Press "Enter" to skip to content

Voices from the Inside | Joshua Stone | TEDxCoconutGrove


have you ever had the fear that you

would have been a passive bystander in

the face of injustice for as long as I

can remember I’ve been afraid of who I

would have been during the long era of

slavery in this country or what role I

would have played during the reign of

Jim Crow it terrifies me to think that I

would have been on the wrong side of

history that I would have been a passive

bystander or perhaps even worse an

active participant few years ago I

discovered something that made this year

more pressing than ever a staggering

statistic that made the question of who

I would have been in history real rather

than merely hypothetical I learned that

the prison population in the United

States of America had increased by over

500% in the last 36 years resulting in a

country which makes up 5% of the world’s

population imprisoning 25% of the

world’s prison population let me repeat

that statistic the United States of

America nation which prides itself on

being the leader of the free world

currently makes up 5% of the world’s

population and yet imprisons 25% of the

world’s prison population making the us

the most jailing country in the history

of the world so here I am face to face

with the reality that injustice isn’t

just something that occurred but that is

occurring what more proof did I now need

to confirm my fear of who I would have

been if I proceeded to do nothing now

mass incarceration is a daunting

adversary for anyone let alone a white

middle-aged middle class high school

English teacher who’s never really taken

on much in regards to activism or any

other kind of so

change after thinking about the

situation realize that I needed I needed

to teach a course on the subject to

share with my students what I had

learned and hopefully to inspire them to

care the course I created is called

voices from the inside stories written

in or about prison and what they can

teach us about ourselves in addition to

teaching Michelle Alexander’s the new

Jim Crow I decided to include work by

dr. Martin Luther King jr. Nelson

Mandela Alexander Solzhenitsyn Viktor

Frankl and others I got really excited

about the class and started thinking

about all the great movies I could use

dead man walking in the name of the

Father and who could ever forget the

however despite my enthusiasm I knew

that something was missing as luck would

have it two days before the first day of

class I bumped into a former student who

was home from college on break started

to tell him about this new class I was

going to teach and about how thrilled I

was to teach it and he said that he had

recently befriended a young man out in

California who had coincidentally grown

up right here in Miami

this young man’s mother happened to be

teaching creative writing at the

Homestead Correctional Institution and

would certainly be interested in what I

was doing within a few hours I was on

the phone with the incomparable Kathy

inspired by her life and work in Haiti

Kathy Klarich dedicated herself to

teaching in prisons over the course of

her 13 and a half years in that country

she developed a heightened appreciation

for how important it is for people to

speak on their own behalf as she said to

me on a number of occasions if we

seriously want to talk about prison

reform we need to hear

those who were most directly affected by

the end of our first phone conversation

Cathy and I agreed to facilitate a

writing exchange between our students

immediately giving new and more profound

meaning to the title of my course voices

from the inside we decided the fashion

our exchange after a model that Cathy

had created with a professor at Florida

Atlantic University that paired students

on the inside with students on the

outside had them write under pseudonyms

in order to preserve anonymity and had

that had them submit a series of

personal narratives and critical

responses to various pieces of

literature those on the inside were

instructed not to write about their

crimes and those on the outside were

instructed not to ask about them the

void that existed in my class prior to

meeting Cathy had just been filled as

the voices my students would he be

hearing would not only be those of

artists and historical figures who had

something profound to say from behind

prison bars but those of people

currently incarcerated and they too had

something important to share under

Cathy’s incredible leadership I joined

the team of impassioned individuals to

start exchange for change a nonprofit

organization that sponsors and

facilitates writing courses in a number

of South Florida prisons since launching

in August of 2014

exchange for change has reached hundreds

and hundreds of students on both sides

of prison walls and this semester we are

currently offering 16 courses in four

different South Florida prisons we’ve

teamed with Oh Miami in an effort to

teach poetry and we are currently

partnering with the University of Miami

Florida International University Florida

Atlantic University and ransom

Everglades school many of our courses

revolve around a sense

for writing exchange which pairs

students on the inside with students on

the outside those on the inside must

undergo a thorough vetting process

implemented by the Department of

Corrections and must successfully

complete a semester long entry level

writing course before participating in

an exchange our theme for today is

escape and it probably seems obvious how

the writing courses we offer provide

those on the inside with a temporary

escape from their daily conditions I

felt that when I attended a graduation

ceremony at Everglades Correctional

Institution reentry this past December

at that event one of our students spoke

about what our courses mean to him he

began by saying that one of the most

important lessons he’s learned in prison

is that if you don’t learn how to

consume time time will consume you

although he originally enrolled in one

of our courses in the interest of

consuming time he soon learned that

something much more valuable was at

stake he said that our courses helped

him express himself and hone his

critical thinking skills and that for

the one hour a week he was in class he

was no longer in prison now one may ask

why should we provide prisoners with an

escape after all most of them are guilty

of committing the crimes that put them

behind bars in the first place but what

we on the outside need to understand is

that the educational escape

organizations like exchange for change

provide help those on the inside express

themselves in healthy ways as

individuals in a place that by its very

design warts individuality our courses

nurture the character and intellect of

our students and that’s in everyone’s

best interest regardless of whether

they’re going to become our neighbors or

remain behind bars

exchange for change has received

overwhelming support from the Department

of Corrections and they’ve provided us

with data as that has helped us assess

the positive impact our programs have

had what we’ve learned in general is

that educational programs inside prisons

improve prisoners reading and writing

skills improve their self-esteem

reinforce positive behavior and decrease

disciplinary problems help prisoners

forge closer relationships with their

families these programs increase release

prisoners chances of finding a job by

28% and decrease their chances of

returning to prison by 43 percent since

exchange for change began in 2014 none

of our formerly incarcerated students

have yet returned to prison that’s a

that’s a statistic we’re extraordinarily

proud of but what may be even more

surprising is that this exchange offers

our students on the outside and escaped

as well and escaped from a preoccupation

with grades from academic pressure and

from many of the ways many of them have

grown to think about their educational

experience instead of studying for a

test or writing a paper that’s going to

impact their GPAs my students engage in

a very different kind of learning one

that has them look past the prison label

by engaging in conversations through

walls erected to prevent them my

students connect with an actual human

being not just with the behaviors that

put that person behind bars as an

English teacher I believe wholeheartedly

in the transformative power of

literature with that said I’ve also

learned that even the best fiction

cannot replace direct human connections

mass incarceration has ballooned in this

country over the past half-century in

part because we’ve built huge

correctional facilities

remote locations out of sight and hence

out of mind we’ve erected massive walls

and massive fences for the sake of

separation and the growth of this system

has been predicated on those on the

outside having little to no contact with

those on the inside the discussions we

facilitate fly in the face of that

design and the results speak for

themselves

here’s an excerpt from an exchange that

took place just last semester my student

writes under the alias of summer and her

hello Siddhartha we have come to her

final exchange and my feelings are

bittersweet I lament that our exchange

of ideas has come to an end

but I’m extremely thankful for the

lessons that I have taken from your

responses I’ll be completely honest many

of my classmates including me gave in to

the stereotype of criminals being

uncivilized and ruthless I don’t really

know if some prisoners fit this

description but now I am confident that

it certainly does not apply to all we

also expected mediocre writing which we

thought would be typical of a criminal

however you and your classmates blew

those stereotypes away I feel so lucky

and could not have asked for a better

partner in this journey thank you for

showing me that prisoners are real

people who feel breathe and think not

monsters ideas stereotypes summer while

summer was completing her final entry

Siddhartha was composing his own high

summer I came to class eager to start

our next assignment then our instructor

reminded us that this would be our last

exchange

what no there’s so much more to summer

so much more to share so much more to

learn alas here we are I didn’t

anticipate learning so damn much you

your classmates are our future you give

me hope here behind these gates these

walls hope is more vital than food to

eat air to breathe hope gives me

to wake up and face a new day hope gives

my life purpose thank you for everything

when I meet our incarcerated students I

let them know that I work at a high

school that presents its students with

extraordinary opportunities and that

because of those opportunities many of

them are going to find themselves in

positions of power and influence later

in life with confidence I tell those on

the inside that from the confines of

your cells you are helping to make them

more empathetic and more sophisticated

as thinkers I don’t know about you but I

want my leaders to be empathetic and

sophisticated talented bright curious

caring wise reflective these are just

some of the adjectives my students now

use to describe their partners

adjectives they never would have

associated with the incarcerated prior

to participating in this exchange as a

facilitator who works primarily with

students on the outside I have to say

that the magic occurs when my students

realize that a person is not an idea as

somers words demonstrate those on the

outside come to learn that those who’ve

been tagged as criminals or felons are

real people with families a lifetime of

experiences ambitions and hope although

many of the lessons learned are shared

and therefore common others are more

unpredictable I would say that most of

my students learn to distinguish between

listening to respond and really

listening to understand to question and

challenge assumptions they previously

weren’t even aware they had and to see

that exercising judgment builds walls

while suspending judgment brings them

down additionally many of my students

emerge from the exchange with more

personal and unique takeaways some of

which relate to what it means to be a

citizen

and others which relate to what it means

to be themselves although I never could

have anticipated it there’s another

voice from the inside that my students

discover by participating in this

exchange and that’s that voice is their

own challenged by the quality the

authenticity and the power in the pieces

they receive my students often find

themselves feeling inadequate especially

early on in the process they quickly

realize that writing from the head just

isn’t going to do it in order to provide

their partners with writing worth

reading they need to learn to write from

the heart in the words of another past

high school participant through this

exchange the voices from the inside

actually came to life it was not Souls

indeed ‘sons ivan denisa bitch a person

I could hardly relate to it was Beth Ann

and extremely passionate and kind lady

who opened herself up to me and tell me

more about myself than I ever imagined I

could know I begin each semester by

introducing my students to the great

Russian novelist Fyodor Dostoevsky’s

profound claim that the degree of

civilization in any society can only be

exchange for change puts my students in

a unique position to more accurately

measure the degree of civilization of

penetrating walls that obscure

understanding is one way to start

bringing them down I’m here today to

recognize the work of all of our

students on both sides of prison walls

while many have gone on to engage more

fully and more directly like one who is

currently fighting for prison reform

through his University and another who

is teaching art classes at a State

Penitentiary through hers almost all of

our students have not only grown

but through this process have

participated in the growth of another I

open this talk with a confession sharing

with you my fear of placing myself in

history and realizing that I would have

been a path a passive bystander in the

face of injustice well what this work

has shown me is that historical

questions are contemporary questions and

though I’ve not yet overcome my fear I

do know that by facilitating these

conversations through prison walls we

are inspiring students on both sides of

those walls to be on the right side of

history thank you

[Applause] [Music]

Please follow and like us: