Press "Enter" to skip to content

This talk isn’t very good. Dancing with my inner critic | Steve Chapman | TEDxRoyalTunbridgeWells


[Music]
I’m terribly sorry to interrupt your day
but I feel the need to warn you about
the next speaker who doesn’t deserve to
be here
I can only assume the organizers made a
clerical error and thought they were
booking a different Steve Chapman one
with intellect and wisdom a true thought
leader this Steve Chapman is a compliant
enough human being but is punching way
above his weight by even considering
walking onto this stage I have been
telling him for many years that he has
ideas way above his station that are
only going to lead to his spectacular
public humiliation I fear that moment is
about to come and I would take no
pleasure in telling him I told you so
I can only apologize on his behalf and
suggest you use the next short while to
check your emails until the next proper
speaker arrives meet my inner critic
that whisper in my ear who constantly
reminds me that I’m not good enough that
my creativity is bad that I should play
it safe and not take risks not try
anything new because I’ll probably make
a fool of myself he’s a familiar
character someone that’s been there my
whole life but someone I took a
particular interest in a few years ago
in September 2012 I spent a week
training with a guru named Keith Keith
was and still is a hero of mine and I
took the opportunity of meeting him for
the first time to let him know I was
writing a book about creativity inspired
by his work keith was incredibly
enthusiastic and buoyed by his
encouragement I set off to continue
working on the project a year later
September 2013 I was once again with
Keith I gave him an update told him some
of the chapter headings the fact that my
six-year-old daughter was illustrating
it
that sounds really interesting I’d love
a copy when it’s done said Keith so a
year later after three years hard work I
was once again with Keith September 2014
I presented him with a copy of the
published book that I’d signs to thank
him from his influence Keith accepted it
with gratitude and placed it carefully
in his bag a few days later he
approached me during a break and said
I’d like to buy you a coffee after class
wow I fought a one-to-one audience with
my hero then that voice started
whispering in my ear he’s going to tell
you it’s the worst book he’s ever read
and you’re a total failure I told a
friend about my concerns and she
reassured me of course keith was going
to love it it was a book that was based
on a master’s dissertation that got
exceptional marks so as we sat in the
rather bland Lee decorated bar of
Keith’s hotel I started to smile inside
maybe he was gonna like it maybe this
was going to be the moment that I proved
my inner critic that I was good enough
Keith looked at me and grimace slightly
and then said about this book I think
you should withdraw it from sale said
everyone you’ve made a mistake get some
help and start again I think this book
will damage your business the world felt
like it stopped spinning for a moment
everything apart from Keith’s face went
out of focus my chest tightened my
cheeks flushed my heart felt like it was
going at a thousand miles an hour
Keith carried on talking but I couldn’t
hear him I had a one-to-one audience
with my hero and all I wanted to do was
run away hide and never have a creative
thought again in that moment my inner
critic felt like it had quadrupled in
size had me in the palm of its hand I
was slowly crushing me with his powerful
grip telling me with venom and malice I
told you so the inner critic or
super-ego as Freud called it is our
idealized sense of self an unattainable
imagined perfect version of us that
never fails everything and receives the
adoration that other human beings for
being a master at literally everything
it manifests in our stay today as a
self-doubt that causes us to distrust
our intuition and
instincts a voice whose constant
narrative of comparison and judgment
stifles spontaneity and creativity
replacing it with self-doubt and shame
now for someone else that afternoon with
Keith may have been inconsequential just
one person’s opinion that was after all
coming from a genuinely well-intentioned
place but for me it was the perfect
storm for my inner critic it ticked all
of his boxes it pressed all of his
buttons and in that moment he stole my
heroes words to use as compelling
evidence that he was right all along
and that I wasn’t good enough it’s world
to recover from that day but when I did
I had an even more of a renewed interest
in this character so I decided to start
an mi5 style investigation into him a
covert inquiry where I gather evidence
on this shady creature where he hung out
what did he like to do where did he
train what did he look like
like a police artists getting a witness
impression of a suspect I started to
draw him which yielded some fascinating
results some of the early pictures were
of a professorial type chap who would
just look at me and shake his head and
totter everything I did but over time he
evolved into an equally disapproving
sinister Zen monk style character both
men both older than me and both
possessing more academic or spirit
spiritual wisdom than I thought I could
ever attain but the really interesting
thing was the more I drew him the more
detail I added the more he evolved and
morphed like a mythical shapeshifter
that realizes it’s been spotted and now
desperately trying to avoid capture and
it was in that moment I thought I’m on
to him the dance has begun I continue to
dig dirt on this character on of his
visit to my parents house I excavated
some old school reports from the loft
and I’m reading them had a simultaneous
sense of anger and excitement there’s
somebody that now knows I suffered from
dyslexia and self-doubt at school the
anger arose from repeated descriptions
of a young boy who would not achieve
anything so he simply didn’t try hard
enough or make enough effort but the
excitement arose from a realization that
the words in these dusty old documents
were almost verbatim what my inner
critic tortured me with on a regular
basis it was like I’d found one of his
secret training manuals
one of his sacred parchments I decided I
needed to confront him about all of this
so I made a puppet of him which would
enable me to have an adult treadle
conversation with him and in doing so I
realized that if I stripped back his
dramatic playground style exaggerations
there really wasn’t much substance to
what he said in fact it seemed he was
the fraud he was the charlatan he was
the imposter I was becoming quite
obsessed of all of this so I started to
tell other people about him and was
surprised to learn that they too had
their own inner critics so encouraged
them to start drawing them resulting in
a beautifully bizarre online gallery of
inner critic artists impressions some of
them were very similar in terms of
appearance and apparent origins stories
many were different and diverse and
unique somewhat bizarre surreal and
scary but for all of the diversity of
their appearance no matter where I went
they all seem to have variations of the
same basic message that they just
repeated over and over again you are not
good enough and you are incapable of
becoming good enough horribly twisted
psychological not that’s difficult to
escape from but it seemed I’d found the
answer my inner critic had been
suspiciously quiet since I started my
investigation so I assumed all I needed
to do was to carry on and then he’d give
up for good then one morning I received
an email I’d been nominated to do a high
profile talk on creativity it was really
excited that the prospect of taking my
work to a global audience I was hoping
the email was going to be my invitation
to speak but when I read it my heart
sank the quality of speakers this year
has been exceptional and we would not be
inviting you to speak on this occasion I
felt the Beast rising on my shoulder
he’s for more hideous and misshapen than
he had been previously he didn’t speak
because he needed no words I could tell
what he was telling me in every fiber of
my body and in that moment I realized
that this is a game without end
an ongoing game of cat and mouse like a
slightly more psychologically disturbing
version of Tom and Jerry for every one
of his wily schemes to get me I would
come up with an equally cunning creative
response
to lure him out into the light I’ve been
working with masks for a number of years
and knew they were a potent way of
getting in touch with the dark recesses
of our personality so I made a mask of
him so I could literally stand in his
shoes walk talk think and feel like him
I enrolled in the Hofmann process an
incredibly intensive seven-day
psychological retreat where I learned
about some of the origins of his power
and authority the early parental
influences the words of teachers and
other authority figures that I’d
swallowed whole as true descriptions of
who I was and who I had the potential to
become for Alexander Technique lessons I
learned the effect he had on me
physically and as a tall man why I
always made myself smaller because he’d
tell me to stand up straight tall and
centered he’s arrogant and said to
myself up for failure and using a
surprisingly simple art therapy
technique I discovered that alcohol was
one of his secret weapons in his most
vicious moments he’d say come and have a
drink that will quieten me in a moment I
did he say why are you drinking you
should be ashamed and right now he’s
telling me that for this talk on this
stage to be any good I should be telling
you that I defeated him I slayed him and
I should be telling you that you too can
just follow my three simple steps to
inner bliss but that simply isn’t true
the dance continues and I suspect it
always will but an acceptance that this
is just part of being a self-aware
self-regulating fully functional
creative human being has been the most
liberating thing influential Gestalt
psychologists called Arnie by Sir
suggested that human change is
paradoxical and if we get more change by
becoming more deeply aware of who we are
rather than striving to be something
we’re not it seems our stuckness when
working with the inner critic arises
from our default response to try and
fight it or prove it wrong
which just results in us trying to
improve which plays into its hands and
it’s not already good enough driver the
biggest thing I’ve discovered from this
inquiry over the last three or four
years is that the practice of bearing
witness is the most potent thing a
deeper awareness and acceptance of what
is without judgment
to learn to dance with the inner critic
rather than to fight them the eminent
Zen writer tick not han suggests that if
we have an energy within us that we wish
to transform we need to take care of it
rather than to battle with it or else it
would destroy us I like to call this
practice taking care of my demons I see
you my little credit it’s in a critic I
know you’re well-intentioned I’m here
for you now and in doing all of this
I’ve developed a relationship with him
he’s now more of an annoyance than an
authority like an irritating flatmate
that you learn to live with because they
pay the rent I’ve even developed an
empathy for the poor thing whose role
early in life was to keep me safe and
him maintain those important early
relational connections but the most
exciting thing has been that as the
inner critic despite his creativity gets
him to know him in more and more
imperfect creative ways really messes
with his mind ironically my creative
nemesis has become my creative muse and
source of inspiration I’ve come to
believe that creativity is simply our
human capacity to experience an express
difference in service of change and
transformation so imagine the potential
in the room if each of us was able to
fully liberate our creative hope and
ambition and at the same time imagine
the power that our collective inner
critics would have to stifle all of that
if we continue to let them operate
underground like some United Nations of
Bond villains we cannot bring forth a
fully flawed but willing human selves in
an atmosphere of self judgment in
comparison but we can use any number of
creative playful and experimental means
to lure these creatures out of the
shadows and into the light
where we can get a good look at them and
see them for what they are and maybe
reclaim some of their power for
ourselves thank you
[Applause]
[Music]
Please follow and like us: