Press "Enter" to skip to content

The price of free entertainment | Jon Giegengack | TEDxPortsmouth


today technology gives us access to more
entertainment options than we’ve ever
had before from Netflix to Facebook to
Xbox Live the average person can have
incredibly immersive entertainment
experiences without ever having to get
off of their couch and even though these
platforms cost billions of dollars to
build and they cost billions of dollars
to maintain many of them are made
available to us a hundred percent for
free so how can that be and is this
something that we should worry about so
to understand the answer to this
question it pays first to think about
how pervasive technology has become in
our lives today eighty-nine percent of
Americans use the Internet
sixty-eight percent of us have a
Facebook account and among younger
people it’s 95 percent and seventy-seven
percent of us have smartphones about
double the number just five years ago a
huge point of engagement with technology
is video games 97 percent of boys and 92
percent of girls play at least some kind
of video games and most of them play
every day but video games are not just
for kids two-thirds of US households
have at least one person who games
regularly and many of them are adults as
an example that’s my xbox live profile
that’s that’s me I’m sure that’s obvious
that that number at the bottom is my
gamer score and my gamer score is an
expression of my cumulative performance
across all the games that I play on Xbox
Live so mine was 40,000 when it when I
took this I played some games last
nights a little bit higher now when I
did the research for this presentation I
found out that the average Xbox Live
member has a gamer score of 11,000 which
was a little horrifying and I do I do
have to play some video games for my job
to be fair but at the same time you can
see that gaming is a huge source of
entertainment not just for kids but also
for grownups now the biggest category of
games the fastest-growing category now
is a category called free-to-play which
is where you download the game for free
and then you have the option to buy more
content to use after you’ve started
playing so 85 percent of people who play
video games play at least some
free-to-play games and the net impact of
all of this is that a growing number of
us are really never
disconnected from technology so in 2018
25% of all Americans and 45% of teens
say that they’re doing something on the
internet almost constantly among teens
that’s almost twice as high as just
three years ago so that’s a look at how
pervasive technology has become but what
is it that makes it so engaging why do
we get so hooked on it and the short
answer is that these experiences are
designed to be that way so this is a
gentleman named BF Skinner who was a
behavioral psychologist at Harvard and
he pioneered lots of theories about what
drives human behavior and how that
behavior can be manipulated using
rewards one of his most important
theories at least for this conversation
is something called variable ratio
reinforcement variable ratio
reinforcement explains a lot of why we
get so hooked on entertainment
technology this picture is something
that he developed called the Skinner box
a Skinner box is a it’s a box and inside
the box there’s a rat there’s a lever
that the rat can push and then there’s a
chute that delivers food and so he used
this to experiment on how an animal’s
behavior can be changed using different
methods of introducing rewards and he
tested three different methods one is
called continuous reinforcement and
that’s where every time the rat pushes
the lever he gets food the second one is
called fixed ratio reinforcement and
that one is where the rat every certain
number of times that the rat pushes the
delivers say five times the food appears
and that interval remains the same every
time and then the last one’s variable
ratio reinforcement where the rat pushes
the lever and the food appears but the
number of times you have to push it each
time is different so the reward is
delivered unpredictably now for each of
these three he measured two things about
the rats behavior he measured the
response rate which is how fast does the
rat push the lever and then he measured
the extinction rate which is how fast
does the racket board and stop pushing
with continuous reinforcement where the
rat gets food every time the activity
level is slow and the extinction rate is
fast he gets bored quickly with fixed
ratio the activity level is a little bit
faster and the behavior persists a
little bit longer but with variable
ratio reinforcement the activity is the
fastest and the extinction rate is the
slow
the rat keeps pushing for the longest
period of time so in other words
unpredictable rewards have a much bigger
impact on behavior than predictable ones
do and these principles apply to people
the same way that they apply to rats in
fact scientists have done experiments to
show that variable rewards delivered at
an unpredictable basis create higher
levels of activity and dopamine cells
than predictable rewards do and higher
levels of dopamine are often associated
with compulsive behavior like drug abuse
so where do we see variable
reinforcement variable racial
reinforcement in entertainment today one
place that we see it is in gambling
especially in things like slot machines
and scratch tickets we see it in social
media where likes and notifications get
delivered to us on an unpredictable
basis and keep us engaged and we also
see it in video games where
variable-ratio reinforcement is a
central theme of how many games are
designed and in fact it’s even something
that’s taught in game design school so
we’ve talked about variable ratio
reinforcement as something that makes
entertainment more entertaining but as
BF Skinner showed us it also creates
opportunities for behavior to be
manipulated so let’s tie this back to a
real-life example of entertainment
technology how many people here play or
know someone who plays a game called
fortnight so way to quite a few people
for anybody who’s not familiar where
that for tonight is a free-to-play game
like I talked about that was introduced
about a year ago and since then it’s
become not just a gaming industry
phenomenon but it’s really a cultural
phenomenon so the game was introduced in
July at 2017 and about a month later it
had a million players just under a year
after that in June of this year it had
127 million players now as I mentioned
the game itself is free-to-play but once
you download it you can buy add-on
content for your character you can buy a
ton of outfits helmets costumes you can
even buy emotes which are these gestures
that your character will make in the
game and other characters can see it
none of these things has any impact on
your ability to play or on whether or
not you win or perform well in the game
they’re purely cosmetic but even so in
February of this year for tonight
players spent a hundred twenty six
million dollars on this add-on content
in April two months later that was up to
almost three
million dollars 300 million dollars in
one month to give you an idea of I mean
it sounds like a lot of money anyway but
even just to give you an idea even in
their entertainment perspectives how
much that is another entertainment
property that came out in April was
Marvel Avengers infinity war the movie
that was a monster movie in fact it had
the biggest opening gross
weekend of any movie in the history of
movies and here’s how much it made so as
you can see people are spending a ton of
money on these games but it’s
interesting to look at who is spending
this money in a recent study among
fortnight players researchers found that
the median spend among people who had
spent anything of the game was 40
dollars but the average spend was 85
dollars and that means that the spending
distribution looks like this chart where
there’s a small number of players
generating most of the revenue and a lot
more players who are only spending a
little bit or not spending anything at
all and that’s not unusual in fact
free-to-play games are designed assuming
that a very small percentage of players
about anywhere from 5% or less are going
to invest tremendous amount of time in
the game and spend money there’s a
there’s a term for them they call them
whales and that’s the same term
interestingly that’s used in the casino
industries for the for the heavy players
but those whales that that 2 to 3% of
players are the ones that generate
almost all the revenue for games like
these and as you can imagine that level
of engagement for some people comes at
the expense of other things in life in
November 2017 the gaming blog Kotaku
published an interview with a teenager
who had spent thirteen thousand five
hundred dollars on a set of free-to-play
games
in June of this year a librarian and
Utah pled guilty to embezzlement after
he spent eighty nine thousand dollars a
city money on a free game called game of
and one more data point from those for
tonight players among the respondents in
that study who were students 35% of them
said they had skipped school at least
once to play for tonight but video games
are not the only form of Technology of
entertainment that we get for free
because of Technology another big one is
social media just by show of hands how
many people in here have a Facebook or a
Twitter or Instagram account anything
like that so just about everybody how
many of you remember clicking I accept
at the bottom of a privacy policy when
you first signed up for one of those
still some people now here’s the hard
question how many of you who did read
that or remember what it says but full
on zero all right
if you don’t remember you’re not alone
this chart shows the number of words in
the privacy policies of some common
online platforms this purple bar shows
how many words are in the US
Constitution now the average the average
person can read about 200 words per
minute and the average person has more
than one of these social media platforms
so it’s not surprising that even though
almost all of us use social media very
very few of us understand the agreement
that we’ve entered into by using these
platforms and that agreement is not at
all an insignificant one let’s use
Facebook as an example depending on how
much you use it and how complete your
profile is you have agreed to share a
lot of information about yourself with
Facebook they know who you are your age
your gender where you live they know
your behavior online so your likes and
your posts on Facebook and they might
know about activity on other accounts
that you’ve linked to your Facebook
account they know who are the people
that you know and that you communicate
with and finally they have really
specific information on how to how to
find you how to talk to you either email
address maybe your phone number and your
name but it might surprise you that in
some cases they might even know what
motivates you maybe even better than you
know this yourself how many people here
have ever filled out a personality test
and a survey on facebook some people
have
those personality tests and person
telling personalities like that I should
say have been used by psychologists for
years to classify people attitudinally
so classify them based on things are you
an introvert or an extrovert how well do
you get along with other people how
compassionate are you how open or closed
are you to new experiences things like
that now when all of this information
gets stored in one place it can be
combined to create a profile of you that
is incredibly complete and incredibly
powerful the information about who you
are where you are how to reach you and
then finally what are the things that
you care about what are the issues and
the emotions and the imagery that are
going to be the most likely for you to
find compelling and to influence your
behavior so this is more targetable and
more precise than any form of
advertising that’s ever existed before
and is this a bad thing not necessarily
it doesn’t have to be and in fact in
some cases it can even be helpful one
example of a company that uses these
profiles a cosmetics company created
multiple campaigns for the same product
with different messaging based on how
women feel about their appearance so one
campaign with messaging for women who
are shy one campaign with messaging for
women who are confident etc this is a
really good way to sell more cosmetics
but it also means that consumers are
seeing advertising that’s relevant to
them and if you have to see advertising
anyway why not see some advertising that
you’re going to care about these
profiles are also used by political
campaigns to advertise to voters so they
can target people very specifically
based on all the things we just talked
about your education level what kind of
a job you have they can target people in
specific states or even specific zip
codes within States and then they can
build the campaigns around the messaging
that the issues that these people are
going to have the strongest feelings
about so the things that are most likely
for example to create a sense of urgency
about getting out to vote or the things
that are most likely to make people
favor one candidate over another so the
value to advertisers here is obvious
it’s huge but the value to consumers is
maybe not as clear as in the other
example I used so what does this mean
what should you do about it
and good news the first thing you should
do is enjoy it we’re in a golden
of entertainment right now there’s never
been more entertainment to choose from
it’s never been easier to get access to
and by almost any measure it’s never
been more fun so those are all really
good things and we should enjoy them but
it’s important to remember that these
companies are not charities on the
contrary they’re throwing off profits
the likes of which the world has never
seen before
and in many cases their ability to
generate these profits depends on two
things one is their ability to influence
your behavior and the other is their
ability to gather your data so just to
give you an example of how important
that is in May of this year new online
privacy rules are rolled out called the
general data protection regulation or
the gdpr
some folks might have heard of that
these new rules place just some limits
on the ability of online companies to
use data from their users but even so
they had such a cooling effect on the
growth of a berta looks advertising
business then in July when they reported
their numbers Facebook stock lost 120
billion dollars of market value in one
day that’s the biggest one-day drop in
the history of the stock market so a
good rule of thumb is that if you’re
having a valuable experience online and
nobody is asking you to pay for it
you’re probably not the customer you’re
probably the product and in many cases
that might be just fine things like for
fortnight and Facebook fortnight
especially is a blast and a lot of
consumers would be happy to give up some
information about themselves to get
access to that game for free but it’s
important to remember that the the
potential exists for that data to be
used in ways that you didn’t expect and
we’re all using these platforms so much
now this technology is so pervasive that
you can’t afford to be ignorant about
your role in these transactions so learn
about the businesses that you’re working
with be aware of the kinds of data that
you’re sharing and that’s the way that
you can be sure that the price of free
entertainment is not more than you’re
willing to pay thank you [Applause]
Please follow and like us: