
we reached peak law book in 1998 so I
started law school in the fall of 1999
one of the very first things that we had
to do at law school was complete a
library research assignment so we were
given multiple questions we had to go
into the stacks roam around find the
correct thick leather bound volumes to
answer the questions in the assignment
and it really was at Paper Chase we had
to chase from stack to stack find the
cross references and it took several
hours to get through this and we were
all fighting for largely at the same
volumes and you know fighting over these
books
two weeks later I found myself in the
basement of the same Law School Library
in the computer lab 20 computers so as
with 19 of my colleagues in the law
school class and completely
independently of this research
assignment we were being instructed how
to use online legal research tools to
answer largely the same questions using
an online system and my mind was blown
it was so much easier to find what we’re
looking for then chasing through the
stacks fighting over you know books but
I’m not here to dump on the book or say
that the book is a terrible thing of
course the book is an amazing invention
if you think back to Gutenberg’s
printing press in 1440 and the
combination of that with movable type
and what ensued in the following six
centuries it’s actually phenomenal
alright originally millions of Bibles
were produced mass-produced using the
printing press that led to things like
the Protestant Reformation the Counter
Reformation the Council of Trent but
eventually led to significant progress
in the arts and science dissemination of
progress in the arts and sciences led to
the enlightenment led to the Industrial
Revolution led to public libraries led
to public education led to reforms to
the way in which we govern ourselves but
two very significant
old changes led to on and on and on
right up to the present a very
complicated modern nation-state who has
a and we should we have as it’s one of
its key infrastructure elements the
legal system now if we zoom in on the
legal system and the role that the book
has played in the legal system it’s
equally compelling so think about the
legal system in the absence of printed
books it’s really it’s hard to think of
we have oral traditions before that we
would have had you know rules that were
hand written prior to the development of
the book but with the book made possible
is the common law so case reporters were
some of the earliest books produced and
just publication of what the courts are
actually doing that led to things like
secondary materials like commentaries on
the laws of England by Blackstone an
incredible scholarly effort going
through and reading hundreds and
hundreds and hundreds of judgments of
the courts the common law courts in
England and compiling what it actually
meant for the legal system in trying to
draw categories and identify trends in
the case law subsequent to that of
course we have the publication of lots
of primary material statutes regulations
and the publication of all of these
materials allowed for the emergence of
the modern law school led to the
emergence of a thriving scholarly
enterprise of critiquing the laws
commenting on the normative desirability
of the laws led to everything that we
now take for granted as part of the
legal infrastructure that led to the
modern regulatory state all of this is
because of the book now I teach tax law
tax law is my specialty so I’m going to
use tax as an example of why we’ve
reached the end of the line completely
but largely the end of the line for the
book in law
so think about April every year in April
every year I experienced a pang of
apprehension when I’m confronted with
this little check
that says are you sure that your tax
return is accurate and complete and I
experienced this pang of apprehension
because I know it’s almost impossible
for me to be certain that it’s accurate
and complete why well I’m too acutely
aware of how much material I would need
to comprehend in order to make that
claim with 99% confident in fact I’m
really confident that I’m introducing
some kind of mistake
into my return when I when I check that
when I check that checkbox and so what I
take comfort in is it says the best of
my knowledge well to the best of my
knowledge okay that’s fine and to the
tax authorities it really is to the best
of my knowledge if you’re watching this
then don’t come after me um but the real
reason why it’s so hard to make sure
that I’m actually getting it right is
because the materials are so voluminous
right I know one can work through the
tens of thousands of cases that have
come through the courts in tax law no
one can read through the entire statute
no one can read through the regulations
no one can even get into the
administrative treatment of all of those
things it’s just life is too short you
have to move on you have to complete
your tax return and get back to daily
living so that’s that’s just true and so
the solution to too much printed
material relating to tax is not to print
more material relating to tax hence the
catch-22 right so so what do we do and
the answer lies in artificial
intelligence and machine learning lies
in legal technology and so you know the
book has been fantastic has led to
enormous economic growth political
development social development
scientific progress but there are
limitations to the book in law and so
how is legal tech going to be influenced
by the computer well I see it unfolding
in five stages stage one started in the
1960s 1970s with the digitization of a
lot of materials that used to be in
books so just a straight up translation
from these analog paper-based materials
to digital copies of those materials and
making it available in digital format
Stage two involves and it’s stage one is
still ongoing by the way so there are
huge projects
digitizing the past repository of
primary and secondary literature in law
it’s still ongoing we’ll catch up soon
and a lot of the most recent stuff is
available natively in digital formats
stage 2 involves what I would call
networking or cross-referencing so
indexing all of this stuff making it
searchable and making it accessible from
anywhere on earth so now there are
commercial publishers there are
nonprofit organizations are dedicated to
making this comprehensive legal
information available from anywhere on
earth using an internet connection and
really fantastic initiatives are ongoing
but so far at stage one the
digitalization and stage 2 the
networking and making it available from
anywhere are relatively uncreated in
what they’re doing with this legal
information why because we’re taking
stuff that used to be on paper and put
it on a screen and yes you can find it
more quickly and yes you can find it
from anywhere but it’s relatively
uncreated so what gets me really excited
is what’s happening at stage 3 and
what’s starting to happen at stage 3 and
the work that we’re doing in Toronto is
synthesizing the contents of these big
databases of digital legal information
to figure out what happens in new
circumstances so we’re using machine
learning and artificial intelligence to
Train algorithms on what courts will do
in new situations and we’re able to do
that with up to 94% accuracy in novel
situations and that compares with what
lawyers are able to do with conventional
legal training and that’s in most
circumstances between 60 and 70 percent
accurate so these algorithms have the
benefit of being able to look at every
case decided on a particular legal issue
and use that to guide predictions about
what courts will do in the very next
case so it’s a very very powerful
approach to predicting legal outcomes
and so over the next several years maybe
decades what will happen is this is
going to happen in every area of the law
so far we started in tax law and in
employment law but in principle there’s
no reason why we have to stop there and
in fact our vision is to bring absolute
clarity to every area of the law
everywhere and on-demand so there should
be no boundaries geographical with
respect to different legal systems we
should be able to bring clarity to all
the areas of law using AI and machine
learning if a human can in principle do
it then I think a machine learning
algorithm can be taught to do the same
thing now this leads to stage 4 and
stage 5 and so stage 4 involves what
what I kind of think of as a hangover of
sorts so imagine you throw a really
raucous host party and you have a great
time you pass out it’s your house you
pass out you wake up the next morning
and you look around and in the light of
day everything is a complete mess I
think that’s very likely to happen when
we start having amateur stage 3 of legal
technology we will look around and go
did did anyone know that this this is
the pattern of consequences associated
with our current legal system Denny
would actually realize that things are
as messy as actually are and I think
it’s going to kick off a very serious
look at law reform in a in a number of
dimensions and they’re gonna be
difficult political conversations a lot
of normative work for folks like me who
are law professors who are meant to you
know commentate and guide the
development of the law but pitch
political battles over the content of
the law so that that will happen and
there will be significant changes I
suspect to our political and legal
institutions as a result of that
Stage five gets us into sci-fi territory
and I think it leads us to self-driving
laws or the legal singularity we’re
actually legal uncertainty is largely
eliminated so 99 percent of legal
uncertainty is eliminated you realize
that every year there are 18 million
lawsuits filed in the United States it’s
a lot of litigation and a lawsuit
emerges when two parties have different
attitudes or beliefs about what’s likely
to happen if something’s going to go to
court if we have almost completely
eliminated legal uncertainty a lot of
that litigation is superfluous you don’t
need litigation if the answer is very
predictable and that’s where all of this
is going and so I’ll leave you with
two thoughts and both of them relate to
what you’re gonna be doing next April
the first is as you confront that
checkbox and think oh now I feel this
pang of apprehension number one you’re
not alone in that apprehension even
those who are experts in tax feel that
paying of apprehension when they’re
signing off on their tax return and
number two the law is becoming more
transparent more accessible more fair
more just and it’s happening right now
in Toronto and it’s coming soon around
the world thank you very much [Applause]
started law school in the fall of 1999
one of the very first things that we had
to do at law school was complete a
library research assignment so we were
given multiple questions we had to go
into the stacks roam around find the
correct thick leather bound volumes to
answer the questions in the assignment
and it really was at Paper Chase we had
to chase from stack to stack find the
cross references and it took several
hours to get through this and we were
all fighting for largely at the same
volumes and you know fighting over these
books
two weeks later I found myself in the
basement of the same Law School Library
in the computer lab 20 computers so as
with 19 of my colleagues in the law
school class and completely
independently of this research
assignment we were being instructed how
to use online legal research tools to
answer largely the same questions using
an online system and my mind was blown
it was so much easier to find what we’re
looking for then chasing through the
stacks fighting over you know books but
I’m not here to dump on the book or say
that the book is a terrible thing of
course the book is an amazing invention
if you think back to Gutenberg’s
printing press in 1440 and the
combination of that with movable type
and what ensued in the following six
centuries it’s actually phenomenal
alright originally millions of Bibles
were produced mass-produced using the
printing press that led to things like
the Protestant Reformation the Counter
Reformation the Council of Trent but
eventually led to significant progress
in the arts and science dissemination of
progress in the arts and sciences led to
the enlightenment led to the Industrial
Revolution led to public libraries led
to public education led to reforms to
the way in which we govern ourselves but
two very significant
old changes led to on and on and on
right up to the present a very
complicated modern nation-state who has
a and we should we have as it’s one of
its key infrastructure elements the
legal system now if we zoom in on the
legal system and the role that the book
has played in the legal system it’s
equally compelling so think about the
legal system in the absence of printed
books it’s really it’s hard to think of
we have oral traditions before that we
would have had you know rules that were
hand written prior to the development of
the book but with the book made possible
is the common law so case reporters were
some of the earliest books produced and
just publication of what the courts are
actually doing that led to things like
secondary materials like commentaries on
the laws of England by Blackstone an
incredible scholarly effort going
through and reading hundreds and
hundreds and hundreds of judgments of
the courts the common law courts in
England and compiling what it actually
meant for the legal system in trying to
draw categories and identify trends in
the case law subsequent to that of
course we have the publication of lots
of primary material statutes regulations
and the publication of all of these
materials allowed for the emergence of
the modern law school led to the
emergence of a thriving scholarly
enterprise of critiquing the laws
commenting on the normative desirability
of the laws led to everything that we
now take for granted as part of the
legal infrastructure that led to the
modern regulatory state all of this is
because of the book now I teach tax law
tax law is my specialty so I’m going to
use tax as an example of why we’ve
reached the end of the line completely
but largely the end of the line for the
book in law
so think about April every year in April
every year I experienced a pang of
apprehension when I’m confronted with
this little check
that says are you sure that your tax
return is accurate and complete and I
experienced this pang of apprehension
because I know it’s almost impossible
for me to be certain that it’s accurate
and complete why well I’m too acutely
aware of how much material I would need
to comprehend in order to make that
claim with 99% confident in fact I’m
really confident that I’m introducing
some kind of mistake
into my return when I when I check that
when I check that checkbox and so what I
take comfort in is it says the best of
my knowledge well to the best of my
knowledge okay that’s fine and to the
tax authorities it really is to the best
of my knowledge if you’re watching this
then don’t come after me um but the real
reason why it’s so hard to make sure
that I’m actually getting it right is
because the materials are so voluminous
right I know one can work through the
tens of thousands of cases that have
come through the courts in tax law no
one can read through the entire statute
no one can read through the regulations
no one can even get into the
administrative treatment of all of those
things it’s just life is too short you
have to move on you have to complete
your tax return and get back to daily
living so that’s that’s just true and so
the solution to too much printed
material relating to tax is not to print
more material relating to tax hence the
catch-22 right so so what do we do and
the answer lies in artificial
intelligence and machine learning lies
in legal technology and so you know the
book has been fantastic has led to
enormous economic growth political
development social development
scientific progress but there are
limitations to the book in law and so
how is legal tech going to be influenced
by the computer well I see it unfolding
in five stages stage one started in the
1960s 1970s with the digitization of a
lot of materials that used to be in
books so just a straight up translation
from these analog paper-based materials
to digital copies of those materials and
making it available in digital format
Stage two involves and it’s stage one is
still ongoing by the way so there are
huge projects
digitizing the past repository of
primary and secondary literature in law
it’s still ongoing we’ll catch up soon
and a lot of the most recent stuff is
available natively in digital formats
stage 2 involves what I would call
networking or cross-referencing so
indexing all of this stuff making it
searchable and making it accessible from
anywhere on earth so now there are
commercial publishers there are
nonprofit organizations are dedicated to
making this comprehensive legal
information available from anywhere on
earth using an internet connection and
really fantastic initiatives are ongoing
but so far at stage one the
digitalization and stage 2 the
networking and making it available from
anywhere are relatively uncreated in
what they’re doing with this legal
information why because we’re taking
stuff that used to be on paper and put
it on a screen and yes you can find it
more quickly and yes you can find it
from anywhere but it’s relatively
uncreated so what gets me really excited
is what’s happening at stage 3 and
what’s starting to happen at stage 3 and
the work that we’re doing in Toronto is
synthesizing the contents of these big
databases of digital legal information
to figure out what happens in new
circumstances so we’re using machine
learning and artificial intelligence to
Train algorithms on what courts will do
in new situations and we’re able to do
that with up to 94% accuracy in novel
situations and that compares with what
lawyers are able to do with conventional
legal training and that’s in most
circumstances between 60 and 70 percent
accurate so these algorithms have the
benefit of being able to look at every
case decided on a particular legal issue
and use that to guide predictions about
what courts will do in the very next
case so it’s a very very powerful
approach to predicting legal outcomes
and so over the next several years maybe
decades what will happen is this is
going to happen in every area of the law
so far we started in tax law and in
employment law but in principle there’s
no reason why we have to stop there and
in fact our vision is to bring absolute
clarity to every area of the law
everywhere and on-demand so there should
be no boundaries geographical with
respect to different legal systems we
should be able to bring clarity to all
the areas of law using AI and machine
learning if a human can in principle do
it then I think a machine learning
algorithm can be taught to do the same
thing now this leads to stage 4 and
stage 5 and so stage 4 involves what
what I kind of think of as a hangover of
sorts so imagine you throw a really
raucous host party and you have a great
time you pass out it’s your house you
pass out you wake up the next morning
and you look around and in the light of
day everything is a complete mess I
think that’s very likely to happen when
we start having amateur stage 3 of legal
technology we will look around and go
did did anyone know that this this is
the pattern of consequences associated
with our current legal system Denny
would actually realize that things are
as messy as actually are and I think
it’s going to kick off a very serious
look at law reform in a in a number of
dimensions and they’re gonna be
difficult political conversations a lot
of normative work for folks like me who
are law professors who are meant to you
know commentate and guide the
development of the law but pitch
political battles over the content of
the law so that that will happen and
there will be significant changes I
suspect to our political and legal
institutions as a result of that
Stage five gets us into sci-fi territory
and I think it leads us to self-driving
laws or the legal singularity we’re
actually legal uncertainty is largely
eliminated so 99 percent of legal
uncertainty is eliminated you realize
that every year there are 18 million
lawsuits filed in the United States it’s
a lot of litigation and a lawsuit
emerges when two parties have different
attitudes or beliefs about what’s likely
to happen if something’s going to go to
court if we have almost completely
eliminated legal uncertainty a lot of
that litigation is superfluous you don’t
need litigation if the answer is very
predictable and that’s where all of this
is going and so I’ll leave you with
two thoughts and both of them relate to
what you’re gonna be doing next April
the first is as you confront that
checkbox and think oh now I feel this
pang of apprehension number one you’re
not alone in that apprehension even
those who are experts in tax feel that
paying of apprehension when they’re
signing off on their tax return and
number two the law is becoming more
transparent more accessible more fair
more just and it’s happening right now
in Toronto and it’s coming soon around
the world thank you very much [Applause]
Please follow and like us: