Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Science of Adversity, Resilience, and Transformation | Audrey Stillerman | TEDxUofIChicago


so tonight we’re going to talk about
adversity and health and well-being
across the lifespan about the biology of
personal social and historical
experience as well as building
resilience healing and hope I’d like to
ask you to hold a question in your mind
as we begin I want to ask you what the
following real people have in common a
cancer patient a child with school
problems a heroin addict a politician
who can’t stop lying a pro football
player who beats his child and a Native
American stay tuned
else was coming about 20 years ago the
adverse childhood experiences or a study
was published in the American Journal of
Preventive Medicine this study was the
largest and many would argue most
important public health study of its
kind it was co-authored by dr. Vincent
felitti
of Kaiser Permanente and dr. Robert anda
an epidemiologist from the Center for
Disease Control this study looked at the
relationship between childhood health
and adult illness dr. fouladian anda
surveyed more than 17,000 patients most
of whom were white or Hispanic middle
class middle-aged with some college
education all had health insurance the
doctors and their research team
developed a questionnaire looking at ten
categories of experience of abuse
neglect and household distress as well
as physical emotional and social health
and well-being in adulthood for each
adverse experience that the participants
had they received a point of one and the
sum of all their experiences was there a
score what the research team found was
stunning what they learned was that aces
are common 64% of participants had had
at least one adverse experience 27%
three or more and 5% heads six or more
they learned that aces are interrelated
so every participant who had one ace was
87% likely to have another and they
learned that accumulation of aces
matters that there’s a graded
relationship between experiences of
adversity and our risk for disease
disability social and work problems and
even death chillingly those participants
who had experienced six or more aces had
a life expectancy twenty years shorter
than those participants who had an ace
score of zero looking at these
statistics we know that every day
everywhere doctors will see at least one
patient who’s had experiences of
childhood diversity about five years
later dr. Foley DeAnda and colleagues
revisited the ACE study to answer the
question are aces merely associated with
poor outcomes or do they cause them they
use nine public health principals to
evaluate the ACE study and what they
found is that they study met all nine
principles for inferring cause so we can
say with confidence that aces in fact
are the root cause of our most pressing
health and social problems from cancer
to HIV to IV drug use to domestic
violence and even death we also know now
that we can quantify the contribution of
aces to many of our pressing health and
social problems so aces are the most
powerful known determinants of health so
you might say this is really interesting
but what does a study of a bunch of
white people in California have to do
with us they study in fact was
replicated in diverse populations with
similar results in 32 states in 31
countries around
world here in Illinois some public
health surveys reveal that 32 percent of
children 17 years or younger and 60% of
adults have experienced at least one
experience of childhood adversity there
was a longitudinal study here in Chicago
that looked at lower income and minority
youth over the course of about 20 years
and this population too had about a 64%
prevalence of at least one experience of
aces and those participants who had
experienced four or more aces were much
less likely to graduate from high school
had higher risk of depression and more
likelihood of addiction they were more
likely to have a juvenile arrest or
felony charge and they were less likely
to hold skilled jobs or have advanced
degrees so we know that aces can change
our bodies but what is the pathway and
with that information how will that
change our approach to solving problems
in creating health I’m a little daunted
because we have a neuroscientist in the
audience so bear with me around the same
time that the ACE study was collecting
its data there was an explosion of
sophisticated neuroscience research so
we’re going to have a little crash
course here about neuro development and
attachment so that we can better
understand the relationship between
experience and health and I’m going to
pull out my handy model of the brain and
for the sake of argument we’re going to
imagine that the brain is composed of
three parts the brain stem or the
survival brain the midbrain or the
emotional brain in the cortex or the
thinking brain our brain is responsive
to experience it develops from the
bottom up from the survival brain to the
thinking brain starting prenatally and
going till about age 24 there are
critical and sensitive
periods of development so for example if
we’re stuck in a room with no light
during the critical period of
development of vision we’ll be blind
attachment is a special emotional
relationship which involves the exchange
of care comfort and pleasure our
attachment styles are established in our
early infant caregiver relationships
attunement is our ability to understand
and perceive the needs and wants of
others childhood adversity and trauma
can cause toxic stress disrupt
attachment and derail the optimal
development of the brain it’s signaling
to the autonomic nervous system and
other body systems and our overall
physiology attachment and attunement
help to protect us from the consequences
of adversity and from distress stress
and trauma so you’re probably wondering
what do genes have to do with all this
stuff
our country has spent lots and lots of
money looking at genetics well it turns
out that genes are in a dynamic
relationship with the environment as
well and genes have markers called
epigenome Dean’s on or off making us
healthier or sicker and these genetic
modifications can be passed from
generation to generation to prepare us
for the environment that will face
recent research has revealed that
children of Holocaust survivors have in
fact inherited genetic modifications
that can be traced back to their parents
response to stress so we know that
adverse childhood experiences change the
body but what about poverty in
discrimination and violence in 2014 dr.
Roy Wade and colleagues in Philadelphia
developed an expanded ace questionnaire
that included many indicators of adverse
community environments like violence and
community disruption economic hard
ship and problems and conflict with
systems like schools child welfare in
the juvenile justice system and guess
what those things are really important
too in fact those adverse community
environments cause the same kind of
changes in our brain and our physiology
and behavior as adverse childhood
experiences you won’t see it here but
there are things lurking in the soil as
well and those things are experiences of
historical trauma like slavery cultural
genocide and Holocaust and they have an
impact on our brains and physiology
across the generations as well so in
summary our genes epi genes and
experiences their timing severity and
chronicity all shaped the growth and
development of our brain and can lead to
adaptations that are hardwired into our
biology that caused chronic disease
mental health problems work and social
issues
addictions crime poverty even disparity
and these things can be passed from one
generation to the next so we know that
there’s great cost in human suffering
but what does this cost us in dollars
and cents in 2014 it was estimated that
each first-time episode of childhood
maltreatment would cost about 1.8
million dollars over the course of that
victims lifetime and about 6 trillion
dollars in total for all those victims
imagine how much good we could do with
that money so let’s take a deep breath
because that’s heavy stuff and we’re
going to talk about some good news
we humans have some really cool things
going for us our brains are plastic they
actually respond to our experiences in
our environment both in terms of
function and structure of course are
over the course of our whole lives we
also have the capacity for resilience
which is the ability to bounce back and
it turns out that secure attachments and
social support help us build revolt
millions we need to use these ideas and
embed them in strategies throughout our
human ecology from the individual level
all the way through the structural
levels across time we can do things like
raise awareness build individual
knowledge and skills train our service
providers change organizational practice
and even influence policy legislation
and high-impact conversations where do
we start well we start at the beginning
we give our parents and families the
tools and resources that they need to be
their best selves so that they can
foster secure and attached relationships
with their children to build healthy
bodies and brains it’s really that
simple we have to ensure the basics for
everybody we need to make a commitment
to social welfare so that all of us have
a physiologic needs met our needs for
safety and security and for love and
belonging so that we can find our true
purpose and fulfill our potential
interestingly with all this scientific
evidence not much of it has made its way
into curricula of medical schools
colleges of education nursing Social
Work law or business many of these
schools are stuck in a paradigm that
focuses on high-stakes testing zero
tolerance and a pill for every ye’ll but
we can develop a new paradigm based on
science history and justice that
includes time-honored practices of
cultivating awareness through meditation
moving our bodies using the arts for
creative self-expression and fostering
healing relationships where we don’t ask
what’s wrong with you what we ask what
happened to you where we listen with
acceptance and where we respond with
compassion we can use trauma specific
treatments like neurofeedback
EMDR in eco therapy which by the way is
going outside all of these activities
and treatments help to settle down our
autonomic nervous systems heal our
brains and foster flourishing I’d like
to give you a few specific examples
there are many many many around the
country and around the world here at UIC
there’s been a pop up pantry to serve
students with food insecurity so that
they can be well fed and ready to learn
on the West Campus at UIC in the
emergency room there’s a better health
through housing program which has housed
25 chronically homeless patients the
patients are thrilled and the hospital
is saving $2,000 per patient per month
in Walla Walla Washington an alternative
school has adapted trauma sensitive
practices provided many opportunities
for creative expression and focused on
healing relationships they have
decreased their suspension rate by 85
percent they’ve improved grades and
attendance and their graduation rate is
up from 18% to 78% and finally in
Washington State
the legislature has made a commitment to
parents who have been arrested to keep
them from going to prison so that the
state won’t be adding another a stool
knurl families the promising results
from this program are that only 6% of
ex-offenders have returned to prison and
only 8% have committed another felony so
if aces could be eliminated we could
increase our work productivity by about
61 percent decrease suicide and life
satisfaction by about 67 percent and
decrease anxiety by about 56 percent and
frankly that’s just the beginning
so in summary our experiences current
and historical individual and collective
shape who we are because they affect our
biology and they chart the course of our
growth and development humane social
conditions and and secure attached
relationships help build resilience and
allow us to weather life’s storms we
have the knowledge and the power to
prevent mitigate and treat the cause of
our deepest suffering and we have the
ability to allow all of us to find our
true purpose and fulfill our potential
our lives and the lives of the next
seven generations depend on our putting
this knowledge and skills into practice
transformations possible transformations
imperative I’d like to join ask you to
join me in acting now let’s just do this
thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: