Press "Enter" to skip to content

What horror films teach us about ourselves and being human | Dr. Steven Schlozman | TEDxNashville


Wow standing ovations haven’t done
anything yet
it’s don’t hardly feel right as they say
okay sorry
this is your last thing right so this is
why you’re gonna look at that behind you
that’s a mirror okay that’s a mirror of
all of you not trying to be insulting
it’s just true and it’s a mirror of me
it’s a mirror pretty much anybody who
looks at it except the guy in the
picture cuz we know he doesn’t show up
on film right we know that’s how it
works but it’s okay that that’s a mirror
because if it were more pristine if it
were more kind of accurate I think it’d
be hard to look at this is what I’m
gonna try and tell you about horror it
teaches us about ourselves it actually
entertains us and helps us to love each
other even more and I know it sounds
like a cliche so you’re gonna have to
bear with me for a little bit and you’re
gonna have to bear with me as I as I
tell you some stories so let’s let’s get
started that’s me as just bangs make the
difference
when I was 11 years old with fangs I I
saw a vampire I did he was someone’s
brother this vampire and he was hovering
outside the second-story window through
which he was trying to gain access and
his his nails they’d grown unnaturally
long throughout the night he he was
staring at me with these kind of
lifeless glowing yellow bile filled eyes
and you know what I let that vampire
into the house I let that vampire into
the house no I’ve been thinking about
that vampire for a long long time he was
scratching at the window
and he was smiling so if I could play
you this scene which we can’t because of
copyright reasons but that’s good
because the music alone would scare the
hell out of me again and I’d be back at
that time when I had bangs so rather
than to do that what I’d like to do for
you is paint the picture I’d like to
take you back so like I said I was 11
years old 1978 you need to picture a
wood-paneled basement ok
and and I’m home all alone it’s it’s
just me and my trusty dog patches who is
this mongrel this white mongrel animal
whose white fur kind of blended
seamlessly with the white shag carpet my
parents were out for the evening my
sister is having a sleepover at
someone’s house and I’ve eaten all but
the last piece of one of those god-given
toastie know frozen pizzas those are
like the greatest gift ever to frozen
food and I’m clutching in one of those
seventies plastic translucent cups which
you’ve seen which you probably still
have in your basement I’m clutching a
glass of dr. pepper and there’s a
vampire at the window so I tell you what
you know what I did I got up and I ran
up the stairs and I turned on every
light in the house every light went on
and I didn’t care that I had little bits
of pizza crumbs stuck to my flannel
shirt and I didn’t care that my dog was
running after me going what’s going on
Steve what’s all the fuss I didn’t care
if that I was pretty sure I’d knocked
over that dr. pepper thing down below
none of that mattered to me what
mattered was that there was a vampire at
the window in the basement so I had to
do something I had to take action my dad
was a doctor so I went into the bathroom
and I found all these tongue depressors
and and then I found these rubber bands
and I made them into crosses I mean like
12 crosses out of rubber bands I really
I did this but you know what the
funniest part of all this is I’m Jewish
I never had never made a cross in my
life you know but I knew the rules but
there was a vampire in the basement and
and I wasn’t taking any chances so so
that vampire those who may have
recognized him that was from the
made-for-tv movie Salem’s Lot that was
on network television I know how they
got that one past network television if
you talk to people from my generation
and you say what was the scariest movie
you’ve ever seen they’ll go through the
cannon they’ll say the am evil horror
The Exorcist The Omen then you say here
we see Salem’s Lot and their eyes will
grow wide and look at this big smile
like oh my god yeah that movie scared me
to death
directed by the same guy who directed
the Texas Chainsaw Massacre but but I
will bet you a thousand tickets to a
thousand horror conventions that if they
tell you their story about Salem’s Lot
it’ll be a lot like the story I just
told you it might not involve toasty
nose frozen pizza it might involve like
a bag of Doritos instead it might
involve a sleepover but nobody sleeps
over right everyone’s up all night in
this delightful terror after having seen
the show and this is what horror does
horror grabs you when you’re 11 years
old which by the way is the average age
when people see their first horror film
it’s 11 so there’s something
transgressive about horror it grabs you
and it makes some of the most loyal fans
on the planet even bad horror films make
money but don’t get me wrong there are
plenty of really really good horror
films films that are celebrated by the
critics and the fans alike let’s wander
through them The Shining who has not had
nightmares about those twins in the
hallway that little kid with his Red Rum
thing and the bike in the elevator the
shiny
there’s Rosemary’s Baby 1960
eight I teach this film to Harvard
undergraduates they’ve grown up with
YouTube right they need the story to
begin middle and end by three minutes
and they sit through two plus hours of
rosemarys descent into literally into
hell and they have this huge smile on
their face and they say why don’t we see
movies like this anymore
there’s it follows a movie that came out
very recently if you want to see a
terrifying depiction of what it means to
come of age in this society this is your
movie there’s this one which we’re going
to come back to Nightmare on Elm Street
a generation of people grew up on this
movie including me
and there’s dawn of the freakin dead if
if you if you see one zombie film this
is the one you want to see 1978 this
movies made what a Romero’s to us with
this movie he showed us that you don’t
need a contagion or radiation or the
rage fires to become a zombie what you
need is a shopping mall
that’s it that’s what makes the change
these are the movies that I love I am a
horror fan I have always loved war these
movies scare me to death but I will go
back again and again with a big smile on
my face and I’ll come out with an even
bigger smile on my face but there’s a
bit of a problem for me here because you
know what I’m also a child psychiatrist
I mean I I have a bona fide MD and I
take care of children for a living not
just the kids I’m raising but the kids
whose parents actually pay me you know
to see them and and if you bring your
kid to see a doctor you do what
everybody does nowadays you google their
name right and in addition to being a
child psychiatrist I’ve written horror
novels I’ve written a couple of novels
I’ve written horror short stories I’ve
been involved in horror movies and video
games we even have a project right now
when we’re using virtual reality to
create a strap around horror experience
so if you google me and you say this is
the person I’m gonna take my trial to to
help you might get that image okay
that’s actually an image from for one of
the books I wrote and you know what
happens the kids they say yeah it’s a
guy want to see but the parents they
don’t do that the parents say uh-uh I
don’t know so if you’re a child
psychiatrist and you like whore
that Harvard man can only get you so far
okay but I think because I’m a
psychiatrist
I’m not so bothered by this I’m actually
sort of fascinated by my love of the
McCobb I’m wondering what is it about
horror that we find so attractive that
those of us who are fans find so
illuminating
how does horror teach us about ourselves
is there something sneakily provocative
about it
why when I was 13 years old still with
things did my grandma Bobby
give me that book my sweet grandma Bobby
for Hanukkah gives me this book I asked
for this book that’s why I wanted to
learn about this genre that I was so
fascinated by is there something kind of
sneakily profound buried in all the gore
and I want to say yes that’s the case
I’m gonna make for you today I’m gonna
say that horror makes us ask questions
that we are very uncomfortable asking in
any other setting except in the campy
displacement that hoar affords and
because of that we can get to know
ourselves better we can tolerate our
foibles better and we could learn to
love each other better so let me give
you some examples I told you were going
to come back to this guy that’s Freddy
Krueger from Nightmare on Elm Street so
I apologize for the spoiler alerts here
if you haven’t seen this movie and most
people have seen this movie many times
or they’re never going to see this movie
there’s not a lot in between on that one
but if you haven’t seen I’m gonna spray
a little bit of it Freddy is a demon
okay now those those claws he has those
are like razor blades that he’s fastened
to these gloves and he haunts teenagers
in their dreams so so he he gets into
their dreams and these kids go to sleep
and he slashes them in their dreams and
then they wake up and they’re still
bleeding in fact if he catches you and
your dream you could bleed to death in
real life so what are the teenagers do
they refuse to go to sleep does that
sound familiar to anybody so the
teenagers refused to go to sleep in this
town and Freddy is a monster he is a
demon and you hate Freddy for most of
the movie but around three quarters into
the movie you learn Freddy’s backstory
Freddy wasn’t always a demon Freddy was
once a human being he was a living
breathing soul just like you and me
and and he committed unthinkable acts in
the very town that he now haunts and he
got caught and he got tried but he’s
released on a technicality that’s the
words in the movie so the town folk
before their kids are grown up they take
justice into their own hands and they
capture Freddie and rather than giving
him back to the authorities they burn
him alive that’s why his face looks like
this you don’t see idiots in the movie
that’s all the backstory so now you’ve
got a problem
I mean Freddie’s a monster he’s got to
go he’s killing children in their dreams
children who didn’t they weren’t even
part of this mob justice thing right
they’re not responsible and nevertheless
no one deserves to be burned alive
everybody who went to that movie
believed in due process everybody in the
movie believes in due process the whole
movies about due process believe it or
not and yet Freddie gets burned alive so
even if you don’t believe in due process
does somebody really deserve that kind
of ending and before you know it just
like that this trifling film this
throwaway this thing that you rented
probably because that face caught your
attention now you’re thrust into this
really interesting discussion of the
ragged world of mob justice and we can
ask those questions much more easily in
a horror film I told you that that
vampire was a brother and I told you
that we let that vampire into the house
so another spoiler alert here I got to a
little bit about Salem’s Lot two
brothers on their way home Suns going
down they know they’re not supposed to
get home after Sun Goes Down and they
know they’re going to be late so there
is of course an obligatory shortcut
through the woods every horror film has
a shortcut through the woods right
that’s the way it works so the big
brother says to the little brother come
on dad’s gonna kill us we don’t get home
on time let’s take the shortcut through
the woods the little brother says dad’s
gonna be really mad if we go through the
woods and the big brother says
accurately dad will never know that we
went through the woods so let’s just go
so the little brother sighs follows the
big brother because he’s stronger he
could move all the brambles out of the
way and when he pops out literally into
his backyard out of where the woods end
he notices that his brother’s not with
him anymore he’s lost his brother in the
woods so he doesn’t think anything
rottens happened he just as scared so he
goes inside he says to his parents look
we came home
through the woods and and I lost my
little brother and I don’t know where he
is and his parents are mad so they send
him upstairs onto that second story and
they go out to look for him and that’s
when that vampire shows up who used to
be his brother in fact that’s why his
brother didn’t make it home his brother
got attacked by the vampire when I was
watching this movie
I wasn’t thinking don’t let him in I was
thinking he will definitely let him in
because it’s his brother okay and that
blood bond of brotherhood transcends the
fact that his brother is now a vampire
now this may seem really silly and trite
to you except take away the word vampire
and insert something new I will not let
my brother at the dinner table because
he is a criminal or I will not let my
brother at dinner table because he’s an
addict or I won’t have dinner with my
brother because he didn’t vote for the
same guy I voted for
and if ever there were a timely debate
that we can handle better and that can’t
be displacement of horror it happens in
movies like this and you might wonder
did I really get that when I was 11 yeah
not because I’m anything special I work
with 11 year olds for a living and I can
tell you they sense intuitively when
there’s a profound question on the table
they get it much better than adults you
know the movie that did this best night
a Living Dead 1968 hundred thousand
dollar budget not even copyright I know
George really well George Romero the guy
who made this movie he didn’t know he’d
be a filmmaker he was and I’m not making
this up
the chief cameraman for mr. Rodgers when
he made this film so he chips in some of
his own money he gets his buddies to
make this movie and it takes the movie
world by storm and in one fell swoop
it attacks racism it attacks sexism it
attacks a war that we as a nation
couldn’t seem to extract ourselves from
it asks us what we do in a postmodern
world when science actually fails us
when we can’t get the answers we need
from science and most importantly it
asks us what we do when fear overpowers
our ability to be reasonable and how we
can become violent all that from a
hundred thousand dollar non copyrighted
he didn’t know he’d be a filmmaker so we
never copyrighted non copyrighted movie
that’s a pretty impressive step if you
think about it so
how does it do that let’s move over to
the brain that the organ I’m actually
supposed to know something about okay
let’s talk for a second about the tricks
our brain play so that we can get to
these fairly profound conclusions from
horror films and we do that through
clowns no we don’t really do that
through clowns but I’ve showed you a
picture of a clown here so you could
engage in the first thing I want to talk
about a metacognition so a metacognition
means thinking about what you’re
thinking about and in studies of people
who like horror films there’s two really
important findings the first one is that
they are frightened so you know this by
measuring things like skin conductance
you can see that people are sweating
respiratory rate heart beat you know
that you at least have a fight-or-flight
response and as those folks come out of
the movie you sort of say okay you had a
fight-or-flight response to us you did
you did
what’d you think of the movie and the
first person of the fight-or-flight
responses never again never again you
say okay thank you for your time but
somebody else comes out and says yeah
yeah I was I was really scared but that
was really good that was really good and
say well what made it good and then they
stopped but they’re saying that’s a good
question I have to think about what made
it good I have to think about what I’m
thinking so clowns are the perfect
example of that many people even before
all the nonsense that happened this fall
are afraid of clowns many people don’t
like clowns nope but why don’t we like
clowns
that’s a metacognitive exercise so let’s
just do a little little experiment here
a little thought experiment a clown at
the circus or at a birthday party or at
a rodeo that’s okay right I mean you
might not like clowns but you understand
that’s where he belongs but a clown in
your backyard holding a meat cleaver at
11:30 at night and staring that’s not
right right that’s a moment that doesn’t
fit the pattern
that’s a metacognitive moment where
you’re saying I know we’re clowns belong
and it’s not there okay
that actually has to do with the second
concept I want to talk about and that’s
the concept of pattern recognition you
recognize the pattern of where a clown
ought to be so another example that’s a
pug everybody does that when I saw that
photo at all so if you ask your
two-year-old is that what is that she’ll
say that’s a doggy and you’ll say why is
that a doggy and she talks her head kind
of funny and like you’re out of your
mind she says well because it looks like
a doggy and if you say well how was the
doggy different from a kitty she’s not
gonna say well kiddies have retractable
claws and those funky pupils she’ll just
say kitties look like kitties and
doggies look like doggies and can I go
now
and you know what she’s right she
recognizes the pattern of a doggy
pattern recognition sets in at a very
young age it’s an adaptive response it
allows us to see when things are just
slightly off and to take guard to be
aware to know that things just aren’t
quite right so we’re gonna do a little
experiment with this very cute pug Dora
I’m not gonna hurt him I promise we’re
just gonna tweak this pug just a little
bit there okay nope you all laughed
right you laughed because you recognized
before you understood why the patterns
here those are cat eyes on a pug and you
didn’t say I am laughing because those
are kitty cat eyes on a pug face your
brain registered it is not quite fitting
in even before you knew why you had to
kick it north to that prefrontal cortex
we heard about earlier in order for it
to make sense but you know what happens
then
when we have that cognitive dissonance
of two patterns that get shoved together
and we feel a little bit frightened then
we step away you wonder is that the
source of prejudice is that the source
of racism something that looks really
similar to you but it’s a little bit
different is that under a biological
substrate for one of the worst things we
can do as humans these are the questions
that horror can ask in ways that we
cannot ask directly we’re very funny
species we don’t like difficult
questions unless somebody poses it in
displacement and horror films give us
that opportunity it’s a
very subtle thing or you might not know
that hora is subtle except when it’s not
guys remember this film my goodness this
movie that’s alien that’s Ridley Scott’s
alien the tagline for this movie is in
space nobody can hear you scream I tell
you what when I watched this movie
people heard me scream like the whole
neighborhood heard me scream everybody
up and down when that thing busted out
of that guy’s gut it was like you know
to quote the sequel to alien aliens it
was game over man game game over it got
Bill Paxton just passed away God rest
his soul well I don’t remember being
terrified I remember laughing as I was
screaming game over and I remember
laughing with my buddies because I
didn’t see alien in the theater I rented
it I was 17 years old then my parents
were not home I you guys are gonna think
I grew up with no one watching me ever
it was my parents weren’t home my sister
wasn’t there I had all my friends over
and mom dad were in the audience tonight
forgive me we had procured some 3.2%
alcohol beer which was legal at the time
in Kansas if you were 18 and in that
funky kind of logic that adolescents
like to engage in I was not 18 but I
figured because I had friends who were
18 we’re in the same class I could drink
of this beer so we watched this movie
and laughed and screamed a delight and
this is what horror does for you it
doesn’t make you drink that’s not what
I’m saying
it creates community that creates
connection and that’s the third part it
makes you think it makes you recognize
patterns but it brings us together and
that’s like gold to our social brains
we’re wired to connect with each other
and we need ways to do that have you
ever been to a horror film in the
theater because if you haven’t you
should they place so much better than
the theater and it’s the only movie
setting where it is not only permissible
it is expected to yell to scream to say
I can’t watch to shout instructions to
the guy on the screen to say what are
you do we don’t split up and if you if
you do split up there’s this dark creepy
tunnel that you just discovered don’t go
down there and if you do go down there
why in god’s name are you taking a match
and not the flashlight that you
in your truck this is what happens in
hoard that happened in the conjuring if
anybody saw that very seed and everybody
theater starts laughing we love that
moment we know that the filmmaker loved
the idea of the match and couldn’t give
it up that connection horror is so
derivative that you see every horror
film in every other horror film and you
feel immediately like you’re part of the
club liqueur is a mirror okay it’s a
distorted mirror by high definition it’s
not what we think we’re seeing when we
look in it but if it were super pristine
I don’t think we could tolerate it
because we’ve got some ugly sides to us
but if we move it into displacement we
can ask some pretty provocative
questions about ourselves and we can
answer them learn to tolerate our
vulnerabilities our foibles actually
even learn to love ourselves more that
mirror can be a present to us so go out
and see the next war film thanks for
coming
[Applause] [Music]
Please follow and like us: