Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Shareholder Illusion Is Over: Enter Triple Bottom Line | Mike Shesterkin | TEDxLivoniaCCLibrary


so this story began for me about 10
years ago I was a senior level manager
of a large multinational corporation and
I was working on developing sustainable
business strategies and we were charged
with how to come up with it and in the
term at the time was even more of an
abstraction than it is today
few of us understood what the word meant
and even fewer of us were building
business strategies around it and the
interesting thing is it’s not as if the
word was new or is new back in the late
60s the Club of Rome had given us the
idea of sustainability as a concept and
in 1987 a UN Commission gave the term
the definition that goes something like
this sustainability is the ability to
meet the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future
generations to meet their needs now
armed with that definition I work for a
company that lived by the bottom line
the single bottom line right and so that
my bosses would come up to me and they
would ask me on a regular basis you know
Mike how are we gonna make money on
sustainability and I pondered this
question and thought about it and one
night as I’m sure all of us do in this
age I was searching the web for answers
and I came across a an initiative out of
Georgetown University a Jesuit
initiative called the Woodstock business
conference and as I read the material on
this page I had an epiphany an insight
opened up for me
and I realized that business isn’t just
about profits in fact it’s about so much
more
yet if we don’t take the time to think
about it and consider this stuff we will
not understand that now if you buy into
the notion that we need to become
sustainable by the definition if we buy
into the notion that business is more
than simply profitability then we might
ask ourselves a few questions such as
why don’t we just export our way of life
to the rest of the planet so before we
even begin to answer that question
consider this at 300 million people in
this country we comprise four percent of
the world’s population yet we consume
more than 25 percent
the world’s output of energy so science
says which is a pesky place where
alternate effects don’t exist that we’re
not capable of doing this right that’s
kind of what the science says so if you
buy into the science and if you buy into
the notion that business is more than
simply profitability and if you buy into
the notion that we need to become
sustainable then what are we to do well
I would suggest that what we need in
this age is a new philosophy for
business and some of you out there might
say well you know what Mike I get it but
philosophy and business don’t go
together
I disagree each one of us gets out of
bed every day with a worldview or a
philosophy about life and the truths in
the in the fact is this is true of
corporations as well and business and
generally how we look at the world so
what I would suggest is what we have is
an opportunity to borrow on the
tremendous wealth of philosophical
traditions that emerge from our culture
Western philosophical traditions and
that we need to look at that and borrow
on the rich heritage that we have there
the very heritage that gives us the
country in which we live in the way we
look at the world as Americans
so what let’s just do that for a bit
let’s travel back 2500 years back to the
time of Socrates now Socrates was an
interesting sort of guy he would walk
around the streets of Athens and he
would come up to people and ask them why
do you think the way that you do what
does the term justice mean to you and he
was trying to get people to think a bit
more differently about how they looked
at the world and of course Socrates
taught Plato who in turn taught
Aristotle and here and we have the
tripartite of Western philosophical
traditions now this etching here is a
depiction of one of the stories that
Plato gives us and it’s called the
allegory of the cave and in this picture
or in the story
prisoners are inside a cave and they’re
chained in such a way that the only
thing that they can see are shadows on a
wall the only thing that they can hear
our aleut are echoes and whispers in
fact their entire lives are illusions
and Plato suggested that many of us go
through life in the same way we live in
sort of an illusion of what reality is
I would submit to you that our illusion
in this age is framed by incessant
advertising advertising that tells us
that the way to happiness is through
consumption that if we have more stuff
we will be happier that we find the
bigger car we’ll be happier if we
remodel a house we’ll be happier and so
forth and so on this is an illusion now
let’s fast forward to the 18th century
and the philosopher William friedrich
hegel hegel said that the way we look at
the world is something that goes like
this we all sort of share a dominant
view of the world he called that the
thesis then he said that there are small
groups of us who share a lesson dominant
view an emergent view of the world he
called that the antithesis he said that
its were always an attention between the
thesis and the antithesis and what
emerges from that is the synthesis
eventually the synthesis becomes the
dominant way of seeing the world and we
progress throughout human history
advancing hopefully to a greater level
of civilization our thesis the way we
see the world in this country primarily
especially what it has to do with
business and markets and how those sorts
of things function is given to us by
this gentleman here he’s an
eighteenth-century fellow
his name is Adam Smith what Adam Smith
looked at his front door he saw a world
controlled primarily by the crown in
fact if you were born at the lower rungs
of the socio-economic ladder your
chances of going up were about as close
to zero as one could imagine and what he
said was we need to liberalize things we
need to open things up a little bit more
and allow people to move up the
socio-economic ladder if you think about
it back then if you wanted to start a
business back in Smith’s day you would
have to petition the crown to charter
your business businesses were chartered
by the crown that was the only way you
could start it so he gives us the way we
see the world today which is the free
market primarily obviously others
contributed to that but now if you
fast-forward toward the end of the 19th
century and you imagine yourself in
London England and you’re walking around
the streets of London and the coal
mining industry and you notice that
there are
children working in the coal mines and
maybe you’ll run into characters like
Dickens Ebenezer Scrooge not very nice
people right and then you might begin to
understand what so enraged Karl Marx
about unbridled capitalism the trouble
is in our age though if you long for the
good old days what you’ll do is you’ll
quote Smith ad infinitum you’ll talk
about how the visible hand of the market
is going to somehow lift up humanity and
make the world a much better place the
trouble with this is is that actually a
co-opted reading of Smith’s works Smith
wrote two very important books once
called Moral Sentiments and the other is
called Wealth of Nations now if you’re a
one-percenter and you think that all of
existence is driven by profitability you
skip Moral Sentiments and jump right to
the wealth of nations in ergo we have
what is called neoliberalism and the
narrative for neoliberalism goes
something like this government is wrong
government is the problem
regulations are the problem we need to
get regular government out of business
and oh by the way the only people in
government ought to be people who run
businesses because government ought to
be run by a business that’s the
narrative now I’m not sure about you but
when I look at thoughtful government and
thoughtful policy I am very thankful for
it especially when it comes to things
like child labor laws now emergent from
our infatuation with capitalism are a
couple of paradigms I’d like to talk
about right now one is called
consumerism and the other is called the
shareholder value model a consumerism is
a way of thinking is framed primarily by
a couple of principles when it emerged
back in nearly part of the 20th century
they they are that earth has an
unlimited abundance of materials from
which we can make stuff and the second
is a little Limerick
the solution to pollution is dilution if
you remember I was taught that years and
years ago and that is obviously many of
us are laughing and that’s not true
but let’s break down consumers I’m going
to look at it a little bit more
carefully consumerism begins well let me
give you the
finition of it first before we go here
so consumerism is defined as the notion
that ever-increasing consumption of
goods leads to a healthy and vibrant
economy ever-increasing consumption
that’s the definition so begin something
like this we extract materials and that
sort of thing from the earth chemistry’s
steel model and on that steel but the
minerals and so forth that we produce
stuff with which takes a lot of energy
in the form of fossilized fuels highly
concentrated energy in the form of
fossilized fuels the next step is the
refinement and the production of the
stuff that we use so we take the
minerals and raw materials and turn them
into the product the building blocks of
what we’re going to produce such as
automobiles and TV sets and
refrigerators and so forth and then
because the system demands
ever-increasing consumption we
essentially get rid of what we have to
make room for the new and improved
version of essentially the same thing
and so this is what we wind up with we
throw it away at the end we call this as
a very simple linear model take make
waste now the problem with it is it is
that it’s predicated on three
assumptions that are patently incorrect
the first of which is that there is a
limitless supply of materials in the
Earth’s crust the second of which is
that there is a limitless supply of
highly concentrated energy in the form
of fossil fuels and finally and the most
importantly that earth can absorb all
the garbage that we put into it all
three of those are patently incorrect
now we’ll move on to the next one this
is the Chicago School of Economics and
it’s favorite Sun Minister Milton
Friedman and he gives us the notion that
the purpose of business is to maximize
shareholder value he wrote an article in
The New York Times in 1970 where he put
forth this idea and it has taken nearly
50 years but finally educators and
business leaders are waking up to the
notion that this is one of the most
bankrupt ideas ever to hit humanity in
fact in the latter part of the 1970s
while he was the president at Quaker
Oats Kevin Mason is quoted as saying
maximizing shareholder value is no more
the purpose of business than eating is
the purpose of life
one would hope that life is a little bit
more challenging and broader than simply
eating of course the problem with this
idea is that it’s this greed make good
idea is that it is caused untold human
suffering it has led to the
justification for globalization and
literally the frenetic acceleration of
consumerism the problem of course with
these two paradigms is that they are
simple linear paradigms that the purport
to explain things as complex as human
nature itself and nature and of course
that they don’t work very well for that
there isn’t any time right now to get
into all of the peer-reviewed and
validated science that is telling us
overwhelmingly that our behavior is
having a negative and significant
negative impact on the environment and
it’s not just climate change it’s
everything that we do from
industrialized agriculture to the
pharmaceuticals we flush down the toilet
daily everything that we’re doing under
the consumerist model is having a
negative effect on the environment in
fact in August of last year geologists
took another significant step toward
calling this age the Anthropocene which
means that if geologists are around
millennia from now to study the
fossilized record of this age they will
see that we had a significant impact on
it and to me that is one of the most
telling examples of how significant our
behavior is on the environment and what
it’s doing to it you know just to put
this into context and give it some scale
back in the latter part of the 60s in
the early 70s when we saw the first
images of Earth from space from the
Apollo missions we began to realize just
how remote we are in space and how
fragile this system is what we see from
space is an eleven point three mile
thick veil that covers earth the akin to
of wrapping a basketball with cellophane
and within that thin veil all of life is
contained
it took 4.5 billion years for this to
emerge and for us as modern human beings
we’ve only been here for about a hundred
and twenty thousand years
and in the last roughly 300 years we’ve
begun to threaten the stability of this
system because of our behavior at the
core of our behavior is the hubris the
likes of which have never before been
seen and the way we see things we look
past the complex mystery of life we see
earth not so much as an interrelated web
of life and existence infused with
spirit but rather as a machine the
purpose of which is to generate money
our way of seeing the world denies what
Plato taught us denies what he said was
most important and that is it’s not the
material it isn’t the sense8 it isn’t
the commodification of all things but
rather the intangibles
that’s what Plato taught us are the most
important there is so much more to life
than simply what is before us in the
material so we’ve heard about a lot of
this today where we talk about these
things the intangibles and their value
what I would suggest to you today is
that emerging before us in this age is
the Hague lien dialectic the antithesis
struggling to find its voice is a new
way of seeing reality and a new way of
proposing business a way of proposing
business that holds up as important
Plato’s intangibles and sets them as
guiding principles of how business ought
to be run in his book spirit of
leadership the Jesuit father Robert
Spitzer points out that the intangibles
of spirit vision and Trust are worthy of
our investment organizations that invest
in spirit vision and Trust are capable
much greater depths of creativity and
adaptability the very things that we
need to survive in the ages to come when
we take spirit vision and Trust and
translate that into a tangible way of
seeing things we turn ourselves to John
elkington’s book cannibals with Forks
where he proposes the triple bottom line
of people planet and profit this gets
passed
looking at the business as being only
there to generate profits for ownership
what Elkington says is that businesses
need to focus on also creating planet
value by lowering their negative
environmental impacts they need to
invest in the dignity of the human
person within the organization and
within the communities in which they
operate and thereby create social
capital this is the triple bottom line
and we began with talking about how it
is such an abstraction that this idea of
sustainability this idea of looking at
business beyond simply profitability
what I want to talk about now is where
it meets the road and I want to hold up
as a great example cascade engineering
which was founded by Fred Keller they’re
on the west side of the state and Grand
Rapids it is a wonderful example of how
the triple bottom line is manifest in a
business cascade engineering is a more
than 300 million dollar a year supplier
in the automobile business and when when
Fred Keller started and founded the
business back in the early part of the
70s about the same time that Milton
Friedman was writing his article he knew
then that business was much more than
simply generating profits for ownership
and what cascade engineering has done to
create sustainability with triple
bottom-line value is is an incredible
thing so I will leave you with that I
will show you that we’ve given you a
tangible example we go study this that
the businesses that look beyond simply
the single bottom-line of profitability
and work on developing and investing in
spirit vision and Trust are the sort of
businesses that realize that creating
value goes beyond profitability it goes
into the triple bottom line and the very
good example of that is cascade
engineering out on the west side of
state and Grand Rapids so thank you so
much for your time
[Applause]
you
Please follow and like us: