
in my working life
I am ignored I’m ridiculed and tested to
my limit on a daily basis and yet I love
what I do I’m a teacher in a pupil
referral unit for young people who have
been permanently excluded from
mainstream schools 25 years I work with
all kinds of different young people most
of whom have challenging behavior and
I’m here today to be a voice for them
because their real needs lying beneath
the behavior
all too often go unseen unheard and I’m
mad now these children are easy to
dislike they challenge our authority as
adults they disobey us and disrespect us
they can make us feel out of control and
sometimes scared like we’re failing
incompetent and powerless in short they
can make us feel like they feel and it
is unbearable
so in our schools we prefer them to go
away and be someone else’s problem but
these are our most vulnerable and
disadvantaged young people in our
society and they need our help and
expertise the most and yet we’re failing
them on a huge scale over the last three
years in schools in England we’ve seen a
40% increase in permanent exclusions 40%
and in 2016 there are over six and a
half thousand permanent exclusions and
the estimated cost of this over the
lifetime of that one group is estimated
to be over 2 billion pounds what we know
about excluded children is that they’re
more likely to live in poverty more
likely to experience abuse and neglect
at home there’s 7 times as likely to
have a learning difficulty special
educational need and over half of them
are experiencing some form of mental
health related condition
ultimately excluded children go on to
make up over 60% of our British prison
population and they’re not just other
people’s children they could be yours or
they could be mine like the
fifteen-year-old girl who helped to
nurse her mum until she went into a
hospice who struggled to cope when her
dad moved his girlfriend into the home
and then one day at school she was
walking down the corridor and another
pupil made a really cruel comment about
her dying mum and she lashed out and
found herself permanently excluded not
long after that she went into care and I
later learned that by the time she was
18 she’d become involved in prostitution
I firmly believe that with the right
support her life could have taken a very
different path just imagine if she’d
been your child what would you have
hoped for her and what would her mum
have wanted we human beings are
wonderfully diverse but our needs are
fundamentally the same and our need for
human connection is the most important
dr. brenner Brown says connection is why
we’re here
it’s what gives our lives meaning and
purpose and studies have shown that the
happiest people have the most positive
human connections
so when connections unravel so too does
our ability to cope with everyday life
and for children with challenging
behavior they’ve often become
disconnected
they’ve lost their faith in adults and
any sense of security that they had and
if they could do well at school they’d
be doing it but there are barriers
standing in the way there are reasons
and then it’s never ever simply that the
child doesn’t want to but knowing there
are reasons doesn’t help our mainstream
teachers in their incredibly difficult
jobs challenging behavior in our
classrooms creates anxiety
causes disruption to learning and
together with workload it’s one of the
main reasons teachers give for their own
mental health related absence and
ultimately why some teachers leave the
profession altogether and this is where
the ideas and approaches and expertise
that staff use and pupil Referral Units
and other alternative provision could be
so useful if it was extended and
utilized in mainstream schools what my
colleagues and I know is that without a
significant relationship we can’t
achieve a single thing these children
won’t like us and respect doesn’t do as
we say simply because we’re adults and
teachers adults have often let them down
so we have to prove ourselves worthy of
their trust we have to earn it
now fortunately for society as a whole
most children follow rules but it’s been
shown time and again that children with
challenging behavior follow people first
unreal second put simply if they like us
they’ll feel safe and if they feel safe
they’ll relax and if they relax they’re
more likely to comply and to learn I’ve
asked countless pupils young people what
you think makes a good teacher and their
responses are typically the same they
say things like the ones that restrict
but that you can still have a laugh with
or the ones that seem interested in
getting to know you or ones that treat
you like you’re a human being I asked
one young man and my pupil referral unit
this question recently and he said I
never thought about that before miss
just give me a sec I gave him a sec and
I waited and eventually he said right
get on to this miss I think that teaches
good teachers are ones that you can have
like a high you know like a proper bond
with do you know what I mean
I told him I knew exactly what he meant
so is it possible for mainstream
teachers to build connections with
challenging pupils I believe this
requires a shift in thinking towards a
greater sense of collective
responsibility for these children now
many of us know that our current
educational environment does nothing to
encourage this schools are primarily
rewarded on academic results they’re
actually incentivized to exclude pupils
Ofsted inspections make no separate
judgment about outcomes for children
with special needs and those with
challenging behavior and newly qualified
teachers often report for they’re
unprepared for how to teach these
children but there are things that
teachers can do in the meantime the
teacher and author Paul Dix says it’s
the small stuff it’s the daily acts of
care
it’s the perpetual generosity of spirit
and the interest you show in their daily
lives that matters most small things
that can have a huge impact and we
shouldn’t underestimate the ripple
effect that one positive teacher pupil
relationship can have there is nothing
more beautiful to me than hearing one
pupil I’ve spent some time with say
quietly to another pupil that struggling
to settle nah bro leave it out this is
sound
collective responsibility is where it
starts but if we want pupils with
challenging behavior to learn how to
behave we have to teach them explicitly
and not just expect them to get it and
this is where restorative approaches to
behavior can be so useful now these are
not hugging our alternatives are the
opposite end of the bring back the birch
argument rather they are tried and
tested approaches designed to reinforce
relationships and they explicitly teach
missing skills like how to reflect on
consequences like how to develop empathy
and a conscience and they instill in
pupils the expectation that reparation
needs to happen detentions timeout
exclusions and isolation do none of this
and we’ve got plenty of evidence now
that shows that our current systems of
punishments and sanctions are
ineffective with challenging pupils the
head teacher and author John Ithorian
says a fixed-term exclusions that they
are in action masquerading as action
they make us feel like we’re doing
something when we’re doing nothing of
the sort
it is respite it is not improvement so
we need a new way forward if we’re going
to meet the needs of the most vulnerable
and disadvantaged pupils in our society
because while the world is full of
tragic stories that were helpless to do
anything about we can do something about
outcomes for these children so let’s
take collective responsibility and let’s
make connections let’s share our
expertise and integrate the best ideas
we should question and challenge an
inspection system and a culture that
ignores them how can that be right and
we should never forget that children
with challenging behavior are just
children doing their best to deal with
what life is handed to them without any
of our adult skills and if they could
tell you what they need they would
probably say
something like don’t be scared of me
please don’t give up on me make me feel
I’m important and give me hope that
things can and will get better please
see past my behavior it’s not who I
really am so I’m joining with them today
in their challenging behavior to try to
get their needs met or be in a more
socially appropriate way and I invite
you to do the same the only difference
between all of us and the children I
speak on behalf of is luck education and
opportunities like this one let’s make a
difference thank you
[Applause]
I am ignored I’m ridiculed and tested to
my limit on a daily basis and yet I love
what I do I’m a teacher in a pupil
referral unit for young people who have
been permanently excluded from
mainstream schools 25 years I work with
all kinds of different young people most
of whom have challenging behavior and
I’m here today to be a voice for them
because their real needs lying beneath
the behavior
all too often go unseen unheard and I’m
mad now these children are easy to
dislike they challenge our authority as
adults they disobey us and disrespect us
they can make us feel out of control and
sometimes scared like we’re failing
incompetent and powerless in short they
can make us feel like they feel and it
is unbearable
so in our schools we prefer them to go
away and be someone else’s problem but
these are our most vulnerable and
disadvantaged young people in our
society and they need our help and
expertise the most and yet we’re failing
them on a huge scale over the last three
years in schools in England we’ve seen a
40% increase in permanent exclusions 40%
and in 2016 there are over six and a
half thousand permanent exclusions and
the estimated cost of this over the
lifetime of that one group is estimated
to be over 2 billion pounds what we know
about excluded children is that they’re
more likely to live in poverty more
likely to experience abuse and neglect
at home there’s 7 times as likely to
have a learning difficulty special
educational need and over half of them
are experiencing some form of mental
health related condition
ultimately excluded children go on to
make up over 60% of our British prison
population and they’re not just other
people’s children they could be yours or
they could be mine like the
fifteen-year-old girl who helped to
nurse her mum until she went into a
hospice who struggled to cope when her
dad moved his girlfriend into the home
and then one day at school she was
walking down the corridor and another
pupil made a really cruel comment about
her dying mum and she lashed out and
found herself permanently excluded not
long after that she went into care and I
later learned that by the time she was
18 she’d become involved in prostitution
I firmly believe that with the right
support her life could have taken a very
different path just imagine if she’d
been your child what would you have
hoped for her and what would her mum
have wanted we human beings are
wonderfully diverse but our needs are
fundamentally the same and our need for
human connection is the most important
dr. brenner Brown says connection is why
we’re here
it’s what gives our lives meaning and
purpose and studies have shown that the
happiest people have the most positive
human connections
so when connections unravel so too does
our ability to cope with everyday life
and for children with challenging
behavior they’ve often become
disconnected
they’ve lost their faith in adults and
any sense of security that they had and
if they could do well at school they’d
be doing it but there are barriers
standing in the way there are reasons
and then it’s never ever simply that the
child doesn’t want to but knowing there
are reasons doesn’t help our mainstream
teachers in their incredibly difficult
jobs challenging behavior in our
classrooms creates anxiety
causes disruption to learning and
together with workload it’s one of the
main reasons teachers give for their own
mental health related absence and
ultimately why some teachers leave the
profession altogether and this is where
the ideas and approaches and expertise
that staff use and pupil Referral Units
and other alternative provision could be
so useful if it was extended and
utilized in mainstream schools what my
colleagues and I know is that without a
significant relationship we can’t
achieve a single thing these children
won’t like us and respect doesn’t do as
we say simply because we’re adults and
teachers adults have often let them down
so we have to prove ourselves worthy of
their trust we have to earn it
now fortunately for society as a whole
most children follow rules but it’s been
shown time and again that children with
challenging behavior follow people first
unreal second put simply if they like us
they’ll feel safe and if they feel safe
they’ll relax and if they relax they’re
more likely to comply and to learn I’ve
asked countless pupils young people what
you think makes a good teacher and their
responses are typically the same they
say things like the ones that restrict
but that you can still have a laugh with
or the ones that seem interested in
getting to know you or ones that treat
you like you’re a human being I asked
one young man and my pupil referral unit
this question recently and he said I
never thought about that before miss
just give me a sec I gave him a sec and
I waited and eventually he said right
get on to this miss I think that teaches
good teachers are ones that you can have
like a high you know like a proper bond
with do you know what I mean
I told him I knew exactly what he meant
so is it possible for mainstream
teachers to build connections with
challenging pupils I believe this
requires a shift in thinking towards a
greater sense of collective
responsibility for these children now
many of us know that our current
educational environment does nothing to
encourage this schools are primarily
rewarded on academic results they’re
actually incentivized to exclude pupils
Ofsted inspections make no separate
judgment about outcomes for children
with special needs and those with
challenging behavior and newly qualified
teachers often report for they’re
unprepared for how to teach these
children but there are things that
teachers can do in the meantime the
teacher and author Paul Dix says it’s
the small stuff it’s the daily acts of
care
it’s the perpetual generosity of spirit
and the interest you show in their daily
lives that matters most small things
that can have a huge impact and we
shouldn’t underestimate the ripple
effect that one positive teacher pupil
relationship can have there is nothing
more beautiful to me than hearing one
pupil I’ve spent some time with say
quietly to another pupil that struggling
to settle nah bro leave it out this is
sound
collective responsibility is where it
starts but if we want pupils with
challenging behavior to learn how to
behave we have to teach them explicitly
and not just expect them to get it and
this is where restorative approaches to
behavior can be so useful now these are
not hugging our alternatives are the
opposite end of the bring back the birch
argument rather they are tried and
tested approaches designed to reinforce
relationships and they explicitly teach
missing skills like how to reflect on
consequences like how to develop empathy
and a conscience and they instill in
pupils the expectation that reparation
needs to happen detentions timeout
exclusions and isolation do none of this
and we’ve got plenty of evidence now
that shows that our current systems of
punishments and sanctions are
ineffective with challenging pupils the
head teacher and author John Ithorian
says a fixed-term exclusions that they
are in action masquerading as action
they make us feel like we’re doing
something when we’re doing nothing of
the sort
it is respite it is not improvement so
we need a new way forward if we’re going
to meet the needs of the most vulnerable
and disadvantaged pupils in our society
because while the world is full of
tragic stories that were helpless to do
anything about we can do something about
outcomes for these children so let’s
take collective responsibility and let’s
make connections let’s share our
expertise and integrate the best ideas
we should question and challenge an
inspection system and a culture that
ignores them how can that be right and
we should never forget that children
with challenging behavior are just
children doing their best to deal with
what life is handed to them without any
of our adult skills and if they could
tell you what they need they would
probably say
something like don’t be scared of me
please don’t give up on me make me feel
I’m important and give me hope that
things can and will get better please
see past my behavior it’s not who I
really am so I’m joining with them today
in their challenging behavior to try to
get their needs met or be in a more
socially appropriate way and I invite
you to do the same the only difference
between all of us and the children I
speak on behalf of is luck education and
opportunities like this one let’s make a
difference thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: