
good afternoon everyone I’m Lydia lui
and I want to spend a little time this
afternoon talking to you about
corporations that they were originally
designed to do public good what went
wrong
and as many of us were having lunch this
afternoon I was on the phone with my
family in the Dominican Republic and in
Miami talking about Irma and Jose that
is also immediately behind it and I want
to say that disasters do happen and when
they do our reaction to them is critical
my talk today begins with regard to deep
horizon as many of you recall deep
horizon caught on fire and exploded in a
matter of minutes in 2010 in the Gulf of
Mexico and as many of the world watched
in horror there were those that
responded immediately to help
particularly the US Coast Guard private
ships that were in the area to rescue
the 125 crew members that were on board
and needed to exit the rig immediately
125 individuals on board 17 severely
injured with second and third degree
burns eleven died in the explosion and
the ones that were rescued the first
thing that they did upon being rescued
was bending down and praying for those
of their colleagues that have not made
it the human impact on all of us
was staggering that this type of
connectivity was something that we too
would hope that whenever a tragedy would
strike that we would be able to respond
in kind for days and weeks later the
world watched as Deepwater Horizon
continued to burn it burned and 4.9
million barrels of oil spilled into the
Gulf of Mexico and as no water tends to
travel so as the water
downward into the Caribbean Sea so did
the oil and many of the Caribbean
islands where I am from are still
suffering from the environmental impact
of deepwater horizon out the world watch
this type of shocking human drama we
wanted answers and bp’s management
responds to questions that they were
being asked by the media The Guardian
the New York Times as to how this could
have happened Tony Hayward who was the
CEO at the time gave answers that were
very disturbing there were things such
as oh the Gulf of Mexico is such a large
body of water the amount of oil that
we’re putting in it
infant testimony other comments such as
well how did we BP get into the
situation it showed a disconnect for the
human interests and the actual
individuals that were suffering because
of the Deepwater Horizon explosion for
many of us we wanted answers in the US
and the US Congress responded
immediately with an investigation did
not waste any time in determining that
BP was reckless in its constant delay of
maintenance of the rig the US Committee
on Energy and Commerce specifically
noted that had BP management spent a
hundred and twenty eight thousand
dollars more and ten hours of work the
disaster would have been avoided that
angered a lot of people around the world
the just position of lives to be sick
maintenance that was avoided bothered us
greatly as a result of that BP reached a
settlement with the US government
fifteen point seven billion was given to
the US government in the various states
that were affected Texas Louisiana
Alabama Mississippi Florida my home
state these are the same states that you
might say are in the media again with
regard to
the Hurricanes Harvey Erma and now Jose
that is on its way
beep he continued to spend another fifty
four billion in environmental cleanup as
well as economic damage relief to those
who had lost everything so we must ask
ourselves why didn’t BP make the safety
repairs that needed to be done to
stabilize the Deepwater Horizon rig and
the answer is simple drilling schedule
bps concern is that if they didn’t
maintain their drilling schedule they
would be delayed in drawing the oil out
of the earth in barrelling the oil and
distributing it to its wide distribution
network in making the sales and in
making the profits so BP then traded
lives of individuals for profit
maximization of its shareholders we must
ask ourselves how did we get here where
there’s a trade-off to human lives to
profit and in particular it bothers me
greatly because that was not the
original purpose of corporations in the
United States corporations were
originally designed to build hospitals
and roads and home and highways and
schools and ports it was for the public
good and the immediate community in
which that corporation operated it
wasn’t to destroy lives or to simply
make a dollar so when did it change in
the US well the change primarily with
one man and one Court decision Henry
Ford Ford Motor Company he was the
majority shareholder and at the time in
1917 he wanted to implement an employee
benefits program because he had an
excess imagine this in excess of ten
million dollars of profit in 1917 that
is incredible and what he wanted to do
with the money was give it back to the
employees by giving them food housing
healthcare education make
are cheaper for his employees to
purchase and why would he do that you’re
wondering while it was right after World
War one and the US was in yet another
recession and some might even say light
depression there was very little food to
eat in the US was very little housing
and as the Chattanooga Times quoted
people were dying in the streets in the
United States and mr. Ford felt that his
money could be spent in bettering the
lives of his employees there was one
little problem the Dodge Brothers the
Dodge Brothers were minority
shareholders at the dodge at the Ford
Motor Company at the time and they
wanted that 10 million dollars of excess
profits distributed to them because they
had a little business to that they were
developing and they needed the money to
grow their business so here was a fight
between strong spirited men off to court
they went the Dodge Brothers sued Ford
Motor Company and a Michigan Court
decided when they read the corporate
charter of the Ford Motor Company which
indicates what is the legal purpose of
your business the judge realized all
handwritten into the line of what is
your legal purpose Henry Ford’s attorney
had written to make money and the court
said well if that is your purpose then
Ford Motor Company is not a charity you
cannot develop this type of employee
program the excess profits must be
distributed to the shareholders but the
court was speaking as to the Ford Motor
Company only it wasn’t speaking about
all corporations for all time to come
and it was focused on the purpose that
Henry Ford’s attorney had indicated in
the corporate charter every since then
we have had this culture not just within
the United States but it’s a global
culture within business that the focus
is to maximize profits for shareholders
and at times that the expense of the
environment and at the expense of human
lives so why has this misconception can
continued I cannot be the only person
who has read this surely there are
others that must say wait a minute
we’ve misunderstood all this time well
here’s what happens you will hear a lot
of Business School students business
scholars business leaders CNBC experts
tell you that management has a
responsibility to maximize profits for
shareholders and they are wrong
the truth is they are confusing the
concept of what we call if I do sherry
Duty which are two things one do what is
in the best interest of the corporation
and to be loyal to the corporation it
does not include making money for
shareholders by any means necessary that
is a custom that has developed further
to that there’s no US law that requires
a corporation to maximize profits for
shareholders it is only a custom that we
have become accustomed to this concept
was further entrenched by Milton
Friedman’s article in The New York Times
in 1970 where Milton Friedman is often
quoted as saying the sole responsibility
of corporations is to utilize all of his
resources and activities to maximize the
profits of shareholders that is not what
Milton Friedman said and nor was it what
he personally believed the remainder of
the sentence of his statement was never
included in anything that you really
read about mr. Friedman he said so long
as the corporations remain within the
rule of the game and that is to say that
they engage in free competition they do
not commit deception nor fraud that is
what he said but for the past 50 or so
years the American culture and global
business culture has disregarded that
and focused rather on maximizing profits
for shareholders but there’s good news
since 1995
particular since 2014 you see a huge
jump almost 200 percent jump with the
billions of dollars that are going into
the investments of socially conscious
investment strategies and whether that
be for social change in rural
communities whether that be for economic
development within urban centers whether
that be return to work for single moms
or those that are disabled there is a
consciousness within the US and other
countries as well that we can do better
there is an alternative construct by
which we can conduct business and not do
damage not to damage to the environment
not do damage to individuals and that
construct is the public benefits
corporation and within the Mandate of
the public benefits corporation what you
find is that there is a requirement for
the board and management to agree from
the onset that while in the process of
seeking profit they must must it is not
optional must weigh the impact of their
business decisions as to how it will
affect employees how will it affect the
environment how will it affect the
society within which they operate and
how will it affect for generations to
come
there is a conscious collective thought
process that we should not do harm with
the business decisions that we do today
and what we find is that this concept is
taking root it is taking root not only
in the United States and you see 33
states have already agreed to legalize
and support this concept of the public
benefits corporation and these are not
little States these are big states this
is the state of Maryland the state of
Pennsylvania the state of New York the
state of Delaware which has the which is
the largest venue of the multinational
corporations in the world have said we
the Chancery Court of Delaware agree
that there should be a different
mechanism
by which corporations are seeking
profits and you might say well are these
corporations that are considering the
welfare of others above making profits
their names that we recognize Ben and
Jerry’s a little ice cream anyone Cabot
a little cheese anyone let’s see which
is a European equivalent to eBay where
we’re all sort of trading stuff that we
don’t want anymore so these are large
companies well-known companies powerful
companies that are saying we can do
something different we can do it in a
different way that isn’t causing harm
while we are still making money and this
is not just happening the US that’s
happening in the UK in Canada in
Australia Italy last year said the
entire country can easily reincorporate
itself into a public benefits
corporation to make a statement that we
as a people can do better while seeking
the dollar so for me this is simply a
reconstruction of what the US
corporations were originally intended to
do provide a public good to the society
within which they operate it is good to
see that almost 200 years later we’re
fulfilling that goal
thank you
[Applause]
and I want to spend a little time this
afternoon talking to you about
corporations that they were originally
designed to do public good what went
wrong
and as many of us were having lunch this
afternoon I was on the phone with my
family in the Dominican Republic and in
Miami talking about Irma and Jose that
is also immediately behind it and I want
to say that disasters do happen and when
they do our reaction to them is critical
my talk today begins with regard to deep
horizon as many of you recall deep
horizon caught on fire and exploded in a
matter of minutes in 2010 in the Gulf of
Mexico and as many of the world watched
in horror there were those that
responded immediately to help
particularly the US Coast Guard private
ships that were in the area to rescue
the 125 crew members that were on board
and needed to exit the rig immediately
125 individuals on board 17 severely
injured with second and third degree
burns eleven died in the explosion and
the ones that were rescued the first
thing that they did upon being rescued
was bending down and praying for those
of their colleagues that have not made
it the human impact on all of us
was staggering that this type of
connectivity was something that we too
would hope that whenever a tragedy would
strike that we would be able to respond
in kind for days and weeks later the
world watched as Deepwater Horizon
continued to burn it burned and 4.9
million barrels of oil spilled into the
Gulf of Mexico and as no water tends to
travel so as the water
downward into the Caribbean Sea so did
the oil and many of the Caribbean
islands where I am from are still
suffering from the environmental impact
of deepwater horizon out the world watch
this type of shocking human drama we
wanted answers and bp’s management
responds to questions that they were
being asked by the media The Guardian
the New York Times as to how this could
have happened Tony Hayward who was the
CEO at the time gave answers that were
very disturbing there were things such
as oh the Gulf of Mexico is such a large
body of water the amount of oil that
we’re putting in it
infant testimony other comments such as
well how did we BP get into the
situation it showed a disconnect for the
human interests and the actual
individuals that were suffering because
of the Deepwater Horizon explosion for
many of us we wanted answers in the US
and the US Congress responded
immediately with an investigation did
not waste any time in determining that
BP was reckless in its constant delay of
maintenance of the rig the US Committee
on Energy and Commerce specifically
noted that had BP management spent a
hundred and twenty eight thousand
dollars more and ten hours of work the
disaster would have been avoided that
angered a lot of people around the world
the just position of lives to be sick
maintenance that was avoided bothered us
greatly as a result of that BP reached a
settlement with the US government
fifteen point seven billion was given to
the US government in the various states
that were affected Texas Louisiana
Alabama Mississippi Florida my home
state these are the same states that you
might say are in the media again with
regard to
the Hurricanes Harvey Erma and now Jose
that is on its way
beep he continued to spend another fifty
four billion in environmental cleanup as
well as economic damage relief to those
who had lost everything so we must ask
ourselves why didn’t BP make the safety
repairs that needed to be done to
stabilize the Deepwater Horizon rig and
the answer is simple drilling schedule
bps concern is that if they didn’t
maintain their drilling schedule they
would be delayed in drawing the oil out
of the earth in barrelling the oil and
distributing it to its wide distribution
network in making the sales and in
making the profits so BP then traded
lives of individuals for profit
maximization of its shareholders we must
ask ourselves how did we get here where
there’s a trade-off to human lives to
profit and in particular it bothers me
greatly because that was not the
original purpose of corporations in the
United States corporations were
originally designed to build hospitals
and roads and home and highways and
schools and ports it was for the public
good and the immediate community in
which that corporation operated it
wasn’t to destroy lives or to simply
make a dollar so when did it change in
the US well the change primarily with
one man and one Court decision Henry
Ford Ford Motor Company he was the
majority shareholder and at the time in
1917 he wanted to implement an employee
benefits program because he had an
excess imagine this in excess of ten
million dollars of profit in 1917 that
is incredible and what he wanted to do
with the money was give it back to the
employees by giving them food housing
healthcare education make
are cheaper for his employees to
purchase and why would he do that you’re
wondering while it was right after World
War one and the US was in yet another
recession and some might even say light
depression there was very little food to
eat in the US was very little housing
and as the Chattanooga Times quoted
people were dying in the streets in the
United States and mr. Ford felt that his
money could be spent in bettering the
lives of his employees there was one
little problem the Dodge Brothers the
Dodge Brothers were minority
shareholders at the dodge at the Ford
Motor Company at the time and they
wanted that 10 million dollars of excess
profits distributed to them because they
had a little business to that they were
developing and they needed the money to
grow their business so here was a fight
between strong spirited men off to court
they went the Dodge Brothers sued Ford
Motor Company and a Michigan Court
decided when they read the corporate
charter of the Ford Motor Company which
indicates what is the legal purpose of
your business the judge realized all
handwritten into the line of what is
your legal purpose Henry Ford’s attorney
had written to make money and the court
said well if that is your purpose then
Ford Motor Company is not a charity you
cannot develop this type of employee
program the excess profits must be
distributed to the shareholders but the
court was speaking as to the Ford Motor
Company only it wasn’t speaking about
all corporations for all time to come
and it was focused on the purpose that
Henry Ford’s attorney had indicated in
the corporate charter every since then
we have had this culture not just within
the United States but it’s a global
culture within business that the focus
is to maximize profits for shareholders
and at times that the expense of the
environment and at the expense of human
lives so why has this misconception can
continued I cannot be the only person
who has read this surely there are
others that must say wait a minute
we’ve misunderstood all this time well
here’s what happens you will hear a lot
of Business School students business
scholars business leaders CNBC experts
tell you that management has a
responsibility to maximize profits for
shareholders and they are wrong
the truth is they are confusing the
concept of what we call if I do sherry
Duty which are two things one do what is
in the best interest of the corporation
and to be loyal to the corporation it
does not include making money for
shareholders by any means necessary that
is a custom that has developed further
to that there’s no US law that requires
a corporation to maximize profits for
shareholders it is only a custom that we
have become accustomed to this concept
was further entrenched by Milton
Friedman’s article in The New York Times
in 1970 where Milton Friedman is often
quoted as saying the sole responsibility
of corporations is to utilize all of his
resources and activities to maximize the
profits of shareholders that is not what
Milton Friedman said and nor was it what
he personally believed the remainder of
the sentence of his statement was never
included in anything that you really
read about mr. Friedman he said so long
as the corporations remain within the
rule of the game and that is to say that
they engage in free competition they do
not commit deception nor fraud that is
what he said but for the past 50 or so
years the American culture and global
business culture has disregarded that
and focused rather on maximizing profits
for shareholders but there’s good news
since 1995
particular since 2014 you see a huge
jump almost 200 percent jump with the
billions of dollars that are going into
the investments of socially conscious
investment strategies and whether that
be for social change in rural
communities whether that be for economic
development within urban centers whether
that be return to work for single moms
or those that are disabled there is a
consciousness within the US and other
countries as well that we can do better
there is an alternative construct by
which we can conduct business and not do
damage not to damage to the environment
not do damage to individuals and that
construct is the public benefits
corporation and within the Mandate of
the public benefits corporation what you
find is that there is a requirement for
the board and management to agree from
the onset that while in the process of
seeking profit they must must it is not
optional must weigh the impact of their
business decisions as to how it will
affect employees how will it affect the
environment how will it affect the
society within which they operate and
how will it affect for generations to
come
there is a conscious collective thought
process that we should not do harm with
the business decisions that we do today
and what we find is that this concept is
taking root it is taking root not only
in the United States and you see 33
states have already agreed to legalize
and support this concept of the public
benefits corporation and these are not
little States these are big states this
is the state of Maryland the state of
Pennsylvania the state of New York the
state of Delaware which has the which is
the largest venue of the multinational
corporations in the world have said we
the Chancery Court of Delaware agree
that there should be a different
mechanism
by which corporations are seeking
profits and you might say well are these
corporations that are considering the
welfare of others above making profits
their names that we recognize Ben and
Jerry’s a little ice cream anyone Cabot
a little cheese anyone let’s see which
is a European equivalent to eBay where
we’re all sort of trading stuff that we
don’t want anymore so these are large
companies well-known companies powerful
companies that are saying we can do
something different we can do it in a
different way that isn’t causing harm
while we are still making money and this
is not just happening the US that’s
happening in the UK in Canada in
Australia Italy last year said the
entire country can easily reincorporate
itself into a public benefits
corporation to make a statement that we
as a people can do better while seeking
the dollar so for me this is simply a
reconstruction of what the US
corporations were originally intended to
do provide a public good to the society
within which they operate it is good to
see that almost 200 years later we’re
fulfilling that goal
thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: