Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Story of Alabama’s Three Largest Newspapers | Amy Soverow | TEDxTuscaloosa


[Music]

I want to say that I realize we have

these papers technically still being

published so when I talk about them

being vanished I fully realize they’re

small copies floating around okay I’m

talking about the seven-day-a-week big

thick one okay that one because this is

what happened down the digital click

hole click click click

goodbye papers right I’m a class this is

my media life now this photo is a

project by Birmingham photographer

charity ponter where she photographs

artists dream selves and so if you go to

charity you can have yourself

photographed however you like and I

really like that idea of about dreams

but it got me to thinking about my media

life and what media was like in the in

the 18th and 19th century and that got

me to thinking of how different things

are today for example it was possible to

hold things with each hand because you

didn’t have a cell phone in one write

this image in charity is 28 this image

is actually bound for a book it’s not an

electronic form like you see it here

today but she’s her second book so I’m

very much working with artists who

believe in the print media you know 30

years ago media and communication would

have been very different if I had been

speaking with you we would just be here

in this room right I’d like you to try

to consider that possibility we would be

gathered as a group to listen to ideas

no cell phone no internet no 24/7 news

hole or anything just us sharing ideas

and you would be totally present here

with me and I would have the opportunity

to earn your attention but in the only

way we could communicate outside the

room be with phone or in that would be

like have a cord phone right or send a

note out and if you wanted photographs

of it I mean you’d have to wait weeks I

just want to bring that context of what

communication was for thousands of years

because it’s going to give you an idea

of what we lost in Birmingham mobile and

Huntsville when we lost the paper and

you know how print media is different

when you’re ready to to

except information and that’s why it

perform has the bedrock for Alabama’s

information streams telling the stories

of the vanishing newspapers and yes I

said that vanishing newspapers in

Alabama is very important its PAC

impacted our state and workforce in a

variety of ways that aren’t good you

know we’ve really decimated our media

industry here in my opinion and I find

this really interesting I walked by this

when I went to work with the news every

day I walked by it when I went out for

lunch I walked by it when I had meetings

and the next photograph you see of me on

four stories up from this okay

this building now has an insurance

company in it I’m going to be started

right so I’m sorry I’ve waited to talk

to this I’m from some friends that say

just get it out of your system Amy it’s

been five years I’m like come on my

paper back right so the other thing

we’re going to talk about is what’s

happened because it’s interesting it

doesn’t say freedom of speech of the

press as long as the advertising revenue

stream can support it or as long as the

the advance publication chooses to

publish it it’s technically one of our

rides correct so our story remains an

evolving one I believe we lost

irreplaceable community narratives

across the state past present and future

when the newspapers ceased to publish in

Birmingham Mobile in Huntsville in 2012

but we could also be the first state as

we all are in a digital era to figure

out how to get our print back how do we

get a fundamentally reliable print

narrative back into our community

because I believe print should be one of

my options for informing myself

currently we are swimming in a spaghetti

of information streams our opportunity

here in Alabama is to identify the

important ones and figure out how to

connect ourselves inform ourselves

become a community but also preserve our

narrative for future history keep in

mind that I’m a researcher I’m the geeky

people right and the first place we go

is the newspaper so five years ago we

stopped our narrative in Birmingham

Huntsville mobile for people like me so

that’s probably why get really worked up

about this anyway I have always loved

reading the newspaper this is my media

life seven years ago and this

we’re stories up from from the the slide

I just showed you first minute and we’re

launching the business section we didn’t

want a lot of wonderful things in 2010

in my opinion but we’re relaunching the

business section and I left Fox six for

one reason only I believed in the

newspaper I saw it in the research I

knew it informed us and I thought I’m

going to go work for the paper and my

friends at the station are like have you

lost your mind they’re dead trees and

I’m like I really think that they reach

more people than we do so it shocks me

that everyone that was in this building

all the by lines it’s going on I mean

it’s just vanished from downtown

Birmingham Alabama is the first state in

the nation where this has happened half

of our population half of our population

more than 2 million people do not have

access to a daily paper Birmingham

mobile and Huntsville is gone Tuscaloosa

News I can see in the pig right so I do

have access to the Tuscaloosa news in

Birmingham so in my opinion half the

population is totally uninformed four

days of the week in terms of Birmingham

Huntsville and ‘mobile and only slightly

inform the other three right so by

default and perhaps serendipity Alabama

is the first state in the nation to face

this digital to face this digital news

transition without the newspapers that

have formed our narratives for hundreds

of years I mean the Birmingham news have

been writing about Birmingham for 125

years when we cease to publish it

correct right

so um we’re going to talk about now is

how important the newspaper is to the

bedrock information stream in any market

and you know I have a lot of friends in

television and after all this happened

we would go out to lunch and they’re

like you know we can’t do the news

without the paper and I’m like I didn’t

stop publishing it right so I wanted to

talk a little bit about this the daily

newspapers in any market feed the

information stream okay because you’ve

got Barnett right covering County you’ve

got the special masters report being

read you’ve got this whole staff of

people and what happens is that the TV

and radio stations they will pick that

up newspaper people don’t like that

right but that’s what happens and then

it gets rebroadcast again and all it is

it does is improve the dissemination of

a story

so what happens when you take your daily

newspaper away okay

so what’s coming out of your information

streams now in Birmingham Oberlin

Huntsville and you know it feels like

that on sometimes in the tape I had to

do to do this I literally had to put my

husband’s death on Facebook for four

weeks to try to get the information out

so this is really what has been going on

in the market but further I want to talk

about exactly what’s happened these are

statistics I am a nerd okay these I felt

were really important when I look at the

Bureau of Labor and Statistics database

and if you want a party I can show you

how to do it right 2010 to 2014 Alabama

has lost editors the people that make

sure I’m right that it’s typed right

that it’s correct that we asked the

question 15 times national average we

have lost editors in this state at 15

times the national average Botox at

eight times the national average who

needs pictures PR people at four times

the national average and this is really

problematic all right

PR people let’s just focus on them for

just a second the average PR person has

a daily newspaper which we don’t right

now places about 10 stories a week then

we lost more than a thousand of them but

I’m going to keep it a thousand to keep

the math easy right so 10,000 stories a

week times a thousand PR people we lost

times 52 weeks means over half of the

500,000 plus stories or press releases

or story ideas that were never pitched

so to me these are the stories that were

never written or published in Alabama to

me it’s the business opening she knows

cityscene that kind of local business

they were just never published so one of

the days and you know I will say that I

have to journalism colleagues that

disagree with my conclusion about what

I’m about to say and I’ll point there

their reasons out but we used to

circulate a hundred and three thousand

Birmingham News’s on Saturday

traditionally home to high school sports

information unavailable elsewhere so I

look in Scarborough dad and I’m just

trying to see if this has changed

anything and we’ve lost a hundred

thousand high school football fans in

Burma

over the past four years I mean high

school football not possible now Tom

Ehrenburg who is studying here thinks he

thought it was security and my friend

Cynthia Gould who does fighting for you

at 3340 thought it was money too too

much you know to get into the games but

I’m telling you high school sports

should be fairly consistent you know and

and the print experience is just so

important historically it’s it’s for any

community it’s it’s defined the spatial

geographic political cultural

institutional anything that’s going on

in the community I happened to find a

part box of party glasses know the story

right but they were packed with this

Obama wins and I’m like wow Erik Velasco

right here he’s writing about the race

for the top court is too close to call

have I seen any of that information in

four years no and speaking of that in

2014 Alabama’s voter turnout was the

lowest it had been in twenty eight years

at forty one percent

scarborough research is showing that

people say they always what vote in

local elections that is also declining

and I can kind of on a sample of one and

I get that but no I don’t really know

what’s going on in the court races maybe

somebody else in Birmingham test anyway

I do I feel like I’m not informed

because I’m not getting this I’m not

getting the content they used to come

through professional journalists with a

time-tested vetting process and then it

showed up on my door my 24 year old son

says why can’t we get a paper delivered

and I’m like you know you know I’m

working on this speech right you’ve

watched me live this right you know I’m

no longer down in that building and what

was interesting to me too and those of

you ghetto geeks

check out the Pew Research 2016 study on

media fifty one percent of every

newspaper consumer says keep the digital

I want it exclusively in print let me

say that again half of people who

consume newspaper content just want the

print keep the digital okay so it’s been

really interesting and when we lost

everybody we lost and I was in the

building the day we all find out whether

or not we kept our jobs all that kind of

stuff it’s like the information

just kind of left and I think that

that’s just really important to

understand all the institutional people

hundreds of people that knew where

everything went so um this is just

really kind of interesting to me how

many of you have a special paper that

you say for yourself

anybody have newspaper clippings at home

okay what do you do now I mean I don’t

know you put the iPad iPad on the wall

yeah I’m just just not really sure what

happens so we’re going to do a little

bit of comp theory just a little enough

to be dangerous okay we had five senses

you know what they are we won’t go

through that and they’re usually used to

do things like Oh spoken word writing

dance song and drawing the sunset what

have you and there was a somebody I

studied in on which the schools named

Marshall McLuhan and he talked about hot

and cool media and he felt like like

that that really was a difference he

wrote in the 60s about this and so

what’s happened is a hot medium like

demand your central nervous system it

blinks it stimulates you know it’s

demanding your central nervous system

and you don’t really have a choice about

whether or not to participate you know

when Fox 6 News says stay right there

you know you’re like this we’re print

extends it through the alphabet and in

fact historians can trace the rise of

Western civilization to three things

right the wheel we got that paper

because stick carrying the stone tablets

around got heavy right and the printing

press and that these three things

pivotally changed the world okay but we

don’t have the printing press in Alabama

right now it’s silent at least at least

in my market it is so um you know print

is definitely a cool medium in the sense

of how it engages your body biologically

and I think that that’s important to

make a distinction as we move forward to

talk about our favorite media extension

today this is our favorite media

extension today our mobile phone I don’t

know if I’m in the minority or not but I

still use a landline to find the darn

thing right but I see this right and I’m

like really we used to have two hands so

I want to talk about this media

extension for a while and immediate

extension is anything that takes you out

of your present surroundings and put

to some place you’re not we’re not going

to have the conversation today about

whether it’s actual communication but I

think it’s important to understand then

that we love our phones in preparing for

this speech because I use mine basically

to do business and email some of the

things you can do with your cell phone

via app truly shocked me and I didn’t

want to know how that process would be

finished right fertility testing with

the one that came across and I’m like I

don’t even want to know right so now we

have we have everything we need to know

everything we want to see everyone we

want to talk to we don’t really care

whether it’s vetted as long as it makes

it feel good right and now we carry

everything around with us and I think

one of the things that gets lost in this

conversation is the editorial discussion

right public versus private property

whether or not we can use your photo I

mean none of that’s happening to our

information and it doesn’t happen on

these devices everything comes across as

looking the same but it’s not so I have

friends going I’m just looking

Washington Post in the New York Times

but realistically we need a better

strategy to be informed in that this is

our biggest problem I’ve never seen a

thousand-dollar bill I found it on the

internet I thought everyone would like

to see it too so we’ve all seen a

thousand dollar bill right um what’s

happened is that there used to be a wall

between advertising and journalism a

very very very very tough wall you know

we’re the journalists and we’re making

the money and and and never the two

shall meet unless this happens right

okay so now what’s happened is in the 60

billion dollars that is now digital

advertising that’s out there to be had

it’s not going to the local media

two-thirds of all digital advertising

goes to the top five companies Google

Yahoo Bing Microsoft and Facebook if the

top four if that’s only for add Twitter

so the hot the big deep revenue streams

that used to finance everything and keep

the journalists going and send the sales

the clients on the fancy trips all that

is gone now what okay so we need to

figure I think we need to figure out a

way to be informed again I’d like to

propose something

and what I like to call it is

collaborative journalism what do we do

now i I think that between all the

technology we have all the institutions

we have the fact that we still have the

wheel the paper and the printing press

that we ought to be able to figure out

something and I hope that we do at some

point because the content is out there I

had lunch with my friend Barnett right I

don’t know how many of you know Barnett

and he he was the one reading the

special masters report he wrote about

the bankruptcy and everything and he’s

now editor for the Birmingham Times and

he ran a story on human trafficking I

happen to see on Facebook one hundred

and fifty nine billion dollar human

trafficking industry runs through

downtown Birmingham on I 20 59 I saw it

on Facebook I go to lunch with him and

he says my website crashed what paper

rolled out I might Barnett those stories

should flow over right I had no idea so

it’s really important that to understand

that this content is still being

generated

Barnett’s publishing a paper there are

former news people publishing Alabama

news centers there are smaller papers

why can’t we reverse publish and put

something out there I mean I really

think it’s incumbent upon us to find a

way to get our narrative back now I

don’t know if anybody else has the same

passion for it but I certainly do and

you know it’s really kind of interesting

my two passions have now intersected

glass and I do run a glass studio and I

am making a living doing it

yay and media because everything is now

a glass screen we are all glass artists

we’re all communicating on a glass

screen 24/7 and I think it raises the

question it now that we all can

participate

now that we’re all global content

generators on the web exactly what do we

put out there first of all and secondly

how do we connect to ourselves in each

other in a meaningful way and thirdly

how do we preserve it for future

generations because print is cool media thank you

Please follow and like us: