Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Unexplored Depths of Story-Listening | Priscilla Jebaraj | TEDxNLUO


mother was a refugee when she was 14 her

world fell apart it was middle of World

War two and she and her family had to

flee from Burma and make the long hard

Trek over the mountains to India now

when my cousins and I were small

children we used to beg her to tell us

that story of the journey we would sit

in a circle around her she would feed us

Burmese food that she still enjoyed

making and we would listen to us it was

a tale of adventure and excitement there

were nighttime rides on the river there

were villains who tried to rob the

family they were daring rescues and

miraculous escapes it was so exciting

it was better than in any adventure

novel but as I grew up I learned to

listen between the lines to the pain of

leaving behind everything that she knew

heading towards an uncertain future the

dangers of that wartime journey and the

heartbreak and grief of losing a beloved

older sister to illness along the way we

had to bury her in an unknown grave in

the mountains but perhaps less dramatic

but more traumatic than that was what

came at the end of the journey you see

my grandmother and her family where were

originally from India they were Tamils

who had migrated to Burma three

generations earlier and all they knew

was Burma none of them had ever seen

India her father was a well-respected

municipal commissioner in the town they

lived in a big teak house at 14 my

grandmother wore short skirts went to a

British school and played tennis and

competed in athletics the world they

fled to was completely different they

were dependent for food and shelter on

distant relatives whom they barely knew

my grandmother had to exchange her short

skirts for wearing a half sari at 14 and

certainly there was no there was no

place for a young girl to learn tennis

when I was a young journalism student in

Chennai at 20 I met another refugee she

must have been about 16 let’s call her

Rani

now Rani and her family had fled from

Sri Lanka from the war there when she

was a young child and they were among

the thousands of refugees housed in

refugee camps across the state of Tamil

Nadu and the government was just

starting to talk about repatriation now

Ronnie’s mother and those of her

generation in the camp told me a story

that is very common to refugees across

time whether from Burma of the 1940s or

Sri Lanka of the 1990s or the Syrians

today Syrian refugees who dominate the

headlines today it’s a story of the

horrors of wartime the risk they took to

their lives in trying to get out and

once things got better how desperately

desperately they wanted to go back home

but I heard the true echoes of my

grandmother’s story in what Ronnie told

me Ronnie was a young teenager she

barely remembered life in Sri Lanka her

entire world was in doubt she enjoyed

Indian food she knew Indian customs she

had big dreams of going to college in

India to think of Sri Lanka she she

didn’t even know what she could dream of

in Sri Lanka and so when I went back

with my report it focused on a young

girl watching her world fall apart

facing an unknown future your topic here

at TEDx today is imbibe innovate impart

right and I’ve been a journalist for

well over a decade so I suppose I fit

firmly into the impart section of things

right I am a professional storyteller

that’s it’s my passion it’s my

profession at what I do i impart but

I’ve learnt over the years that if I

begin with imparting whether it’s

information stories analysis whatever

before I do the imbibing I’m in deep

trouble

and it sounds simple right you have to

listen to a story before you can tell it

everyone knows that

but it’s astonishing how often we are

bad at doing just that and how serious

are the implications

when we fail when I looked up the

definition of the word in the dictionary

the definition of the word in the

dictionary the first definition you see

is to drink alcohol they were imbibing

far too many pictures of your I don’t

suppose that’s the kind of imbibing

you’re advocating here at TEDx today I

the second definition of course is to

absorb or to assimilate ideas or

knowledge right and that’s the kind of

imbibing that’s so often we are bad at

doing we hear stories but we fail to

listen to them we don’t absorb stories

to assimilate them into how we see the

world into our knowledge of the world

imbibing is it’s a multi-sensory verb it

it’s important to look deeply to listen

well sometimes to even live out story to

almost taste it at the back of your

mouth before you can tell it I have a

confession to make I am not used to

speaking without notes usually and so

I’d intended to spend this morning this

morning session practicing so that I

knew how I was going to do this then I

thought how hypocritical I to spend the

time talking to myself instead of

listening to the stories which were

being shared here on stage this morning

and it was truly rewarding there were

powerful stories shared so you see this

isn’t just about me and my fellow

journalists professional storytellers

we’re standing here today in a law

university many of you are not students

you’re about to enter the judicial

system of the country right and the

system for justice in this country

and at the heart of justice is truth

truth is what we seek to uphold in the

courts of law truth is I hope the basis

of journalism truth lies at the

foundation of any just society and when

we fail to listen properly we fail to

hear truth and that is the first step in

denying justice to those who need it

let me go back to journalism to tell you

what the implications can look like when

we fail to listen properly

one of my first news articles as as a

national news reporter covering

environmental issues was about Vedanta

now Vedanta is a multinational mining

company which was set up an alumina

refinery here in Odisha in the calahonda

district and they originally intended to

source their raw materials by mining the

nearby neoguri hills there were people

who were for the project hoping for

industry and development and jobs that

that region needed badly and there were

those who were against the project for

seeing pollution and deforestation and

most importantly local activists people

were firmly against the project because

they saw the knee on Geary Hills as

sacred as their God and about 400 people

had turn up and 27 people spoke and

they’d recorded the statements of these

27 people off the 27:17 we’re completely

against the projects they were opposed

to it

there were nine who were on the fence

some of them they felt that they would

welcome the opportunities for employment

but they worried that the company was

not keeping its promises on pollution

and on giving jobs to locals and one

person out of the 27 was completely in

favor of the project so 17 9 and 1 let

me tell you let me quote from the record

of of that report they said that we have

given Vedanta our motherland and it has

given nothing back they said that the

unit is polluting the surroundings and

we will hold a none Dolan a protest they

said that the hill is our mother the

villagers will never agree and it goes

on and on like this for about six pages

of statements and the after these six

pages of mostly passionate opposition

which was faithfully recorded by these

two officials these same two officials

are concluded that report with a single

concluding statement and it says the

overall opinion of the public about the

project was favorable provided the

proper netiquette of their issues I have

to wonder what were those officials

listening to they had heard the stories

they’d heard the statements against it

but they chose to completely disregard

after about a decade of protests and

legal cases back and forth

last year the Supreme Court in a final

verdict came down in favor of the

tribals and against the government and

the company but I wonder in the process

how many stories were raised

how many never even came to light there

are other subtler ways of erasing

stories if for example it can depend on

who is telling the story who you’re

listening to tell the story I saw an

example of this sadly in a police

station which is supposed to be the

first building block of our judicial

system I was accompanying a group of

government officials and NGOs I know

rescue of people who had been trafficked

for labor this was in contributing

district in southern Tamil Nadu and in

famine aru and these were also adivasi

people were illiterate and they and

after the rescue we headed to the police

station to file an fi our right the

first information report this is the

first official recording of a story the

first listening in a criminal case and

it was the middle of the night so the

police invited the NGO social workers to

come in to sit down to have a cup of tea

while the forms were being filled but

they wanted to leave the ardi wasi

families outside in the dark sitting on

the hard ground later when the owners

the employers turned up they were also

invited in to have their say and so

ultimately the police could say that

they had told both sides they’d listened

to both sides of the story there was no

bias they listened to the social workers

speak on behalf of the victims and the

owners beak on behalf of the oppressors

on but they hadn’t actually listened to

the laborers to the adversities to tell

their own story and if the NGO hadn’t

insisted it wouldn’t have happened one

of the police officers asked me ah what

could they possibly have to say they’re

illiterate tribals they know nothing I

have to admit that as a journalist I’m

often guilty of that kind of listening

it’s lazy but it’s easy to listen to the

spokesperson the activists the social

worker

rather than to hear the story directly

the inside story directly from those who

have the right to tell it don’t get me

wrong there’s nothing there’s value in

being a voice for the voiceless victim

but we would your truth better do

justice better if we would give a voice

to the voiceless victims themselves and

perhaps we would start best by not

labeling them victims at all let me tell

you about real now I could tell you that

Rio is the victim of sex trafficking in

Mumbai and the terrible circumstances

that brought her there and it would be

true but when I met RIA it was I was

working on a project for an

anti-trafficking NGO with a very

talented photographer named dick kill

Roshan and we listened to her tell a

story that went well beyond

victimization she she told us how after

she had gotten out of that situation she

had completed school she’d completed a

technical certification and she was

working she just got in a job working in

the shipyard the Bombay shipyard and she

was she was so proud of herself she

lived with a group of friends in a PG

and they enjoyed walking down marine

drive and eating ice cream now the law

requires that we don’t show the faces

the facial features of sex trafficking

victims and so photographers have to

work around that and on that project

Nikhil had done in several ways you can

take photos of the back of a person you

can take photos in silhouette so that

you’re against the light and the face

isn’t seen but in India especially one

of the most common ways is because

Indian women wear a sari or the potaro

chimney is to have the woman cover her

head and cover her face

perhaps with only the eyes showing or

even the eyes veiled right it’s a

convenient way but we found that having

heard real story

we couldn’t portray her simply as a

it’s still using the scarf but this

isn’t the portrait of a victim it’s not

the portrait of bondage it’s a picture

of freedom it’s rias own story the truth

it can be hard to hear stories that are

far from our own experience to discover

the truth goes well beyond what we

personally know especially for those of

us raised in urban India the stories of

rural India can seem too far

linguistically geographically in every

way and veteran journalist peace on

earth has been trying to bridge that gap

for decades and recently start the

project called the people’s archive of

rural India here as team have been

trying to record and absorb and imbibe

the stories of the villagers and put

them online and recently they they start

a project to record the songs that

village women sing as they work with

their grind mills by grinding grain or

spices or whatever as motorized grinding

comes in that’s being lost and they’re

looking to capture these songs and

they’re putting about a lack of them

online you should listen to a city girl

raised on rap rock and YouTube those

songs can feel like they come from a

different world and yet if we don’t

listen if we don’t absorb the stories of

rural India we simply will not be able

to build a just society one of my

favorite TED Talks is by the Nigerian

novelist Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie I hope

I’ve pronounced it right and she speaks

on the dangers of a single story right

and one of her examples is off of how

the Western world sees Africa the single

story of a continent of conflict

corruption and poverty and we in India

are familiar with that kind of

stereotyping right for a long time the

western wall saw as an exotic land of

snake charmers and elephants of beggar’s

and Rajas that’s fast changing as we

export the stories of software companies

of modern development of Bollywood

alongside what happens when we live with

some ancient prejudices especially of

caste and gender but even as we expand

the stories that we tell the rest of the

world I feel that we are narrowing the

stories we tell ourselves

I worry that as a nation we’re trying to

draw a billion very different people

into the street jacket of a single story

a single story of our history of our

religion our culture our language and of

our future our future path of

development and those who are left on

the margins or outside the rigid

outlines of this story are also too

often left outside the safety net of

justice and so if the story that we hear

is that India is a land of Hindus and

Hindi speaking peoples then it becomes

okay to treat those from other religions

or other languages as second-class

citizens to impose the single-story of

the majority on many minorities if in

our single story the beautiful Indian

woman is we just skinned whatever that

means

has large eyes and is demure and modest

then it becomes okay to sell fair and

lovely creams it becomes okay to rape a

girl in a short skirt if the constant

story we listen to is of growth and

development so that India can become a

global power then we are in danger of

drowning out the stories of those who

face the cost of that growth those

dispossessed by development in fact it

becomes anti-national to listen to those

stories and of course if the story is

that India’s a meeting is a land of

vegetarians and meat eaters don’t really

deserve justice do they it becomes okay

to debate whether Mohammed o’clock had

mutton or beef in his fridge rather than

to be appalled then a mob killed a man

over his food habits the stories we

listen to are important whose stories we

listen to is important how we listen to

them can change our world we don’t even

always have to tell the stories we

listen to in order

for that listening to have impact I have

never before told in such a public fora

the story of my grandmother the refugee

and someday I hope to go to Burma to

retrace her journey and to tell her

story but it was the very act of

listening to her stories of imbibing and

absorbing them that built in me the

capacity for empathy to hear other

people’s stories to your truth to seek

and to safeguard justice thank you for

listening [Applause]

Please follow and like us: