Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Terrorist and the Couch: Reevaluating the Threat | Sebastian Torero | TEDxSciencesPoCampusMenton


had to build it up a little bit there

all right so behind me there are two

pictures one is of a terrorist

specifically a member of Isis and the

other of a couch now I want to pose to

you and to anyone who may be watching

this a question which of the subjects of

these two images is the more frightening

the terrorist I think we can all agree

that based on these two pictures alone

the terrorist is the more frightening

I’d be surprised if anyone answered the

couch but now I want to point something

out and this goes particularly to the

Americans in the audience I will admit

that the speech I want to give today and

the points that I want to make pertain

almost exclusively to Americans but I am

an American firstly I want to speak to

the people of my country

secondly we Americans are notorious for

not really caring about the rest of the

world we do though I promise well some

of us do but I digress

back to the pictures and the point that

I want to make see while the terrorist

is more frightening if you are an

American you are just as likely to be

killed by unstable furniture as you want

to be killed by a terrorist I doubt that

you’ll be looking at couches the same

or will you will you look at couches any

differently with the knowledge that they

are just as likely to kill you perhaps

even more likely to kill you than a

terrorist I would guess that you

wouldn’t you won’t fear couches you

won’t have police monitor furniture

stores you won’t call for a complete and

total shutdown on any furniture at all

entering the United States until we can

figure out what the heck is going on

with all these couches now terrorism is

a very real threat in the world we live

in today terrorist organizations are

responsible for the deaths of thousands

of people they commit heinous acts they

commit genocide they send children to

blow themselves up they enslave and

abuse women they destabilize regions and

spread fear across the globe in 2010

13,000 186 people were killed in

terrorist attacks and this was before

the emergence of perhaps better put the

resurgence of Isis and of those 13,000

186 people 15 were Americans 15 and of

those 15 Americans killed in terrorist

attacks in 2010 none were killed on

American soil

now those 15 lives were precious and

irreplaceable 15 lives that meant the

world to many other people but I would

argue it is time for Americans to take a

minute and seriously and soberly reflect

on how much we are threatened by

terrorism as Americans we value our

personal liberties we cherish our right

to live our lives the way we want to the

mayor of New York wants to ban big sodas

our president wants to make us get

health insurance well March petition

we’ll put on wigs and wave flags one of

the enduring symbols of the America

revolution is a snake poised and ready

to strike underneath that snake are the

immortal words don’t tread on me I like

this image it’s been appropriated by a

certain segment of the Republican Party

that I may not agree with and it’s a bit

file

and aggressive maybe but I love the

gumption it says we will live the way we

want to

we will live freely and we’ll be damned

if you try and tell us what to do or

trying to make us do something that we

don’t want to but when it comes to

terrorism we forget this we lose our

gumption we lose our courage nowadays

some of the loudest advocates for small

governments are more than willing to

allow the government to monitor its own

citizens and chip away at our civil

liberties as long as it’s in the name of

national security we allow Americans who

have not been charged with a crime to be

killed in drone strikes we say that the

Boston bomber an American citizen shall

have been given his Miranda rights

because that way the FBI could have

gotten more out of him and we allow

hateful rhetoric and unconstitutional

ideas to be treated as legitimate

security policy suggestions and it might

seem like common sense there is a global

threat the global threat of terrorism

and many terrorists speak openly of

their hatred for the United States of

their desire to attack the United States

shouldn’t we adjust our behavior I argue

that we should but we should adjust it

to reflect the reality of the threat not

our perceptions of it now think about

driving when you get behind the wheel of

a car to go to the supermarket or to

work you understand the risks we know

that driving is dangerous we allow

serious regulation of our driving

practices speed limits stop signs

traffic lights the list goes on in

Illinois before you get your license you

have to get a permit drive for 50 hours

in the car with an adult with a certain

amount of time dedicated to highway

driving at night time driving pass a

test and even then for the first year of

your license you can only drive with one

other person in the car that isn’t

family we allow common-sense regulation

of driving to make the practice safer

and still so many people die in car

license every year over 37,000 and

millions injured according to the

Association for safe international road

travel but now take a moment to think

when you get behind the wheel of a car

are you gripped with fear are you

terrified just waiting for this drive to

be over so you can get out of this

two-ton metal projectile that is

surrounded by other human beings

controlling their own two-ton metal

projectiles probably not and why not I

talked to someone about this about why

we are so terrified of terrorism but so

casual mentally about driving generally

speaking even when the latter is far

deadlier and this person’s are something

to me that I find quite interesting see

when you drive you feel some control and

you feel some trust you have confidence

and your abilities to do what you can to

avoid a risk and you believe that others

for the most part will do what they

can’t do but when it comes to terrorism

and the average citizen has very little

control and with the media reporting on

terror attacks from across the globe

daily with attacks in places like Paris

and Brussels and nice getting coverage

for months not to mention places like

Beirut and Istanbul with our leaders

constantly warning of the threat of

terrorism and the brutality of terrorist

organizations it’s no wonder we fear

psychologists will support this

terrorism is meant to target our

emotions and its unpredictability it

causes us to react emotionally

terrorists as the name would suggest are

very good at playing to people’s fears

but the fact is there are so many things

that threaten us so much more at home

issues we truly need to tackle

researchers at Columbia University found

that between 1986 and 2006 nearly one in

five deaths in America was related to

obesity research for diseases such as

Alzheimer’s and diabetes receives far

less than the trillions that have been

invested in the war on terror

yet these diseases killed thousands of

Americans annually and then there is the

violence in America itself between 2005

and 2015

71 Americans were killed in all

extremist attacks in Chicago in 2016

alone more than 760 people were murdered

the most since 1997 neighborhoods not

too far for I’m from

war zones for gang conflict where little

boys are executed in alleyways whose axe

whose brutality and cowardice can not be

fattened why is it no political sense

around issues like gang violence or

obesity or disease why are we not so

much more frightened of these issues

that threaten us so much more at home

and why our leaders not constantly

mentioning these issues under bates on

the floor of congress we should all be

asking ourselves these questions now the

biggest challenge to changing america’s

perception of terrorism and the way

confronts terrorism is that it’s not

politically savvy to say that for all

intents and purposes the threat of

terrorism harming Americans is

misunderstood and perhaps even

exaggerated now democracy is a messy a

beautiful thing one of the occasionally

messy aspects is in order to keep their

jobs politicians must win elections I

can’t fault the politician for making a

decision based on winning an election

they want to keep their jobs just like

everybody else sometimes this means

saying what’s popular without saying was

necessarily right but one of the

beautiful things about democracy and

this may be optimistic but in a

democracy we have the ability to shape

what is politically expedient as a

nation we are truly and deeply

frightened of terrorism and as a nation

we need to look deeply and objectively

and rationally at the threat it poses to

our daily lives we have shaped our

counterterrorism policy in reaction to

one of the darkest days in American

history as the dust was still clearing

at Ground Zero following the terror

attacks of September 11th we as a nation

declared war against those who had

attacked us and those associated with

our attackers now we made our decisions

in a timely manner which was perhaps

necessary but we also made them when we

were scared and hurt and angry and any

psychologist will tell you what’s best

to make major decisions once emotions

such as fear and pain and anger have

passed and now more than a decade since

9/11

with no comparable attacks on American

soil since it is time for us to confront

the true nature of the threat

we must urge our leaders to deal with

terrorism in a way that reflects the

reality of the issue as a threat to the

world but not particularly to Americans

at home we should not disregard our

thinking but we should re-evaluate our

priorities in such a way that we change

the national discourse it is our job to

reform our thinking so that our leaders

can do the same thank you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: