Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Uncertainty of Refugee Statistics | Funda Ustek | TEDxUCLWomen


we’re surrounded by data this gives us

the impression that we know about the

world more than we ever did before and

that everything we have data for is more

certain more tangible but once we have

data we rarely questioned what it makes

it what what it makes invisible while

making other things visible I’m a

sociologist and I’m interested in

studying people who go missing in data I

do not mean missing in the sense that

they don’t get counted though sometimes

this is the case but missing in

categories missing in representation I’m

interested in studying this both from

the point of the people who think their

voices do not get hurt or they do not

fit in today tiny categories in the

survey forms but I’m also interested in

studying this from the point of the data

producers who talk about groups that are

difficult to count and characteristics

that are difficult to account for but

sometimes even the most trivial and the

most mundane may be uncertain and data

in many ways my own personal story has

been learning about the uncertainties in

what seemed like certainties um I come

from Turkey and although we do have a

registration system in our family there

are three people whose birth dates we’re

not so sure about and this is my

grandmother my father and my aunt they

were all registered at a point when they

needed to my grandmother was a

registered before she got married and my

father was registered before he started

school and my aunt was registered just

because my father was being registered

but we don’t know about the exact

birthdate month or year we have an

estimate that looks like a certainty in

data I’ll come back to this point paying

attention to uncertainties are important

because once social realities are made

into

later it becomes difficult to undo their

impact and leave the lenses behind leave

the lenses data gives us behind this

might sound like an obvious point to

make but we often do not see have the

cultural social and other political

codes enter our data one important

example of this is refugee statistics

refugee statistics are widely quoted but

notoriously inaccurate the so-called

refugee crisis has been a hot topic for

almost five years now the information we

get in popular media about refugees and

about migrants is at best puzzling on

the one hand it’s a crisis made by the

unmanageable T of numbers but on the

other hand it’s an humanitarian crisis

made by the same very large numbers but

most often when you compare numbers

across news newspapers official accounts

numbers really match if at all it also

becomes confusing a trace who sites

whose data and based on what definitions

and estimations the question of who’s a

refugee become opaque in data with

value-laden statements about who is

deserving and who is not deserving and

how we can clinically verify deserving

pneus when for instance we talk about

child refugees the difference between

age 18 and age 19 gained profound

importance calculation mistakes of

registration personal or unknown or

unprovable birth dates then become

evidence for undeserving pneus of the

refugee status can we ever then talk

about accurate refugee statistics to

talk about accuracy of refugee

statistics we need to understand the

interests in ames behind collecting them

there are multiple reasons for

collecting refugee statistics the most

common being the allocation of resources

in any refugee crisis knowing or at

least estimating the number of people

involved is one of the first steps in

determining responses to the situation

neighborhood countries might set up camp

humanitarian agencies might organize

emergency aids and international bodies

might evaluate the situation to come up

with appropriate responses and these all

require data they all require numbers

but then once these data are made they

are taken as evidence as for everything

and the allocation of refugees to

individual countries all humanitarian

aid are then made from those numbers

although the reasons for collecting

refugee statistics might seem

straightforward the actual task of who

should be counted as refugee is not very

obvious first we have the problem of

definitions who is a refugee while there

are international agreements most

notably the 1951 Geneva Convention which

gets frequently cited the disagreements

in the interpretation application and

limitations imposed on this convent

convention based on owned by individual

countries rarely get discussed as a

result we deal with multiplicity of

categories multiplicity of definitions

seconds statistics are gathered by

technocratic means and there are usually

many bodies involved which sometimes do

not agree on who should be included in

the definition this is why it is

possible to hear about three different

counts from the same countries different

institutions as well as three different

organizations working within the same

country and coming up with different

numbers refugee statistics are therefore

an arena of struggle and reflect

interests of the parties involved

putting a definition definitional issues

aside there are also multiple and

sometimes conflicting conflicting

interests in including and excluding or

in seeking to be included or excluded

from refugee statistics refugees for

instance might seek to be counted if

being counted involves assistance and

security but why the same logic they

might seek to defer being counted until

they reach a destination where they can

access security and and assistance

convention status or the refugee status

is a special status with an Internet

law and grants important rights and

privileges to those who receive it

however not all asylum applications are

successful and this might be a reason

for going missing in data in other cases

refugees might be exaggerating their

household sizes so that they gain as

much assistance as possible to help

those who they know that they will not

be able to get the same assistance the

possibility of doing DS is higher in

some context than others but the main

issue here is that people do shape their

existence in data if and whenever they

can host sites might also have their own

reasons for counting refugees and their

own techniques the arrival of refugees

without any resources and in need of

immediate assistance is a big challenge

for all countries especially the poor

neighboring countries and conflict zones

given that whatever assistance the

states will be getting will be in direct

proportion to the refugees they’re

hosting they might be inflating their

numbers but the same countries might

also be reducing the numbers they report

if they won’t if they would like to give

the impression that displaced people

that the situation is not long-term and

a displacement will not be for a long

time and the people are expected to go

back to their countries and

international and international

humanitarian agencies might have their

own reasons with refugee statistics

especially if they are funded by

donations and do not have stable sources

of income given that their success rates

are based on how they manage the numbers

they might increase or reduce their

numbers to prove that their day they are

funding has been successful or not own

has been successful and last but not

least one thing we don’t necessarily

hear about when we discuss refugee

statistics is the ethics of data

collection when we talk about official

statistics we expect that people’s data

are protected and they are treated

fairly and ethically throughout the data

collection we also expect that

enumerators and interviewers are

safe and they do not experience any harm

however in the context of refugee

security concerns are a really important

important so does the country’s allowing

independent enumerators to come in and

observe and count and make their

estimates it is not impossible to

imagine that in certain contexts when

the conflict is still going and the

places are not safe same persons might

be counted double and some people might

not be counted at all and it’s also

possible to imagine that there might be

a rough estimates about people’s

characteristics such as their age

educational attainment occupation or

country of origin seeing a number is not

the same as hearing someone’s story and

among all the uncertainties of refugees

statistics it is easy to get caught up

with making statistics more accurate but

forgetting the very conditions that make

refugee statistics so uncertain the

story of Island Corday the boy who

washed ashore in Turkey was a breaking

point in that regard or the survival

story of Noah from a sunk boat which

cost lives to 500 people from mare

numbers refugees became suddenly lives

with past and lost possible features it

is important to pay attention to what we

lose when we reduce the stories two

numbers we’re also rounded by data more

than ever before and we have access to

information more than we ever before but

we need to start talking about the

missing persons and the missing stories

in our data looking at refugee

statistics is just one way of doing that

it’s only when our worlds intersect with

the stories we do not say and listen on

a usual basis then we can imagine all

the possible worlds and perhaps much

better ones thank you

[Applause]

you [Music]

Please follow and like us: