
I’m Lise Howard I am a political
scientist I’m a professor here at
Georgetown and I am a student of
peacekeeping today I want to talk about
peacekeeping because I’ve been studying
it for more than twenty years I want to
talk about the origins of peacekeeping
peacekeeping success and failure rates
and peacekeeping operations I want to
talk about how peacekeepers use power
and distinguish peacekeeping from war
fighting it’s important to get a handle
on what’s going on in peacekeeping
because peacekeepers are the most
numerous type of troop in the world
today in conflict zones there are nearly
100,000 peacekeepers deployed in 15
different conflicts across the world
peacekeepers save millions of lives and
they’re the best method we’ve devised to
help in those transitions from war to
peace they’re the best way we’ve come up
with to secure the peace especially
after civil wars so I want to start
today by talking about my favorite
disrupter and the person who came up
with this idea in the first place and
that is dr. Ralph Bunche dr. bunch led
an extraordinary life he he was active
in the American civil rights movement he
was active in the world movement to
decolonize he helped to draft the
Universal Declaration of Human Rights he
worked alongside Eleanor Roosevelt and
drafting this document that enshrines
our basic moral principles that as human
beings we all enjoy the right to elect
our representatives the right to protest
those representatives the right to life
liberty security the right to freedom
from what the right to freedom of
religion these basic noble ideals that
lie at the foundation of every just free
and open society so after World War two
there a conflict broke out in the Middle
East and the founding of Israel Israel
was at war with its neighbors and they
asked dr. bunch to mediate this conflict
in the Middle East in the course of
those mediations he came up with this
crazy idea of using soldiers not to
fight a war but to help secure the peace
so in the course of mediating it became
very clear that none of the warring
parties was going to sign on to a peace
deal unless there was some kind of third
force third party that would help make
sure that everybody was living up to
what they’d signed up to in the peace
deal and so in the course of these
negotiations they realized that this
force would have to be impartial so that
everybody would agree that they could
deploy and monitor the ceasefire lines
that the force would deploy with the
consent of all the warring factions and
also that these troops would promise to
use force only in self-defense that they
would not use force now for this peace
deal
dr. bunch won the Nobel Peace Prize in
1950 and these three principles that
came out of this event impartiality
consent in the non use of force
those remain the founding principles of
peacekeeping today nearly 70 years later
now as a social scientist I like to
think about measuring things that’s what
we do we try to think about success and
failure and how to measure success and
failure some of my colleagues have come
up with measurements for how to evaluate
peacekeepers well they’re deployed in
the field
and they’ve demonstrated that when
peacekeepers are present in the midst of
conflict they correlate with a lot of
things you would like to see they
correlate with fewer civilian casualties
with fewer battle deaths of military
deaths they somehow they correlate with
a geographic contraction of the conflict
in my own work I’m measuring
peacekeeping differently I’m looking at
the big multi-dimensional missions in
civil wars these are these big missions
that try to help in the transition from
war to peace they help in reconstituting
the political social economic and legal
institutions of the state to make sure
that the state moves away from violence
toward peace now since the end of the
Cold War the UN has completed 15 of
these big multi-dimensional missions and
of those 15 the US the UN has
successfully completed its mandate in
ten places and all of these countries
it’s not to say that every one of these
countries is a model democracy today but
I will say that even after the
peacekeepers left not one has returned
to full-scale civil war in the way that
the that the place was experiencing war
before the peacekeepers arrived so just
to give a sense of where all these
countries are we have El Salvador and
Guatemala
in Central America Namibia Mozambique
Burundi sierra leone cote d’ivoire in
africa Croatia in the eastern slavonia
and region of Croatia in Europe Cambodia
and East Timor
so these missions have successfully
implemented their mandates in many
regions of the world and I just want to
point out that of these ten we had Co
deployed in for missions actual military
forces we had NATO Co deployed alongside
the UN peacekeepers in eastern civil
an australian led Coalition of the
Willing in Timor Leste British special
forces in Sierra Leone and in Kosovo we
had French troops alongside the
peacekeepers and this division of labour
worked in those cases now alongside all
of these cases of success we have the
four devastating failures and if you
know anything about peacekeeping you’ve
probably heard about these starting at
Somalia Angola didn’t get as much press
even though it should have Rwanda and
and the genocide in Bosnia during these
terrible tragedies peacekeepers watched
while the slaughter occurred and no
other militaries intervened to halt the
conflict we recent from this time people
started saying maybe peacekeepers should
get a little tougher maybe they should
become more robust maybe we should give
peacekeepers the mandate to use force
and as I’m I’ve demonstrated in a
forthcoming article with my co-author
Angela Dayal we have shown that all
peacekeeping mandates the complex
mandates now have the mandate to use
force and peacekeeping is not going very
well in many places we have our most
recent our 15th mission that recently
concluded in Haiti and I don’t know
which column that one’s going to fall
into but I do know that peacekeepers
brought cholera to Haiti and that in
Haiti and elsewhere peacekeepers have
committed sexual exploitation and abuse
and sometimes in the course of
fulfilling these robust mandates they
have killed some of the very people they
they were sent to protect
peacekeepers make wrong choices because
they are human but because they are
peacekeepers they have to be held to a
very high standard of accountability and
we don’t have the standards and
accountability measures that we need
when peacekeepers don’t practice what
they preach
they undermine their primary source of
power which is the power of persuasion
so I’m suggesting now that peacekeepers
use persuasion to accomplish their goals
as a political scientist we like to talk
about power power is the ability to get
somebody to do something they otherwise
wouldn’t do and I think of power as
being operative in three basic ways we
have persuasion I use my words this is
what ted ted ted talks are about right i
use my words to persuade you
it is not material in nature we have two
other basic forms of power inducement
and coercion
those are both material it’s about
carrots and sticks inducement is about
giving carrots and taking them away and
forming institutions to shape behavior
coercion is about the stick I see these
three forms of power operating in a lot
of different places in a lot of
different ways as a parent I can say
that I’ve tried them out on occasion
just kidding about the last one
peacekeepers when they’re most effective
exercise persuasion they have these big
information and education campaigns
where they could try to convey the basic
messages in the Universal Declaration of
Human Rights they mediate disputes
before they escalate into violence they
use their powers of persuasion to keep
the peace
they also induce by providing things
that people need when they’re recovering
from a civil war veterinary assistants
health assistants
mental assistance and they try to
reconstruct those basic institutions of
the state they don’t do it themselves
they help people figure out how to
construct institutions and then there’s
coercion peacekeepers sort of use
coercion and they sort of don’t and it’s
a little hard to get a handle on exactly
what they’re doing so I’m relying now on
my colleague Robert arts typology of
military power he and other military
theorists have argued that there are
four basic types of military power
we have Compellent which is about the
kinetic use of force think what we’re
doing now to defeat Isis there’s defense
I defend against someone’s attack
there’s deterrence when you try to
prevent an outbreak of violence from the
very beginning that requires a second
strike capacity and then there’s swagger
and swagger is a little hard to
understand swagger is a little more
about persuasion so I’m gonna use some
pictures now from my field research in
the Central African Republic to
illustrate what I’m talking about now in
the Central African Republic
peacekeepers word Co deployed alongside
a French military operation and that
French force the stabilization force
exercised compel ‘its to achieve it
their goals they deployed in 2013 and
indeed they stabilized the Central
African Republic to restore order
drawing mainly on the power of
Compellent
now in contrast peacekeepers have been
using other forms of military power
peacekeepers in this case they look very
different it actually in all cases they
look very different from war fighting
troops peacekeepers patrol in white
vehicles they wear blue hats and blue
helmets to signal that there
there to hide or to fight in this
instance they’re dependent they’re
defending the parliamentary building and
they’re probably exercising some measure
of deterrence here again is an example
of peacekeepers both exercising defense
and a little bit of deterrence and then
there’s swagger swagger is about making
yourself feel strong it’s about looking
strong here we have this is and in the
countryside in the Central African
Republic we see mangoes on the ground
because none of the factories are
working and the farms aren’t working to
harvest and process the mangoes we have
peacekeepers patrolling in a white
vehicle which signals their humanitarian
mission with an anti-aircraft gun bolted
to the back of the pickup truck and the
guys were saying that if they tried to
fire so this isn’t a this isn’t a
conflict where no one is fighting in the
air there aren’t any planes in the air
nobody has that kind of capacity
nevertheless they’re patrolling with an
anti-aircraft gun the guys were saying
that if they tried to fire that gun
horizontally it might knock over the
truck so what are they doing what is
this this in my mind is an instance of
swagger they’re trying to feel and look
tough and indeed we do that in a variety
of settings but most of what
peacekeepers are doing is engaging in
persuasion they’re practicing persuasion
they’re there patrolling on foot they’re
mediating disputes they sit at
contentious intersections between rival
groups but they’re often more like gangs
than really than full-scale rebel forces
they do their best to protect civilians
they mediate disputes before they move
into violent conflict peacekeeping is
not
fighting militaries have proven
effective at using the power of
Compellent peacekeepers have proven
effective at using other forms of power
short of military Compellent
peacekeeping is most effective when it
holds tight to those ideas of
impartiality consent and the non use of
force
except in self-defense when peacekeepers
hold tight to those noble ideals
enshrined in the Universal Declaration
of Human Rights they have and may
continue to accomplish their goals
because as Ralph Bunche argued hearts
are strongest when they beat in response
to noble ideals
thank you
[Applause]
scientist I’m a professor here at
Georgetown and I am a student of
peacekeeping today I want to talk about
peacekeeping because I’ve been studying
it for more than twenty years I want to
talk about the origins of peacekeeping
peacekeeping success and failure rates
and peacekeeping operations I want to
talk about how peacekeepers use power
and distinguish peacekeeping from war
fighting it’s important to get a handle
on what’s going on in peacekeeping
because peacekeepers are the most
numerous type of troop in the world
today in conflict zones there are nearly
100,000 peacekeepers deployed in 15
different conflicts across the world
peacekeepers save millions of lives and
they’re the best method we’ve devised to
help in those transitions from war to
peace they’re the best way we’ve come up
with to secure the peace especially
after civil wars so I want to start
today by talking about my favorite
disrupter and the person who came up
with this idea in the first place and
that is dr. Ralph Bunche dr. bunch led
an extraordinary life he he was active
in the American civil rights movement he
was active in the world movement to
decolonize he helped to draft the
Universal Declaration of Human Rights he
worked alongside Eleanor Roosevelt and
drafting this document that enshrines
our basic moral principles that as human
beings we all enjoy the right to elect
our representatives the right to protest
those representatives the right to life
liberty security the right to freedom
from what the right to freedom of
religion these basic noble ideals that
lie at the foundation of every just free
and open society so after World War two
there a conflict broke out in the Middle
East and the founding of Israel Israel
was at war with its neighbors and they
asked dr. bunch to mediate this conflict
in the Middle East in the course of
those mediations he came up with this
crazy idea of using soldiers not to
fight a war but to help secure the peace
so in the course of mediating it became
very clear that none of the warring
parties was going to sign on to a peace
deal unless there was some kind of third
force third party that would help make
sure that everybody was living up to
what they’d signed up to in the peace
deal and so in the course of these
negotiations they realized that this
force would have to be impartial so that
everybody would agree that they could
deploy and monitor the ceasefire lines
that the force would deploy with the
consent of all the warring factions and
also that these troops would promise to
use force only in self-defense that they
would not use force now for this peace
deal
dr. bunch won the Nobel Peace Prize in
1950 and these three principles that
came out of this event impartiality
consent in the non use of force
those remain the founding principles of
peacekeeping today nearly 70 years later
now as a social scientist I like to
think about measuring things that’s what
we do we try to think about success and
failure and how to measure success and
failure some of my colleagues have come
up with measurements for how to evaluate
peacekeepers well they’re deployed in
the field
and they’ve demonstrated that when
peacekeepers are present in the midst of
conflict they correlate with a lot of
things you would like to see they
correlate with fewer civilian casualties
with fewer battle deaths of military
deaths they somehow they correlate with
a geographic contraction of the conflict
in my own work I’m measuring
peacekeeping differently I’m looking at
the big multi-dimensional missions in
civil wars these are these big missions
that try to help in the transition from
war to peace they help in reconstituting
the political social economic and legal
institutions of the state to make sure
that the state moves away from violence
toward peace now since the end of the
Cold War the UN has completed 15 of
these big multi-dimensional missions and
of those 15 the US the UN has
successfully completed its mandate in
ten places and all of these countries
it’s not to say that every one of these
countries is a model democracy today but
I will say that even after the
peacekeepers left not one has returned
to full-scale civil war in the way that
the that the place was experiencing war
before the peacekeepers arrived so just
to give a sense of where all these
countries are we have El Salvador and
Guatemala
in Central America Namibia Mozambique
Burundi sierra leone cote d’ivoire in
africa Croatia in the eastern slavonia
and region of Croatia in Europe Cambodia
and East Timor
so these missions have successfully
implemented their mandates in many
regions of the world and I just want to
point out that of these ten we had Co
deployed in for missions actual military
forces we had NATO Co deployed alongside
the UN peacekeepers in eastern civil
an australian led Coalition of the
Willing in Timor Leste British special
forces in Sierra Leone and in Kosovo we
had French troops alongside the
peacekeepers and this division of labour
worked in those cases now alongside all
of these cases of success we have the
four devastating failures and if you
know anything about peacekeeping you’ve
probably heard about these starting at
Somalia Angola didn’t get as much press
even though it should have Rwanda and
and the genocide in Bosnia during these
terrible tragedies peacekeepers watched
while the slaughter occurred and no
other militaries intervened to halt the
conflict we recent from this time people
started saying maybe peacekeepers should
get a little tougher maybe they should
become more robust maybe we should give
peacekeepers the mandate to use force
and as I’m I’ve demonstrated in a
forthcoming article with my co-author
Angela Dayal we have shown that all
peacekeeping mandates the complex
mandates now have the mandate to use
force and peacekeeping is not going very
well in many places we have our most
recent our 15th mission that recently
concluded in Haiti and I don’t know
which column that one’s going to fall
into but I do know that peacekeepers
brought cholera to Haiti and that in
Haiti and elsewhere peacekeepers have
committed sexual exploitation and abuse
and sometimes in the course of
fulfilling these robust mandates they
have killed some of the very people they
they were sent to protect
peacekeepers make wrong choices because
they are human but because they are
peacekeepers they have to be held to a
very high standard of accountability and
we don’t have the standards and
accountability measures that we need
when peacekeepers don’t practice what
they preach
they undermine their primary source of
power which is the power of persuasion
so I’m suggesting now that peacekeepers
use persuasion to accomplish their goals
as a political scientist we like to talk
about power power is the ability to get
somebody to do something they otherwise
wouldn’t do and I think of power as
being operative in three basic ways we
have persuasion I use my words this is
what ted ted ted talks are about right i
use my words to persuade you
it is not material in nature we have two
other basic forms of power inducement
and coercion
those are both material it’s about
carrots and sticks inducement is about
giving carrots and taking them away and
forming institutions to shape behavior
coercion is about the stick I see these
three forms of power operating in a lot
of different places in a lot of
different ways as a parent I can say
that I’ve tried them out on occasion
just kidding about the last one
peacekeepers when they’re most effective
exercise persuasion they have these big
information and education campaigns
where they could try to convey the basic
messages in the Universal Declaration of
Human Rights they mediate disputes
before they escalate into violence they
use their powers of persuasion to keep
the peace
they also induce by providing things
that people need when they’re recovering
from a civil war veterinary assistants
health assistants
mental assistance and they try to
reconstruct those basic institutions of
the state they don’t do it themselves
they help people figure out how to
construct institutions and then there’s
coercion peacekeepers sort of use
coercion and they sort of don’t and it’s
a little hard to get a handle on exactly
what they’re doing so I’m relying now on
my colleague Robert arts typology of
military power he and other military
theorists have argued that there are
four basic types of military power
we have Compellent which is about the
kinetic use of force think what we’re
doing now to defeat Isis there’s defense
I defend against someone’s attack
there’s deterrence when you try to
prevent an outbreak of violence from the
very beginning that requires a second
strike capacity and then there’s swagger
and swagger is a little hard to
understand swagger is a little more
about persuasion so I’m gonna use some
pictures now from my field research in
the Central African Republic to
illustrate what I’m talking about now in
the Central African Republic
peacekeepers word Co deployed alongside
a French military operation and that
French force the stabilization force
exercised compel ‘its to achieve it
their goals they deployed in 2013 and
indeed they stabilized the Central
African Republic to restore order
drawing mainly on the power of
Compellent
now in contrast peacekeepers have been
using other forms of military power
peacekeepers in this case they look very
different it actually in all cases they
look very different from war fighting
troops peacekeepers patrol in white
vehicles they wear blue hats and blue
helmets to signal that there
there to hide or to fight in this
instance they’re dependent they’re
defending the parliamentary building and
they’re probably exercising some measure
of deterrence here again is an example
of peacekeepers both exercising defense
and a little bit of deterrence and then
there’s swagger swagger is about making
yourself feel strong it’s about looking
strong here we have this is and in the
countryside in the Central African
Republic we see mangoes on the ground
because none of the factories are
working and the farms aren’t working to
harvest and process the mangoes we have
peacekeepers patrolling in a white
vehicle which signals their humanitarian
mission with an anti-aircraft gun bolted
to the back of the pickup truck and the
guys were saying that if they tried to
fire so this isn’t a this isn’t a
conflict where no one is fighting in the
air there aren’t any planes in the air
nobody has that kind of capacity
nevertheless they’re patrolling with an
anti-aircraft gun the guys were saying
that if they tried to fire that gun
horizontally it might knock over the
truck so what are they doing what is
this this in my mind is an instance of
swagger they’re trying to feel and look
tough and indeed we do that in a variety
of settings but most of what
peacekeepers are doing is engaging in
persuasion they’re practicing persuasion
they’re there patrolling on foot they’re
mediating disputes they sit at
contentious intersections between rival
groups but they’re often more like gangs
than really than full-scale rebel forces
they do their best to protect civilians
they mediate disputes before they move
into violent conflict peacekeeping is
not
fighting militaries have proven
effective at using the power of
Compellent peacekeepers have proven
effective at using other forms of power
short of military Compellent
peacekeeping is most effective when it
holds tight to those ideas of
impartiality consent and the non use of
force
except in self-defense when peacekeepers
hold tight to those noble ideals
enshrined in the Universal Declaration
of Human Rights they have and may
continue to accomplish their goals
because as Ralph Bunche argued hearts
are strongest when they beat in response
to noble ideals
thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: