Press "Enter" to skip to content

What Coming Out as Trans Taught Me About Islamophobia | J Mase III | TEDxLosGatos


[Music]
so imagine you’re going into a store and
when you’re going into the store you see
a store clerk and a security guard and
when you see them one of them doesn’t
matter which but one of them says hello
to you and when they say hello to you it
comes out sort of like this like hey
hello is that someone generally trying
to seem friendly yes yeah
some of y’all a little skeptical I like
that you better forget let’s say you go
into the story different day and so on
this day again you go in you see a store
clerk and a security guard and one of
them says hello to you only this time
when they say hello it comes out sort of
like this hello is that someone trying
to seem friendly no right so what I’m
hoping we can get from this exercise is
that simple polite gestures like Hello
don’t always equal friendly can we agree
on that and we’ve all been in a moment
or experience in which what someone said
was different than what was being
communicated does that make sense to
everyone so when I think about myself as
a trans person I’ve been out and as an
adult longer than I’ve been in the
closet right I also spent a lot of my
time talking about identity and talking
about trans miss and I usually express
myself in a way that’s outside typical
gender norms so people are generally
rarely surprised to hear me say that I’m
trans even if they don’t quite have the
language for it does that make sense and
so that’s not surprising but what does
become surprising for folks is when I
say that I grew up in a multi-faith
household in particular that I have a
father who was raised Muslim and a
mother who was raised Christian now when
I say that people who perceive
themselves as being in solidarity with
the part of me that is trans immediately
want to focus in on my father and they
weren’t enough well what did your father
think about you coming out and when
folks asked me this question a few
things kind of come up so one it’s clear
that they don’t think it’s important to
unpack the relationship I had with my
non-muslim parent so I noticed that I
noticed the places in which they want me
to accept or reject whatever notions
they have about who Muslim people are
here the places where they’re not
actually concerned about the real
relationship I had with my father
they’re not concerned about the standing
breakfast date we had every Saturday
morning and we would spend 30 days
arguing about who got to pay he got to
pay that day that’s why he looks so
happy they’re not concerned about the
fact that he was my best friend and the
person I spent the most time talking
about my faith and spiritual journey
with they don’t care about the old chain
of his that I wear around my neck with
his name on it nah
they want to hear a critique how do I
know they want to hear a critique
because when I follow up their question
with wonderful stories about the
relationship between my father and I
after coming out they are always in
shock but when they’re asking this
question they’re very polite about it so
should I accept the Islamophobia
projected onto my family and my family
dynamics simply because the asker is
polite about it so just based off the
title I know for some of y’all you might
have been expecting that this was going
to be a coming-out story well surprise
I’ve been out for a long time and so I’m
not invested in dissecting that part of
my journey with you what I do want to
talk about is the behavior of others
when we live in our truth as trans
people as people of color and folks from
other targeted communities I really want
to talk about politeness and in
particular I want to talk about the
untrustworthiness of polite people all
right y’all ready for that talk y’all
ready for that cuz we going to get into
it all right and so when we think about
politeness right according to the
magical tool that is dictionary.com
politeness is defined as having or
showing behaviors that are respectful
and/or considerate of other people
having or showing behaviors that are
respectful and/or considerate of other
people now when people hear me talk
about my family’s upbringing and
specifically the religious background if
we’re getting to that place in the story
there’s a 99.9% chance that they already
know my father has passed and so that
they know that they’re potentially
bringing up a negative experience with a
person I love who has died right and so
if you could imagine for a second that
you have a dying family member and
before consoling you someone said oh my
goodness that’s so sad but like did they
ever kill anyone or you
ded great my totally go like did she
ever take a puppy once we would think
that question is absurd right and
insensitive right and I thought you
can’t talk about puppies without having
a puppy on screen so I decided to put
that that’s my actual puppy who’s never
been kicked anywhere but we would think
that question is absurd right so when
someone is asking this question that
they are projecting some negative pieces
onto my family are they necessarily
being respectful and considerate of me
right are they being respectful and/or
considerate of my grief no they’re
generally being respectful and/or
considerate of experiences and stories
that they’ve been told about who trans
people and Muslim people are and whether
or not they can be the same thing or
coexist together they’re generally being
respectful and/or considerate of a
system that the humanizes Muslim people
every day and perpetuates Islamophobia
does that make sense for y’all does that
make sense and I’m not totally psychic
but I’m sensing that not everyone is
quite there with me on the politeness
piece yet especially if you do not come
from targeted communities that get
interrogated at the same level that
people like myself and other folks often
are every day about who we are and our
experiences it might be hard to measure
the harm that is caused from that kind
of framework so I’m gonna give you all
better story right more clear story
y’all ready for that okay some we’re
gonna travel back in time to a few years
ago so a few years ago I was
volunteering at a summer camp this
summer camp was seventy percent white
and it was happening on a college campus
okay and so one day in particular
there’s an event happening outside or
inside of a building on campus and
myself and three other black folks were
standing outside of the building having
a conversation about some things that
came up in the day and so everybody else
is inside and so within 10 to 12 minutes
of us being outside three white police
officers rushed up toward us with their
hands on their weapons okay not yet
drawn but making sure that we’re clear
that they have them okay and so when the
police officers that I’m perceiving to
be in charge is looking at us and is
about 40s or 50s and says we’ve got a
noise complaint it was hard to find
right and so this presents a cognitive
dissonance right so how can it be that
we are both so loud that we require
police intervention yet so quiet that
it’s hard to find us okay is anyone here
anxious giggler anyone anxious giggle
raise your hand really anxious giggler
right that’s something that I do is that
a the greatest response to stress
no is it a human response to stress yeah
yeah so in this moment lots of things
are bubbling up for me especially as I’m
seeing this juxtaposition of us as four
black folks standing outside in
proximity to these white police officers
that are cornering us simply because of
a perceived noise complaint or noise
violation and so as I’m getting more
anxious the first thing I can think to
say out of my mouth is well of course
you got a noise complaint there’s four
black people standing outside and so the
police officer in that moment he doesn’t
just get angry he becomes anger right
he becomes anger and so as he’s shouting
and things are getting really real my
spirit is kind of floating above my body
and I’m imagining all the different
things and scenarios that can happen in
this moment and as that is happening my
friend who is a Virgo and thinks a lot
more about what she says before she says
it starts to be escalating the situation
which is something she shouldn’t have to
know how to do but she does it very well
in that situation and so eventually the
police officers leave and we go back
inside and now we are tasked with
explaining to a mostly white group of
people what just happened to us and so
as we’re talking to people a lot of
people start crying and hugging us and
telling us oh my goodness I can’t
believe that happened to you I’m so
sorry that happened to you
which is another paradox right because
here we were in this moment and where we
allowed to cry no the littlest bit of
anxiety that I showed got rained in
really quick by the police and so camp
ends a few months later it’s
time to play for the next camp and so at
the time the executive director is being
very evasive about where the next camp
is gonna be then he gets to this kind of
a critical mass point where you kind of
got to know where things are happening
or can’t can’t happen and so eventually
the executive director reveals well
actually we’re gonna have camp this same
exact place we had it last year so me in
the place that we just got held up right
and so why was that so the executive
director who was white called up the
police departments as well as the campus
staff and said well you know everyone
apologized which is inaccurate because
they did not apologize to the people
that actually experienced the trauma
digs they apologized to a leadership
team and you know they were very polite
and they were nice and the campus even
gave us a discount to return gave us a
discount to return right so when those
of us that experience that profiling
incident push back we were told that we
were being irrational we were being
divisive we were being mean right and as
a result of the fallout of that none of
us that actually experienced that racial
profiling incident are part of that
organization anymore right so what was
the function of politeness in that
moment politeness served three major
functions one it allowed the leadership
team to keep their business contacts
happy right because there was no
consequences for anyone right – it
became a financial endeavor right and
there was a financial benefit they
actually traded our racial profiling
incident in for a discount right thirdly
whether intentional or unintentional it
served to weed out parts of community
that were targeted communities as part
of that organization does that make
sense and that’s something that many
organizations deal with that they’re
always wondering oh my goodness why is
there such a high overturn of this XYZ
population as part of the organization
well what stuff happened that showed
people they were unsafe was the
organization invested in politeness or
justice you’ll understand that so in
that moment if that is what politeness
looks like on the ground
what is the ask of justice so what does
the ask of justice so if we move closer
to justice and actually I want you to
raise your hand if you if you would
answer yes to the next question I’m
going to ask you have you ever had a
conversation in which someone kept doing
something that caused you harm but said
they were trying to help you have you
ever had a conversation in which someone
kept doing something that caused you
harm but said they were trying to help
you raise your hand if you experienced
that okay and so you want to hear
something that’s gonna make you feel
real queasy you want to hear something
you’ve been that person to somebody else
and too many somebody else’s especially
if your approach to justice is to focus
on the ways you can’t possibly be
invested in white supremacy that you
can’t possibly be transphobic that you
can’t possibly be Islamophobic or
xenophobic or ablest does that make
sense for you right so we have to own
our role in a framework that prioritizes
politeness over justice why because
there have been some goodies that you
have been getting in exchange for your
niceties there have been goodies that
you have been getting in strange for you
niceties and we must be honest with that
in order to move forward so that means
for white folks in the room what sort of
goodies do you get an exchange for your
politeness and niceties in the face of
trial Macon’s black and brown people is
it keeping a certain type of job is it
having a bank account that looks a
certain type of way is it getting the
promotion on time is it being seen as
the nice person who is friends with
quote-unquote everybody right what are
the goodies you’re getting this is
gender folks
what sort of goodies do you get for
being polite and nice in the face of
trauma that happens to trans people
right so is it that you get to be quirky
but not as weird as these people over
here is it again that you get to laugh
at that joke without a conscience right
what are the goodies for non-muslim
people is it a false sense of safety
what are the goodies you’re getting does
that make sense so you must own your
role in politeness right next we must
accept that urgency is different for
everyone do you think my urgency when I
was dealing with the police was higher
love what was it it was high why
I thought my life was at risk merely for
being perceived as talking too loudly
outside of a building on a college
campus during the middle of the day in
the dead of summer right do you think
the urgency of someone who is houseless
is going to be higher or lower than
someone who has a well-paying
nine-to-five job and owns our own home
higher as a black person if I am part of
an organization with a 95% white
leadership team and my job becomes at
risk for bringing attention to the lack
of awareness of racism and white
supremacy at that organization is my
urgency going to be higher or lower than
a white colleague that never even
considered there was a racial justice
problem it’s going to be higher right so
accepting that the people that are nice
and polite you want to go to a barbecue
with on the weekend may not the people
be the people that you want to rely on
when your life is actually at risk next
we must defer leadership so what does
that look like and what does that mean
as nice and great as you are when you’re
a kid you’re learned let one plus one
equals two you learn that two plus two
equals four
you learned subtraction division
percentages decimals and at some point
you decided whether or not math was for
you right we never expect someone with a
kindergarten level understanding of math
to have the same conversation about math
as we do an astrophysicist
well we consistently expect in a system
of white supremacy for white folks to
have the same conversation about racial
inequity that black and brown folks do
it’s now possible we expect cisgender
men to have the same conversation about
gender inequity that we do intersex
folks trans and says women that we
expect trans men and non-binary folks to
have it’s not possible we expect in a
system as it is right now for folks that
have access to wealth and the same
conversation about economic injustice as
someone that can’t afford to pay their
rent and for a bottle of milk in the
same pay period it’s not possible that
makes sense for you so it must defer
leadership to people who are actually
experts on the devastation that is
happening on the ground next we must
redistribute resources we must
redistribute resources why because
politeness is a tool used to hoard
resources from targeted and vulnerable
communities politeness is a tool used to
hoard resources from targeted and
vulnerable communities and blame them
for their own oppression you all see
that works do you all see how that works
yes so when I’m talking about Reda
street or psa’s I’m talking about things
like land space credentials titles money
that scares people but you know what you
cannot smile white supremacy away your
dentist is not that good right you must
do actual work and be invested in
actually giving resources back to
communities that made those resources
possible and next how many of y’all by a
show of hands perceive yourself to be
someone who is invested in social
justice raise your hand if you see
yourself as someones invest in social
justice raise your hand high Ray J and I
be proud of that be proud of it okay so
but I think about having the support of
sir so that is what I call my father not
because he made me but because that is
what I named him out of affection
because I loved this man when Sir was
born in 1943 in Virginia and his one of
his favorite moments was actually once
being a security guard from Malcolm X
back in the day and I know but he didn’t
know much about queerness or analyst
before I came out but you know what I
saw I saw him allow himself to be humble
enough to be transformed by my
experience as what was happening for me
on the ground and I often wondered what
would it take for people of power of
privilege of access to be transformed by
the experiences of those dealing with
systemic and systematic discrimination
on a large-scale basis every day right
so again for those y’all that said that
you had your hands up that you said you
were invested in social justice raise
your hands again raise your hands again
keep them high keep going high on this
day keep it you keep your hands up
GPIO say take him down if he ends up on
this day I dare you to be more invested
in social justice than you are in
politeness I dare you to be more
invested in justice than what’s in your
bank accounts I dare you to be more
invested in justice than your business
contacts I dare you to be more invested
in justice than your ego and being seen
as a nice person and more than all of
that I dare you to be defiantly
righteously and necessarily impolite in
the face of other people’s oppression or
at least get out of the way for folks
that must be in order to survive [Applause]
Please follow and like us: