
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
[Applause]
let me guess what you’re thinking oh he
is nervous he forgot what he’s gotta say
TEDx Dayton’s first epic fail no no I
sure hope not we just experienced the
power of silence in this case the power
of silence to make us uncomfortable
we don’t really like silence that’s why
we fill it with background music with
talk radio with cat videos with podcasts
and playlists but there isn’t enough
silence in our lives our lives are too
filled with noise too filled with
distractions too filled with stuff
silence is nature’s beautiful antidote
to all that craziness I’m a conductor
surrounded by music the opposite of
silence but every piece of music I
conduct begins from silence and ends
into silence it’s crazy but I conducted
orchestras for more than 30 years before
I ever realized that and I never truly
appreciated the real power of silence
until three years ago when I went on a
five-day retreat at the Abbey of Our
Lady of Gethsemane near Bardstown
Kentucky Gethsemane is a Cistercian
monastery founded in 1848 it’s perhaps
best known as the home of the great
philosopher monk Thomas Merton silence
is an integral part of a monk’s life at
the Abbey
the monks use silence as a tool to focus
their attention inward to prayer and
outward to work among other things they
make killer fudge some batches even
flavoured some batch is even flavored
with good old
Kentucky Bourbon but the monks aren’t
completely silent seven times a day they
come together in Gethsemane a church to
sing songs
[Music]
[Applause]
every two weeks they sing their way
through all 150 Psalms and then they
start all over again so how did an
agnostic Jewish conductor find himself
on a five-day retreat where he sang
Psalms seven times a day with a bunch of
otherwise silent Trappist monks first of
all like many people I had read some
Thomas Merton and I found his takes on
life religion and humanity deeply
fascinating second I fell in love with
the chant liturgy when I was a freshman
in college first semester music history
is basically the story of music in the
early Roman Catholic Church and one of
the first things you learn about is the
monastic life and the chants and songs
that monks sing as part of their daily
routine so three years ago when I was
about to go into rehearsals for Dayton
operas production of Aida I was looking
for a place where I could get away for a
few days clear my head and just study
the Opera and I realized that the answer
was three and a half hours south of
Dayton at Gethsemane one of the most
powerful experiences I had during that
first retreat to the abbey was running
into an old friend of mine
Don Hawke retired first trombone of the
Milwaukee Symphony Orchestra someone I
hadn’t seen in more than 10 years Don
and I found ourselves sitting next to
each other at lunch one day eating in
silence and gazing out at the
incomparable beauty of late winter
turning into early spring we didn’t say
a word
but the silence we shared was amazing
you’d think after all those years we’d
have lots to talk about and we did later
on we got together on a bench outside
the Abbey to catch up and reminisce but
somehow
I felt as if we said more to each other
during that wordless lunch then when we
actually spoke and that’s when I
realized for the first time the true
power of silence silence of course is an
important element of music to music is
made up of notes but when there aren’t
notes there are rests and every rest is
a silence musical silences can be quite
short here’s the shortest one I know the
silence that begins Beethoven’s fifth
symphony fourteen one hundredths of a
second
it’s the tiny sliver of time between
when you first see the next slide and
when you first hear the music for me
that itty-bitty little silence is like
the instant of the Big Bang setting off
an explosion that creates an entire
musical universe now if that’s maybe the
shortest silence in all of music this is
probably the longest four minutes and 33
seconds by the bad boy of classical
music John Cage I think this is the most
important piece of music of the 20th
century and I know it’s the most
misunderstood that’s because four
minutes and 33 seconds is really four
minutes and 33 seconds of silence but
it’s no joke Cage was dead serious when
he wrote it in 1952 for pianist David
tutor who premiered it at the Maverick
concert hall in Woodstock New York
maverick is an amazing building with
walls open to the outside so when David
Tudor sat at the piano for 4 minutes and
33 seconds and never played a note there
wasn’t silence the audience could hear
the sounds of
danger all around them and that’s what
cage was after he wanted his audience to
listen to four minutes and 33 seconds of
the world with the same attention and
the same concentration that they would
normally devote to four and a half
minutes of Mozart or Beethoven or Brahms
when the piece is performed and it does
get performed it’s usually done in three
movements as David Tudor first played it
this is what the sheet music looks like
the first movement is thirty seconds of
silence tacit is music lingo for don’t
play then comes two minutes and 23
seconds of silence and finally one
minute and 40 seconds of silence with
the beginning and end of each movement
marked by the opening and closing of the
piano lid now you know how they say
there’s an app for that well there’s an
app for that
an app that lets you record and then
upload your own performances so let’s
make TEDx Dayton History and record one
on my iPhone right now we’re not in the
Maverick concert hall with walls open to
nature but we can try to create our own
urban equivalent right now TEDx
volunteers are going to start opening
the doors to the theater
not just the doors to the auditorium but
also the doors to the outside that’s so
we can let the sounds of the world
around us join with the silence to focus
our attention and our listening for
minutes and 33 seconds is about going
inside yourself like the monks and
opening yourself up to the music of the
world around you even if it’s cars and
buses in the streets of Dayton Ohio so
let’s do it
[Music]
so what are the lessons we can learn
from four minutes and 33 seconds besides
the fact they’re a whole bunch of people
talking in the lobby who missed my talk
try to find some silence in your life
[Applause]
it doesn’t have to be four and a half
minutes it’s hard start with maybe start
with four seconds then try 33 seconds
work your way up even a few moments of
silence can make a real difference in
your life
calming your soul and opening your
perception when silence does find you
try not to fill it as we continue our
day of listening here at TEDx dating
let’s try to have the experience of four
minutes and 33 seconds in form the way
we listen the rest of the day don’t sit
back and relax sit up and listen like
your life depends on it
I’ll leave you with one final beautiful
bit of serendipity three years ago when
I went on that first retreat to
Gethsemane Abbey my wife did me a favor
and packed my suitcase for me I didn’t
look at it till I got there and when I
opened my suitcase I found this my four
minutes and 33 seconds t-shirt Lisa had
no idea what it was or how significant
it was for her it was just a nice clean
t-shirt somewhere near the top of the
pile but before I left the Abbey to
return to Dayton and Aida and the hubbub
of everyday life
I put on the shirt went outside the
entrance to the retreat house and took
my first-ever selfie
[Applause]
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
[Applause]
let me guess what you’re thinking oh he
is nervous he forgot what he’s gotta say
TEDx Dayton’s first epic fail no no I
sure hope not we just experienced the
power of silence in this case the power
of silence to make us uncomfortable
we don’t really like silence that’s why
we fill it with background music with
talk radio with cat videos with podcasts
and playlists but there isn’t enough
silence in our lives our lives are too
filled with noise too filled with
distractions too filled with stuff
silence is nature’s beautiful antidote
to all that craziness I’m a conductor
surrounded by music the opposite of
silence but every piece of music I
conduct begins from silence and ends
into silence it’s crazy but I conducted
orchestras for more than 30 years before
I ever realized that and I never truly
appreciated the real power of silence
until three years ago when I went on a
five-day retreat at the Abbey of Our
Lady of Gethsemane near Bardstown
Kentucky Gethsemane is a Cistercian
monastery founded in 1848 it’s perhaps
best known as the home of the great
philosopher monk Thomas Merton silence
is an integral part of a monk’s life at
the Abbey
the monks use silence as a tool to focus
their attention inward to prayer and
outward to work among other things they
make killer fudge some batches even
flavoured some batch is even flavored
with good old
Kentucky Bourbon but the monks aren’t
completely silent seven times a day they
come together in Gethsemane a church to
sing songs
[Music]
[Applause]
every two weeks they sing their way
through all 150 Psalms and then they
start all over again so how did an
agnostic Jewish conductor find himself
on a five-day retreat where he sang
Psalms seven times a day with a bunch of
otherwise silent Trappist monks first of
all like many people I had read some
Thomas Merton and I found his takes on
life religion and humanity deeply
fascinating second I fell in love with
the chant liturgy when I was a freshman
in college first semester music history
is basically the story of music in the
early Roman Catholic Church and one of
the first things you learn about is the
monastic life and the chants and songs
that monks sing as part of their daily
routine so three years ago when I was
about to go into rehearsals for Dayton
operas production of Aida I was looking
for a place where I could get away for a
few days clear my head and just study
the Opera and I realized that the answer
was three and a half hours south of
Dayton at Gethsemane one of the most
powerful experiences I had during that
first retreat to the abbey was running
into an old friend of mine
Don Hawke retired first trombone of the
Milwaukee Symphony Orchestra someone I
hadn’t seen in more than 10 years Don
and I found ourselves sitting next to
each other at lunch one day eating in
silence and gazing out at the
incomparable beauty of late winter
turning into early spring we didn’t say
a word
but the silence we shared was amazing
you’d think after all those years we’d
have lots to talk about and we did later
on we got together on a bench outside
the Abbey to catch up and reminisce but
somehow
I felt as if we said more to each other
during that wordless lunch then when we
actually spoke and that’s when I
realized for the first time the true
power of silence silence of course is an
important element of music to music is
made up of notes but when there aren’t
notes there are rests and every rest is
a silence musical silences can be quite
short here’s the shortest one I know the
silence that begins Beethoven’s fifth
symphony fourteen one hundredths of a
second
it’s the tiny sliver of time between
when you first see the next slide and
when you first hear the music for me
that itty-bitty little silence is like
the instant of the Big Bang setting off
an explosion that creates an entire
musical universe now if that’s maybe the
shortest silence in all of music this is
probably the longest four minutes and 33
seconds by the bad boy of classical
music John Cage I think this is the most
important piece of music of the 20th
century and I know it’s the most
misunderstood that’s because four
minutes and 33 seconds is really four
minutes and 33 seconds of silence but
it’s no joke Cage was dead serious when
he wrote it in 1952 for pianist David
tutor who premiered it at the Maverick
concert hall in Woodstock New York
maverick is an amazing building with
walls open to the outside so when David
Tudor sat at the piano for 4 minutes and
33 seconds and never played a note there
wasn’t silence the audience could hear
the sounds of
danger all around them and that’s what
cage was after he wanted his audience to
listen to four minutes and 33 seconds of
the world with the same attention and
the same concentration that they would
normally devote to four and a half
minutes of Mozart or Beethoven or Brahms
when the piece is performed and it does
get performed it’s usually done in three
movements as David Tudor first played it
this is what the sheet music looks like
the first movement is thirty seconds of
silence tacit is music lingo for don’t
play then comes two minutes and 23
seconds of silence and finally one
minute and 40 seconds of silence with
the beginning and end of each movement
marked by the opening and closing of the
piano lid now you know how they say
there’s an app for that well there’s an
app for that
an app that lets you record and then
upload your own performances so let’s
make TEDx Dayton History and record one
on my iPhone right now we’re not in the
Maverick concert hall with walls open to
nature but we can try to create our own
urban equivalent right now TEDx
volunteers are going to start opening
the doors to the theater
not just the doors to the auditorium but
also the doors to the outside that’s so
we can let the sounds of the world
around us join with the silence to focus
our attention and our listening for
minutes and 33 seconds is about going
inside yourself like the monks and
opening yourself up to the music of the
world around you even if it’s cars and
buses in the streets of Dayton Ohio so
let’s do it
[Music]
so what are the lessons we can learn
from four minutes and 33 seconds besides
the fact they’re a whole bunch of people
talking in the lobby who missed my talk
try to find some silence in your life
[Applause]
it doesn’t have to be four and a half
minutes it’s hard start with maybe start
with four seconds then try 33 seconds
work your way up even a few moments of
silence can make a real difference in
your life
calming your soul and opening your
perception when silence does find you
try not to fill it as we continue our
day of listening here at TEDx dating
let’s try to have the experience of four
minutes and 33 seconds in form the way
we listen the rest of the day don’t sit
back and relax sit up and listen like
your life depends on it
I’ll leave you with one final beautiful
bit of serendipity three years ago when
I went on that first retreat to
Gethsemane Abbey my wife did me a favor
and packed my suitcase for me I didn’t
look at it till I got there and when I
opened my suitcase I found this my four
minutes and 33 seconds t-shirt Lisa had
no idea what it was or how significant
it was for her it was just a nice clean
t-shirt somewhere near the top of the
pile but before I left the Abbey to
return to Dayton and Aida and the hubbub
of everyday life
I put on the shirt went outside the
entrance to the retreat house and took
my first-ever selfie
[Applause]
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
Please follow and like us: