
hypothesis and batteries people could
look at the same exact thing and see
something completely different that
seems a little counterintuitive but let
me explain
oh this is a photo of Kendrick Lamar
acclaimed and Grammy winning hip-hop
artist on the cover of Rolling Stone
magazine this is also a photo of
Kendrick Lamar on the cover of GQ
magazine and as you can tell these two
depictions of the same human being the
same pop-culture figure are quite
different under my experiment I asked
participants to look at each photo to
describe what they saw and more
importantly tell me how they felt
whether or not they liked the photo and
so when I show this photo I had one
participant look at it and said that’s a
dope photo of Kendrick I like it because
it’s hip-hop
right there he looks hardcore he looks
like he’s been through a lot I think the
photo is pretty representative of
Kendrick
he talks a lot about pain and his Saul’s
struggles and hardships from where he is
people dealing with addiction and just
in general rough lifestyle in Compton I
had a second participant look at the
same exact photo and say I know can’t
drink of it because I listen to some of
his music but beyond but don’t know
really much beyond that
his clothes I think make him look like a
gang member
gang members might wear clothes like
that he looks confident but he’s not
smiling his hand is in his pocket which
is kind of threatening we see the same
divergence of perception with this
second photo the same first participant
said in this photo it looks like he’s
saying I’m just getting out there I got
to look clean for the people and I got
to put a good impression for the people
I’m going to hold a mic in my hand to
let people know that I’m a musical
artist you got the skinny tie on with a
cheesy smile and a nice baby
but the Kendrick now is not trying to
show
put on a show Friday he’s real so this
looks a little cheesy to me in that
sense I had the second participant look
at the same photo and say I like this
photo of Kendrick more than the other
one I just think he looks a little more
friendly and welcoming I guess the suit
makes him look very sharp like just
about to present at the Oscars he looks
happy I would want to talk to him what
was really interesting to me is that we
have two participants looking at two
very different representations of the
same figure and even though they saw the
same things they felt something very
different
they use their prior context their prior
life experiences to inform and
rationalize the judgments that they made
they could be looking at the same thing
but seeing something completely
different and this trend continued
throughout my experience these are true
depictions of LeBron James arguably one
of the most well known athletes of our
generation when I show participants
these photos they describe him in the GQ
cover as friendly professional and
welcoming they looked at the Vogue cover
and described it as angry aggressive and
now here’s it here’s an interesting
phenomenon because now we have everyone
all the participants who knew LeBron
James who had some prior knowledge of
them look at these two representations
and feel something completely different
based on how he looked in his photo so
as I was trying to discover the
relationship between media and people I
found that this relationship was more
complex than I thought as I showed
participants each image a pattern began
to emerge while people describe the
contents of each photo with clarity and
consistently they would say LeBron is
wearing a suit he’s smiling he has a
flaming basketball in his hand the way
they felt about it the conclusions they
drew were quite different and based upon
their personal experiences now what is
the same of us what does it mean that
two students from the same University
could look at the same exact image and
see and more importantly feel something
so different
what is the impact of this phenomenon on
our everyday lives you see I think we
take for granted our own worldview our
own perspectives because they’re formed
by our own life experiences the things
that happen around us all the time but
we often don’t consider the complex
relationship that each one of us have
with media and how that shapes our
perception of reality as individuals
we’ve always craved the ability to
contextualize our human experience with
those around us we want the ability to
say we want to look at someone and say I
see what you’re doing what you’re
thinking what you’re saying when you’re
feeling so that I know how to think how
to act and how to feel not necessarily
to mimic those around us but simply to
contextualize who we are our unique
human experience in the spectrum of
possibility and the funny thing is that
media has provided us with that ability
that ability to say I know how to act in
a situation I watch a sick and now I
know how to act on a date i watch the
red carpet and now I know how to act how
but because of how old we are where we
come from our race ethnicity class
gender and things that we don’t
necessarily have control over because of
these factors we’re exposed to different
types of media and not only are we
exposed to different types of media we
process this media point differently and
as a result we all have unique
relationships with media and because of
this our perceptions of the world
diverges from one another we can be
looking at the same facts the same
images reading the same facebook
statuses and see them feel something
completely different and our social
context begin to diverge so in 2016
a time when most of us are attached to
our devices looking at our screens Media
has become this pervasive and constant
filter for how we see society how we see
reality and as we Traverse our different
lives important to recognize that we
each have unique filters we inhabit
unique digital worlds even though we sit
together here as part of one Lehigh
community we actually are part of very
distant worlds our unique filters as
they manifest on our Facebook news feeds
who we follow on Instagram what news
platforms we care about as a result of
this we inhabit very distinct digital
worlds fit to our exact personalities
feeding into our very specific emotional
needs and I think this is quite
problematic yeah when it comes to
trivial things like what memes we enjoy
what public figures we like to follow
what Instagram pages we enjoy our
diversion filters have relatively little
impact they’re harmless it doesn’t
matter that I like to follow one dog
Instagram page and you like to follow
cats that doesn’t matter but when it
comes to more serious issues and content
that requires thoughtfulness discussion
clarity empathy most importantly love a
divergent filters Bayless we self
indulge in these echo chambers and
clickbait news articles that only affirm
our deepest emotional drives and
insecurities the internet social media
news these are institutions that the
highest level ideally should be bringing
us together and they should free us from
the limitations of our media physical
realities but instead you see that
I do think it’s interesting Albert that
people are beginning to place blame as
society begins to realize how much
they say the media is dividing us based
on things like waste class politics
recently people have been condemning
Facebook for not doing a better job and
calling them misinformation that spread
like wildfire over the past election
season and ideally yes we should fold
these platforms these companies to a
higher standard so that they can provide
a service that ultimately leads to
social good put the divertor the
responsibility that we have and the
guilt and blame that we have onto these
companies I would feel that that sense
of it is a bit misplaced because in the
economic social and political atmosphere
that we live in now I don’t see a future
where the role of media will
automatically change because in the
system that are so entrenched in our
society media has become a zero-sum game
to grasp moments of our attention a
phenomenon that has less dollars to say
that we’re living in an attention
economy media is no longer service of
entertainment media element service of
information but not entertainment and
emotion all Ed’s videos and even these
magazine covers that I showed you before
are all designed to evoke specific
emotions sparked discussion out of age
to cost shares a purchase ultimately for
profit driven incentives as a result
when you think about the dynamics that
we’ve been talking about and bring them
in the context of today’s aim which is
ignorance we have to see media as a
two-edged sword because on one hand
media has allowed us to transcend our
media physical realities it’s allowed us
to gain exposure to things that we
wouldn’t have media is the reason why
people like me you live
in Pennsylvania get to know what is
happening in North Dakota and
potentially get engaged in that process
I think that’s an extremely powerful and
good thing but on the other hand media
and more specifically our digital
filters have limited our worldview
feeding us things that we like to see
that we already know and these dynamics
aren’t constant tension with one another
and the frustrating thing is the media
companies and platforms that we rely on
they’re not obligated to resolve this
tension in fact they’re more aligned to
exploitive these media companies offer
us suggestions curating content for us
that we know you will enjoy they shield
us from looking at things that might
make us use their platform less they
feed into our passions our insecurities
our ego and every facet of our
complicated identities just to make sure
that we continue to use their platform
to continue to use their content in
order for us to feel comfortable self
righteous and satisfied so if I’m saying
that the blame and responsibility does
not fall solely on these companies the
question then becomes how do we accept
and respect the beauty of our divergence
digital worlds how to reconcile with the
fact that me and you we actually like
different things and we are going to see
things differently how to respect that
fact and yet work together
simultaneously bring them together to
build unity how do we learn about the
other the unknown in a way that isn’t
meaningful authentic and long-lasting
because the media has always provided a
crutch for us so that we don’t have to
do the work so that we don’t have to go
in there and engage in the unknown
without bias or fear it inhibits our
self-awareness and motivates the
projector insecurities our ego our
mentality outwards instead of in words
in order to build unity and this
era of divergence caused by our digital
worlds we need to curb our dependence on
filtered experiences and instead truly
engage and immerse ourselves in direct
ones so I’ll leave you with a quote
stripped of your ordinary surroundings
your friends your daily routines your
refrigerator full of food your closet
full of your clothes with all this taken
away you’re forced into through into
direct experience I eventually realized
that direct experience is the most
valuable experience that I can have thank