
on April 14th 2005 I was a primary care
physician walking through a hospital
hall like I had done many times before
but this day was different because I was
about to be the patient I was about to
give my left kidney to Robert Phillips a
man who had been on dialysis for several
years and who I have started dating less
than a year prior now how I got to this
point I think can best be summed up by
part of a quote from Maya Angelou when
you know better do better and I say this
because when I was a resident physician
and training I took care of lots of
patients in the hospital who are on
dialysis but then I was usually
sleep-deprived and always eager to get
on to the next patient
I paid careful attention to the dialysis
orders and the blood test results but
sadly not so much to the person living
with a serious illness all that changed
when I became Roberts girlfriend as
Roberts girlfriend I wasn’t in a rush
anymore I wanted to be with him at
dialysis as often as possible to help
him pass the time for hours three times
a week trying hard not to move his left
arm too much and dislodged the needles
that were connecting him to the dialysis
machine as girlfriend I watched him
struggle to not drink too much liquid in
between Dallas’s treatments even though
he was thirsty all the time because if
he did because his kidneys couldn’t pee
it out he would pay for it with swelling
and cramping and feeling short of breath
I went with him to his transplant
evaluation appointment and there I saw a
sight of medicine that I couldn’t see as
a primary care doctor it was a sigh that
felt like it was stacked against him
because it was part of a system in which
blacks waited nearly two years longer to
get a kidney transplant than whites so
it was that day that I decided I was
gonna give him one of my kidneys because
I knew what he was going through because
I knew better and because I knew better
I also went on to become a nephrologist
a kidney doctor so my goal today is to
tell you about three patients that I’ve
encountered since becoming a
nephrologist that I say demonstrate how
we can all do better
the first is Chris when I met Chris he
was this 25 year old fresh-faced
strawberry blonde head at young man who
should have been able to just focus on
his future but instead he was facing
kidney failure his kidneys were failing
because of an autoimmune disease called
IgA nephropathy and he needed to start
dialysis less than a year later now I
don’t know how many of you noticed this
little guy at the bottom of the picture
having tea with Chris but this is his
dialysis catheter surgically implanted
into his belly and this is the way Chris
coped with his illness take the little
face on it named it called it his
closest newest friend Chris also had two
older brothers both healthy but both
said no to giving baby brother a kidney
they figured he’s on the waiting list to
get a kidney from somebody who’s passed
away and he can just do dialysis until
then now the problem with that logic is
that it can take up to nine years to get
a deceased donor kidney transplant
depending on your blood type and where
you live and every year there are
another hundred thousand people on that
same list but we only do about 12,000
deceased donor kidney transplants each
year and another 5,000 roughly living
donor transplants so that’s how we end
up with thirteen people dying
every day waiting for a kidney
transplant one of the brothers came to
visit Chris for the first time since he
started Dallas’s and he saw how Chris
had to connect himself every night to a
Dallas’s machine that pushed and pulled
fluid in and out of the space between
his skin and his abdominal organs all
night long and Chris just hoped it he
could get through the night before the
alarm would be beeping are accidentally
tugging on his catheter and that’s all
it took to make the brother change his
mind
and he decided to give Chris one of his
kidneys
now his donation gave Chris the best
chance for a longer and better quality
of life better than a deceased donor
kidney could way better than the Alice’s
could after five years two-thirds of all
kidney transplants are going strong at
five years but only about a third of
Dallas’s patients are even alive now
four months after surgery Robert became
my husband I know he kind of had to
marry me
but he has had my kidney for 12 years
and Counting and the longest living
kidney lasted for 54 years
in a man who died when he was 88 years
old now this man happened to be named
Robert Phillips – you know at my core I
am a superstitious country girl so I
take that as a very good sign so if now
that you know what people with kidney
failure are facing if you know if
there’s somebody in your life who is in
need of a kidney transplant and you’re
healthy enough to give one I hope you’ll
consider it I get that it’s a bit
daunting I had all kinds of butterflies
in my stomach the morning of surgery
but when I woke up and I saw this bag at
the foot of Roberts bed in recovery just
filling up with lots of pale yellow
urine I was like that’s my kidney doing
that
and I was just so happy because I knew
that soon he won’t be able to drink as
much ice-cold beverages his thirst
desired and if I could go back in time I
would do it again and to be a donor you
don’t need to be related and the only
race that matters is the human race you
don’t even have to be a perfect match in
fact Robert and I only had 1 out of 6
genetic markers felt important at the
time and common at the very least I hope
you will consider registering as a organ
donor with the DMV and let your family
know that you did so that after you’re
gone
they will uphold your wishes and all
your healthy parts will go to make the
lives of others longer and better now if
you’re one of the 26 million adults in
this country with chronic kidney disease
the story of my next patient who I’ll
call miss a photo is for you miss a
photo was almost 50 years old when I met
her she had this smooth brown Samoan
skin but her kidneys were shrunken and
shriveled hardly functioning because of
years and years of uncontrolled diabetes
and high blood pressure which caused
two-thirds of chronic kidney disease in
this country but even though she has
such advanced disease she tried to run
away from it she wouldn’t believe me
when I told her that her kidneys would
soon fell and that she needed to prepare
for analysis she said things like you
know the swelling in my legs that’s
that’s because I’ve been on my feet all
day and this metallic taste that’s
because of the pills that you tell me to
take not because of kidney failure truth
is there is no outrunning kidney failure
unless something else gets you first
like you get hit by a bus or your heart
stops beating kidney failure will catch
you and I know she was hoping for a
miracle but in truth the only miracle
that was really in her near future was
dialysis because 60 years ago
Dallas’s didn’t exist and everybody with
kidney failure just passed away so
because miss of futa could not face the
reality she ended up with a lot of
avoidable things like the trauma of
feeling like you’re about to die and
having to call 9-1-1 13 hours in the
emergency room a plastic Dallas’s
catheter in her chest a hospital
admission she was looking at dialysis as
if it would be the end of her life when
in truth it would just make her life
different no it wouldn’t be perfect or
take away all the issues that come with
a vital organ dying yes it would have
his frustrations and take time but the
time in between could be filled with
life and all the things that she wanted
to keep doing with Dallas’s she could
expect to live for many years without it
once her kidneys fail completely
she get a week maybe two now roughly 80%
of adults in this country have
significant chronic kidney disease and
don’t even know it so if you might be a
patient for example you have diabetes or
high blood pressure or even if it just
runs in your family
get tested a simple blood and urine test
can detect kidney disease long before
you’ll ever feel anything and knowing is
doing better for yourself and your
family if you already know you’re a
patient then don’t let fear get in the
way of you accepting reality so that you
can do
how many of you saw this movie The Book
of Eli starring Denzel Washington yeah
not many so the next patient that I’ll
tell you about looks exactly like Denzel
in this movie now I know what some of
you are probably thinking but I have
never been among the multitudes of women
who would just wriggle out of her
panties and throw them on any stage that
Denzel stands on I just saw my patient
who I will call because Eli as a
good-looking brother who had a chronic
kidney problem now when I met Book of
Eli
he was very muscular I needed a large
extra-large blood pressure cuff to take
his blood pressure but five years later
as his kidney disease declined from a
disease called membranous nephropathy
his muscles had wasted away too and so a
regular blood pressure cuff would do at
every visit I would tell him about all
of his test results and cout including
creatinine the blood tests that we used
to find out about kidney function in
1999 a group of researchers publish a
study of 1,600 adults who they examined
to find out equations that we could use
to estimate kidney function using
creatinine now because creatinine is a
breakdown product of our muscles
released at a fairly constant rate all
day the equations that they came up with
also include age and gender because as
we get older we tend to lose muscle mass
and men tend to have higher muscle mass
the women but if the patient is black
they suggested that we also need to
multiply by 1.2 because what they found
is that blacks in their study generally
had a higher muscle mass than the white
folks did
so these equations got applied to the
entire population everybody even though
that original study only included about
200 black people and no American Samoans
no Native Americans no Asians no Latinos
and these groups have very different
body frames but in our equations they’re
just not black so the implication then
only black people are different and the
problem with generalizations at least
one of them is that sometimes they’re
not true but in medicine we tend to not
challenge these things particularly when
they are in line with our underlying
assumptions and beliefs like the belief
that our social construct of race is the
same as a real biological science even
though the human genome project
completed sequencing the entire human
DNA into in 2003 and found that we
humans are 99.9% identical and that
point 1% difference does not fit into
our made-up race categories now I wonder
how many health care providers when
they’re sitting in front of their
patients interpreting lab results and
deciding what they will do or not about
them how many remember or even know that
this race adjustment is really supposed
to be about muscle mass a proxy for
muscle mass or are they just focusing on
the race or the person in front of them
and which one of these people they would
quote the race adjusted kidney function
estimate to the skinny black woman or
the white male bodybuilder these
shortcuts can have significant negative
consequences for black people who need a
kidney transplant
and happen to have lower muscle mass
like my patient Book of Eli so I
explained all of this to him and I asked
him to collect his urine for a full 24
hours and get a blood test so that we
could get a more accurate measure of how
well his kidneys were filtering blood
what we call a glomerular filtration
rate our GFR now this more accurate
estimate showed that his GFR was 20 and
that was the same as the shortcut
equation GFR but not racist at one at 20
at a GFR 20 people can be placed on the
waitlist for kidney transplant Book of
Eli would have had to wait an additional
year had I waited for his race adjusted
estimate which was 24 at the time to
fall to 20 and this matters because time
on the waitlist is one of the most
important determinants of when a person
gets a kidney transplant so by using a
more accurate estimate Book of Eli got
more time on the list and for patients
dealing with kidney failure time is life
so today I’ve told you about Robert and
Chris so that you would know at least
some of what people with kidney failure
are going through I told you about Ms o
futa so you would know what happens when
we let fear paralyze us and I told you
about Book of Eli so you wouldn’t know
how when we make assumptions about race
it can blur the lines of real science so
now that you know better what would you
do
thank you
you
physician walking through a hospital
hall like I had done many times before
but this day was different because I was
about to be the patient I was about to
give my left kidney to Robert Phillips a
man who had been on dialysis for several
years and who I have started dating less
than a year prior now how I got to this
point I think can best be summed up by
part of a quote from Maya Angelou when
you know better do better and I say this
because when I was a resident physician
and training I took care of lots of
patients in the hospital who are on
dialysis but then I was usually
sleep-deprived and always eager to get
on to the next patient
I paid careful attention to the dialysis
orders and the blood test results but
sadly not so much to the person living
with a serious illness all that changed
when I became Roberts girlfriend as
Roberts girlfriend I wasn’t in a rush
anymore I wanted to be with him at
dialysis as often as possible to help
him pass the time for hours three times
a week trying hard not to move his left
arm too much and dislodged the needles
that were connecting him to the dialysis
machine as girlfriend I watched him
struggle to not drink too much liquid in
between Dallas’s treatments even though
he was thirsty all the time because if
he did because his kidneys couldn’t pee
it out he would pay for it with swelling
and cramping and feeling short of breath
I went with him to his transplant
evaluation appointment and there I saw a
sight of medicine that I couldn’t see as
a primary care doctor it was a sigh that
felt like it was stacked against him
because it was part of a system in which
blacks waited nearly two years longer to
get a kidney transplant than whites so
it was that day that I decided I was
gonna give him one of my kidneys because
I knew what he was going through because
I knew better and because I knew better
I also went on to become a nephrologist
a kidney doctor so my goal today is to
tell you about three patients that I’ve
encountered since becoming a
nephrologist that I say demonstrate how
we can all do better
the first is Chris when I met Chris he
was this 25 year old fresh-faced
strawberry blonde head at young man who
should have been able to just focus on
his future but instead he was facing
kidney failure his kidneys were failing
because of an autoimmune disease called
IgA nephropathy and he needed to start
dialysis less than a year later now I
don’t know how many of you noticed this
little guy at the bottom of the picture
having tea with Chris but this is his
dialysis catheter surgically implanted
into his belly and this is the way Chris
coped with his illness take the little
face on it named it called it his
closest newest friend Chris also had two
older brothers both healthy but both
said no to giving baby brother a kidney
they figured he’s on the waiting list to
get a kidney from somebody who’s passed
away and he can just do dialysis until
then now the problem with that logic is
that it can take up to nine years to get
a deceased donor kidney transplant
depending on your blood type and where
you live and every year there are
another hundred thousand people on that
same list but we only do about 12,000
deceased donor kidney transplants each
year and another 5,000 roughly living
donor transplants so that’s how we end
up with thirteen people dying
every day waiting for a kidney
transplant one of the brothers came to
visit Chris for the first time since he
started Dallas’s and he saw how Chris
had to connect himself every night to a
Dallas’s machine that pushed and pulled
fluid in and out of the space between
his skin and his abdominal organs all
night long and Chris just hoped it he
could get through the night before the
alarm would be beeping are accidentally
tugging on his catheter and that’s all
it took to make the brother change his
mind
and he decided to give Chris one of his
kidneys
now his donation gave Chris the best
chance for a longer and better quality
of life better than a deceased donor
kidney could way better than the Alice’s
could after five years two-thirds of all
kidney transplants are going strong at
five years but only about a third of
Dallas’s patients are even alive now
four months after surgery Robert became
my husband I know he kind of had to
marry me
but he has had my kidney for 12 years
and Counting and the longest living
kidney lasted for 54 years
in a man who died when he was 88 years
old now this man happened to be named
Robert Phillips – you know at my core I
am a superstitious country girl so I
take that as a very good sign so if now
that you know what people with kidney
failure are facing if you know if
there’s somebody in your life who is in
need of a kidney transplant and you’re
healthy enough to give one I hope you’ll
consider it I get that it’s a bit
daunting I had all kinds of butterflies
in my stomach the morning of surgery
but when I woke up and I saw this bag at
the foot of Roberts bed in recovery just
filling up with lots of pale yellow
urine I was like that’s my kidney doing
that
and I was just so happy because I knew
that soon he won’t be able to drink as
much ice-cold beverages his thirst
desired and if I could go back in time I
would do it again and to be a donor you
don’t need to be related and the only
race that matters is the human race you
don’t even have to be a perfect match in
fact Robert and I only had 1 out of 6
genetic markers felt important at the
time and common at the very least I hope
you will consider registering as a organ
donor with the DMV and let your family
know that you did so that after you’re
gone
they will uphold your wishes and all
your healthy parts will go to make the
lives of others longer and better now if
you’re one of the 26 million adults in
this country with chronic kidney disease
the story of my next patient who I’ll
call miss a photo is for you miss a
photo was almost 50 years old when I met
her she had this smooth brown Samoan
skin but her kidneys were shrunken and
shriveled hardly functioning because of
years and years of uncontrolled diabetes
and high blood pressure which caused
two-thirds of chronic kidney disease in
this country but even though she has
such advanced disease she tried to run
away from it she wouldn’t believe me
when I told her that her kidneys would
soon fell and that she needed to prepare
for analysis she said things like you
know the swelling in my legs that’s
that’s because I’ve been on my feet all
day and this metallic taste that’s
because of the pills that you tell me to
take not because of kidney failure truth
is there is no outrunning kidney failure
unless something else gets you first
like you get hit by a bus or your heart
stops beating kidney failure will catch
you and I know she was hoping for a
miracle but in truth the only miracle
that was really in her near future was
dialysis because 60 years ago
Dallas’s didn’t exist and everybody with
kidney failure just passed away so
because miss of futa could not face the
reality she ended up with a lot of
avoidable things like the trauma of
feeling like you’re about to die and
having to call 9-1-1 13 hours in the
emergency room a plastic Dallas’s
catheter in her chest a hospital
admission she was looking at dialysis as
if it would be the end of her life when
in truth it would just make her life
different no it wouldn’t be perfect or
take away all the issues that come with
a vital organ dying yes it would have
his frustrations and take time but the
time in between could be filled with
life and all the things that she wanted
to keep doing with Dallas’s she could
expect to live for many years without it
once her kidneys fail completely
she get a week maybe two now roughly 80%
of adults in this country have
significant chronic kidney disease and
don’t even know it so if you might be a
patient for example you have diabetes or
high blood pressure or even if it just
runs in your family
get tested a simple blood and urine test
can detect kidney disease long before
you’ll ever feel anything and knowing is
doing better for yourself and your
family if you already know you’re a
patient then don’t let fear get in the
way of you accepting reality so that you
can do
how many of you saw this movie The Book
of Eli starring Denzel Washington yeah
not many so the next patient that I’ll
tell you about looks exactly like Denzel
in this movie now I know what some of
you are probably thinking but I have
never been among the multitudes of women
who would just wriggle out of her
panties and throw them on any stage that
Denzel stands on I just saw my patient
who I will call because Eli as a
good-looking brother who had a chronic
kidney problem now when I met Book of
Eli
he was very muscular I needed a large
extra-large blood pressure cuff to take
his blood pressure but five years later
as his kidney disease declined from a
disease called membranous nephropathy
his muscles had wasted away too and so a
regular blood pressure cuff would do at
every visit I would tell him about all
of his test results and cout including
creatinine the blood tests that we used
to find out about kidney function in
1999 a group of researchers publish a
study of 1,600 adults who they examined
to find out equations that we could use
to estimate kidney function using
creatinine now because creatinine is a
breakdown product of our muscles
released at a fairly constant rate all
day the equations that they came up with
also include age and gender because as
we get older we tend to lose muscle mass
and men tend to have higher muscle mass
the women but if the patient is black
they suggested that we also need to
multiply by 1.2 because what they found
is that blacks in their study generally
had a higher muscle mass than the white
folks did
so these equations got applied to the
entire population everybody even though
that original study only included about
200 black people and no American Samoans
no Native Americans no Asians no Latinos
and these groups have very different
body frames but in our equations they’re
just not black so the implication then
only black people are different and the
problem with generalizations at least
one of them is that sometimes they’re
not true but in medicine we tend to not
challenge these things particularly when
they are in line with our underlying
assumptions and beliefs like the belief
that our social construct of race is the
same as a real biological science even
though the human genome project
completed sequencing the entire human
DNA into in 2003 and found that we
humans are 99.9% identical and that
point 1% difference does not fit into
our made-up race categories now I wonder
how many health care providers when
they’re sitting in front of their
patients interpreting lab results and
deciding what they will do or not about
them how many remember or even know that
this race adjustment is really supposed
to be about muscle mass a proxy for
muscle mass or are they just focusing on
the race or the person in front of them
and which one of these people they would
quote the race adjusted kidney function
estimate to the skinny black woman or
the white male bodybuilder these
shortcuts can have significant negative
consequences for black people who need a
kidney transplant
and happen to have lower muscle mass
like my patient Book of Eli so I
explained all of this to him and I asked
him to collect his urine for a full 24
hours and get a blood test so that we
could get a more accurate measure of how
well his kidneys were filtering blood
what we call a glomerular filtration
rate our GFR now this more accurate
estimate showed that his GFR was 20 and
that was the same as the shortcut
equation GFR but not racist at one at 20
at a GFR 20 people can be placed on the
waitlist for kidney transplant Book of
Eli would have had to wait an additional
year had I waited for his race adjusted
estimate which was 24 at the time to
fall to 20 and this matters because time
on the waitlist is one of the most
important determinants of when a person
gets a kidney transplant so by using a
more accurate estimate Book of Eli got
more time on the list and for patients
dealing with kidney failure time is life
so today I’ve told you about Robert and
Chris so that you would know at least
some of what people with kidney failure
are going through I told you about Ms o
futa so you would know what happens when
we let fear paralyze us and I told you
about Book of Eli so you wouldn’t know
how when we make assumptions about race
it can blur the lines of real science so
now that you know better what would you
do
thank you
you
Please follow and like us: