Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Power of a Simple Idea | Jody Hoffer Gittell | TEDxRochester


[Music]

you

so my idea is really simple think about

the work you do think about all the

people you work with it organized like

this so organized more like this what

difference does it make

well I’ve always been interested in how

people work together I think it’s

because I grew up on a farm twelve

thousand chickens it seemed like we were

always working and it really seemed to

make a difference how we did it whether

we were taking care of the chickens

whether we’re candy Tomatoes working in

the garden you know did we do it well

didn’t do it quickly did we have time to

play even play with inventing things

like pillows for towels and lanterns

made out of fireflies but it really

seemed to matter and and it was fun so

you know fast forward a few years and

one year a glue came through the county

Lancaster County and almost all of our

chickens died so I remember that day

when a couple of men and dark suits and

shiny shoes came crunching down the lane

not to take over the farm but to recruit

my dad to work in real estate and he did

few years later my mom joined him they

were used to working together and

somebody moved into town and it seemed

like life went to from talking about

farming to talking about real estate I

have about ten years later they started

their own company and it became the

largest real estate company in Lancaster

County

Associates but what I really noticed was

the way they worked with people whether

it was the farm whether it was a real

estate company there was something kind

of similar it was whether they were

working with each other with their

colleagues with their clients with the

builders the bankers the lawyers they

really strive to build relationships of

shared bowls shared knowledge mutual

respect throughout their network of kind

of harmonious way of working and getting

something sometimes very difficult work

done but I wasn’t really interested in

farming or real estate it wasn’t really

my thing

I did a lot of jobs you know I painted

houses I worked at the gap I waited

tables

I taught migrant farm workers in Oregon

I taught city kids in Brooklyn and I

lock it in DC but what really interested

me is how people work together

particularly how do we work together to

create value so I became a social

scientist and when I eventually went off

to MIT to get my my PhD and

I wanted to study that more as the

colleagues said you should shake the

check out the airline’s they’re going

through some really tough times right

now and you know it’s kind of a

transition in the industry you might

really learn something about how people

work together what what difference does

it make

so I go off to Logan Airport to watch

how people do it you know that’s the way

I think one great way to study things is

just like like the rig hearing just go

watch it and talk to people and hear

what they’re thinking about their work

and this is kind of what I was hearing

you know people felt like they were in

their little bubble you know doing their

job and they were in a hard time getting

timely communication from other people

and they needed it accurate

communication people didn’t share their

faults and didn’t seem to understand

each other’s jobs they did seem to

message filters back for their jobs and

when things went wrong a lot finger

pointing rather but problem solving and

you can tell there’s a lot of

frustration so it’s like pretty strong

ties within it at these bubbles but

across it starting to break down and the

station manager Lynne Heitmann

watson was really frustrated as well and

my interview with her was like her exit

interview not only was she leaving

America she was leaving the industry she

had had but she did say as she was

leaving you know you should study

Southwest what’s that who’s that but I

figured it out they hadn’t come to the

Northeast yet

and I got access and started to study

this other airline and you know

interviewing people watching what they

did and it seemed like there were some

real differences they talked about

having the same goals

you know they each had different jobs

but we’re you know we’re here to get you

there on time with your luggage and

happy and so on safely and they seemed

to understand each other’s job not just

their own job and how it connected and

to feel respect for each other’s work

that’s just important as the pilot you

know no one departments any more

important than the other the kind of

things you would hear and so I thought

this could be really interesting this

could be driving outcomes that any

organization might care about

so I expanded my stanbow several sites

in Southwest American and United and

continental and figured out how do I

measure these things so it came up with

seven questions these what I call

relationships and communication and ask

people to answer them about each of the

functions each of the work groups

involved in their work process if you

develop basically a network measure and

got a lot of input from our flight

transportation lab on the other side of

campus that have been management school

and there are at the very end arenda but

you go track them down they know a lot

about measuring outcomes and how to risk

adjust and so on so what I eventually

found and this is that

I have a snapshot of a lot of regression

models but that these pas risk-adjusted

quality performance outcomes are very

tied to the strength of those sites

across workgroups something that’s

pretty invisible driving something that

managers are trying very hard to achieve

and not only to get the high quality but

to do it efficiently not that they can

offer the low fare and not go on

business so I thought this was

interesting and my colleagues at MIT

thought it was pretty interesting too

but they thought you know maybe this is

just an airline thing or maybe just a

Southwest thing and I don’t think so I

thought it was bigger than that about

that time I went into the hospital – for

the first time ever as a patient had my

being first me arose and so the next day

I wasn’t thinking about too much while

she was being born

except her but the next day I noticed

that my nurses were working really well

together

and you know one we’re coming to say I

know you’ve heard about this they just

wanted to reinforce it and tell you

about that all these people buzzing

around a lot of information to say again

as a new parent and if you know this is

really impressive

are you that you’ve been working on your

coordination and one moves that now

we’ve been doing TQM and it’s working

great and then I said a little later

where’s my doctor come

oh we don’t know they don’t tell us

anything but okay this could be a

challenge here to where in these bubbles

are silos people have the same job they

understand each other’s work their

respective and goal that doesn’t always

happen that way but tends to and then

across where the coordination needs to

happen as well things start to break

down so it’s under study this and that

became my first study a few years later

when I started teaching at Harvard

Business School and that was the first

study of

Airlines and I found nine hospitals that

were doing you know high volumes of

joint replacements and in New York

Dallas and Boston and measured the same

ties across the people who were involved

in joint replacement surgeries surgeons

nurses physical therapists case manager

social workers and measured these

outcomes again with partnership with

colleagues who really know the industry

know the outcomes and I found something

pretty similar going on here and so I

wasn’t surprised at this point I have

expected given all the interdependence

and uncertainty and of the work this was

probably going to matter for performance

but when I’ve talked to some people were

surprised I remember a conversation with

a surgeon who said quiet leave me

I believe the findings and read the

articles you know but it’s hard for me

and my colleagues to realize it’s not

just what we’re doing on the operating

table that matters you know that was

looking here these outcomes include

laying the stay patient satisfaction for

clinical outcomes and it really was

driven not just by the skill of the

surgeon but by this whole set of

connections this whole coordination

across this team so not so surprising

but and I didn’t really come away with

this sense of based on my research you

really can’t blame the individuals

involved here because if you think about

it go back to that organization chart

that’s how we often organize the work

the people are accountable for outcomes

in their own silo that are rewarded for

their outcomes and they’re all side

except selected and trained pretty much

to focus on their own job and even

conflict resolution tends to happen up

and down the silos not necessarily

across where the patient journey goes so

it’s just it’s something kind of built

into the situation and as I did this

research about that cross-cutting

structures where they existed predicted

higher RC and higher performance

outcomes but we’re not there in many

cases so fast-forward to 2011 just I

don’t know what it was about that year

but several people I’d never met

approached me either by phone or email

or some came to visit to say you know

this is cool research but I think it

could really help us in practice too we

could use this tool as an organizational

change kind of method and I said well

that’s way over my head but go for it

and let me watch what you do and some

things in common so we find an

organization like many of is struggling

with coordination create change team

needs some leaders bunch of people from

frontline different stakeholders and

then often will do an assessment a

measurement of relational coordination

to see how are we doing on these

dimensions you know where the weak ties

where the strong ties and they say it’s

kind of like looking in the mirror

together or putting the elephant on the

table or and candidates sometimes say we

put the Moose on the table so you can

all kind of look at it together but it’s

really just looking at our own data and

helping us see and have conversations

that we don’t usually see like oh you

know we’re kind of weak

communication well what’s timely for you

guys oh well I didn’t realize if we come

here in the morning around early

afternoon to check out the patient we

can get them out sooner and you know

we’re low on shared knowledge well what

do you guys do how does it relate to our

job all right we’re having a problem

here with respect but what is respect

with like for you so it starts to open

up this and humble inquiry that can lead

to solutions and it’s not top demo and

it’s not rocket science

but some of these solutions are kind of

redesigned of our basic structure some

of them are micro structures like we

should have morning Huddle’s you know

that might work and you can experiment

with them because now you know what

you’re trying to get to so you have an

experiment some of them are macro

structures like we need a different kind

of accountability so that we’re not just

siloed and that might involve people

higher in the organization and reward

structures might have to talk to you

taters if you’re in the healthcare

industry

so there’s their macro things that

aren’t that easy to pull off and their

micro structures that we can change

right away but often the conversations

really do revolve around these

dimensions and they’re fairly simple to

fix because these are not like really

challenging concepts the word relational

coordination is a little complicated but

the underlying ideas are really simple

so where’s the work I mean I think one

thing I work now has gone beyond the US

and healthcare you know just looking

patient care people have been working

with this in Canada and UK and Ireland

and Denmark Sweden in Norway they do

tend to like it quite a bit

Australia Japan Netherlands so it’s

really fun to see people take a really

simple idea and make it work in their

own very unique environments and talk

about unique I’ve got colleagues now

we’re looking at this some of them in

their dissertation some in role like

work banking in Pakistan and retail in

China construction industry in Norway

where I go talk to them and in two weeks

about what they’re doing there and an

even immigrant integration into Swedish

communities and how do we think about

connecting across the community to

integrate new immigrants into our into

our society but I think what it is is

basically a very simple idea and it

basically suggests we have the power to

change our organizations but we often

don’t even realize it and it involves

first of all this kind of shift or maybe

flip in the way we look at our

organizations do we see them as that org

chart which basically suggests that the

coordination that we need is happening

up here and down here we’re just

basically doing our own jobs

is there no lines there pretty much only

connected up here or do we see that

Network where any of those lines might

might be necessary and we’ve got any

paying attention to who we might need to

communicate with at any moment rather

than waiting for that coordination to

happen up here that it’s not going to

happen most organizations are too

complex it gets overloaded very quickly

when you try to centralize like that so

it’s a big aha we’re so there are two

places where I think are very cool down

to share our I think some of the new

frontiers are one of them is Billy Safe

Communities and some of this work is

happening in Massachusetts cities where

you know getting to get a youth

advocates with people from the district

attorney’s office and the police of the

probation officers and the schools and

you know even the faith communities to

talk about you know what is that that

we’re doing that’s not working here and

can we build some of these bridges

across our differences so that we can

accomplish we can address substance

abuse and use violence and so on and

these aren’t easy conversations I’ve

with

some of them and they basically get down

to you know you guys just enter the

school-to-prison pipeline are we going

to do something about this you know

because there are different interests

and how do we find that shared goal and

start to work around it you see there

are some strong ties and you know we can

recognize those but those orange ones

are where they’re like seriously me

tights at the start and we’ll see what

comes after all the work they’re doing

another one that I’m really passionate

about educating our students I think

this is another cool frontier for RC

work because if you think about it

schools like most of our industries have

inherited bureaucracy they’ve been

around forever so of course we’ve got

these bureaucratic models where students

sitting there classroom teachers pretty

much do their own thing and there’s not

a lot of connecting but when you think

about the innovations in education and

in the workplace that we’re preparing

our students to go out and succeed in

it’s not about sitting there in a chair

and telling what you know it’s about

performing it’s about connecting it’s

about doing things which requires a very

collaborative school community whether

you call it competency-based learning

student-centered learning projects such

as learning it’s really about connecting

across a lot of these levels to and with

students and Families

in order to to build those capabilities

so I think it’s really promising and

think there’s some work I’m going to go

on here at Rochester certainly Boston

and I’m very excited about it we got a

lot of people talking here today about

education so I know we all care about it

it’s our future so just to sum up you

know you can take the simple idea things

like most simple ideas they they apply a

lot of places you know it’s not like the

Golden Rule or anything but you know

there’s there’s some ideas that they’re

so basic but a lot of the things we’re

talking about here today that you could

translate them into many kinds

many industries and sectors that’s what

makes maybe an idea we’re spreading it’s

so simple but it first of all requires a

kind of different way of looking at

things that we’ve heard a lot in this

case and different way of looking at our

organizations rather those charts that

suggest that the only connections are

needed up here to a network map where

you can see the opportunities for so

many more connections that could be

really productive and create value so I

would encourage you so you know it

applies globally but I also like to

think that people up and say it works

really well at home to try on your

teenagers and that’s kind of a cool

thing that you can think about how to

use this at home think about how it

might change the way you do the work

like change the way you think about your

community and the whose job is it to

organize the community or going to the

neighborhood so I would suggest you just

give it a try thank you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: