
I am virgin te vasantha Mowgli that’s my
full name and I’m transgender person who
identifies as a woman the theme of your
talk is making space and before we
before I set it out and set the tone and
primarily my talk will be about the
LGBTQ community with a focus on
transgender people now who are
transgender people who are LGBTQ
community my time is just 20 minutes so
I will try to be as succinct gender
gender identity and sexual orientation
and biological sex as five four
different things are unfortunately in
incidentally conflated often in Indian
even across the world in drama books in
English you would have a student seen
gender and sex used synonymously for
masculine and feminine gender and sex on
forms and so on while sex is about the
biological sex that a person is born
into which is determined by chromosomes
genetic structure external genitalia
physiology and so on gender is not
limited or reduced to one’s Anatomy
genders how a person experiences himself
or herself or themselves and how that
person sorry would like the society to
identify him or or them so it transcends
the limitations or the boundaries of
biological sex a parking gender aside
for a few seconds for half a minute even
biological sex is itself not binary your
students of engineering you understand
binary so biological sex is
selves when babies are born they could
be born as neither male nor female with
no genetalia with both genitalia or but
partially formed a fully formed
genitalia of one sex and partially
formed genitally of the other all these
three possibilities are at least
externally visible there are babies who
seem to be who appear to be male or
female but people don’t know till they
attain puberty because they don’t attain
puberty at the age of puberty and there
are many other possibilities multiple
permutations and combinations are not a
biologist so I won’t get into all of
that but what I’m trying to do now is to
separate biological sex from gender and
if biological sex is itself so diverse
and this diversity within biological sex
is not acknowledged because of certain
forms of social exclusions that are
deeply entrenched into our society beat
patriarchy just say our pictus a target
a hole in DNA yep it – Swami M in Telugu
or other forms of social exclusions
right um now transgender people coming
to transgender people could be people
born into such different bodies at birth
or they may not be there could be people
who are not born into different bodies
or not intersex at Birth the terms for
such babies born difference is intersex
there could be non intersex transgender
people – but who are transgender people
by virtue for condition which is not a
disease or a disorder which is just a
condition by virtue of which a person’s
mind conflicts with the person’s gender
assigned at birth remember genders
almost always assigned at Birth you did
not know as a one-year-old or a one day
old baby that you’re a boy until people
told you that you were a boy or a girl
so genders almost always assigned at
birth and that tends to collide head-on
and violently military
in the minds of transgender people
because there’s always a conflict
between the mind and the body and the
gender assigned to that person at birth
this condition is gender dysphoria as
its called by the American by DSM
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual and
the World Health Organization follows
the International classification
diseases now it’s called gender
incongruence it was pathologized earlier
pathology study of diseases disorders
it’s no longer pathologized because both
the ICD that the World Health
Organization follows and DSM that the
miracles follow have deep apologized it
and have changed it from gender identity
disorder to gender dysphoria and gender
incongruence respectively the DSM called
the gender dysphoria and ICD calls it
gender incongruence
now that’s just about transgender people
there are people who do not identify
with the different gender as compared to
the one assigned to them at birth they
they may not fit into the
heteronormative
the heteronormative stipulation that men
should only marry women and women should
only marry men and they could have
different sexual orientations and some
such people could identify themselves as
lesbian or bisexual or gay and there are
many other categories for the paucity of
time we I would limit myself to just
them now most transgender and queer
LGBTQ children almost always are thrown
out of their homes as as opposed to a
child born into a repressed caste
background in the village who segregated
even till date in some villages and not
allowed to eat or drink sit sitting in
the same row of other children of a
dominant caste when that child goes back
and tells his or her parents about it
the parents are able to understand it
because a child born into a repressed
caste background is born to teach
parents of repressed caste but gender
non-conforming children or queer
children are not necessarily born to
queer or transgender parents
so our parents have no understanding of
it so the violence begins at homes the
non-acceptance and stigma begins at
homes parents take to it as their
children pretending to be something
between the fashioned fad or it being
some kind of crazed that needs to be
exorcised through Baba’s and mullahs and
maldis and Baba’s and sons and Mahatma’s
and pastors and so on or even quacks and
doctors medicine has itself undergone
evolution and it as I said it was
pathologized earlier it’s not
pathologize now but the Medical Council
of India has not gotten updated the
medical curriculum is yet obsolescent
and the until date conversion a version
conversion and reparative therapies are
sold away to parents or desperate to get
their children changed at exorbitant
costs and there’s a whole lot of medical
medic medical mafia running the Medical
Council of India has itself been pulled
up on many cases by the Supreme Court
that came heavily down on it and it’s on
its extinction there’s a new law that
will replace replace the Medical Council
of India right so um I was thrown out of
my house when I was fifteen by my own
father and my own step elder brother and
my extended paternal family because they
didn’t take too kindly to this fourteen
fifteen year old child and this is not
just about me it’s quite the lived
reality I don’t want to make it just
about me it’s quite the lived reality of
many transgender people who either
thrown out of their homes or who run
away from their homes unable to bear the
torture and violence at home and there
are only two sources of livelihood that
are available which are not mainstream
modes of an options of employment and
this is universal this is not limited to
just this city of Telangana India which
are begging and sex work so not so the
transgender communities heavily
stigmatized for only begging and being
dependent only on begging and sex work
but
for the Society of the likes of us here
the likes of you pass a judgement let’s
also ask ourselves have there been
options for transgender people to
educate themselves it was only on 15
April 2014 that something historic and
watershed happened and that was the
Supreme Court that delivered the null
services Union of India judgement which
said the transgender people have the
right to self identify their gender I’m
just reading quoting out of the
operative part of the summary of the
judgement the rights of transgender
people to self-identify their gender is
upheld and the central and state
governments are thus directed to
recognize their self-identified gender
transgender people need to have access
to restrooms of their self-identified
gender or at least gender-neutral
restrooms
state and central governments have to
take up welfare schemes to ensure that
transgender people are able to be part
of the society that that belongs
rightfully to everybody this the the
judgment was quite a circus it was a lot
of italics legal and judicial athletics
that our judges did in in that judgement
because it read into gender
there are many judgments of the Supreme
Court that a poor gender is protected on
the fundamental right because you have
lots of judgments in Supreme Court is
delivered in the seventies eighties 90s
for women and the genders protected
under fundamental rights it cannot only
be protected for a certain section it
has to be protected for all and if
gender is protected on the fundamental
rights then it flows out of it that all
fundamental rights are the domain and
the responsibility of the states to
protect and if it is the responsibility
of the states to protect the state thus
it was a logical corollary out of it
that the state should ensure the
transgender people are able to live
their genders which is not possible
unless they undergo those procedures
that they require to and hence it
mandated that sex reassignment surgery
or gender confirmation surgery
sex-change surgeries be borne by the
state that was historic that was
historic um it’s been four and a half
years since the Supreme Court it’s been
a little more than four and a half years
they’re just about five state
governments at a big-gun some work on it
that have just begun even too late the
Telangana government has not issued a
Geo or a policy so when a transgender
person goes to apply for a gender change
it’s a hell of a task it’s it’s hell
because we you know the government
departments are clueless and as
transgender people it’s our
responsibility to apply for it we can’t
print our own ID cards
the journey is similar if not identical
to what’s women went through after
vishaka vishakha versus the state of
rajasthan was passed in 1996 and the law
was only passed in 2013 in 17 years the
Parliament took to enact a comprehensive
legislation and it required a lot of
contempt petitions in the Supreme Court
as well right so if a transgender person
does not have an ID card mind you it’s
not the fault of the transgender person
it’s our responsibility to apply for it
but if to to access a bathroom to access
an ID card I think odd har and pan card
and voter ID card in bank accounts which
you have access to by default are not
available to many transgender people and
when such transgender people go to
litigate in court they don’t even get
employed because they you know you
google and you see a lot of RT is and
PIL that transgender people have filed
and employers say oh you are a litigant
won’t you be a litigant if you do not
have access to public sanitation which
is read into right to life with dignity
would you not be a litigant if you are
not able to get a bank account for
yourself who will your employer pay and
how will the employer pay if you don’t
have a bank account right so now 2009
the Delhi High Court gave a historic
judgment call NARS foundation versus
Union of India which
homosexuality 2004 2013 the ministers of
justice and empowerment gave a
comprehensive report on transgender
people 2013 December a to judge bench of
the Supreme Court real criminalized
homosexuality in the the decriminalized
sections of section 377 and it took
another four and a half years to get it
decriminalized but in the interim in the
interim December 2013 the Supreme Court
recognized homosexuality but in April
2014 another bench of the Supreme Court
of Justice Arthur Griffin and Justice
sikri did this historic and watershed
judgment Colin alsa which was thrown
like a spanner into the wheel of Kaushal
judgment if Kaushal was supposed to be a
juggernaut to trample upon the rights of
the trunk of the LGBT community another
bench of the Supreme Court to a spanner
into that wheel through the null so
judgments and then in September 2017
came justice fortas Romney and others
versus union of India the privacy
judgement that upheld that trilha see is
a fundamental right and that almost
broke the wheel and then came not did
singular and others versus union of
India which decriminalized homosexuality
it is only decriminalized sexual acts
all acts of love of adults consenting
adults consent adults and in Trident
yeah so but this is just
decriminalization what about the way
ahead in technically in law now large
sections of the society have ceased to
be criminal for their sheer existence
for their sheer identities and just a
month ago I leveraged that filed RTI a
year ago and got the repressive freak
constitutional pre-constitutional felon
on a UNIX Act of 1919 put it thrown into
abeyance by
bench of the high court of the Chief
Justice put that into abeyance stayed
the operation of the Telangana UNIX Act
of 1919 I was the principal petitioner
there are many other words there are
many other laws and the nob did Singh
Joe her judgment is quite a treasure
trove of jurisprudence justice Nariman
said all pre constitutional laws that
yet operate the assumption of their
constitutionality cannot be made earlier
for all laws that predated the
Constitution petitioners had to prove in
courts of law that these laws are not
constitutionally entire burden of
proving the unconstitutionality was are
not on petitioners now not they’d sing
Joe her and others it’s just not about
homosexuality or LGBT community it will
break open the doors for many other
communities for many other vulnerable
marginalized communities be the women or
acid attack survivors or people with
disabilities and many other vulnerable
modulized communities to question and
challenge the constitutionality of pre
constitutional laws because that that
judgment clearly lays down that the
burden has now to shift from the
petitioners to the government to prove
its constitutionality in court right so
now the way ahead as I see it is to have
is to question the assumption of
constitutionality of pre-constitutional
pre-independence laws and it’s just not
about laws because you know if you have
to question laws then you need to be
activists and lawyers
what are low-hanging fruits for people
like you students who not adapted law
were not trained in law RTI is right to
information it’s a low-hanging fruit to
spend trend rupees to ask government
pertinent pointed questions pertinent
pointed questions spending ten and if
you’re a person below the poverty line
that’s also exempted right instead of
just giving representations to which
governments may or may not respond ask
the same questions invoking the Right to
Information Act 2005 the government’s
are required to respond
public institutions that required to
respond to you in 30 days and through
those responses if you see discrepancies
illegalities you can precipitate public
interest litigation there are many
lawyers who do PIL and pro bono
loitering and these are some low-hanging
fruits that I see as the way ahead for
the LGBT community and for all of us to
to access and through all of this I
exhort your conscience and I exhaust
your compassion as human beings and your
humanity to make space for all people
not excluding the LGBT community not
excluding people with disabilities not
excluding women not excluding people
below the poverty line not excluding
acid attack survivors and to make spaces
to question yourselves to ask yourselves
with your campuses and affinity groups
support groups for LGBT community what
is one of you or some of you are people
with disabilities what is there are some
of you who are people living with HIV
Duke do your LGBT friends feel
comfortable enough to tell you that
they’re LGBTI OQ the other friends among
you who could be people living with HIV
are they comfortable enough to tell you
because of the stigma so this is these
are things that I want you to mull over
I’m not going to give you the answers
but I would want to apply your own
critical thinking and there could be
people who oppose it they could be
people who will stump it at the very
outset but that will at least initiate
the critical engagement that lacks in in
our spaces and societies with that I
thank you all and before I sign off and
I’m yet left with one minute the only
thing if there is that seperates many of
us from each other and particularly the
transgender community from the rest of
the quote unquote mainstream society is just opportunity thank
full name and I’m transgender person who
identifies as a woman the theme of your
talk is making space and before we
before I set it out and set the tone and
primarily my talk will be about the
LGBTQ community with a focus on
transgender people now who are
transgender people who are LGBTQ
community my time is just 20 minutes so
I will try to be as succinct gender
gender identity and sexual orientation
and biological sex as five four
different things are unfortunately in
incidentally conflated often in Indian
even across the world in drama books in
English you would have a student seen
gender and sex used synonymously for
masculine and feminine gender and sex on
forms and so on while sex is about the
biological sex that a person is born
into which is determined by chromosomes
genetic structure external genitalia
physiology and so on gender is not
limited or reduced to one’s Anatomy
genders how a person experiences himself
or herself or themselves and how that
person sorry would like the society to
identify him or or them so it transcends
the limitations or the boundaries of
biological sex a parking gender aside
for a few seconds for half a minute even
biological sex is itself not binary your
students of engineering you understand
binary so biological sex is
selves when babies are born they could
be born as neither male nor female with
no genetalia with both genitalia or but
partially formed a fully formed
genitalia of one sex and partially
formed genitally of the other all these
three possibilities are at least
externally visible there are babies who
seem to be who appear to be male or
female but people don’t know till they
attain puberty because they don’t attain
puberty at the age of puberty and there
are many other possibilities multiple
permutations and combinations are not a
biologist so I won’t get into all of
that but what I’m trying to do now is to
separate biological sex from gender and
if biological sex is itself so diverse
and this diversity within biological sex
is not acknowledged because of certain
forms of social exclusions that are
deeply entrenched into our society beat
patriarchy just say our pictus a target
a hole in DNA yep it – Swami M in Telugu
or other forms of social exclusions
right um now transgender people coming
to transgender people could be people
born into such different bodies at birth
or they may not be there could be people
who are not born into different bodies
or not intersex at Birth the terms for
such babies born difference is intersex
there could be non intersex transgender
people – but who are transgender people
by virtue for condition which is not a
disease or a disorder which is just a
condition by virtue of which a person’s
mind conflicts with the person’s gender
assigned at birth remember genders
almost always assigned at Birth you did
not know as a one-year-old or a one day
old baby that you’re a boy until people
told you that you were a boy or a girl
so genders almost always assigned at
birth and that tends to collide head-on
and violently military
in the minds of transgender people
because there’s always a conflict
between the mind and the body and the
gender assigned to that person at birth
this condition is gender dysphoria as
its called by the American by DSM
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual and
the World Health Organization follows
the International classification
diseases now it’s called gender
incongruence it was pathologized earlier
pathology study of diseases disorders
it’s no longer pathologized because both
the ICD that the World Health
Organization follows and DSM that the
miracles follow have deep apologized it
and have changed it from gender identity
disorder to gender dysphoria and gender
incongruence respectively the DSM called
the gender dysphoria and ICD calls it
gender incongruence
now that’s just about transgender people
there are people who do not identify
with the different gender as compared to
the one assigned to them at birth they
they may not fit into the
heteronormative
the heteronormative stipulation that men
should only marry women and women should
only marry men and they could have
different sexual orientations and some
such people could identify themselves as
lesbian or bisexual or gay and there are
many other categories for the paucity of
time we I would limit myself to just
them now most transgender and queer
LGBTQ children almost always are thrown
out of their homes as as opposed to a
child born into a repressed caste
background in the village who segregated
even till date in some villages and not
allowed to eat or drink sit sitting in
the same row of other children of a
dominant caste when that child goes back
and tells his or her parents about it
the parents are able to understand it
because a child born into a repressed
caste background is born to teach
parents of repressed caste but gender
non-conforming children or queer
children are not necessarily born to
queer or transgender parents
so our parents have no understanding of
it so the violence begins at homes the
non-acceptance and stigma begins at
homes parents take to it as their
children pretending to be something
between the fashioned fad or it being
some kind of crazed that needs to be
exorcised through Baba’s and mullahs and
maldis and Baba’s and sons and Mahatma’s
and pastors and so on or even quacks and
doctors medicine has itself undergone
evolution and it as I said it was
pathologized earlier it’s not
pathologize now but the Medical Council
of India has not gotten updated the
medical curriculum is yet obsolescent
and the until date conversion a version
conversion and reparative therapies are
sold away to parents or desperate to get
their children changed at exorbitant
costs and there’s a whole lot of medical
medic medical mafia running the Medical
Council of India has itself been pulled
up on many cases by the Supreme Court
that came heavily down on it and it’s on
its extinction there’s a new law that
will replace replace the Medical Council
of India right so um I was thrown out of
my house when I was fifteen by my own
father and my own step elder brother and
my extended paternal family because they
didn’t take too kindly to this fourteen
fifteen year old child and this is not
just about me it’s quite the lived
reality I don’t want to make it just
about me it’s quite the lived reality of
many transgender people who either
thrown out of their homes or who run
away from their homes unable to bear the
torture and violence at home and there
are only two sources of livelihood that
are available which are not mainstream
modes of an options of employment and
this is universal this is not limited to
just this city of Telangana India which
are begging and sex work so not so the
transgender communities heavily
stigmatized for only begging and being
dependent only on begging and sex work
but
for the Society of the likes of us here
the likes of you pass a judgement let’s
also ask ourselves have there been
options for transgender people to
educate themselves it was only on 15
April 2014 that something historic and
watershed happened and that was the
Supreme Court that delivered the null
services Union of India judgement which
said the transgender people have the
right to self identify their gender I’m
just reading quoting out of the
operative part of the summary of the
judgement the rights of transgender
people to self-identify their gender is
upheld and the central and state
governments are thus directed to
recognize their self-identified gender
transgender people need to have access
to restrooms of their self-identified
gender or at least gender-neutral
restrooms
state and central governments have to
take up welfare schemes to ensure that
transgender people are able to be part
of the society that that belongs
rightfully to everybody this the the
judgment was quite a circus it was a lot
of italics legal and judicial athletics
that our judges did in in that judgement
because it read into gender
there are many judgments of the Supreme
Court that a poor gender is protected on
the fundamental right because you have
lots of judgments in Supreme Court is
delivered in the seventies eighties 90s
for women and the genders protected
under fundamental rights it cannot only
be protected for a certain section it
has to be protected for all and if
gender is protected on the fundamental
rights then it flows out of it that all
fundamental rights are the domain and
the responsibility of the states to
protect and if it is the responsibility
of the states to protect the state thus
it was a logical corollary out of it
that the state should ensure the
transgender people are able to live
their genders which is not possible
unless they undergo those procedures
that they require to and hence it
mandated that sex reassignment surgery
or gender confirmation surgery
sex-change surgeries be borne by the
state that was historic that was
historic um it’s been four and a half
years since the Supreme Court it’s been
a little more than four and a half years
they’re just about five state
governments at a big-gun some work on it
that have just begun even too late the
Telangana government has not issued a
Geo or a policy so when a transgender
person goes to apply for a gender change
it’s a hell of a task it’s it’s hell
because we you know the government
departments are clueless and as
transgender people it’s our
responsibility to apply for it we can’t
print our own ID cards
the journey is similar if not identical
to what’s women went through after
vishaka vishakha versus the state of
rajasthan was passed in 1996 and the law
was only passed in 2013 in 17 years the
Parliament took to enact a comprehensive
legislation and it required a lot of
contempt petitions in the Supreme Court
as well right so if a transgender person
does not have an ID card mind you it’s
not the fault of the transgender person
it’s our responsibility to apply for it
but if to to access a bathroom to access
an ID card I think odd har and pan card
and voter ID card in bank accounts which
you have access to by default are not
available to many transgender people and
when such transgender people go to
litigate in court they don’t even get
employed because they you know you
google and you see a lot of RT is and
PIL that transgender people have filed
and employers say oh you are a litigant
won’t you be a litigant if you do not
have access to public sanitation which
is read into right to life with dignity
would you not be a litigant if you are
not able to get a bank account for
yourself who will your employer pay and
how will the employer pay if you don’t
have a bank account right so now 2009
the Delhi High Court gave a historic
judgment call NARS foundation versus
Union of India which
homosexuality 2004 2013 the ministers of
justice and empowerment gave a
comprehensive report on transgender
people 2013 December a to judge bench of
the Supreme Court real criminalized
homosexuality in the the decriminalized
sections of section 377 and it took
another four and a half years to get it
decriminalized but in the interim in the
interim December 2013 the Supreme Court
recognized homosexuality but in April
2014 another bench of the Supreme Court
of Justice Arthur Griffin and Justice
sikri did this historic and watershed
judgment Colin alsa which was thrown
like a spanner into the wheel of Kaushal
judgment if Kaushal was supposed to be a
juggernaut to trample upon the rights of
the trunk of the LGBT community another
bench of the Supreme Court to a spanner
into that wheel through the null so
judgments and then in September 2017
came justice fortas Romney and others
versus union of India the privacy
judgement that upheld that trilha see is
a fundamental right and that almost
broke the wheel and then came not did
singular and others versus union of
India which decriminalized homosexuality
it is only decriminalized sexual acts
all acts of love of adults consenting
adults consent adults and in Trident
yeah so but this is just
decriminalization what about the way
ahead in technically in law now large
sections of the society have ceased to
be criminal for their sheer existence
for their sheer identities and just a
month ago I leveraged that filed RTI a
year ago and got the repressive freak
constitutional pre-constitutional felon
on a UNIX Act of 1919 put it thrown into
abeyance by
bench of the high court of the Chief
Justice put that into abeyance stayed
the operation of the Telangana UNIX Act
of 1919 I was the principal petitioner
there are many other words there are
many other laws and the nob did Singh
Joe her judgment is quite a treasure
trove of jurisprudence justice Nariman
said all pre constitutional laws that
yet operate the assumption of their
constitutionality cannot be made earlier
for all laws that predated the
Constitution petitioners had to prove in
courts of law that these laws are not
constitutionally entire burden of
proving the unconstitutionality was are
not on petitioners now not they’d sing
Joe her and others it’s just not about
homosexuality or LGBT community it will
break open the doors for many other
communities for many other vulnerable
marginalized communities be the women or
acid attack survivors or people with
disabilities and many other vulnerable
modulized communities to question and
challenge the constitutionality of pre
constitutional laws because that that
judgment clearly lays down that the
burden has now to shift from the
petitioners to the government to prove
its constitutionality in court right so
now the way ahead as I see it is to have
is to question the assumption of
constitutionality of pre-constitutional
pre-independence laws and it’s just not
about laws because you know if you have
to question laws then you need to be
activists and lawyers
what are low-hanging fruits for people
like you students who not adapted law
were not trained in law RTI is right to
information it’s a low-hanging fruit to
spend trend rupees to ask government
pertinent pointed questions pertinent
pointed questions spending ten and if
you’re a person below the poverty line
that’s also exempted right instead of
just giving representations to which
governments may or may not respond ask
the same questions invoking the Right to
Information Act 2005 the government’s
are required to respond
public institutions that required to
respond to you in 30 days and through
those responses if you see discrepancies
illegalities you can precipitate public
interest litigation there are many
lawyers who do PIL and pro bono
loitering and these are some low-hanging
fruits that I see as the way ahead for
the LGBT community and for all of us to
to access and through all of this I
exhort your conscience and I exhaust
your compassion as human beings and your
humanity to make space for all people
not excluding the LGBT community not
excluding people with disabilities not
excluding women not excluding people
below the poverty line not excluding
acid attack survivors and to make spaces
to question yourselves to ask yourselves
with your campuses and affinity groups
support groups for LGBT community what
is one of you or some of you are people
with disabilities what is there are some
of you who are people living with HIV
Duke do your LGBT friends feel
comfortable enough to tell you that
they’re LGBTI OQ the other friends among
you who could be people living with HIV
are they comfortable enough to tell you
because of the stigma so this is these
are things that I want you to mull over
I’m not going to give you the answers
but I would want to apply your own
critical thinking and there could be
people who oppose it they could be
people who will stump it at the very
outset but that will at least initiate
the critical engagement that lacks in in
our spaces and societies with that I
thank you all and before I sign off and
I’m yet left with one minute the only
thing if there is that seperates many of
us from each other and particularly the
transgender community from the rest of
the quote unquote mainstream society is just opportunity thank
Please follow and like us: