
think of the food you’re gonna eat today
we’re gonna be sort of lunch right and
if you think that your food is going to
contain plant products raise your hand
anything made from crops you’re gonna
eat today
I see I see a lot of hands you know and
that’s not surprising because plants are
the foundation of our nutrition and if
we to gather in this deal or next year
and eat exactly the same food made from
crops grown in exactly the same
conditions then we’ll be slightly less
nutritious in the year after that it’ll
be even less nutritious and the trend of
declining food quality will continue for
decades affecting not only our nutrition
but also of our children and when I say
that crops will be grown in exactly same
conditions that’s not exactly true
because your two concentrations carbon
dioxide concentrations next it will be
slightly higher primarily because we
burn fossil fuels and I’ll be linking
that increase in co2 to drop in minerals
such as calcium magnesium potassium and
zinc and you know our bodies can make
minerals we have to get them from our
food and these minerals you know they
keep our immune system and bones strong
and our brain and heart healthy and you
know a lot of the food is plants like
rice and wheat provide about forty
percent calories worldwide but not
enough nutrients for examples in zinc
deficiency affects about 1 billion
people worldwide a new estimates show
that calcium deficiency affects 3.5
billion people every
person on earth and prospective mothers
they sometimes don’t get enough iron and
that affects not only them but also
their babies and you know knowing that
food quality is declining is not good
news and you might be skeptical not
believe me and you’re certainly not
alone there are many scientists that
were also skeptical of my claims and
I’ll share with you some of the
challenges of proving that it’s true and
I also hope that opportunities along the
way
now I’ve never really thought that I’m
gonna work on nutrition I was growing up
is a mathematician to be a mathematician
in the Soviet Georgia and it was program
was very rigorous was mostly math
classes I did have passion for ecology
but couldn’t really take a classes in
ecology but was reading some books on my
own but then my mathematics studies get
interrupted I get drafted to this
military service I’ve sent to the
secretive military base highly guarded
in Lithuania they have these nuclear
warheads underground and above it just a
green pasture in a leg and cows and I’m
assigned to be a guard and reading the
psychology textbooks I learned it that
ecologists call grass or any type of
green plant as producers because they
use the energy of sunlight and co2 to
make starches sugars this is a world’s
factory of carbohydrates they also take
minerals from you know the soil in water
to make organic matter our food they
produce food that’s why they’re
producers and those that consume them
like cows or as consumers and so there
was a cow taker position so I applied
and got it and all I had to do is take
care of cows no guarding and I had to
milk them twice a day but the irony of
the Soviet Union is that they had a
sophisticated military equipment but no
milking machine so I had to move
cows twice a day with my hands I still
remember how to do that and I noticed
that the amount of milk I get from each
cow you know as I was doing it manually
dependent not only on amount of grass
they ate but also its quality that was
interesting because according to
traditional ecological theory no it was
mostly focusing on food quantity and
food quality and then you know once I
finished my studies in my service the
Soviet Union collapses and a lot of
stuff becomes worthless like money and
the textbooks filled with you know a
history ideology based stuff but one
thing hold its value Nets mathematics
fortunately for me because that’s what I
learned because mathematics transcends
all the boundaries political boundaries
in geographical boundaries mathematical
equation in the Soviet Union works the
same way as in America or here and so
this allows me to come to Arizona State
University and continue my studies in
math but I’m allowed to take courses and
ecology in there I learn about this
really interesting experiments so they
grow this algae of phytoplankton in
those flasks these are producers also
and they put different amount of light
on them and of course the more light you
put you know the more producers you get
and then they feed that to zooplankton
and I would think more light more food
more zooplankton there happen up to a
point when there was a lot of light you
had a lot of food but zooplankton eating
all that food did really bad in fact one
of the experiments just died and the
explanation psychologists game was
really neat you see the amount of
mineral phosphorus in those flasks was
limited just as it is in real lakes and
oceans and so when you put a lot of
light these things get a lot of carbon
but not enough
prosperous I mean enough for them but
not for this all practice so Joplin was
getting poor quality food so for my PhD
thesis I focused on making a simple
model mathematical model that will
capture that effect and and so you know
one equation describes producers and
other consumers and you know the beauty
about mathematics is that it it crosses
not just geographical boundaries but
species boundaries if something is true
you know and nothing in those equations
were specific to plankton then then it
should be also true for other species so
for my postdoctoral work I moved to
Princeton University and started to
think well they use light and co2 right
and when we increase light
photosynthesis goes up but we’re not
really increasing you know we’re not
making our Sun brighter but we do
increased co2 concentrations and by the
way this is co2 concentrations at the
time 371 parts per million and that was
increasing every year so I’m thinking
huh what if that increase in co2 can
affect our food and then us right so
this mathematics allows you to make this
kind of transfer
you know parallel from from this
plankton system to crops and humans by
replacing light with co2 and I published
that published it you know in a top
ecological journal and make this logical
argument and I am Anna top university in
I namely think okay I kind of shown
prove that but ecologist you know they
they they want evidence and we didn’t
really have evidence very few data and
be color just actually do raise plants
at elevated co2 and they measure you
know the measure of their growth and
yield and sometimes we measure minerals
but you know it’s like measuring whether
three times in Bratislava are you gonna
detect global
all right you need a lot of data and we
didn’t have them so I thought maybe you
know could generate data but everything
went downhill so I moved to Nebraska
it’s a crop state for my faculty
position in the it’s a mathematics
department so I applied to the
mathematics division at National Science
Foundation to generate more
sophisticated mathematical model and
they tell me you have too much biology
there
we don’t really fund that go apply to
biology division so I come up with
really I think a neat idea
I write to these directors of centers
that raise plants at elevated co2 and I
say share symbols with me so I’ll pull
all the samples and then we’ll analyze
them and they agree they agree in
writing they say sharable share samples
I put all these letters and apply to the
right go somewhere else essentially and
I do I apply to I apply to other places
and for one or another reason get
rejected it’s a cross-disciplinary
proposal doesn’t really fit anywhere and
then Great Recession happens and so you
know my department wants to save money
and I am not bringing any money any
grants so they cut me out come on
employed and I take my grant proposal
and post online so somebody maybe who
has money could generate data but along
the way here’s what I do instead of
pulling plant samples which I don’t have
I pull data from the literature a little
bit by a little bit they publish the
data on minerals and so I accumulate
them I don’t have enough and by 2011 I
actually run out of my savings so I
applied to government for food
assistance and they misspelled my name
but they actually give me this time they
approve they give me $200
so I have to buy cheaper food for my
family and I start to buy cheaper food I
see it has more sugar in it and I’m like
wow this big for the industry in just
sugar in our food supply because it’s
very cheap for them to do and then I
have at the time enough tilde to what
you receive it
co2 rising co2 does the same thing gets
more starchy sugars and marrow stroke
and I’ll tell you something weird I felt
at the time that I was the only like
person in the world who knew that’s
happening and the reason why I probably
I was because next year ecologist
published this paper and they say you
know what we’ll so pull data and there’s
no effect
there’s no change in brain quality in
fact if you look say the grass is in
zinc it actually increases well I said
it can be true right I look at their
sample size their sample size is 2 they
essentially sell noise for actual signal
and then their data contains so many
errors it to their credit three years
later they retract their study you
cancel it but at the time that was the
last word affected
International Panel on Climate Change
that in their fifth assessment said you
know co2 doesn’t really change crop
quality so I said okay I have to publish
it it took me two years for peer review
and then I published this paper and it’s
called I called hidden shift for two
reasons first when you look at your food
right you can’t really see the quality’s
lower second if you have small sample
you can’t see you have the massive
amount of data and the ion ohm refers
here to all these minerals okay so all
these minerals that we get from food so
thanks to all these researchers that
were you know four continents raising
these plants at elevated co2 my dataset
covered 15,000 more 15,000 observations
and 130 plant varieties so it was such a
massive data say that he cut through the
noise and show the signal and here what
happens carbon increases in plants in
all these minerals calcium magnesium and
zinc and iron they decline now if we
look at crops major crops for which we
have data we also see that minerals
decline in all major crops now that
effect actually is global if you look at
different latitudes you could see it’s
in temperate regions and it is in in
tropical regions and for all the
countries for which we have enough data
that also happens there
and what about type of experiment right
some raise it in in greenhouses they
elevates you to some do it in open
fields well just continuously pumped co2
concentrations well if you look at that
in both experiments minerals decline
what about wild plants does this just
happen to two crops well if you look at
that turns out it helps in wild plants
as well and crops and happens to little
plants in big trees
so the evidence was so compelling that
the next year the US government calls me
and says you know we’re writing this
report about climate change impacts on
human health and can you help us are
they sure
so in 2016 they produce a report but
it’s key finding one of its key findings
is that rising co2 lowers food quality
and it’s one of the only very few key
findings that is of high confidence very
likely to happen couple of months later
I receive a letter from the White House
from the Executive Office of the
President
so the US government that was declining
on my grants all these years now thanks
me for the service to the nation and
what was more pleasing that America
became the first industrialized country
that acknowledged that effect
now they decline in you know crop
quality and minerals minerals decline
like five or ten percent might not sound
as big right but think of it every time
you’re gonna eat food for the rest of
your life all these minerals and protein
will be replaced with carbohydrates
empty calories in your thought I thought
I have this effective ending for my top
of the talk I thought that this
cumulative effect of extra carbs would
be maybe like a bucket you know and I
thought I’m gonna dump this back
autonomy you know they show you that but
but when I actually did their
calculations I realized I better not do
it because if I’m gonna dump all the
amount on me at once it will kill me
instantly so this is the amount of extra
carbs will consume instead of minerals
and protein or our lifetime as co2
concentrations rise and you know they
give advise finish at a TED top with
call for action
but you know I am I’m not a policy maker
I am not comfortable giving people
advice I am a scientist I usually answer
questions or raise new questions so I
want to finish this talk by raising this
question how much these extra carbs and
sugars will consume these empty calories
because overriding co2 are going to
affect diabetes and obesity that is
rising worldwide we don’t know that
answer to this question but I do hope
those people that try to answer it won’t
have to go through multi year problems I
went through and will get the answer
sooner thank you very much
[Applause] [Music]
we’re gonna be sort of lunch right and
if you think that your food is going to
contain plant products raise your hand
anything made from crops you’re gonna
eat today
I see I see a lot of hands you know and
that’s not surprising because plants are
the foundation of our nutrition and if
we to gather in this deal or next year
and eat exactly the same food made from
crops grown in exactly the same
conditions then we’ll be slightly less
nutritious in the year after that it’ll
be even less nutritious and the trend of
declining food quality will continue for
decades affecting not only our nutrition
but also of our children and when I say
that crops will be grown in exactly same
conditions that’s not exactly true
because your two concentrations carbon
dioxide concentrations next it will be
slightly higher primarily because we
burn fossil fuels and I’ll be linking
that increase in co2 to drop in minerals
such as calcium magnesium potassium and
zinc and you know our bodies can make
minerals we have to get them from our
food and these minerals you know they
keep our immune system and bones strong
and our brain and heart healthy and you
know a lot of the food is plants like
rice and wheat provide about forty
percent calories worldwide but not
enough nutrients for examples in zinc
deficiency affects about 1 billion
people worldwide a new estimates show
that calcium deficiency affects 3.5
billion people every
person on earth and prospective mothers
they sometimes don’t get enough iron and
that affects not only them but also
their babies and you know knowing that
food quality is declining is not good
news and you might be skeptical not
believe me and you’re certainly not
alone there are many scientists that
were also skeptical of my claims and
I’ll share with you some of the
challenges of proving that it’s true and
I also hope that opportunities along the
way
now I’ve never really thought that I’m
gonna work on nutrition I was growing up
is a mathematician to be a mathematician
in the Soviet Georgia and it was program
was very rigorous was mostly math
classes I did have passion for ecology
but couldn’t really take a classes in
ecology but was reading some books on my
own but then my mathematics studies get
interrupted I get drafted to this
military service I’ve sent to the
secretive military base highly guarded
in Lithuania they have these nuclear
warheads underground and above it just a
green pasture in a leg and cows and I’m
assigned to be a guard and reading the
psychology textbooks I learned it that
ecologists call grass or any type of
green plant as producers because they
use the energy of sunlight and co2 to
make starches sugars this is a world’s
factory of carbohydrates they also take
minerals from you know the soil in water
to make organic matter our food they
produce food that’s why they’re
producers and those that consume them
like cows or as consumers and so there
was a cow taker position so I applied
and got it and all I had to do is take
care of cows no guarding and I had to
milk them twice a day but the irony of
the Soviet Union is that they had a
sophisticated military equipment but no
milking machine so I had to move
cows twice a day with my hands I still
remember how to do that and I noticed
that the amount of milk I get from each
cow you know as I was doing it manually
dependent not only on amount of grass
they ate but also its quality that was
interesting because according to
traditional ecological theory no it was
mostly focusing on food quantity and
food quality and then you know once I
finished my studies in my service the
Soviet Union collapses and a lot of
stuff becomes worthless like money and
the textbooks filled with you know a
history ideology based stuff but one
thing hold its value Nets mathematics
fortunately for me because that’s what I
learned because mathematics transcends
all the boundaries political boundaries
in geographical boundaries mathematical
equation in the Soviet Union works the
same way as in America or here and so
this allows me to come to Arizona State
University and continue my studies in
math but I’m allowed to take courses and
ecology in there I learn about this
really interesting experiments so they
grow this algae of phytoplankton in
those flasks these are producers also
and they put different amount of light
on them and of course the more light you
put you know the more producers you get
and then they feed that to zooplankton
and I would think more light more food
more zooplankton there happen up to a
point when there was a lot of light you
had a lot of food but zooplankton eating
all that food did really bad in fact one
of the experiments just died and the
explanation psychologists game was
really neat you see the amount of
mineral phosphorus in those flasks was
limited just as it is in real lakes and
oceans and so when you put a lot of
light these things get a lot of carbon
but not enough
prosperous I mean enough for them but
not for this all practice so Joplin was
getting poor quality food so for my PhD
thesis I focused on making a simple
model mathematical model that will
capture that effect and and so you know
one equation describes producers and
other consumers and you know the beauty
about mathematics is that it it crosses
not just geographical boundaries but
species boundaries if something is true
you know and nothing in those equations
were specific to plankton then then it
should be also true for other species so
for my postdoctoral work I moved to
Princeton University and started to
think well they use light and co2 right
and when we increase light
photosynthesis goes up but we’re not
really increasing you know we’re not
making our Sun brighter but we do
increased co2 concentrations and by the
way this is co2 concentrations at the
time 371 parts per million and that was
increasing every year so I’m thinking
huh what if that increase in co2 can
affect our food and then us right so
this mathematics allows you to make this
kind of transfer
you know parallel from from this
plankton system to crops and humans by
replacing light with co2 and I published
that published it you know in a top
ecological journal and make this logical
argument and I am Anna top university in
I namely think okay I kind of shown
prove that but ecologist you know they
they they want evidence and we didn’t
really have evidence very few data and
be color just actually do raise plants
at elevated co2 and they measure you
know the measure of their growth and
yield and sometimes we measure minerals
but you know it’s like measuring whether
three times in Bratislava are you gonna
detect global
all right you need a lot of data and we
didn’t have them so I thought maybe you
know could generate data but everything
went downhill so I moved to Nebraska
it’s a crop state for my faculty
position in the it’s a mathematics
department so I applied to the
mathematics division at National Science
Foundation to generate more
sophisticated mathematical model and
they tell me you have too much biology
there
we don’t really fund that go apply to
biology division so I come up with
really I think a neat idea
I write to these directors of centers
that raise plants at elevated co2 and I
say share symbols with me so I’ll pull
all the samples and then we’ll analyze
them and they agree they agree in
writing they say sharable share samples
I put all these letters and apply to the
right go somewhere else essentially and
I do I apply to I apply to other places
and for one or another reason get
rejected it’s a cross-disciplinary
proposal doesn’t really fit anywhere and
then Great Recession happens and so you
know my department wants to save money
and I am not bringing any money any
grants so they cut me out come on
employed and I take my grant proposal
and post online so somebody maybe who
has money could generate data but along
the way here’s what I do instead of
pulling plant samples which I don’t have
I pull data from the literature a little
bit by a little bit they publish the
data on minerals and so I accumulate
them I don’t have enough and by 2011 I
actually run out of my savings so I
applied to government for food
assistance and they misspelled my name
but they actually give me this time they
approve they give me $200
so I have to buy cheaper food for my
family and I start to buy cheaper food I
see it has more sugar in it and I’m like
wow this big for the industry in just
sugar in our food supply because it’s
very cheap for them to do and then I
have at the time enough tilde to what
you receive it
co2 rising co2 does the same thing gets
more starchy sugars and marrow stroke
and I’ll tell you something weird I felt
at the time that I was the only like
person in the world who knew that’s
happening and the reason why I probably
I was because next year ecologist
published this paper and they say you
know what we’ll so pull data and there’s
no effect
there’s no change in brain quality in
fact if you look say the grass is in
zinc it actually increases well I said
it can be true right I look at their
sample size their sample size is 2 they
essentially sell noise for actual signal
and then their data contains so many
errors it to their credit three years
later they retract their study you
cancel it but at the time that was the
last word affected
International Panel on Climate Change
that in their fifth assessment said you
know co2 doesn’t really change crop
quality so I said okay I have to publish
it it took me two years for peer review
and then I published this paper and it’s
called I called hidden shift for two
reasons first when you look at your food
right you can’t really see the quality’s
lower second if you have small sample
you can’t see you have the massive
amount of data and the ion ohm refers
here to all these minerals okay so all
these minerals that we get from food so
thanks to all these researchers that
were you know four continents raising
these plants at elevated co2 my dataset
covered 15,000 more 15,000 observations
and 130 plant varieties so it was such a
massive data say that he cut through the
noise and show the signal and here what
happens carbon increases in plants in
all these minerals calcium magnesium and
zinc and iron they decline now if we
look at crops major crops for which we
have data we also see that minerals
decline in all major crops now that
effect actually is global if you look at
different latitudes you could see it’s
in temperate regions and it is in in
tropical regions and for all the
countries for which we have enough data
that also happens there
and what about type of experiment right
some raise it in in greenhouses they
elevates you to some do it in open
fields well just continuously pumped co2
concentrations well if you look at that
in both experiments minerals decline
what about wild plants does this just
happen to two crops well if you look at
that turns out it helps in wild plants
as well and crops and happens to little
plants in big trees
so the evidence was so compelling that
the next year the US government calls me
and says you know we’re writing this
report about climate change impacts on
human health and can you help us are
they sure
so in 2016 they produce a report but
it’s key finding one of its key findings
is that rising co2 lowers food quality
and it’s one of the only very few key
findings that is of high confidence very
likely to happen couple of months later
I receive a letter from the White House
from the Executive Office of the
President
so the US government that was declining
on my grants all these years now thanks
me for the service to the nation and
what was more pleasing that America
became the first industrialized country
that acknowledged that effect
now they decline in you know crop
quality and minerals minerals decline
like five or ten percent might not sound
as big right but think of it every time
you’re gonna eat food for the rest of
your life all these minerals and protein
will be replaced with carbohydrates
empty calories in your thought I thought
I have this effective ending for my top
of the talk I thought that this
cumulative effect of extra carbs would
be maybe like a bucket you know and I
thought I’m gonna dump this back
autonomy you know they show you that but
but when I actually did their
calculations I realized I better not do
it because if I’m gonna dump all the
amount on me at once it will kill me
instantly so this is the amount of extra
carbs will consume instead of minerals
and protein or our lifetime as co2
concentrations rise and you know they
give advise finish at a TED top with
call for action
but you know I am I’m not a policy maker
I am not comfortable giving people
advice I am a scientist I usually answer
questions or raise new questions so I
want to finish this talk by raising this
question how much these extra carbs and
sugars will consume these empty calories
because overriding co2 are going to
affect diabetes and obesity that is
rising worldwide we don’t know that
answer to this question but I do hope
those people that try to answer it won’t
have to go through multi year problems I
went through and will get the answer
sooner thank you very much
[Applause] [Music]
Please follow and like us: