Press "Enter" to skip to content

Thinking through drawing | Andrea Kantrowitz | TEDxEastsidePrep


I’m determined to remind people that we

all draw we all started out drawing it’s

before there was paper we drew in the

sand we drew in the dirt across all

cultures throughout human history and

before we’ve drawn so why is that what

is so powerful about drawing that makes

it such a universal practice I really

believe in the importance of drawing as

a tool of thought and as such I’m going

to explain what I mean by that it

recruits all kinds of innate human

capacities I don’t have time to discuss

them all today but I have a few that

we’re going to talk about the embodied

and situated nation Eicher of human

cognition visual perception the way that

we as humans are uniquely capable of

thinking with our hands we think with

our hands all the time even when we

don’t realize it and the power of

analogical reasoning and how that is

facilitated through the drawing process

so starting with embodied and situated

cognition what I mean by that is that

cognition is grounded in our bodily

experiences and interactions with the

world everything that we know comes

through our bodies even the most

abstract concepts have a physical analog

balancing the scales of justice for

example how do we get this information

there’s modes of perception we’re all

familiar when we think about perception

we think about the five senses those

five senses are known by psychologists

is extra reception

there’s also proprioception which is the

information we get as we move through

the world the movement of parts of our

bodies in space that’s important

information and interoception

which is our awareness of our inner

metabolic states heartbeat respiration

our inner mental states and feelings for

example one thing that psychologists

have learned lately is that the emotion

that we feel actually stems from our

physical responses our heart starts

beating faster we start breathing

heavily and then we are afraid so what

happens is the cognition is actually

distributed we really are not aware of

as much as we think we are at any given

moment we’re moving through the world

we’re getting these little bits and

pieces of information and cognition is

actually distributed between the mind

the body and the world the world remains

out there on a need-to-know basis so I’m

going to go back to visual perception

because it is a really important part of

how information comes in and is

processed by our brains that’s my

daughter at 18 months and something you

learn as a mother about infant

development you can’t really learn from

books one thing that was really

surprised me about my own children is

how drawing was such a natural and

automatic thing that they did they

didn’t need to be taught and again when

you don’t have paper and pencil you use

a stick in the sand here she’s dealing

with the problem of how do you make a

line that ends where it begins so it’s a

circle right she managed to figure out

how to 18 months how to draw a circle

and then what do you do with a circle

you can fill it in you can take a bite

out of it and then you see something

maybe you see something familiar the

jogs a previous memory many people see

pac-man when they look at this I also

hear sometimes they say pie sometimes

they say pizza that’s what they see you

move the pieces around a little bit you

reconfigure it reimagine it what do you

see thank you very much most people see

a triangle where is a triangle there’s

no triangle there but our brain is

putting it together what we know innate

perceptual predispositions with what we

see it’s always a negotiation between

what we know and what we see but we’re

often seeing things that aren’t

necessary

there right happens all the time when

you think about it it’s better to

imagine that there’s a saber-toothed

tiger in the bushes then to ignore that

feeling that you might have so let’s go

back to the triangle again we can move

things around we can reconfigure them

change them add to them this is what’s

going on there’s always this

conversation between what’s coming top

down we’re aware of and what’s floating

up from underneath from all these

different sources of perception it’s

this prior knowledge that’s interacting

with what’s happening right now in the

moment so the information goes from our

retinas to the back of our brain that’s

the visual cortex right here but it

doesn’t end there

it’s it’s processed in a very

complicated way so we know that it’s not

like there’s some little guy back there

who’s figuring it all out for us so what

percentage of the brain do you think is

devoted to visual perception mental

imagery many people it’s very

interesting when I talked to crowds of

artists they’ll say 90 percent and when

I talk to everyone else they’ll say well

maybe five percent so it turns out that

40 percent is probably a pretty

conservative estimate it depends on how

you define it it could be when you’re

talking about spatial reasoning it’s

actually a lot more than that it sort of

fans out the the activity fans out in

two main directions one is about the

where stream this was an evolutionarily

older process you see this in a lot of

mammals the same pathway which is about

just navigating around the world

understanding where things are located

how to move through space and then the

ventral stream is actually more specific

to higher primates and humans and it’s

about objects processing noting the

specific features textures

colors of important significant objects

in the environment facial processing

happens in that area of the brain

thinking with our hands again this is

something which is uniquely human right

this bipedal motion we have these

amazing hands that are moving much more

complicated ways than even our closest

relatives and we also have these

shoulders which allow for an incredible

range and variety of kinds of movement

we pay a high price for that right many

of us have experienced back pain and

shoulder injuries because of that our

shoulders are only attached right here

to the rest of our skeleton and it

allows for an incredible amount of

freedom but also difficulties but it’s

been so valuable to us as a species to

have these hands have the ability to

think with our hands and think with our

arms and think with the gestures that we

make we’ve seen that on a lot of the

speakers today how they communicate

through gesture and in fact evolutionary

biologists believe that language emerged

from gesture gesture comes first and

then words so this is a very new member

of my family and she’s very far from

saying her first words but she already

communicates very clearly with gesture

this was taken last week and I hadn’t

seen her for a while and it really had a

huge impact on me emotionally when she

saw me she opened her arms to greet me

and we both knew what I needed to pick

her up of course immediately so gesture

susan goldin-meadow is a cognitive

psychologist who’s really been a pioneer

in gesture studies and this is based on

pia JS conservation of volume tasks what

she found is that a child that goes the

water in this tall glass is more and in

the short class is less there’s a match

between what he’s doing with his gesture

and what he’s doing with the hands but

the girl is saying well

the tall glass has more but the short

glass has less there’s a mismatch she’s

measuring the width of the glass and

she’s hesitating maybe a little in her

speech and that means that she’s

actually ready to go on to the next

level of understanding

dr. goldin-meadow found this and there’s

a now a really robust area of research

that shows that both children and adults

when there’s this kind of mismatch

between what they’re saying and what

they’re doing that what they’re doing is

more advanced than what they’re actually

able to articulate so drawing is able to

capture this Nikolaidis is someone who

really understood the power of gesture

drawing really popularized it and what

he noticed was that the gesture is a

feeling which reaches out and guides

students to knowledge so that his

drawing students were able to capture

something on the paper that they didn’t

even understand themselves so

psychologists now understand that motor

actions are now viewed as both a

facilitator and beneficiary of

psychological functions so we learn by

doing

David Rosen is an art historian who

studied Leonardo’s who made some amazing

drawings of phenomena in the natural

world that had never been visualized

before so this is the very first

visualization of turbulence and Rosen

talks about it was Leonardo seeing pen

it was through the motion of his hand as

it followed the motion of the water that

enabled him to understand what he was

experiencing so making that analogy

analogy between the movement and the

phenomenon analogic reasoning is a

really powerful feature of human

cognition that can be accessed through

drawing and David Rosen talks about the

magic that to make a mark or trace a

single line upon a surface immediately

transforms that surface the graphic

imposition turns the actual flatness of

the ground into virtual space turns the

material reality into the fiction of the

imagination

so one of my go-to experts maybe before

Leonardo is Harold and Harold really

understands the magic of drawing right

so he draws his trees maybe a little

hungry he draws some apples and then a

tree and then they’re so delicious he

has to draw a monster to protect his

apples so they’ll be there when he gets

back the monster that he draws is so

scary that it startles him so he’s the

drawing is talking back to him and he

backs away and he gets so freaked out

that his hand actually starts to shake

and pretty soon he’s over his head but

he still has his purple crayon so he’s

able to respond to the changing

situation and come up thinking fast and

in no time he had drawn himself a boat

he had solved his problem quickly

setting sail and the moon sailed along

with him so if they’re making that

analogy here this is a cat it’s not

playing with the yarn because he thinks

oh I need to get better catching mice

I’m going to play with this yarn and see

if it helps me do that no he’s

exercising his essential Cadmus and we

as humans when we draw are exercising

our essential humaneness but there’s a

difference between us and the cat is

that we can really use that trace of

what we’ve done and reflect on it and

learn from it and discover something new

that we would otherwise not have

imagined I became very interested in the

improvisational nature of expert drawing

practice and I did a study and just as I

was finishing up my study I heard this

quote this interview on the radio with

Staff Sergeant Kent ebo of the Marine

Corps jazz ensemble and he said all

instrumentalists feel that their

instrument is an extension of themselves

and it’s not just about making it up as

you go along it’s about being creative

within and around a known

set of boundaries for which you’ve

prepared a great deal so there’s this

drawing in and out there’s this

engagement with the present moment

drawing it in and then there’s drawing

out all that prior experience and it’s

the interaction going back and forth

between those two so these are the

artists that I looked at Jane fine works

with comic books William Holton works

with biological processes Winnie Kwang

Michael Moore Margaret Neal who does

site-specific work responding in the

moment to what’s happening in a

particular space all these artists were

artists that had drawing as a center of

their practice they were all over 40

that was something that was important to

me in my study they weren’t they had

been really devoted to this for many

many years but what I found from a video

analysis of watching these artists

drawing and having them narrate their

process is they there was a lot that

they had in common there was this

experience of beginning they had a

beginning strategy they knew how to get

the fire started and once it got started

it had a kind of momentum of its own

they could stand back a little bit and

let it happen okay and they were very

conscious about that so there was this

the engine of that was this back and

forth feedback between looking at the

specific details and working towards

overall coherence so it’s about

alternating between the whole in the

parts and this relates back to what I

was talking about at the beginning of my

talk the what and where pathways so

they’re very consciously alternated

between thinking about moving through

the space through the page and really

paying a lot of attention at specific

details not getting lost in the details

pulling back and then rien gauging and

this is the kind of thing they said when

that fire started going they would say

the drawing seems to take over it’s like

you’re surfing I get myself in a

situation and then I have to work myself

out of it you were driven by the drawing

it’s not just you okay it’s telling me

some stuff

I’m telling it some stuff these are some

of the things that artists would say to

describe what this is like and again

it’s this top down bottom out

conversation our minds and our bodies

and human cognition has multiple

sources multiple circuits as we heard

today and it’s how all of these are

orchestrated working together to create

a sense of connection so I’m going back

to Sharon rosensweig talking about the

theme of resurgence she and her husband

created a comic book based on the Old

Testament and in the course of working

on this book they found that God was a

woman who knew how did this happen

originally she sort of imagined God as

being like her jerky older brother who

was kind of a bully because face it when

you think about the God of the Old

Testament he really was quite a bully

but as she kept working on her drawings

things started to happen that she wasn’t

planning and she would keep insisting it

was her brother and people would tell

her hey Sharon he’s looking pretty curvy

not looking so much like your brother

anymore and finally she had to admit it

and the whole book became a flirtation

between God as a woman and Moses here’s

one of the panels from the final comic

book and you can see there was kind of a

romantic comedy that kind of emerged

from the Old Testament from their

version of the Old Testament which was

not at all what had planned but which

had emerged through the process of

drawing and what drawing allows us to do

is be able to make a mark to make a

drawing

tear it up do it again and create

destroy create destroy and that is the

magic it allows us to do things that we

would never be able to do in real life

and in that way come up with solutions

we could never have imagined that’s what

it means to think through drawing and I

hope we all go and do it and practice it thank you very much

Please follow and like us: