Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Rise and Fall of Animal Trials | Ryan Wittingslow | TEDxUniversityofGroningen


in mid-2014 a nature photographer by the
name of David Slater licensed these
images to the cater news agency
unfortunately for him anyway it was
revealed that he did not in fact take
the photograph himself what it actually
happened was that this handsome 8th
behind us they crested black macaque I
can’t recall the name had seized the
remote camera trigger and taken a photo
of herself twice
these are intact monkey selfies so on
those grounds these photographs were
uploaded to Wikimedia Commons David
Slater was very upset but he sued
Wikimedia Commons it started a spate of
countless suits between Wikimedia
Commons
Peter any number of other organizations
that is currently working its way toward
the courts right now so what’s
interesting about this I think is that
it the reason why the photograph was
uploaded as Wikimedia Commons was
because the monkey took the photograph
meaning that David Slater himself was
not this is not his intellectual
property the labor that created the
photograph was conducted by the monkey
not by the photographer and this is
really interesting as sort of legal
ramifications right so what kind of
thing is an animal that it can hold
intellectual property what kind of
animal can possess intellectual property
I think these sorts of questions really
are braids nicely against sort of the
way we think about not only our
relationships with animals but also what
it means to be a human
what what what entitles one to
personhood and both in a social but also
in a legal sense so that in mind so this
kind of question right whether or not
something like a monkey this crested
black macaque can hold
whether or not it can hold intellectual
property it probably seems very
progressive it seems maybe enlightened
it seems you know something comes out of
our own or an age in which we’re
interested in things like vegetarianism
and we’re disavowing ourselves or things
like industrial farming and we don’t
like fur anymore and all these kinds of
things but my argument is that instead
of being a matter of this would have
been lightened progressive thing it’s
more a a reconfiguration of a kind of
latent medieval ISM it’s a disavowal of
an enlightened my dear of animals as
machines and it returns to a medieval
idea that animals have minds and motives
and are capable of moral judgments in
very much the same way we are and that’s
one of the things we’re going to talk
about and unpack today so the idea of
the legal rights of animals has actually
quite a long and interesting history in
the West and legal tradition I mean
Western the broader sense of being
Europe the Near East and northern Africa
I don’t have time unfortunately to
create some kind of universal thesis as
to why this is the case but I am
interested in this in a very precise
moment in time and precise by precise
it’s only two centuries but precise
enough between the 15th and the 17th
centuries this is at the the height of
the Renaissance now at this point at the
height of the Renaissance there is this
weird spike in animal trials these
criminal trials of animals where animals
are treated as if they’re legal persons
and they’re tried as such if you’re
given what we know about the Renaissance
that seems kind of weird and I’ll I’ll
go through that right now so this year
is a is is a I suppose it’s a detail
from the ambassador’s by Holbein the
younger and it shows two very handsome
the third men lounging luxuriating if
you like in front of a bunch of
scientific instruments so I mean these
two men are a renaissance science par
excellence
when we think about the Renaissance we
are talking about you know no doubt you
remember from school the Renaissance is
is a period where there’s a sort of
massive revolutions in science and
philosophy in politics in a whole bunch
of other things so what happens in this
period and what inspires paintings like
this is an event called the Scientific
Revolution and the Scientific Revolution
is this sort of first attempt to try and
do science without the meddling of
Aristotle it’s the first time that
scientists can function and they look at
raw data and try to extract findings
based upon that data so that alone is
weird
and it seems like though that instead
there’s this view that the animals
they’re not people right there’s no sort
of there’s a little humans for these for
these medieval jurists there’s no sort
of ontological confusion about whether
or not these this pig is a person I mean
they’re not don’t think it’s a human
being but nonetheless in some sense it’s
a legal person not a human but a legal
person it’s really really weird so this
is this is obviously the time before
such things like rights exist like we
talk now about human rights or about
legal rights and this kind of you know
free easy way but the idea that what we
think of now is rights there I mean they
kind of a recent legal philosophical
invention right so I don’t want to go
out and saying that these animals had
human rights
who is that’s clearly crazy but what I’m
one of arguing is that animals in this
period were entitled to certain judicial
protections I guess under the law that
you would absolutely not expect okay so
you’re with me I’ll give you a couple of
examples this is an easy good this is
really funny I promise so in 1750 a
Frenchman by the name of Jacques Farrell
was arrested for buggering a donkey he
had been captured episode of key but
he’d been he’d been caught by the
villagers in delicto flagrante as they
say
and they’re both the donkey and Jacques
fat all had been arrested both arrested
with they’re both the rest of the
Chrysler’s charge of sodomy right of
sort of unnatural sex acts and this is
violated both the the laws of both God
and country
both the donkey in the man were arrested
and and and japheth all had his trial
first and it was a summary trial he was
found clearly guilty and he was hanged
by the neck until he was dead
bugger the donkey though was a good
donkey and so what happened was the
local prior so the local er the the
local pastor is on behalf of its
substituents II wrote a letter to the
magistrate saying she is a good donkey
she is a clean donkey she would never
commit to this of her own free will
she is the victim of violence and the
magistrate would say that the street
went that’s totally reason the donkeys
moral character was legally relevant
when working out her level of
culpability and the donkey was let go
and I don’t know her name but I assumes
to live the long and happy life there is
another case that I really liked a
little bit earlier early 1500s there’s
this guy called Bartolome Chason a I’m
probably mispronouncing that I apologize
a french jurist another Frenchman I
don’t know what it is and he worked in
both ecclesiastical and civil courts
dealing with trials of animals and one
of his first trials was with a group of
rats
he was the court-appointed defense
attorney for a group of rats hoard of
rats who had consumed the entire
contents of a barley field just devoured
it right and so because they were
because of that the rats were had been
charged for this crime there was someone
to court and of course they didn’t show
up because their rats
and so the magistrate says to Shasta day
mate
come on where is he client what’s he
doing and Jessie says totally reasonably
rats have no fixed place of abode they
didn’t know they didn’t get the letter
and the magistrate says totally fair
they don’t so gets delayed and is the
second summons and the rats again failed
to show up this is a pattern
incidentally and the magistrate says
what’s going on
where are my rats and shafts and I says
oh well you know we need to make
accommodations for the old lien firm
they need to show up as as a unit you
know we need to delay it once more time
and the magistrate begrudgingly does so
and this happens a couple more times on
the fourth or fifth iteration so I
mentor the magistrates remember very
annoyed by this point he says look what
you know we need to do something about
this you need to bring them to court and
Shasta nee invokes a piece of legal
reasoning we still use now he says the
rats live in mortal fear of their
enemies the cats and cannot be expected
to show up to court this is a legal
principle that a lot of jurisdictions
still use now if you have been summoned
to court and you can’t and you fear for
your life you feel like a life would be
engaged in doing so it is the obligation
of the court to provide you protection
that’s necessary that’s it that the
legal right you have Chason they invoked
a legal right back in the 1500s for
these rats and the magistrates went
that’s totally fair so the magistrate
that had two choices do I throw the case
out and let the rats go oh do I
tax the local constituency to round up
potentially thousands of rats to bring
them to court
obviously he let the case go because
he’s not crazy
basically want to be lynched by a bunch
of angry French villagers I mean this is
this is this this case is really
interesting but it this and the previous
one because they both seem to apply that
animals under this innocence of legal
structure were entitled this in some
cases to equal rights under criminal law
as human beings it’s great and I mean
look I’m not gonna deny like being in
animal in the medieval period was
sometimes super shit I mean it sucks you
know I wouldn’t recommend it but it’s
it’s it’s interesting in that in that
human beings were treated equally
brutally under the criminal law you
could be hanged you could be put into
stocks you could be publicly embarrassed
you like your punishments at the
discretion of the local magistrate in a
lot of cases I mean if animals were
treated cruelly under the criminal law
anyway it was only because everyone was
treated cruelly but I think it’s pretty
cool that’s very interesting so what do
we do like we have this problem we have
this thing where there’s supposedly
there’s this Renaissance rise towards
sort of this materialism towards you
know sort of disavowing the the sort of
spiritual or the mental content of
things in the world only humans have
it’s this is sort of materialistic you
know upswing through the Renaissance and
at the same time stuff like this happens
a hundred and forty recorded cases and
there’s probably more 140 recorded cases
of animal trials and Renaissance so how
do we how do we has we’ll work through
this so my argument is that assistive
evidence of the fact that the
Renaissance we talk about this blanket
movement but in fact it’s this uneven
sort of give and take so it starts in
Italy right and sort of it creeps out
and it sort of it’s this battles along
the way and it’s this incomplete kind of
spreading and what we can see here is a
point when something that looks like the
rule of law intersects this medieval
view of animal life the rule of law
thing is also kind of complicated right
so all the although these animals were
entitled to certain rights on the
criminal law say if you are a Jew or a
Muslim
you were not entitled those rights
animals had the rights the Jews and
Muslims not I mean although that sounds
you know so deep it sounds it is deeply
problematic I mean I think what this
really does is highlight the conditions
under which personhood like as an idea
as a legal quality is awarded to people
in the medieval period and so my claim
is that something like personhood is
this is something that belongs to some
members have given faith communities
right your your you know if you if you
live in a village and you participate in
their religious life and you know you
sort of you sort of participate in that
little ecosystem you are in some sort of
limited pre theoretical sense consider
the person but if you don’t participate
you’re not so you’ve got a church or
you’re part of the community you don’t
you know but so we don’t all that seems
fine but the the cascading implication
of that is that for furlongs donkey or
for shaft mates rats both of these
entities are considered to be Christians
under the law which is super-weird so
obviously in the end the the Renaissance
one right so for a very very long time
I mean it’s there’s a reason why animal
trials almost completely die out after
the 17th century there is still some
statistic cases they all basically these
trials basically stop happening right
and so that seems to imply to me anyway
that this that this sort of rule of law
idea it sort of spreads through it
spreads through the community first and
then you have this subsequent belief
which is that of the this sort of the
idea of animals as being these
mechanical constructs right that I think
is sort of this interesting takeaway
from the Renaissance right now we we
talk about with a personhood as being
this this it suddenly becomes flexible
becomes mutable it’s no longer this
abstract inalienable rockhard thing but
it becomes subject to the intuition is
that we hold
about what it means to be a person with
legally or morally or whatever which
bring us to where we’re going now happy
little dolphin so it seems to me that
because of the the way these these
trials the number of which diminishes
but suddenly we have now I think in the
early 20th century we have this this is
somehow a resurgence there’s this
there’s this new growth of people
talking about animals as if they’re
persons and this I think is a lot of
there’s there’s a lot of reasons this
one of which is the cause and in the
Western world we tend to award person in
the contemporary Western world we tend
to award personhood on the basis of
intelligence so we don’t know we no
longer a water in the basis and the
basis of religious community so what
happens is all these sort of all these
studies come out about animal cognition
and people starts thinking seriously
about what kinds of what kinds of
conditions one needs to meet in order to
become a person right and so you have
these these there’s been a number of
interesting cases so in Switzerland in
1992 animals were deemed as beings and
not things under the law
New Zealand gave basic legal rights to
great apes in 1988 I think in 2002
Germany extended those same the same
considerations to all animals in the
early two-thousands their bowel near
islands I’m probably missing that
there’s an autonomous province of Spain
gave full legal rights to all great apes
and in 2015 which I think is the most
amazing one for a very very brief period
I mean it was really it was later
redacted I was ladies to take taken out
of the legal record for a very brief
period period to lab chimpanzees at the
State University of New York were
awarded the right to habeas corpus there
are awarded the right to not be
contained without having committed a
crime
which meant they had the right not to be
in cages that’s pretty amazing that
right was when I think when the judge
realized what he’d done
there was a quick backpedaling
but it’s this really fascinating thing
where we like right now asked in the in
the early 20th century
you know we’ve so long taken these
enlightened my dears of what it means to
be a person kind of fer granted and then
and then suddenly we’re confronted with
you know something like this this sort
of intelligent thinking feeling creature
and we might weave into ourselves maybe
we have to extend the borders of what it
means to be a person a little bit maybe
that’s just what we need to do and so
you in keeping with the theme of the day
this is the rise and fall right this is
these kind of intuitions these are kind
of a litmus test for for how we measure
our own sense of what it means to be a
person and I think that’s really
interesting so that’s my takeaway
message for you today anyway that’s all
thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: