Press "Enter" to skip to content

The phenomenon Donald Trump – did the media cause it? | Ulrik Haagerup | TEDxLinz


I’m a journalist I know sorry about that

I think the world needs better news more

than ever I’m here today to tell you how

and why I have to change my colleagues

and the news industry has to change and

how we can reinstall journalism and

earth or as an authority in societies

where there none left it’s not easy but

we need to do it sometimes you need to

step in front of the mirror and take the

consequence of what you see of you what

you see normally in the news industry we

just break the glass but maybe we need

to shape up a little bit and I went into

journalism 30 years ago because I wanted

to tell important stories to people

about their life and the world in order

for them to make up their own lives and

then my career went on and suddenly I

realized maybe I spent most of the time

doing stories that were good for my

career that my editors liked that

created good headlines that were being

quoted one me prices and was part of the

news culture that I had become part of

and that part of doing good for society

maybe I forgotten that a little bit not

that I was telling stories that were

untruthful but my ambition about doing

something what that was right maybe I’d

forgotten that a little bit and that’s

the problem have you ever thought about

journalism saying why are you so

negative have you ever thought about

that if you do you’re not alone millions

of people around the world have left for

additional news because they think news

is too depressing

it is disengaging especially women

especially young people turn their backs

on traditional news because now they

have alternatives they just go on

Facebook and be reassured about that

picture of the world from the 255

closest friends is that good for

democracy maybe not maybe we need to do

something but each time somebody has

criticized me or my colleagues for being

knit to- doing something wrong we just

don’t want them and we say to

politicians you just want to avoid our

critical questions CEOs criticizing us

we say you just want free airtime

professors in journalism whatever

academia comes and say you do something

wrong we say you are sitting in your

tower you don’t know anything about

journalism and you’re not journalists we

don’t want to listen to you and our

neighbors they just plain stupid so

we’re just all the time people are

accusing us of something we say we’re

just journalists and we do what

journalists have always done so shut up

we know best I’m here today to tell you

maybe not this is this is the fact if we

when we go to you know you know you know

editors day it is we in Denmark we have

editors day you know the day of the cat

the day of the dog the day of Mother’s

and whatever Mother’s Day we have

editors day where editors are good to

editors because that’s the only time of

year anyone is good to editors so we do

great speeches again for each others

telling us we under trust business and

everybody applause but look at this this

will go in your country as well but this

is Danish figures who do people believe

with which professions do they trust and

we go up here and we see nurses down and

down here where we real estate agents

journalists and car dealers politicians

if that put prostitutes they would have

been somewhere up here people don’t

trust us

even though we say when the trust

business we are in trouble and if we

keep on doing what we normally do

we’ll probably end up getting the same

results that we always gotten we need to

change something I was lucky enough to

talk through Helmut Schmidt the former

Chancellor of West Germany two years ago

he was at that time 95 years old he got

just got a new girlfriend she was 80 so

I thought there’s hope for everyone and

this man you are knowing about democracy

politics and being a publisher of

deadside also about media he said

something very important he said we live

in media democracies now when media have

become more

and politicians because in media

democracies politicians care more about

their own re-election that about solving

problems of people five years from now

so they spend all their efforts talking

into the news criterium media and if the

media’s news criteria are conflict

crooks drama and victims which are the

tabloid news criteria being adopted by

even serious TV stations and CB serious

newspapers all over the Western world

then journalism and politics become

tabloid and then Helmut Schmidt said

news media no longer help democracy it’s

so full of negativity and media

democracy produce populates not leaders

and then he mentioned one person they

was Berlusconi as one example of a

populist I was wondering if Helmut

Schmidt didn’t die one year ago who do

you think he would have mentioned and

the question is did we create Donald

Trump in the media we were part of it

Donald Trump got free airtime in news

media in 2015 at a time when he was not

big for one point nine billion US

dollars

he didn’t even though he was a billion

billionaire he didn’t spend any of his

own money because he got free airtime

and as he said meteor loves me because

why because he creates conflict

he creates drama and he divides

everybody into crooks and victims crooks

that’s the Mexicans and the Muslims and

the victims are all you but you are

losers I’ll make your winners wait vote

for me that was what happened we have to

ask ourselves important questions one is

what is actually journalism and count

Bernstein of the Watergate coverage once

told me which I’ve never forgotten I

think it’s the best definition of

journalism journalism is not stenography

journalism is the best obtainable

version of the truth so my moment of

truth came one Friday night one year

after got my present job as news

director Dr so I was in charge of all

newse also on TV and I was coming home

late Friday evening you know Friday

evening come home late huh finally

weekend and you’re sitting there the

wife is beautiful and the kids are clean

and there’s red wine in the glass and

there’s jelly in the jar and there’s a

movie later and who knows what will

happen later would be a fantastic

weekend but first we have to watch the

news because that’s what grown-up people

do in order to get the best obtainable

version of the truth right so here it

came welcome to TV a reason there’s a

terror threat against Denmark shooting

incident in Copenhagen new regional

trains not delivered on time they from

Italy what did they expect so I feel

cancer is now a dangerous for young

girls strike among bus drivers continues

woman act up abducted and abused in a

cottage in Sweden we have the pictures

of the courage the crisis and a social

democratic party and the old man runs

for president in u.s. in a crisis called

case bound about an airplane accident

with a few hundred that people begins

and suppress North Koreans works out a

giant mechanical spiders creates fear in

Liverpool and finally the well forecast

the rain continues have a nice evening I

know if I was watching this I was saying

what is this none of these stories are

not traditional good stories fitting in

sound news for cheer but is that an

accurate picture of the world and

Denmark that day or is it just what we

call news problem that I started reading

newspapers watching satellite television

all over the world and I saw global

illness all over the world we think a

good story is a bad story the rest is

not I went to the BBC to have a talk for

them I was very proud and I took a

screenshot of that morning’s bbc.com

page from BBC News to see because we all

look at BBC because what they do is the

right journalism so we went there and I

just said just see the world the best

obtainable version of the world that day

and you can go today and you will

probably see the same thing but just see

the words they’re using in the headlines

it’s all about misery walls being peeled

people being killed bad weather whatever

this is good news bad news who wins the

prices this every photographer in the

world wants to win this price the world

press photo competition so they point

their cameras to what they think is the

the right filtering of the world right

so look at the category news pictures in

2015 fantastic pictures but it’s the

only kind of pictures that we think a

good journalism Pulitzer Prize winners

2015 great journalism but just look at

the words there it’s none of the stories

are bad it’s great journalism but it’s

the only kind of journalism that is the

right kind of journalism in our culture

we have to understand that journalism is

a filter a filter between reality and

the public perception of reality so if

we now look at the public perception of

reality what do we find

asking people in this country or in my

country are you now more secure or less

secure than you were 10 years ago people

say I’m less secure it’s a very scary

world and we ask them why and say

because of all the murders because of

all the crime the terrorism the wars and

we say we’re in your city say no in

television and on headlines and online

it’s everywhere and we say the facts of

the world is the rate the murder rate

has never been lower in Denmark the

crime rate has never been lower the

amount of traffic accident has been as

low as since they invented the car in

history of mankind we have never had so

few people killed in wars as right now

despite of Syria but do people know that

no because we don’t report it we haven’t

had so few death due to terrorism in

Europe since 1954 do people know that no

they don’t because we don’t report it

not because we are telling lies but we

don’t we forget to tell the perspective

people have started looking into this

professors test people it do it does

something to your mind

negativity controls news flow and their

fall so politics in the public debate

apathy or fear is the result the risk is

that people not only deselect media

sources for news but also that they

disengage in the public debate and if I

do the head as a journalist as an editor

news director I do a shitty job I have

to do something different this guy do

content analysis all over the world what

is printed as news what it goes into TV

and online and he concludes this

negativity is an illness caught by even

serious newspapers magazine that not at

least TV news broadcasters all over the

world the problem is not that the

numbers are wrong the problem is that

the picture gets wrong look at this

asking people asking people in different

countries about important issues what

are the facts and compare that to the

facts look at France for instance how

many people are Muslims in France the

right number in 2014 when this was done

is 8 percent let’s say it’s 8 point

something today but the average French

voter think that almost 1/3 of all

Frenchmen today are Muslim if you have

in your mind that one-third of your

country have become Muslim who do you

vote for look at the United States 1%

Muslim population but the average

American voters think that the number is

15% and look at this how big is

unemployment look at Italy they have a

big unemployment rate at 12% which is

high but the Italians think that almost

half of a pop of the population are

unemployed where does that come from

look at the United States they had an

unemployment rate of 6% during the

American election it was down to 4.5 but

the Americans think that the

unemployment rate is 32% who do you vote

for then our news culture is still the

good stories a bad story and if nobody

gets mad its advertising we say it comes

from America if it bleeds it leads

that’s the idea not anymore it’s not

true anymore things are going down so we

need to change

Einstein said without changing our

pattern of thought

will not be able to solve the problems

we created with our current pattern of

thought introducing constructive news

what is that is that some kind of North

Korean version of journalism where you

ignore all problems and paint the sky

blue no it’s not it’s not happy news

it’s not the cute little story before

the weather about cats coming down from

trees and other cats on YouTube on

skateboards so we can help people kill

time no it’s about serious matters it’s

a supplement there’s a need to

supplement our news criteria people need

inspiration to solutions stories that

focus on ways out and hope and

constructive news is about possibilities

and people who do something the rest of

us might learn from it’s about seeing

the world with both eyes not only the

eye that will confirm the angle we had

when we start researching that will be

new look at this news breaking news more

and more news organization are focused

on speed we think we can beat Twitter we

can’t the focus on breaking news is now

the goal is speed the questions are what

and when the style is dramatic we play

the role of police dramatic and conflict

and investigative reporting is something

different and I think that’s too little

investigative reporting it’s expensive

it’s difficult but it’s all about

yesterday it’s about placing blame to

find the guilty we asked the question

who and why we’re being critical we play

the role of prosecutor sometimes judge

and we look for crooks and victims and

constructive journalism is adding to

this it’s about tomorrow it’s about

inspiration we ask the questions about

now what and how and we are curious and

we are facilitated of a public debate

about a better tomorrow we focus on

solutions and best practice when we do

stories about lack of doctors and rural

districts in Denmark we do all kind of

stories the consequences people die

because there are no doctor and we ask

the minister and they don’t know and

they say it’s not my fault it’s my

predecessor or the regions or whatever

we do all kind of stories the

constructive angle is looking at other

countries have they had the same problem

and what did they do

look at Norway how do you get people to

move from Oslo and 2,400 kilometers up

there as a doctor and we turn out they

had a problem people didn’t want to live

there because it was dangerous because

there were no doctors so they had to do

something and we did a story about what

did they do lower interest rate for

studio loans or whatever and that

enhanced the quality of the public

debate journalism is a filter it’s a

feedback mechanism to help society self

correct and we have to remember that

does it work

yes ninety-three percent of all people

in Denmark now use news for dr they

didn’t before we’re now the most trusted

news brand both on radio TV and online

and we are now also the biggest news

show on Danish TV and we weren’t before

I can assure you that this is a mega

trend people are trying to experiment do

this all over the world not being very

successful because it’s difficult to

change culture constructive journalism

answers the question of why public media

quality journalism matters to society it

gives someone user clear purpose people

relates the constructive stories are

more engaged in them in tradition than

traditional news say people at wasn’t at

the Huffington Post which is by becoming

the biggest news provider and the world

even the BBC has now one month ago

decided that they will implement

constructive journalism because they

could see they have a problem they call

it solution focused journalism there’s a

book out is even in German now on

Chinese and rendering soon very nice and

has this changed and this is I just took

a running rundown of our news the other

day eight years ago since we started

this mindset change the culture change

in our newsroom and just to see the

words and there won’t go through them

but just look at the weather forecast at

the end even the weather is better so

nothing is more powerful than an idea

whose time has come and you know what

Bob the Builder has a slogan which Obama

stole from him and I think that’s a need

for us to

change and we need to do it more now

than ever we need to remember what

journalism should do in society we need

to be a trusted source for news if we

want to be meaningful

not because of journalism to save

journalism not because to save the news

industry but to help democracy and the

societies we serve it’s about time and

can we fix it yes we can thank you very

much [Applause]

Please follow and like us: