Press "Enter" to skip to content

We Are All Criminals | Emily Baxter | TEDxUNG


[Music]

[Applause]

have you ever been convicted of an

offense yes or no that’s the question

that had been weighing upon Anthony’s

mind as he hovered in the back of a

basement at the back of a government

centers basement room some six years ago

yes he would have to answer on his job

applications the last 13 to be exact

yes on his rental application yes on his

college application yes on his loan

application yes yes yes how would you

respond if like me and I you can say no

you haven’t been convicted of an offense

however if you said yes like Anthony

know that you are one of the 65 to 100

million people in the United States with

a criminal record let me tell you how I

met Anthony several years ago I left my

job in public defense to work in public

policy I thought that if I could change

the laws that were so acutely affecting

my clients I could be a better advocate

I took a job at a legal non-profit in

Minneapolis Minnesota and my focus was

on criminal records

we held expungement clinics in the

basement of that government Center in a

small windowless room in this space men

women and youth all pour predominantly

people of color would line up for hours

waiting for the opportunity to speak to

an attorney someone who may be able to

help them wipe that slate clean one

night I’m sure the son had long sent

Seth when in walked our last participant

Anthony was tall thin black and clearly

distraught as he hesitantly walked

toward me he pulled from his back pocket

a copy of his criminal record a printout

he had received from a computer terminal

two flights up I was nervous to open

this what could his record contain that

would cause him this much stress

a theft and a minor wanted that I let

out a short laugh of relief even if the

court doesn’t expunge the matter I said

it’s not like your life is over and with

that Anthony began to cry he told me

that even I Ito me that earlier that day

he had in fact tried to take his own

life

you see what was just a theft to me to

Anthony was a lost job it was miss

housing payments it was skipped meals

it was door after door slammed in his

face it was the loss of respect from his

friends and family the loss of a sense

of self the loss of hope around the same

time I had been traveling all around the

state speaking to legislators and

landlords employers and licensing boards

and imploring them to give my clients a

second chance

time and again I heard you can’t trust a

con once a criminal always a criminal

those words came back to me as I looked

at Anthony and I thought how many times

that I taken something that wasn’t mine

sure I considered my own criminality

before but not like this I hadn’t really

thought about what life would be like

living in the shadow of a criminal

record under the suffocating stigma of

having been caught what would life be

like if I didn’t have the luxury to

forget one in four people in the United

States has a criminal record

and that’s a conservative estimate by

the way I contend that four and four

have a criminal history for the past few

years I’ve been traveling all around the

United States interviewing people like

me the 75% of people who have criminal

histories but no record and asking them

what have you had the luxury to forget

tonight I want to share with you some of

those stories some are going to be petty

some are serious some happen decades ago

others a bit more recently in doing so I

hope to provide for you a new and

personal way of examining the the deep

effects of the juvenile and criminal

justice systems upon a person and the

disparate effect

of those systems upon poor people people

of color and indigenous people across

the US but first I want to make sure

we’re all on the same page this is a

graph made with data taken from the

Bureau of Justice Statistics and it

shows the US state and federal prison

population between 1925 and 2013 you can

see that we haven’t always been an

incarceration nation and some four

decades ago we began the deliberate and

regrettable march toward this the caging

of more than 1.5 million people wars on

drugs and poverty and mental illness

private prisons

three strikes rules mandatory minimum

sentencing in concentrated policing and

minority communities are just a few of

the many policies and practices that

have led to this 80 billion

dollar-a-year mass incarceration mass

disaster now what is additionally

concerning is what happens to people

when they’re no longer in the system

when they’re back in the communities

trying to get on with life that’s when a

new insidious form of punishment begins

when people find that they may not be

locked out or excuse me they’re not

locked up but are now locked out locked

out of jobs and in school and and

housing and countless other

opportunities to move on and move up now

before we delve into the world of

collateral consequences are those

lifelong effects of a criminal record

let’s turn back to this graph as I said

it shows the US state and federal prison

population just as importantly is what

it doesn’t show it doesn’t for example

show the millions of people who are in

county and parish jails those on

immigration holds on civil commitments

or kids in juvenile detention they are

not shown here on this graph it doesn’t

show the billions of people who are on

probation and parole their liberties

curtailed under the thumb of the

criminal justice system just not

spending their nights behind bars they

are not shown here on this graph and it

doesn’t show the tens of millions of

people like Anthony who are locked out

who are held underwater unable to come

up for air they are not shown here on

this graph and just as importantly it

doesn’t show

the nearly three million sons and

daughters the countless brothers and

sisters mothers and fathers of spouses

and partners and greater family and

community members who can all be

profoundly affected when someone is

taken out of the home and then not

allowed back in they are not shown here

on this graph so what may initially

appear to be a tsunami of humanity ready

to crash upon our shores you realize

it’s just a drop in the overall greater

ocean of a crisis that crisis is not

born equally across the country for

example from the Sentencing Project

blackmail sparked in 2001 face a

lifetime likelihood of imprisonment of

one in three for white women it’s 1 in

111 that’s not to say that white women

aren’t committing crimes right but we’re

not who you see proportionately speaking

in our criminal justice system

note that rates of offending do not come

close to explaining these disparities

looking at just the war on drugs for

example arguably one of the greatest

contributing factors to our current

carceral crisis black and white

individuals use and sell drugs at

roughly the same rate yet black

individuals are far more likely to be

stopped searched arrested charged

prosecuted and convicted for engaging in

drug-related activity than are white now

in addition to people of color poor

people people with mental health and

chemical dependency concerns are

likewise disproportionately affected and

yet we do little to address these issues

once someone’s in the system in fact we

do a lot to exacerbate the very problems

prison is where housing with trauma with

too few exceptions meaningful

opportunities for treatment and and

education they’re non-existent saddled

with criminal records people leave

prison I’m making second chances or

firsts exceedingly rare I said I’ve been

collecting these stories over the years

and they range in severity these stories

of the people who have gotten away with

it from quite serious like the student

and his aggravated robbery – and and the

pastor who brought a

loaded gun on an international flight –

relatively innocuous like this gentleman

who had an open bottle that’s carrying a

beer from one house party to the next

petty theft was the next one down that’s

failure to read to return a library book

which is an offense by the way the next

one down was public urination this

gentleman now has a contract worked with

the Department of Defense some of the

highest security clearance in the nation

had he been caught he would find

difficulty getting a job job at a gas

station

I know because many of my clients were

denied those very jobs for these very

records likewise the responses to the

recollections of past transgressions are

also varied like this gentleman who told

me about a time he had taken his uncle’s

hunting rifle out to college with him

one drunken night he decided to liberate

the quarters within a double posted

parking meter a single shot went right

through the locking mechanism letting

loose $40 worth of quarters he calls it

his 40 bucks shot and he laughed

throughout the entire interview some

people recognize not just the luxury to

forget but the luxury to not regret

while others are deeply sorry this woman

told me about a time when she was

working as a barista she said she used

to pad her tips with bills from the till

and she told me this the tears streamed

down her face she said I cannot imagine

what life would be like now had I been

labeled a thief then I’ve heard from law

enforcement officers who reflect upon

the weight of the mistakes that they’ve

made and time and again from people who

recognize that crime is an event in a

life course not a static characteristic

of one’s being and then I’ve heard some

truly heartbreaking stories like the the

gentleman from whom I took this

photograph he said he struggled to

survive his teens after one regrettable

Saturday morning he could have been

charged and convicted with a first

degree assault for the benefit of a gang

he wasn’t he graduated from high school

he got a scholarship to go to college he

went on to graduate school and now has a

PhD in biophysics his future was not for

clothes

and I’ve heard so many stories from

people who engaged in drug-related

activity on college campuses like this

gentleman who said he donated some of

his FAFSA funds to help finance a drug

ring he wanted a girlfriend or this

woman who said that she sold weed to

frat bros and football players that she

could get a hey what’s up in the hallway

she said she was sick of feeling

invisible and then there are some

stories that I just can’t believe we’re

still talking about in 2017 this woman

told me about a time just a few years

ago when her husband was diagnosed with

a particularly aggressive and terminal

form of cancer in the last few months of

his life she said his body became so

riddled with pain that he could no

longer pick up a pencil or shampoo his

own hair this man who the year before

had been an active marine ostensibly at

the peak of his physical career could

now no longer bathe himself she said the

only thing that could have swage that

pain was pot now she had asthma so he

couldn’t smoke it so instead she put the

pot in the butter and the butter and the

brownies and together they would eat it

and she said that when they did he could

on cramp his hand enough to hold hers he

died her life stopped she doesn’t

remember what she did with the pot maybe

she ate it she didn’t think so maybe her

friends did that’s more likely maybe she

threw it away it didn’t matter what

mattered was that her husband had just

died is that a story you think you can

use she said and I told her about a

phone call we had received at that legal

nonprofit there was an elder or Jibo a

woman who had been living with her only

Son a man in his 40s when he was

diagnosed with a particularly aggressive

in terminal form of cancer in the last

few months of his life his body became

so riddled in pain that she said it’s

like she would sit with just a shell of

his former self the only thing that

could have swage that pain was pod that

she

have asthma so he straight-up smoked it

and when he did she said it’s like her

baby was back with her again

he died her life stopped she didn’t move

his work boots from the back door or

toss his toothbrush from the bathroom

sink and she didn’t throw away the

baggies a pot that were in the freezer

some time went by and a search warrant

was executed on her home there have been

allegations she was warehousing drugs

police tore apart the place found the

pot in the freezer

she was arrested charged and later

convicted with a felony level possession

of controlled substances

this woman is 72 years old has no prior

criminal record and because of a felony

record is now living on the streets we

are all aware all criminals is about the

human cost of mass incarceration about

the human cost of mass criminalization

we have all violated the law but more

importantly we are all human and some of

us perhaps one in four of us may be in

need of a second chance but make no

mistake this project is also a

commentary on the disparate impact of

our nation’s policies policing and

prosecution many not all but many of the

participants have benefited from

belonging to a race and class that is

not over-represented in our criminal

justice system and some of the

participants have been pretty straight

up about that I grew up in a very

affluent town he said it was the kind of

place where it was easy not to have

contact with police of the few

interactions I had were very respectful

and innocuous a tap on the shoulder a

suggestion to go home understand that

not everyone is afforded that same

presumption of innocence for many people

in America especially black men and

youth their mere existence is seen as

now while you’re thinking about the

stories of the people who got away with

it consider the lives the narratives of

the people who are serving time right

now or suffering under the weight of a

record right now many for the same

behavior there are millions to choose

from if the criminal justice system was

designed by people that believe that

they might one day be involved he said

then we would have justice so I ask you

tonight what’s your story

what would your chalkboard say what

would life be like for you if you had to

check yes one of your professors Denis

Woodall has been asking students how

people in prison are those with criminal

records should be treated should people

in prison receive two or three meals a

day should they be allowed to study

behind bars a work upon release live

near you after collecting these

responses she then asks students to

reflect upon their own criminality

consider what life would be like had you

been prosecuted had you been punished

had you been labeled a criminal

she then returns to those first

questions once more she tells me that

more than 50% of the time for example

students who had at first said that

people behind prison people behind bars

should receive only two meals a day now

change their answers to three upon

realizing that they themselves could

have been the ones denied dinner for the

next eight years we are all criminals is

about closing that empathy chasm this is

a call for reason for mercy for equity

and an acknowledged ownership in the

problem as well as the solution so that

soon someday when Anthony that’s him

there opens a sheet of paper a page

that’s used to define his character he

finds not thief but father caregiver

nurse

speaker of multiple languages survivor

of genocide volunteer coach and avid

reader

a man not defined by his worst moment

but by his true worth with the luxury to

forget and with the opportunity to be

forgiven a man not tethered to his past

but wholly able to live in the present and to dream of a future thank you

Please follow and like us: