never be a prostitute one more time

think about a time that you felt deep

shame now think about someone who loved

you in that shame maybe they thought

that you had nothing to feel ashamed of

or maybe they could sit with you in that

healthy shame and walk with you on the

journey out of that that feeling is what

we need more of no one deserves to be in

the category of shameful we all deserve

started with a song I’m going to end

with a verse from that same song happy

is the heart that still feels pain

darkness drains in light will come again

swing open up your chest and let it in

just let the love

love-love begin everyone if you haven’t

already open your eyes and let the love begin

Please follow and like us: