Press "Enter" to skip to content

The resurgence of non-commodity agriculture in single malt whiskey | Matt Hofmann | TEDxEastsidePrep


my name is Matt Hoffman I’m the master

distiller and one of the cofounders of

Westland distillery make single malt

whiskey here in Seattle master distiller

is a funny thing because I very rarely

distill these days I do a lot of

spreadsheets send a lot of emails but I

also get to talk to people about kind of

the exciting things that we do here one

of the interesting things again we’re

kind of talking about dinner last night

we all got together one of the things

that kind of echoes both the talk that

we just saw and then the things we

talked about at dinner is the idea of

mastering something I think is false it

is something we can constantly strive

towards we’re trying to always get to

perfection and we’re talking about the

excellence thing but we’ll never get

there and to think that you will get

there to think that you will ever be the

master of something is as arrogant in my

opinion so when we say master distiller

functionally what that means is is kind

of in charge of the process start to

finish does not mean that I have

mastered distilling in any way I don’t

believe that that is possible so single

malt whisky is the original style of

whisky that has been produced at least

as far as recorded history goes for

about 600 years the origin of it is

probably Ireland unless you’re asking

the Scottish people in which case it’s

Scotland but this it’s the origin of all

other styles of whiskey so basically

Scottish Irish immigrants move to other

parts of the world especially the u.s.

find that barley doesn’t grow very well

in the eastern US they plan try instead

I take the ride that the German

immigrants have they use that to make

their whiskey then they all get kicked

out of there it’s something called the

Whiskey Rebellion which is a very

fantastic story we don’t have time for

today and they have to move down to

Kentucky where they find corn is a lot

better and that’s where bourbon comes

from singable whiskey is a hundred

percent malted barley what malted barley

is is basically sprouted barley so

barley grows as has been growing for for

thousands of years and its really kind

of reached

its pinnacle expression in these kind of

cooler climates we have a cooler spring

kind of like the UK and also like the

Pacific Northwest as it turns out so one

hundred percent malted barley so what

they’re going to do is going to take

that raw barley they’re going to soak it

in water for a few days then the barley

grain goes hey it just rained so take

this water in and I’ll begin to sprout

so it goes along and it develops a root

lid and some shoots and then there’s all

sorts of things happening inside of the

grain basically developing enzymes in

the grain that help convert starch into

sugar all this is very important when it

comes to processing the whiskey but we

need to stop it so it doesn’t go into

full barley plant because that would be

disastrous so they stop it by drying it

out and that is what we call malted

barley so that’s used in beer as well as

single malt whiskey so the single part

means produced at one distillery and

this again is most of the time you’re

seeing this come out of Scotland so

that’s kind of that’s what we do here

the Pacific Northwest is the best barley

growing climate in the United States it

is one of the best barley growing

climates in the world outside of the UK

Pacific Northwest are the two best ones

in the northern hemisphere so a lot of

people say oh you guys are Americans why

aren’t you making bourbon well actually

it’s more authentic for us to be making

single malt whiskey here because barley

is what grows here and not corn corn is

used for bourbon so this is barley

everybody say hello barley everything

that’s used in the world of single malt

whisky is commodity barley doesn’t

actually matter and it’s true not just

for whiskey but it’s also true for beer

and any kind of baking products that use

barley it’s all commodity barley so what

does that mean so commodity barley or

any commodity grain is bred for high

yield in the field high yield in the

plant in our case in the distillery it’s

bred for disease resistance and it’s

also bred for what it’s my last thing

that it spread to be dependable it

spread that you can count on every time

when you go to make whiskey like when we

do but also the farmers know what

they’re going to get then you get these

varieties certified by various

organizations in the u.s. it’s called

the ambulance American malted barley

Association all of these things are

admirable the ability to do

high yields and and disease resistance

makes things grow and you know what

you’re going to get but there are also

some downsides to that and those aren’t

commonly talked about this barley

varietal that you see here this is

called full pint this is a new barley

varietal bred by Oregon State University

keep this in mind as we look through the

rest of these slides here this is what

when if you ask a Scottish person what

barley looks like they’re gonna say

looks exactly like this and varley’s

only ever looked exactly like this so

here’s the thing about commodities if

you’re running commodities you’re

probably doing monoculture so that means

you’re planting the same crop year after

year after year after year the US has

mastered this in a really really

depressing way I mean the middle of the

country is corn corn corn corn corn each

year that corn is depleting the soil it

is the taking things out of the soil

they can dump things back in before they

learned how to dump things back and they

simply moved away this is the origin of

the Dust Bowl this is people moved out

kind of into the plain States planted a

bunch of stuff then kind of forgot to

take care of it all and then destroyed

it and then they kept moving but now

these days people are able to dump

synthetic stuff back into the soil over

and over and over again it’s not good

for the soil though it’s not good for

the environment you talk about all this

extra stuff that you have to put into

the system this also includes diseases

if you break up the crops if you plant

this and then do a different crop

different crop different crop then the

disease has time to go away otherwise it

just builds and builds and builds and

builds year after year the other big

thing is that commodity grains are price

fixed it’s a race to the bottom I just

finished reading a great book at highly

recommend it’s called gaining ground

it’s about a farmer out in Virginia I

believe and he inherited he was probably

my age he’s in his 20s and he inherited

so I am in my 20s it’s true actually

so anyways he inherited a he inherited a

farm from his grandparents and he got

really really into the idea of planting

grains and so we planted corn and soy

and he made it through the first first

season the first harvest and he got all

the way to the end there was a little

bit of drought and some things that were

going on there and he he sold all of it

you have 300 acres of this stuff and

sold all of it tallied everything up at

the end of the year and he realized he

made exactly eighteen dollars and that’s

because the price is fixed it’s a race

to the bottom no matter what you can’t

add value to a commodity crop because

that’s against the definition and the

other big thing is it’s always bred for

yield the idea of flavor does not come

into consideration ever which is really

really remarkable actually so again

there’s some admirable things about

commodities but there’s a lot of

negatives so what do we do to try to fix

this this is the resurgence that we’re

talking about here a return to original

styles of farming to rotation crops so

you’re going to get things that are

going to help the soil going to help

each other out there’s a lot of examples

of this throughout the world the rest of

the world knows this a lot of cuisines

are based on this idea of rotation crops

but in America we sadly have no real

concept of it because we’ve always kind

of been able to either take more land or

develop chemicals to get around it

getting value out of these products not

just breeding them for a commodity

system where you you put into a giant

truck that goes to a giant train car and

it goes to a giant commodity market

you’re done with it let’s add value to

these products you can do that if you

take control but then also flavor and

this is a big that I kind of get into

this in a little bit but let’s actually

think about flavor as we develop new

grains so this is the Skagit value can

see that there in Washington State the

barley regions are kind of split into

two places you’ve got Eastern Washington

which is big that’s big AG country that

is there’s we get a lot of barley from

eastern Washington but the system there

is very much commodity system there’s

two varietals of barley that are grown

out there amongst the thousands that

exist and if they grow effectively but

that will come in and and the farmers

you don’t you never meet them

but Western Washington is a little bit

different they’ve rejected the commodity

system for a lot of very simple reason

so the Skagit Valley there those are

tulips a lot of people here will know

that the Skagit Valley is famous for its

tulip festival what they probably don’t

know is that those tulips basically just

destroy this soil not totally but they

can’t do the tulips in the same place

generally speaking year after year

because it takes so much material to

make those tulips work so what these

farmers have been doing for a hundred

years is they’ve been planting barley

after the tulips to help put carbon back

into the soil barley is actually a

carbon fixing it sucks carbon out of the

atmosphere puts it back into the soil

breaks disease cycles then they’ll plant

something like beans they would put

nitrogen back into the soil and away

they go then the complaint tulips again

they don’t have to dump a bunch of extra

stuff in there and that’s a natural crop

rotation cycle this is how a lot of

agricultural communities have existed

for a long time the problem is is that

they had nobody to sell that grain to

they were outside of the commodity

system even if you were farming in

western Washington is a lot more

expensive that it is in eastern

Washington if you manage to get perfect

grain out of this barley you might break

even if it made what’s called moulton

great so be high grade barley but on the

commodity system if not you would get

feed grade barley which goes to cattle

and that you lose money planting that

but they have to do it because it’s good

for their soil this barley here so you

remember the barley is just showing you

a little bit ago this barley is called

purple obsidia I’m going to come up with

there’s there’s a lot of names here that

they are going to see it’s we’re not

involved with marijuana at all purple

obsidian Tibetan purple you know there’s

all sorts of you know no so so anyways

this is a varietal of barley that comes

from Egypt it’s 2,000 years old there’s

an almost unbelievable back story

involving some camel trading routes in

eastern Washington it’s very bizarre but

this is not an approved varietal for

planting for multi barley in Washington

State why not well there’s all sorts of

reasons but one of them

is it melts in four days instead of

seven so actually if you’re thinking

about this it melts faster than what the

standard is but just because it moves

away from what the standard is it makes

it totally reject abul so one of the

things that we move to do and we’re

working we have to work with other

companies to do is we’re working with a

company called Skagit Valley malting to

accomplish this is basically changing

the system to suit the grain to suit the

agriculture and not changing your

agriculture to suit your system this is

only really possible now with technology

so you can change each different batch

you have to be more patient it costs

more money yes but the flavor that you

get from something like this is is

unbelievable people have never tasted it

there’s I mean how many of you have

tasted just an unbelievable piece of

whole wheat bread that totally changed

your mind there’s not enough of you this

is the problem but

but that’s out there when you taste it

in it totally just you have no concept

of this if you’re just raised on Wonder

Bread and all this other stuff that we

are as Americans and so this is a very

very important thing you can take the

varietals that are not just for multi

but a feed varietal that full pint back

there two slides ago that was a feed

varietal that’s also not approved for

malting under the approved list and yet

you can multi and you get incredible

flavor out of it so that’s a really

really that’s a really important thing

to think about when you think about

flavor first just try to get the thing

that tastes best and then work backwards

from there to make it work in order for

this to work you need grain breeder so

we’re going to help you develop new

varietals barley I don’t mean GMO I mean

kind of the old fashioned way of

breeding grain which is you take two

grains and he kind of rub them together

like this sin its it wouldn’t be good at

so but it’s it’s developing grains the

old fashioned way start to finish that

process usually takes 10 years from the

time you make the first cross but to the

time that it could be approved if you

start with a thousand varietals you

might be lucky if you get one that works

so there’s a guy named dr. Steve Jones

he was out breeding wheat and barley at

Washington State University Pullman

Monsanto approached him and said will

you develop a varietal of wheat for us

that we can patent he said no that may

sound obvious he said I’m a land-grant

university professor you’re not supposed

to breed for companies supposed to breed

for the public good he’s the only one in

the u.s. that said no he was banished

from this university from Washington

State University Pullman and before you

think this is a political thing big AG

reaches across both sides of the aisle

when this happened so he was kicked up

to Mount Vernon an hour to the north of

us basically allowed to do whatever he

wanted they stripped him of all of his

funding save his salary and his

assistant salary which continues to this

day by the way everything that he’s done

up to this point he’s only done with two

people salaries and no other funding of

any sort and basically said all right go

nuts up there and so up there the

farmers initially and then other

companies westland helps fund this as

well but also companies like cliff bar

whole foods Patagonia chipotle have to

fund his work in developing varietals of

grain for flavor instead of just for

yield that’s 15,000 varietals of barley

that he’s got in there in Scotland they

only use one varietal of barley so if

you can imagine if you know like the

world of wine merlot what if all wine

was merlot who’s seen the movie sideways

okay so whatever you think about Merlot

even if it’s a if it’s an amazing Merlot

if every wine was Merlot how boring

would that be now I’ll caveat this by

saying the world of Scottish whiskey has

produced a lot of great stuff and that’s

even increasing these days there’s a ton

of great stuff out there and I have a

lot of respect for what goes on in the

Scottish whiskey industry for the most

part but there

there are so many new possibilities of

getting beyond this high yielding type

of barley varietal if you start thinking

about flavor who cares if it yields ten

percent less charge twenty percent more

for it because people go nuts over it

you know people love things that taste

good it’s it’s really not actually that

complicated so the bread lab up there is

doing amazing things you’ll find them in

documentaries again all of their funding

is coming from from donations mostly

from kind of progressive companies and

and from individuals big AG has removed

everything else from them so this is

this is a big deal the end result from

all of this what they’re trying to do is

make sure that these varietals they’re

breeding these varietals to grow well in

the washington state climate in the

Pacific Northwest climate so you don’t

have to dump things back into the system

back into the agricultural system that

don’t belong there the farmers now will

take these varietals and make a living

off of them before they would just feed

it to cows because they couldn’t bother

to sell out on the commodity market now

we can go in and say hey we will pay you

not just above commodity market value

will pay you good money for this grain

that you’re breeding here even though

it’s yielding maybe fifty percent less

per acre even will pay you the

difference and then some to make sure

that you get paid a living wage and

ultimately really the important thing

that comes out of it is you make better

product and and what’s exciting about

this is this is applicable beyond

whiskey this is applicable to a lot of

things there’s a huge movement going on

right now in this country and it’s just

getting started for this style of

thinking we talk about things like

triple bottom line where everybody wins

people get paid more money the

environment ends up better and

ultimately you develop better more

compelling products with better flavor

and this is something we should always

be striving for it’s something we’re

pushing very hard on and something we

want the whole world to see so let’s wake up thank you very much

Please follow and like us: