
[Applause]
have you ever been convicted of an
offense yes or no that’s the question
that had been weighing upon Anthony’s
mind as he hovered in the back of a
basement at the back of a government
centers basement room some six years ago
yes he would have to answer on his job
applications the last 13 to be exact
yes on his rental application yes on his
college application yes on his loan
application yes yes yes how would you
respond if like me and I you can say no
you haven’t been convicted of an offense
however if you said yes like Anthony
know that you are one of the 65 to 100
million people in the United States with
a criminal record let me tell you how I
met Anthony several years ago I left my
job in public defense to work in public
policy I thought that if I could change
the laws that were so acutely affecting
my clients I could be a better advocate
I took a job at a legal non-profit in
Minneapolis Minnesota and my focus was
on criminal records
we held expungement clinics in the
basement of that government Center in a
small windowless room in this space men
women and youth all pour predominantly
people of color would line up for hours
waiting for the opportunity to speak to
an attorney someone who may be able to
help them wipe that slate clean one
night I’m sure the son had long sent
Seth when in walked our last participant
Anthony was tall thin black and clearly
distraught as he hesitantly walked
toward me he pulled from his back pocket
a copy of his criminal record a printout
he had received from a computer terminal
two flights up I was nervous to open
this what could his record contain that
would cause him this much stress
a theft and a minor wanted that I let
out a short laugh of relief even if the
court doesn’t expunge the matter I said
it’s not like your life is over and with
that Anthony began to cry he told me
that even I Ito me that earlier that day
he had in fact tried to take his own
life
you see what was just a theft to me to
Anthony was a lost job it was miss
housing payments it was skipped meals
it was door after door slammed in his
face it was the loss of respect from his
friends and family the loss of a sense
of self the loss of hope around the same
time I had been traveling all around the
state speaking to legislators and
landlords employers and licensing boards
and imploring them to give my clients a
second chance
time and again I heard you can’t trust a
con once a criminal always a criminal
those words came back to me as I looked
at Anthony and I thought how many times
that I taken something that wasn’t mine
sure I considered my own criminality
before but not like this I hadn’t really
thought about what life would be like
living in the shadow of a criminal
record under the suffocating stigma of
having been caught what would life be
like if I didn’t have the luxury to
forget one in four people in the United
States has a criminal record
and that’s a conservative estimate by
the way I contend that four and four
have a criminal history for the past few
years I’ve been traveling all around the
United States interviewing people like
me the 75% of people who have criminal
histories but no record and asking them
what have you had the luxury to forget
tonight I want to share with you some of
those stories some are going to be petty
some are serious some happen decades ago
others a bit more recently in doing so I
hope to provide for you a new and
personal way of examining the the deep
effects of the juvenile and criminal
justice systems upon a person and the
disparate effect
of those systems upon poor people people
of color and indigenous people across
the US but first I want to make sure
we’re all on the same page this is a
graph made with data taken from the
Bureau of Justice Statistics and it
shows the US state and federal prison
population between 1925 and 2013 you can
see that we haven’t always been an
incarceration nation and some four
decades ago we began the deliberate and
regrettable march toward this the caging
of more than 1.5 million people wars on
drugs and poverty and mental illness
private prisons
three strikes rules mandatory minimum
sentencing in concentrated policing and
minority communities are just a few of
the many policies and practices that
have led to this 80 billion
dollar-a-year mass incarceration mass
disaster now what is additionally
concerning is what happens to people
when they’re no longer in the system
when they’re back in the communities
trying to get on with life that’s when a
new insidious form of punishment begins
when people find that they may not be
locked out or excuse me they’re not
locked up but are now locked out locked
out of jobs and in school and and
housing and countless other
opportunities to move on and move up now
before we delve into the world of
collateral consequences are those
lifelong effects of a criminal record
let’s turn back to this graph as I said
it shows the US state and federal prison
population just as importantly is what
it doesn’t show it doesn’t for example
show the millions of people who are in
county and parish jails those on
immigration holds on civil commitments
or kids in juvenile detention they are
not shown here on this graph it doesn’t
show the billions of people who are on
probation and parole their liberties
curtailed under the thumb of the
criminal justice system just not
spending their nights behind bars they
are not shown here on this graph and it
doesn’t show the tens of millions of
people like Anthony who are locked out
who are held underwater unable to come
up for air they are not shown here on
this graph and just as importantly it
doesn’t show
the nearly three million sons and
daughters the countless brothers and
sisters mothers and fathers of spouses
and partners and greater family and
community members who can all be
profoundly affected when someone is
taken out of the home and then not
allowed back in they are not shown here
on this graph so what may initially
appear to be a tsunami of humanity ready
to crash upon our shores you realize
it’s just a drop in the overall greater
ocean of a crisis that crisis is not
born equally across the country for
example from the Sentencing Project
blackmail sparked in 2001 face a
lifetime likelihood of imprisonment of
one in three for white women it’s 1 in
111 that’s not to say that white women
aren’t committing crimes right but we’re
not who you see proportionately speaking
in our criminal justice system
note that rates of offending do not come
close to explaining these disparities
looking at just the war on drugs for
example arguably one of the greatest
contributing factors to our current
carceral crisis black and white
individuals use and sell drugs at
roughly the same rate yet black
individuals are far more likely to be
stopped searched arrested charged
prosecuted and convicted for engaging in
drug-related activity than are white now
in addition to people of color poor
people people with mental health and
chemical dependency concerns are
likewise disproportionately affected and
yet we do little to address these issues
once someone’s in the system in fact we
do a lot to exacerbate the very problems
prison is where housing with trauma with
too few exceptions meaningful
opportunities for treatment and and
education they’re non-existent saddled
with criminal records people leave
prison I’m making second chances or
firsts exceedingly rare I said I’ve been
collecting these stories over the years
and they range in severity these stories
of the people who have gotten away with
it from quite serious like the student
and his aggravated robbery – and and the
pastor who brought a
loaded gun on an international flight –
relatively innocuous like this gentleman
who had an open bottle that’s carrying a
beer from one house party to the next
petty theft was the next one down that’s
failure to read to return a library book
which is an offense by the way the next
one down was public urination this
gentleman now has a contract worked with
the Department of Defense some of the
highest security clearance in the nation
had he been caught he would find
difficulty getting a job job at a gas
station
I know because many of my clients were
denied those very jobs for these very
records likewise the responses to the
recollections of past transgressions are
also varied like this gentleman who told
me about a time he had taken his uncle’s
hunting rifle out to college with him
one drunken night he decided to liberate
the quarters within a double posted
parking meter a single shot went right
through the locking mechanism letting
loose $40 worth of quarters he calls it
his 40 bucks shot and he laughed
throughout the entire interview some
people recognize not just the luxury to
forget but the luxury to not regret
while others are deeply sorry this woman
told me about a time when she was
working as a barista she said she used
to pad her tips with bills from the till
and she told me this the tears streamed
down her face she said I cannot imagine
what life would be like now had I been
labeled a thief then I’ve heard from law
enforcement officers who reflect upon
the weight of the mistakes that they’ve
made and time and again from people who
recognize that crime is an event in a
life course not a static characteristic
of one’s being and then I’ve heard some
truly heartbreaking stories like the the
gentleman from whom I took this
photograph he said he struggled to
survive his teens after one regrettable
Saturday morning he could have been
charged and convicted with a first
degree assault for the benefit of a gang
he wasn’t he graduated from high school
he got a scholarship to go to college he
went on to graduate school and now has a
PhD in biophysics his future was not for
clothes
and I’ve heard so many stories from
people who engaged in drug-related
activity on college campuses like this
gentleman who said he donated some of
his FAFSA funds to help finance a drug
ring he wanted a girlfriend or this
woman who said that she sold weed to
frat bros and football players that she
could get a hey what’s up in the hallway
she said she was sick of feeling
invisible and then there are some
stories that I just can’t believe we’re
still talking about in 2017 this woman
told me about a time just a few years
ago when her husband was diagnosed with
a particularly aggressive and terminal
form of cancer in the last few months of
his life she said his body became so
riddled with pain that he could no
longer pick up a pencil or shampoo his
own hair this man who the year before
had been an active marine ostensibly at
the peak of his physical career could
now no longer bathe himself she said the
only thing that could have swage that
pain was pot now she had asthma so he
couldn’t smoke it so instead she put the
pot in the butter and the butter and the
brownies and together they would eat it
and she said that when they did he could
on cramp his hand enough to hold hers he
died her life stopped she doesn’t
remember what she did with the pot maybe
she ate it she didn’t think so maybe her
friends did that’s more likely maybe she
threw it away it didn’t matter what
mattered was that her husband had just
died is that a story you think you can
use she said and I told her about a
phone call we had received at that legal
nonprofit there was an elder or Jibo a
woman who had been living with her only
Son a man in his 40s when he was
diagnosed with a particularly aggressive
in terminal form of cancer in the last
few months of his life his body became
so riddled in pain that she said it’s
like she would sit with just a shell of
his former self the only thing that
could have swage that pain was pod that
she
have asthma so he straight-up smoked it
and when he did she said it’s like her
baby was back with her again
he died her life stopped she didn’t move
his work boots from the back door or
toss his toothbrush from the bathroom
sink and she didn’t throw away the
baggies a pot that were in the freezer
some time went by and a search warrant
was executed on her home there have been
allegations she was warehousing drugs
police tore apart the place found the
pot in the freezer
she was arrested charged and later
convicted with a felony level possession
of controlled substances
this woman is 72 years old has no prior
criminal record and because of a felony
record is now living on the streets we
are all aware all criminals is about the
human cost of mass incarceration about
the human cost of mass criminalization
we have all violated the law but more
importantly we are all human and some of
us perhaps one in four of us may be in
need of a second chance but make no
mistake this project is also a
commentary on the disparate impact of
our nation’s policies policing and
prosecution many not all but many of the
participants have benefited from
belonging to a race and class that is
not over-represented in our criminal
justice system and some of the
participants have been pretty straight
up about that I grew up in a very
affluent town he said it was the kind of
place where it was easy not to have
contact with police of the few
interactions I had were very respectful
and innocuous a tap on the shoulder a
suggestion to go home understand that
not everyone is afforded that same
presumption of innocence for many people
in America especially black men and
youth their mere existence is seen as
now while you’re thinking about the
stories of the people who got away with
it consider the lives the narratives of
the people who are serving time right
now or suffering under the weight of a
record right now many for the same
behavior there are millions to choose
from if the criminal justice system was
designed by people that believe that
they might one day be involved he said
then we would have justice so I ask you
tonight what’s your story
what would your chalkboard say what
would life be like for you if you had to
check yes one of your professors Denis
Woodall has been asking students how
people in prison are those with criminal
records should be treated should people
in prison receive two or three meals a
day should they be allowed to study
behind bars a work upon release live
near you after collecting these
responses she then asks students to
reflect upon their own criminality
consider what life would be like had you
been prosecuted had you been punished
had you been labeled a criminal
she then returns to those first
questions once more she tells me that
more than 50% of the time for example
students who had at first said that
people behind prison people behind bars
should receive only two meals a day now
change their answers to three upon
realizing that they themselves could
have been the ones denied dinner for the
next eight years we are all criminals is
about closing that empathy chasm this is
a call for reason for mercy for equity
and an acknowledged ownership in the
problem as well as the solution so that
soon someday when Anthony that’s him
there opens a sheet of paper a page
that’s used to define his character he
finds not thief but father caregiver
nurse
speaker of multiple languages survivor
of genocide volunteer coach and avid
reader
a man not defined by his worst moment
but by his true worth with the luxury to
forget and with the opportunity to be
forgiven a man not tethered to his past
but wholly able to live in the present and to dream of a future thank you