
they knew that once a psychologist won the
which is known as the Nobel prize of
economy
have ever heard very well I
ever heard
the potential that psychology has and
other social sciences to contribute
and expand the horizons of the economy
some follow some
[Music]
had heard about this new area
of this emerging area that is called
behavioral economics or economics of
behavior
Well, I invite you to follow this
history and through this discover
some of the ideas is very interesting
would make my passion
to begin with I want everyone to have the
eyes
to see closes them and I want us
let’s go back to the Peru of some decades
back say from the late eighties
that they hear that they see very well
social discontent terrorism
protests hyperinflation and so on now
I want you to open your eyes
look at each other time has
past
see you center and reflect that the
Peru despite the problems we have
because we still have progress has been made
today there are people look at me that we have
goals we have dreams and not only that but
that today it is possible to reach them
well when I thought that
study I wanted something that could be
applied for the development of my country
so I was wondering what it is that
could be behind the main
problems of a society
and what is it in mind that maybe it was the
economy the economy as a basis for
improve the well – being of people
however what happens if one starts to
perceive that this economy is not so
real and as human as one initially
I believed
when one studies economics one gets to
the class of my economy and the first
what they tell you are these
assumptions its rational selection axiom
of bologna mambo reaction of 47 the
axiom of transitivity completeness
continuity independence I want
convey to them the intuition of one of
these the transitivity for example if
I asked them to choose between a dish
orange wine let’s suppose that the great
most prefer the banana and then I
I gave them to contrast between an orange
and an apple suppose that the great
most prefer the orange and I
labors I do the comparison between
banana and apple are going to tell me that
they will prefer the dish
this ordering of ideas these axioms
that we suppose just to
move a rational people that allows us
Well , it allows us
elaborate functions is to have derivatives
consider distributions create models
mathematicians
that’s a very good thing for the economist
but what happens many times we have
tempted sense a little enthralled by
the great elegance of mathematics and
we have taken reality and we have
molded to fit in our
models instead of fighting to expand
our knowledge of mathematics
and could explain at least a little bit of the
great complexity that is the world and the
society
at that time to the university too
a moment to cook a lot for
the languages were a window to new
cultures each of these are continuing
at that time also that there is in mind
in another detail the many economists
sometimes we generalize we speak in terms
aggregates for example maybe they are
examples taken from the hairs but if
they saw extraterrestrial and had to
decide us to us as beings
humans could say that we are people
with two legs two arms a head and
testicle one
on average
they realize what happens when
we generalize economists
obviously we control for gender by
sex and many other variables but
there were always going to be variables that
they lose variables that can be very
relevant at the individual level and the level
ethnic and social groups and so on
at that time and my passion for
languages once outside the
university I found an ad that
I said sign language is taught and I said
good great a new language that
learn a language that studies that
study the signs so great I went and what
What I discovered was that not only
generality that we sometimes do
economists can have an impact on
our models but also how
we perceive and how we finally design
policies
the deaf community is a community of
millions of people in the country but that
usually remains invisible to the point of
that many of the people in this
community feel or see in your link
amical or sentimental with the listeners
as one of its main or its only
means to get older
opportunities and get ahead when not
It should be like that
I want to raise this dilemma dilemma
of the tram or train dilemma raised
initially by the British philosopher
fort in 67 imagine that you see
a train a train that goes by and on the way
that train there are five people tied there
by some evil economists let’s say
I did not go back
and you see that his side there is a
lever with which they can deflect the
train but when you drive it will go by
another way in which there is again a
person tied by some economist
evil that I charged was not me
think about that situation
wanted to
action would do on the lever or not
they would let him kill five people or the
action they would make so that I saw mate a
truly five lives are worth five
times a
How complicated because if besides being
this a moral dilemma of ethical slogan
It is also a clear example of what
complicated that are usually several of
our decisions
was realizing these things that
I understood that the economy could not
explain everything was difficult that can
explain several of our process
decision making at that time in the
college
I had a very good friend a partner
that I studied psychology and that
introduced many of those themes from
from there I started to get very interested in
this connection between the economy and the
psychology that sometimes is not so
evident
but then I had the fortune to train
specialize in this area and discover
a discipline that just combines
these two social sciences and it’s called
behavioral economics or
behavioral economics
I want you to see this image many look
marcos I know those two tables are
exactly the same size of it
long because if it is not that what
I want you to realize is that despite
rationally they know they are the same
equal size your brain is going to do
seeing is going to make him believe and feel that
on the right is longer than the
left even though they are exactly the
very long
now I want that in these two circles
I have seen many times on the internet
which are exactly the same but
remember that although rationally
you know or I can tell you that they are
exactly the same
they will perceive the one on the left as
bigger than the one on the right
They even though as I said are told
exactly the same
it is this same intuition of the
illusions which can also be
understand how we deviate
as we have biases in our process
of decision making and one of them is
known as frame effect nothing to do
with my name by the way is our
reduction to Spanish of framing effects
studied by manifest meat and in 81
imagine that you are ministers of
health in a small nations and certain
people and must face a
foreign disease and its scientists
they give him to choose two types of
medicines a medicine with which
200 people will be saved
or a medication with which there is a
third of probability that 600 people
they go out and two thirds that nobody gets
saves
what option would you choose?
I see a little doubt there but many
they tilt for the first I’ve heard
makes it a little more obvious let’s see
again that situation equal minister
of a small nation’s health say the
people a foreign disease what
medication would choose
medication option x 400 people
die or medication and with which there is
a third of reality that nobody dies and
two-thirds chance that 600
people die they would choose now
now there is a little more doubt there is no
so much inclination for the X out there
I hear a little more of the air because in
this experiment when it was done in the
81 just me the following
results in the first case people
chose the vast majority of the option
72%
and in the second case only a 22 by 7
I said the option x a 78 percent chose
the option
but they have noticed something the
option is exactly the same in the option
x if I suggest countries visits
people if two hundred are saved how many
die 400 which is the option x there is x
they are exactly the same as you see
so are the options in particular
they have not changed the only thing that was modified
it was how it was offered as it framed the
response and that new one in mark to
that change to pose it as a
gain as a loss your impact so
significant to the point of being able to reverse
the preferences of the people
this led to what became known as the
foresight theory which
just contributed to that daniel
Kahneman psychologist will win the prize
nobel of economy in 2002 this india
poses we hold a point of
reference from which
we consider things as lost or
as earnings in addition to the impact of
the losses is much higher in our
minds that their corresponding
gain a loss of 100 soles has
a major impact on our mind is that
a gain say
another very interesting theory a pinnacle
also from the behavior economy
is the discount quasi verbo lic
hyperbolic discount will say that is this
Such a bombastic name is good
name only of a function but I want
leave you with intuition
let’s simplify we think it’s half a day
and I offer them a pizza slider they have
a pizza slide now or maybe
prefer two slides but here to three
hours at three
very much you said if at the beginning a
Pixar slider at this time is fine
it is valid
but what happens if now I was
decide
who prefer a pizza slider from here to
one month at this time
or two is the says pizzas from here to a month
but at three to three
Many will say good if I’m going to wait for a
month then now better but two
months and three and a half hours not your lights
true
well, right there will also be a
reversion of preferences something that low
an exponential discount of the economy
traditional could not be explained
a new example so you have the
intuition imagine that you arrive
Friday after being super tired and
the next Saturday at 11 they have a
exam and you commit to another
early to study and I’m going to do it
how many times have they said that night
previous I do a lot of truth but what
the new one happens
we are approaching the most at the moment in
that we made the decision dawn
the alarm sounds at 5 o’clock in the morning
they have to get up to study
when you have not been tempted
to turn off the alarm nothing good
many truth what happened there again
there was a reversal of preferences
according to the moment of taking
decision approached the present
you suffered this bias from
present and the temptation to sleep a
more time despite that is a benefit
short term and not something so promising
how to give a good test and have a better
performance was finally what impacted
of you imagine that led to
other contexts for example when a
sometimes they have been tempted by some
candy instead of taking care of your health
how many times as a society do we see
tempted to continue polluting instead of
better preserve the environment
interestingly, it has been discovered
that poverty also limitations
economic have a psychological impact
in people and it’s precisely because of
this way
I studied san marcos’ a university
public a university of which I
I feel really very proud and in the
which people of all types come together
diverse economic and very, very, very, very
smart much more than I
I will be
just when I was studying in some
moment I liked to ask my
colleagues and I realized that those
that unfortunately they had more
abe financial difficulties are
they limited in something in their projections
I told them he hears good when in those
what do you want to be that is good to get
a job and there was no more and that’s
totally valid
but those people and in general I
I tell them many times we put aside
in voice of perhaps more pulled benefits
to the present we leave aside benefits
that would be better something more to the future is
true sometimes we have to do some
sacrifices some investments but
those future benefits that we can
get for better training and a
greater effort finally not only go away
to see reflected for us but
also for our families and in
general in our contribution to
our society and our country
then this idea of trying to push
a little to society to people for the
correct path has a name is called
a h is just the definition raised
by richard thaler the Nobel Prize
2017 economy
this idea of how an elephant mother
he pushes his little son for the good
path that is also used in these
tools given by the economy of
behavior to be able to push the
people towards making more decisions
suitable for your own benefit and
for the society
I want to give you this example of donation
of organs for a theme by johnson and
goldstein in 2003 observe the
percentage of donor organs in each
country and in the case of German and the case of
austria notice a big difference 12% in
1 and 99% in another that explains this
cultural differences maybe
it does not seem no germany austria are
relatively similar culturally
Well speaking what is behind
all this is the form that is used in
a first case in the first countries in
red a scarf is worn and in which
defect as a basis people are not a
now of organs unless you indicate what
you want to do
in the second case they are all donors
of organs unless they indicate
they do not want to be and only that little one
change of the default option option
base can have a very impact
significant in the percentage of
effective donors that will finally go to
have a country
and I mention this example for two
things
one
I told you this companion with whom
I started to get interested in psychology
she died very young
He died just because of an aneurysm and
at the time his family
He chose to make him donate his
organs
How nice to be able to expand a
life through other
and the second thing that nice would be to use those
tools given by the economy of
behavior just so that this
could be extended there are so many people
in hospitals waiting day by day
by some donor and neither offer of
donation of organs that would be good
design a policy that contributes to
this
and that is the second point just
this week the health ministry is
debating this change change the option
default of not to be the option
default of the xi always preserving the
free choice we can all be or not
be go of string organs like
we want but finally a change in
this first option can have a
positive impact and even save lives
as you have seen in this example
finally I want to give you some small
prospects of the economy
behavior in the future as already
we have seen this from the neurosciences
every time we understand more how it works
our decision-making circuit
so we also understand how it is that
we value we have already identified the
parts the areas of our brain that
they commit themselves in this little process to
so we can go and go beyond what
that an economist once said as
milton friedman this the models
economic should only be judged by
its predictive capacity but not for the
truthfulness of their assumptions or their
axioms maybe if it ‘s time to go more
beyond that and really the bases that
located in the brain of our process
of taking actions to understand from
more precisely what is happening
within each one of us what is it
what happens in our black boxes
so also today we live in a time of
truth day by day data are generated more
data on facebook on google on twitter
on youtube etcetera and many of your
data that are are social data of
preferences
of elections and so on
all those data that together
we could tell you that they are a big data
social will also allow us to have a
better a better understanding of how it is
that people choose
and so to be able to create oneself more
specific to be able to have an impact
positive in areas of development but
there is one I could say frame this can
be also a bit dangerous if you
use badly and it can be true
a bit dangerous if it is used for
questionable some political purpose perhaps
some end in which we are not all
very much agree and that’s why we should
preserve as long as the scope of
action of nats and the economy of
behavior must be areas of
development areas such as educational improvement
how poverty reduction improves
of the health environment and so on
areas in which we are all in
agreement and I want here to bring up
a phrase from the guy who waits for you
we should always remember and it is
that a great power always entails a
Big responsibility
Finally
both from the side of a better understanding
of people in their capacity in their
emotions his passions his cries and his
laughs as we have felt them today as
on the side of its application in areas
of development in which we are all
in agreement
for those reasons is that I name this
area as a more humane economy
although it is commonly known as the
behavioral economics
once our Nobel Prize Vargas
llosa said that sometimes
economists tell better stories
that the novelists
He said, I do not know if this is one of these
times but humbly I hope that it
have been left with something they have learned
everything happens is something and know how to use it
in the best way thank you very much
[Applause]
which is known as the Nobel prize of
economy
have ever heard very well I
ever heard
the potential that psychology has and
other social sciences to contribute
and expand the horizons of the economy
some follow some
[Music]
had heard about this new area
of this emerging area that is called
behavioral economics or economics of
behavior
Well, I invite you to follow this
history and through this discover
some of the ideas is very interesting
would make my passion
to begin with I want everyone to have the
eyes
to see closes them and I want us
let’s go back to the Peru of some decades
back say from the late eighties
that they hear that they see very well
social discontent terrorism
protests hyperinflation and so on now
I want you to open your eyes
look at each other time has
past
see you center and reflect that the
Peru despite the problems we have
because we still have progress has been made
today there are people look at me that we have
goals we have dreams and not only that but
that today it is possible to reach them
well when I thought that
study I wanted something that could be
applied for the development of my country
so I was wondering what it is that
could be behind the main
problems of a society
and what is it in mind that maybe it was the
economy the economy as a basis for
improve the well – being of people
however what happens if one starts to
perceive that this economy is not so
real and as human as one initially
I believed
when one studies economics one gets to
the class of my economy and the first
what they tell you are these
assumptions its rational selection axiom
of bologna mambo reaction of 47 the
axiom of transitivity completeness
continuity independence I want
convey to them the intuition of one of
these the transitivity for example if
I asked them to choose between a dish
orange wine let’s suppose that the great
most prefer the banana and then I
I gave them to contrast between an orange
and an apple suppose that the great
most prefer the orange and I
labors I do the comparison between
banana and apple are going to tell me that
they will prefer the dish
this ordering of ideas these axioms
that we suppose just to
move a rational people that allows us
Well , it allows us
elaborate functions is to have derivatives
consider distributions create models
mathematicians
that’s a very good thing for the economist
but what happens many times we have
tempted sense a little enthralled by
the great elegance of mathematics and
we have taken reality and we have
molded to fit in our
models instead of fighting to expand
our knowledge of mathematics
and could explain at least a little bit of the
great complexity that is the world and the
society
at that time to the university too
a moment to cook a lot for
the languages were a window to new
cultures each of these are continuing
at that time also that there is in mind
in another detail the many economists
sometimes we generalize we speak in terms
aggregates for example maybe they are
examples taken from the hairs but if
they saw extraterrestrial and had to
decide us to us as beings
humans could say that we are people
with two legs two arms a head and
testicle one
on average
they realize what happens when
we generalize economists
obviously we control for gender by
sex and many other variables but
there were always going to be variables that
they lose variables that can be very
relevant at the individual level and the level
ethnic and social groups and so on
at that time and my passion for
languages once outside the
university I found an ad that
I said sign language is taught and I said
good great a new language that
learn a language that studies that
study the signs so great I went and what
What I discovered was that not only
generality that we sometimes do
economists can have an impact on
our models but also how
we perceive and how we finally design
policies
the deaf community is a community of
millions of people in the country but that
usually remains invisible to the point of
that many of the people in this
community feel or see in your link
amical or sentimental with the listeners
as one of its main or its only
means to get older
opportunities and get ahead when not
It should be like that
I want to raise this dilemma dilemma
of the tram or train dilemma raised
initially by the British philosopher
fort in 67 imagine that you see
a train a train that goes by and on the way
that train there are five people tied there
by some evil economists let’s say
I did not go back
and you see that his side there is a
lever with which they can deflect the
train but when you drive it will go by
another way in which there is again a
person tied by some economist
evil that I charged was not me
think about that situation
wanted to
action would do on the lever or not
they would let him kill five people or the
action they would make so that I saw mate a
truly five lives are worth five
times a
How complicated because if besides being
this a moral dilemma of ethical slogan
It is also a clear example of what
complicated that are usually several of
our decisions
was realizing these things that
I understood that the economy could not
explain everything was difficult that can
explain several of our process
decision making at that time in the
college
I had a very good friend a partner
that I studied psychology and that
introduced many of those themes from
from there I started to get very interested in
this connection between the economy and the
psychology that sometimes is not so
evident
but then I had the fortune to train
specialize in this area and discover
a discipline that just combines
these two social sciences and it’s called
behavioral economics or
behavioral economics
I want you to see this image many look
marcos I know those two tables are
exactly the same size of it
long because if it is not that what
I want you to realize is that despite
rationally they know they are the same
equal size your brain is going to do
seeing is going to make him believe and feel that
on the right is longer than the
left even though they are exactly the
very long
now I want that in these two circles
I have seen many times on the internet
which are exactly the same but
remember that although rationally
you know or I can tell you that they are
exactly the same
they will perceive the one on the left as
bigger than the one on the right
They even though as I said are told
exactly the same
it is this same intuition of the
illusions which can also be
understand how we deviate
as we have biases in our process
of decision making and one of them is
known as frame effect nothing to do
with my name by the way is our
reduction to Spanish of framing effects
studied by manifest meat and in 81
imagine that you are ministers of
health in a small nations and certain
people and must face a
foreign disease and its scientists
they give him to choose two types of
medicines a medicine with which
200 people will be saved
or a medication with which there is a
third of probability that 600 people
they go out and two thirds that nobody gets
saves
what option would you choose?
I see a little doubt there but many
they tilt for the first I’ve heard
makes it a little more obvious let’s see
again that situation equal minister
of a small nation’s health say the
people a foreign disease what
medication would choose
medication option x 400 people
die or medication and with which there is
a third of reality that nobody dies and
two-thirds chance that 600
people die they would choose now
now there is a little more doubt there is no
so much inclination for the X out there
I hear a little more of the air because in
this experiment when it was done in the
81 just me the following
results in the first case people
chose the vast majority of the option
72%
and in the second case only a 22 by 7
I said the option x a 78 percent chose
the option
but they have noticed something the
option is exactly the same in the option
x if I suggest countries visits
people if two hundred are saved how many
die 400 which is the option x there is x
they are exactly the same as you see
so are the options in particular
they have not changed the only thing that was modified
it was how it was offered as it framed the
response and that new one in mark to
that change to pose it as a
gain as a loss your impact so
significant to the point of being able to reverse
the preferences of the people
this led to what became known as the
foresight theory which
just contributed to that daniel
Kahneman psychologist will win the prize
nobel of economy in 2002 this india
poses we hold a point of
reference from which
we consider things as lost or
as earnings in addition to the impact of
the losses is much higher in our
minds that their corresponding
gain a loss of 100 soles has
a major impact on our mind is that
a gain say
another very interesting theory a pinnacle
also from the behavior economy
is the discount quasi verbo lic
hyperbolic discount will say that is this
Such a bombastic name is good
name only of a function but I want
leave you with intuition
let’s simplify we think it’s half a day
and I offer them a pizza slider they have
a pizza slide now or maybe
prefer two slides but here to three
hours at three
very much you said if at the beginning a
Pixar slider at this time is fine
it is valid
but what happens if now I was
decide
who prefer a pizza slider from here to
one month at this time
or two is the says pizzas from here to a month
but at three to three
Many will say good if I’m going to wait for a
month then now better but two
months and three and a half hours not your lights
true
well, right there will also be a
reversion of preferences something that low
an exponential discount of the economy
traditional could not be explained
a new example so you have the
intuition imagine that you arrive
Friday after being super tired and
the next Saturday at 11 they have a
exam and you commit to another
early to study and I’m going to do it
how many times have they said that night
previous I do a lot of truth but what
the new one happens
we are approaching the most at the moment in
that we made the decision dawn
the alarm sounds at 5 o’clock in the morning
they have to get up to study
when you have not been tempted
to turn off the alarm nothing good
many truth what happened there again
there was a reversal of preferences
according to the moment of taking
decision approached the present
you suffered this bias from
present and the temptation to sleep a
more time despite that is a benefit
short term and not something so promising
how to give a good test and have a better
performance was finally what impacted
of you imagine that led to
other contexts for example when a
sometimes they have been tempted by some
candy instead of taking care of your health
how many times as a society do we see
tempted to continue polluting instead of
better preserve the environment
interestingly, it has been discovered
that poverty also limitations
economic have a psychological impact
in people and it’s precisely because of
this way
I studied san marcos’ a university
public a university of which I
I feel really very proud and in the
which people of all types come together
diverse economic and very, very, very, very
smart much more than I
I will be
just when I was studying in some
moment I liked to ask my
colleagues and I realized that those
that unfortunately they had more
abe financial difficulties are
they limited in something in their projections
I told them he hears good when in those
what do you want to be that is good to get
a job and there was no more and that’s
totally valid
but those people and in general I
I tell them many times we put aside
in voice of perhaps more pulled benefits
to the present we leave aside benefits
that would be better something more to the future is
true sometimes we have to do some
sacrifices some investments but
those future benefits that we can
get for better training and a
greater effort finally not only go away
to see reflected for us but
also for our families and in
general in our contribution to
our society and our country
then this idea of trying to push
a little to society to people for the
correct path has a name is called
a h is just the definition raised
by richard thaler the Nobel Prize
2017 economy
this idea of how an elephant mother
he pushes his little son for the good
path that is also used in these
tools given by the economy of
behavior to be able to push the
people towards making more decisions
suitable for your own benefit and
for the society
I want to give you this example of donation
of organs for a theme by johnson and
goldstein in 2003 observe the
percentage of donor organs in each
country and in the case of German and the case of
austria notice a big difference 12% in
1 and 99% in another that explains this
cultural differences maybe
it does not seem no germany austria are
relatively similar culturally
Well speaking what is behind
all this is the form that is used in
a first case in the first countries in
red a scarf is worn and in which
defect as a basis people are not a
now of organs unless you indicate what
you want to do
in the second case they are all donors
of organs unless they indicate
they do not want to be and only that little one
change of the default option option
base can have a very impact
significant in the percentage of
effective donors that will finally go to
have a country
and I mention this example for two
things
one
I told you this companion with whom
I started to get interested in psychology
she died very young
He died just because of an aneurysm and
at the time his family
He chose to make him donate his
organs
How nice to be able to expand a
life through other
and the second thing that nice would be to use those
tools given by the economy of
behavior just so that this
could be extended there are so many people
in hospitals waiting day by day
by some donor and neither offer of
donation of organs that would be good
design a policy that contributes to
this
and that is the second point just
this week the health ministry is
debating this change change the option
default of not to be the option
default of the xi always preserving the
free choice we can all be or not
be go of string organs like
we want but finally a change in
this first option can have a
positive impact and even save lives
as you have seen in this example
finally I want to give you some small
prospects of the economy
behavior in the future as already
we have seen this from the neurosciences
every time we understand more how it works
our decision-making circuit
so we also understand how it is that
we value we have already identified the
parts the areas of our brain that
they commit themselves in this little process to
so we can go and go beyond what
that an economist once said as
milton friedman this the models
economic should only be judged by
its predictive capacity but not for the
truthfulness of their assumptions or their
axioms maybe if it ‘s time to go more
beyond that and really the bases that
located in the brain of our process
of taking actions to understand from
more precisely what is happening
within each one of us what is it
what happens in our black boxes
so also today we live in a time of
truth day by day data are generated more
data on facebook on google on twitter
on youtube etcetera and many of your
data that are are social data of
preferences
of elections and so on
all those data that together
we could tell you that they are a big data
social will also allow us to have a
better a better understanding of how it is
that people choose
and so to be able to create oneself more
specific to be able to have an impact
positive in areas of development but
there is one I could say frame this can
be also a bit dangerous if you
use badly and it can be true
a bit dangerous if it is used for
questionable some political purpose perhaps
some end in which we are not all
very much agree and that’s why we should
preserve as long as the scope of
action of nats and the economy of
behavior must be areas of
development areas such as educational improvement
how poverty reduction improves
of the health environment and so on
areas in which we are all in
agreement and I want here to bring up
a phrase from the guy who waits for you
we should always remember and it is
that a great power always entails a
Big responsibility
Finally
both from the side of a better understanding
of people in their capacity in their
emotions his passions his cries and his
laughs as we have felt them today as
on the side of its application in areas
of development in which we are all
in agreement
for those reasons is that I name this
area as a more humane economy
although it is commonly known as the
behavioral economics
once our Nobel Prize Vargas
llosa said that sometimes
economists tell better stories
that the novelists
He said, I do not know if this is one of these
times but humbly I hope that it
have been left with something they have learned
everything happens is something and know how to use it
in the best way thank you very much
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: