Press "Enter" to skip to content

What We Can Learn From Mountain Communities | Nancy Perini Chin | TEDxUniversityofRochester


in 2011 for the first time I went to my
ancestral village in north
bordick authority had been in that
location for at least 800 years which
spoke to a well adapted population that
knew had to live in the challenging
environment of the mountains they did
things collectively and cooperatively
they brought in the hey together they
decided collectively which timber to
take from from the forest and they
decided with one another how the land
would be farmed and shaped but they also
partied really well that was part of
their social cohesion parties were
almost as long as those winters they
experienced and an eighteenth century
poem described them as being so lively
that depth feared them and that they had
a great amount of mortar being motor
being translates from the Italian very
roughly as that kind of excitement and
energy the children experienced when
they play with each other or that a
woman experiences when she goes to meet
her lover so they had more of being they
had this connection to each other they
had the connection to an astonishingly
beautiful landscape that it folk deep
emotion from them but when I looked at
the contemporary public health data
about this village about the inhabitants
who lived there now what I saw was in
deep contrast to what was described in
their history and what appears in their
landscape the rates of depression
alcoholism and suicide were higher than
the rest of Italy and they had a
demographic landslide of youth out
migration from the villages how could
this be how could they go from water
being to so morbid
and why should we care why should we
care that mountain villages are being
abandoned by their inhabitants not just
in Italy but around the world well
according to the United Nations 13% of
the world’s population lives in mountain
communities that represents 915 million
people and it turns out that if you’ve
been in a landscape for centuries that
you’re good stewards of these Lyn these
landscapes I always think of human
populations in a landscape of damaging
and reversing ecological progress but it
turns out that if you have history of
experience in this then you’re actually
good manager about resources and there
are a lot of mountain resources that we
depend on as lowlanders that keep us
healthy as well so most of the fresh
water in the world originates in
mountain communities the water that we
use at the household level the water we
use in industry in agriculture to
generate electricity mountain
communities how amazing biodiversity
including species that are unique to
high altitudes and all of us participate
in the beauty of mountain communities
either through recreation or through
spiritual solace and pilgrimages we want
mountain communities to flourish we
don’t want people to abandon their
villages that puts us at risk flooding
in the lowlands if they don’t manage the
forest correctly or a having polluted
water if they don’t manage the waterways
now it turns out that the people of Boca
were worried about this problem as well
and I was supported in my curiosity by
methodologies from both anthropology and
public health in anthropology you are
supposed to empathetically understand
people in their own actual setting the
idea is to immerse yourself in the
community to follow people around in
their ordinary lives watch what they do
ask them questions about it and see what
they produce in public health it’s now
the Disciplinary standard that we do
research through a community engaged
approach the people we work with are not
objects of study under a microscope but
their subjects active participants in
shaping the research questions
recruitment strategies and disseminating
the findings so both of these supported
my curiosity and people were very
generous in joining us in this this
product of inquiry they took us to
places that were important to them the
previous picture was a high pasture
where one of our best friends in the
project used to take the cows in the
summer this is our friend Mario Salah
who took us to the barn where his family
still stores implements for farming they
showed us their handicrafts this is Lala
Renata showing us the pillowcases she
embroidered for her wedding
using the themes of local flowers and
this is our pantry Laurent Reata
one of the original founding families he
took us into his metal workshop so we
could interview him there they were
active participants in what we were
doing and we were grateful to be able to
interview them and talk with them in
these settings
now as our interviews continued and we
spent more time in the village and by we
I mean me and a team of you of our
undergraduates what we learned was that
youth spell felt especially estranged
from the beautiful landscape and from
their elders they felt dismissed
disregarded disrespected and when I went
to the elders tonight said did you know
that the youth don’t feel respected here
the dancer I got back I’m choking on it
a little because I’m still surprised as
well they’re stupid did you ever listen
to them talk and it was like bingo I
think I found the problem here so what
we decided to do in collaboration was
the village was a photo voice project
photo voice is used both in anthropology
and public health as a way to give
research tools to the community so that
they systematically collected around
problems that are essential to them it
gives them the right to research so what
happens in a proto voice project is you
give the population cameras you show
them how to use it to create a narrative
and then you interview them about their
photos what is shown here what does it
mean to you what sort of emotions does
it evoke and then you put on a public
display narratives photos and the
photographer’s and you invite the
community to come see what they found so
we gave them assignments in four
different categories we said do a
self-portrait do a portrait of somebody
you love do a portrait of a place you
love and then do a portrait of a problem
that you think needs to be fixed and
they embraced this and ran with it
this is Luca and Paolo at their
self-portrait their young videographers
they have their own YouTube station they
want to be known beyond Borka but they
know they can do that right from their
town they don’t feel that they’re forced
out to go for education or jobs they
have created and empowered themselves to
have a voice beyond their village this
is Mateo Mateo desperately wants to stay
in Boca he doesn’t have neutral feelings
about this he deeply resents that he
might have to go elsewhere he just a
photograph himself
at the intersection of the mighty
boy-toy River and the stately aunt allow
he wanted to capture both emotions that
he sees reflected in his landscape the
power of the river the tranquility of
the mountain this is Marco Marco spent a
long time arranging what he tells us
it’s just a small part of his cart
collection around him so he could take
his self Parcher there he said I I
didn’t clean up the rest of the room I
wanted to be seen in my natural setting
jacquimo when he decided to photograph a
problem looked at themes of caring and
abandonment this is one of the trails
through the mountains and he says we
don’t take enough care of the land
that’s so important to us a landscape
that gives us comfort this shows a lack
of caring this is also doesn’t make a
lot of economic sense since tourists
come here to see a beautiful landscape
and we’re not cleaning up Mario took
this picture of an abandoned second home
people used to come to Barca on vacation
for the whole summer and now they might
only come for two weeks this is a
disruption and an eyesore said Mario he
was very upset that these abandoned
houses are uncared-for when we asked the
teens to do a photograph of somebody
they loved much to our surprise they all
photographed men and men were shown in
unusual capacities as being emotionally
nurturing generous supported that their
dreams and what they wanted to do this
was the only photograph we had of a
woman
this is Mirta a friend of Marcos who had
made him lunch and Marco thought it was
important that she’s hidden behind this
bowl as most women’s labor and caring is
unrecognized and unrewarded he thought
we should pay more attention to the
people who care for us even if their
work is invisible
we took all the photos and we took the
narratives and we displayed them in the
community hall the turnout was the best
we’ve had at any of our community events
mothers cried fathers embrace their
children the mayor took a careful look
at every photograph and read every
narrative the teens were much encouraged
they were so excited about the success
that they took their exhibition to a
regional scholarly conference on the
fragility of mountain communities they
were the only community people who
presented their they were the youngest
people at this conference they came away
from that conference so energized and so
confident that they’ve now started
teaching Photovoice to other teens as a
way to create social change and this
summer what the teens are planning on
doing is documenting through photographs
and videos their attempts to create the
changes that they documented in their
photos last summer they’re confident
they can make change that they can
document the process and they can teach
it to other teens curiosity empowers
communities but curiosity plus research
skills doubly empowers them thank
Please follow and like us: