Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Science of Adversity and the Case for Systemic Empathy | Stan Sonu | TEDxChicago


I want to tell you a story about a man I
should have never met Michael had high
blood pressure diabetes arthritis and
chronic fatigue
his body was weathering the kinds of
things we typically don’t see until
middle-age he said to me doc I don’t
know why I have all these problems but
man I’ve been through some stuff here’s
the thing
Michael wasn’t old he was only 26 he
also had this crippling anxiety bipolar
disorder he smoked cigarettes and was
battling an addiction to heroin and
prescription drugs and what was
bothering him the most was his anxiety
it had recently worsened and he wasn’t
sleeping well he kept having panic
attacks as he told me his problems I
couldn’t help but think to myself it’s
no surprise that your anxiety has
worsened lately because I was seeing him
in a clinic a clinic that was located in
a jail
Michael was locked up awaiting trial
housed in a large room with 30 other men
with problems similar to himself and in
that moment I wondered how do we get
here how does a 26 year old man have all
of these medical problems and as a
physician where do I even start
see I work at a public safety net
Hospital a place that has provided care
for some of the most disadvantaged and
underserved communities in Chicago and
as an internist and pediatrician I
provide care for people across the
entire life course and whether I’m
seeing patients in a jail or on the west
side or in a school Health Center one
thing I learned too very quickly is that
our health is so much more than labs on
a page or medication list or what’s
written in a patient’s chart lived
experiences matter and inform health
narratives matter but during our medical
training I wasn’t always taught this you
know some days it felt like I was
learning how to do disease damage
control more than anything else and over
time I started to accept well this must
just be how medicine is but in my last
year of training just three months
before I was gonna graduate I attended
what became the most important lecture
of
all my training something that
profoundly changed the way I view health
all together and the topic was on
adverse childhood experiences how
decades of research from public health
and neuroscience and psychology have all
found that significant childhood
adversity is linked with several
negative health outcomes and how the way
that’s happening is through how
adversity and trauma affects our brain
now the idea I want to share with you
all today is how for me understanding
this science and then seeing it at play
in the lives of my patients gives me
hope for an idea I call systemic empathy
systemic empathy well keep this term in
mind because I want to build my case for
it let me start by giving you the Cliff
Notes version on what this whole thing
on childhood adversity is all about you
see in the late 90s a landmark public
health study done by the CDC in Kaiser
Permanente surveyed over 17,000 adults
about their history of adverse childhood
experiences or aces for short and these
aces spanned ten different categories
and included questions like what you
ever sexually abused was anybody in your
household ever incarcerated or your
parents ever so drunk or too high to
take care of you and what they found was
the higher number of aces a person had
the higher the risk was for some of the
most common health and behavioral
problems in the u.s. things like
substance abuse mental illness and even
chronic disease so if a person had four
of any of these aces they would be at a
seven times greater risk of having
alcoholism compared to someone with none
of these for lung disease that’s four
times and for heart disease and cancer
over two times and with six or more aces
the average life expectancy goes from 80
years down to 60 now what’s even more
stunning about this research is the part
where the brain comes in because this is
the primary organ that’s targeted by
aces and leads to the health risk
behaviors and chronic diseases that
we’re talking about and to put it simply
aces cause toxic stress the kind of
stress that is so severe that it can
disrupt normal brain development
function and even brain growth toxic
stress causes overactivity of the part
of the brain that
regulates fight-or-flight but it
disrupts and stunts the development of
the part of the brain that’s important
for planning reasoning and controlling
impulsivity and this has real-life
implications for what’s happening in our
city
the crime lab at University of Chicago
has found that when it comes to gun
violence in Chicago there is a troubling
pattern and it tends to involve young
men there’s a disagreement there’s an
impulsive action with a gun around
leading to a dead body again impulsivity
we care about this because it’s
regulated by a part of the brain that is
significantly affected by toxic stress
which brings us back to Michael 26 years
old in jail and with an astounding
burden of disease
Michael had at least six aces if not
more both of his parents battled
addictions and had mental illness his
childhood was a story full of abuse and
neglect and drugs were his way of
escaping from it all and this wasn’t the
first time he had been in jail
in fact just three months before we met
he had just been released after spending
about a year in jail and during this
prior stint he embraced being sober and
was getting help for his anxiety and
bipolar disorder but when he was
released he showed up at his doctor’s
office and was turned away because his
insurance had expired while in jail with
no medications and his anxiety quickly
escalating Michael bought pills off the
street
quickly spiraled out of control and
within weeks he was arrested again I
couldn’t help but think our health care
system failed him on multiple levels not
just on the obvious problem of Michael
not having access to health services but
going even farther back to my own
training and medicine because if it
wasn’t for that one lecture I attended I
never would have understood in this way
I mean he would have been just another
guy who lacked the will and the
self-control to stay clean so I believe
that the science of adversity in trauma
drives us toward something we really
need in our human service institutions
what I call systemic empathy because
what the data show is that narratives do
matter that we can’t just look at people
as a collection of the
problems and diseases but in order to
help in the heal we have to understand
where a person is coming from and the
first critical pivot of being
trauma-informed is when we interact with
a patient or colleague or employee we
stop saying to them what’s wrong with
you but instead we ask what to happen to
you systemic empathy builds on this
framework and is a call to normalize
this mind and heart pivot of not what’s
wrong with you but what’s happened to
you and it’s a call to scale it up to
meaningful cross-sector interventions so
what does that mean
what would it look like in our
institutions what would it look like for
Michael
well what if we took our best treatment
for addiction in the community a program
that includes counseling and group
sessions and medications to help control
cravings and we simply did this program
in the jail and what if if the person
was going to be released we made sure
that their barriers to continuing
treatment and therapy in the community
were addressed well I’m glad to say that
this isn’t a hypothetical example but a
real program that was recently started
at the jail and the reason it happened I
believe is because a group of social
workers and administrators and
physicians they got together and they
looked at this problem of addiction
through a lens of systemic empathy it’s
not rocket science it’s simply changing
our frame of reference away from
pragmatism or profits and back on the
person but here’s the thing right now
this kind of example is the exception
and our patients cannot afford four
pieces of the health system to take
action until our entire Health and Human
Services system is aware and understands
the impact of trauma all we’ll have to
talk about are these one-off examples
systemic empathy requires systemic
change and so I submit to you this if we
ascribe to this idea of systemic empathy
the first critical and tangible thing we
can do is to teach the science of
adversity and trauma as core material in
our human service institutions if we can
have the courage to build an ethos of
systemic empathy we need to be willing
to lay the foundation for it as well
and that means that every future human
service worker from medical students
nursing students to future police
officers educators and litigators and
politicians are all taught in the
science of trauma a long time ago
Hippocrates he said it’s far more
important to know the person who has a
disease than to know what sort of
disease the person has of course he
didn’t have any of the data that we have
today but he was on to something
if the systems have been working from
Michael I never would have met him but I
did and I’m glad I got to know him
instead of just his problems thank you
Please follow and like us: