Press "Enter" to skip to content

TRANS-forming Courts | Jayna Kothari | TEDxCMRIT


can I give you a hug is that allowed in
the High Court asked vegan ‘they just
after we argued our case challenging the
Telangana eunuchs act in the untrodden
the transgender community is one of the
most marginalized and discriminated
groups in India and perhaps all over the
world transgender persons are
criminalized excluded face physical and
sexual violence and even killed for not
conforming to society’s gender norms
many gender non-conforming children are
forced to drop out of school due to
harassment and discrimination a recent
study in India reveals that four out of
ten transgender persons face sexual
violence before the age of 18 years our
criminal laws on rape define sexual
assault only if it is against women
making it impossible for a transgender
person to even file a police complaint
for sexual violence there are laws that
criminalize transgender persons trans
and intersex persons have to live their
whole lives knowing that they are
criminalized and that they could be
arrested any minute just for being who
they are or for not conforming to
society’s gender identity and gender
norms but in 2014 came the nano judgment
this was a historic moment in India for
transgender rights it was in 2014 that
the Supreme Court recognized transgender
persons transgender was used as an
umbrella term to define persons whose
gender identity and gender expression
may not conform to their sex assigned at
birth the Supreme Court held that every
person is an inherent right to gender
identity it was defined
as each person’s deeply felt internal
and individual sense of gender which may
or may not match with basics assigned at
Birth the Supreme Court held that every
person has the constitutional right to
freely express their gender identity and
expression for the first time giving
these constitutional rights to
transgender persons in 2017 the Supreme
Court once again reiterated that the
right to self-identify one’s gender is
isn’t that a powerful idea to
self-identify oneself I would like to
self-identify myself as a woman a lawyer
an activist not necessarily as a married
woman with a child in her forties which
is often how society tries to identify
me and tries to dictate as to what I can
and cannot do transgender rights
therefore the right to self-identify
one’s gender the right to not conform to
society’s notions of gender norms form a
crucial part of the women’s movement and
also part of the larger human rights
battle so with the excitement of all
these Supreme Court decisions at the
Center for Law and Policy Research where
I work we started an initiative called
the trans law cell it started off as a
free weekly drop-in center for members
of the transgender community to come in
with their legal concerns we were
approached by several people for a whole
range of protection of their legal
rights from changing the name and gender
identity in birth certificates to
seeking separate hostels in universities
to even challenging criminal laws in the
Supreme Court I have along with my team
take
a lot of these cases all over India in
the various high courts and the Supreme
Court I appear in the courts and I soon
realized after taking up these cases
that this was often the first time that
our courts our judges had to deal with
cases of transgender persons or even
engage with them this was the first time
that our courts had to deal with
questions of transgender rights I
realized that it was not just therefore
a matter of taking up a case and getting
a favorable decision this was actually
an experiment in transforming the courts
the first case I appeared in was a
challenge to section 36 a of the Penn
Attica Police Act this was a law that
allowed the police to maintain a
register keeping the names and
whereabouts of eunuchs because they were
suspected of kidnapping boys
emasculating young boys and committing
unnatural offenses I represented to
trans activists and we filed a petition
in the Karnataka High Court the judge
before whom a petition was listed was
extremely conservative and did not even
want to hear the case on one occasion
when my clients were in court he told me
that I should tell my clients to behave
themselves on the streets and not create
problems for the general public enraged
by this my clients took up a long in
heart campaign against this law with the
Karnataka government and we went to meet
the law minister the minister was
extremely supportive and assured us that
the government would amend the law at
the end of the meeting however he asked
one of the trans activists tell me why
can’t you just be what nature made you
to this she
what is nature nature is how I feel the
minister had nothing more to see and in
2016 we had our big tree when the
Karnataka government amended section 36
a and removed the word eunuchs from the
law this was the first time in India
that a law discriminating against
transgender persons has ever been
amended following this victory in
Karnataka we were encouraged to
challenge a similar law in a neighboring
state Telangana the Telangana eunuchs
Act this was a law enacted in 1919 and
was an even more draconian law than
section 36 a the law provided that any
eunuch or a transgender person could be
arrested if found in the public wearing
female dress singing dancing or
performing it allowed the police to
maintain a register of the names and
whereabouts of transgender persons it
allowed the police to arrest transgender
persons at any time without a warrant
if found in the company of a boy under
the age of sixteen years we challenged
this petition in the under Pradesh High
Court and three trans activists were the
petitioners and I represented them my
clients response to this law in court
was we are told that we are illegal that
our exist
our livelihood is illegal that our
gender identity and expression is
illegal the response in the unfree –
High Court was extremely positive the
judges were not aware of the law and
they were shocked by it this was the
first time that in the High Court at
Hyderabad arguments on the inherent
right to gender identity and expression
were made this was never done before and
certainly not by a woman lawyer what was
also never done before was that there
were three transgender petitioners
sitting in the Chief Justice’s court all
day waiting for their case to be called
out a petition was admitted and we’re
now awaiting final hearing we came out
of the courtroom and took pictures of
that historic moment unable to contain
her excitement by gently hugged us there
under the gaze of the guards and the
police in the High Court there we were a
team of cysts and transgender women
transforming the High Court at Hyderabad
why are these transgender rights case is
important in my cases from the trans law
cell we have challenged identity and
surveillance laws we have challenged
laws that criminalize same-sex
relationships we have sought for change
of name and gender identity in legal
documents in all these cases we have
been slowly but steadily making small
gains exposing judges courts public
authorities and the general public as to
what it means to be transgender what are
the battles the transgender persons have
to face to get access to basic
entitlements like education employment
or housing things that most of us take
for granted and we realize that for the
transgender and sexual minorities
community each one of these rights are
hard-won their very existence in public
spaces is criminalized and it is through
these cases that we are able to tell
their stories and it is important that
we tell their stories stories of the
daily lives and experiences of
transgender people in court through
these cases we are forcing our courts
our judges our government and our
society to not see transgender persons
as criminals to see them as citizens
with equal constitutional rights to see
them as human beings two years ago when
I first started working with the trans
community I had to go for a community
meeting and I took my eight-year-old
daughter with me she sat there reading
her books while we were discussing
strategy and planning when the meeting
got over and we were heading back home I
asked her in the car if she knew that
the woman who was sitting next to her
was actually born a boy but she decided
to change her gender because she felt
like a girl really she said she hadn’t
realized then I asked her whether she
realized that the boy who was
distributing snacks to us in the meeting
was actually born a girl but wanted to
be a boy she was quiet for the entire
drive home and when we reached home she
said that’s fascinating it truly is
fascinating that we can be who we want
without being dictated by the sex
assigned to us at birth I realized in my
journey of taking up transgender rights
cases that trans issues force us to
question our own understanding of gender
gender is in our head and how we feel
and has nothing to do with our bodies we
may want to identify and express
ourselves as male female transgender
queer or anything else and we’re all
equal our courts our judges our
governments society we all need to
recognize this so let us join hands
today in this transformation [Applause]
Please follow and like us: