Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Peril and Promise of Strategic Integration | Charles Williams | TEDxBocconiU


David and Goliath the story of the
little guy who through some clever
strategy managed to take down the big
guy we’ve learned telling that story
through the ages and in business we’ve
been telling that story a lot lately
we’ve seen our industrial giants of our
last generation tech firms fall before
startups and upstarts in the cellular
industry which I study a lot we’ve seen
Motorola Nokia rim blackberry they’ve
all gone from completely dominant to bit
player in a handful of years it’s pretty
striking so it’s not surprising we’re
fascinated by the theory of disruptive
innovation it tries to tell us some of
when and why these firms are vulnerable
these dominant players might be
vulnerable and in my own research on the
wireless service industry I’ve found
some suggestive evidence of this power
of startups this effectiveness of
startups when we compare how firms
entering the wireless service industry
grow we compare startups to entrants
established players coming in from
outside we see these startups grow
faster initially whether the time their
growth falls off they enter as
triumphant David’s in terms of growth
but little by little they fall back
until they’re actually growing more
slowly than these established players
and when major change comes to the
industry they fall even further behind
so these established Polar’s actually
seem to have some adaptive advantages we
might be interested in and that’s why I
want to talk today about about a piece
of research that we think may shed some
light on what sorts of advantages these
established players have the to think
about where those advanced
has come from just think of these
startups when they first come in to
cellular cellular industry what
advantages did they have that make them
these fast growers well they’re starting
from scratch they can put the pieces of
their business together so that the the
operations the marketing the pricing all
the elements of the business model
really work together effectively at this
moment of entry they’re masters of
strategic integration but over time
changes happen the industry they require
those parts to be put together in a new
fashion and it appears that the
established players the giant telcos the
cable television companies they’re
actually noticing and reacting to these
changes they’re managing to adapt now
this is mostly speculation theoretical
speculation that we’re trying to
interpret what we find in the growth
data here strategic strategic
integration is awfully difficult to see
in practice it’s difficult to measure
and even if we think we’ve observed it
somewhere it is even harder to say with
confidence that the performance of some
firm is actually the result of this
integration because these companies are
run by smart people they’re doing the
best they have with the elements of the
company and they’re anticipating what
might happen in this industry so in
terms of research integration is a
pretty tough nut to crack
now around the time that was finishing
this this study on the solar industry I
was moving to Bocconi joining the
department of management and technology
and young boss walked into my office
Young was a PhD student at Bocconi well
trained in methods interested in
strategy and organization and deeply
passionate about cars and motorsports
none was
is a huge Formula one fan he knows the
sport inside and out and is a
fascinating sport I’m not an expert but
I’ve learned something about it that the
cars are miracles of modern engineering
they do things that those of us in our
everyday cars can’t quite imagine the
kind of performance that teens eat out
of them and they do it with up to 10,000
precision parts carefully integrated the
teams are models of organization they
run huge budgets they have as many as a
thousand workers in their system and
they manage broad supply chains as Adam
power puts it who is the former leader
of Williams racing no relation we need
in Formula one requires mastery not just
of multiple technical disciplines but
also the economics and the politics that
are essential to the competitive
position of each team so
multi-dimensional sport a lot going on
and a lot of these dimensions line up
with what we know are very important in
business and young boss is aware of
where the official observers of this
industry and the obsessive fans track
every aspect of the sport so we can see
not just how the teams and their drivers
are performing in races we can observe
changes to the car to different
components of the system and when
they’re reported to have problems below
cuts in engines difficulties with
aerodynamics problems with with brakes
so we want to use this to study if some
of these teams are actually better at
the strategic integration than others
then we start by looking at changes to
the car the engineering of the car and
whether that results in better
performance fewer problems in the car
and and faster racing but at this broad
level of the data actually don’t find
much in the way of state
patterns now
there’s another aspect of the sport I
need to tell you about and that’s the
rules the governing body of further one
sets wide-ranging rules they cover and
restrict aspects of the car the
operations of the team and from season
to season they frequently change these
rules they may change them to improve
the power knee between teams they
sometimes change them for the financial
benefit of the sport and sometimes for
other reasons
but what we discover is that sometimes
these rule changes require a team to
change the supplier for an individual
component and this looks like a classic
integration challenge these teams need
to learn to work with a new part build a
new relationship with a supplier all
while designing and improving and racing
their car so we want to see we want to
see what happens with this integration
challenge we choose a real change from
2007 for the first time the sport
announces a single tire supplier for the
entire sport before that some teams had
work with Bridgestone others with
Michelin as a researcher this looks a
lot like a naturally occurring
experiment we have a control group genes
that had worked with Bridgestone in the
past after the rule change can continue
to work with Bridgestone we are the
treatment a set of teams who are subject
to this new integration challenge those
that have been working with Michelin now
they have to work with with Bridgestone
and we can compare the performance of
these two different groups and see how
they react with the system of the car
and how that impacts their performance
so what do we see in the data well not
surprisingly the teams that are forced
to change supplier they see their
performance fall and when we look more
deeply and what we can observe in the
car they have more problems with their
car
more problems with the tires sure but
also with other components of the car so
this change entire supplier is cascading
through the system is creating changes
and potential problems in other
components and not all teams are
reacting to those problems the same now
we’re strategy researchers this is just
what we’re interested in are some teams
actually better at adapting to this
change than others and we do find that
there are some differences across the
successful adapters and the others they
they make more changes to the car they
have fewer problems and they perform
better in the races but to understand
what kind of changes are really making a
difference I need to tell you about one
other concept from the study and that is
an engineering dependence matrix it’s a
mouthful what it means basically is it’s
a map of how the different elements of a
system relate to one another which ones
are tied more closely and which are more
distant imagine if your car the
components of your car are several
islands your engine your chassis the
steering and some of those islands are
closer together and they have a bridge
between them whereas others are further
apart and there’s no bridge the
dependence matrix is basically a map of
those bridges so we take this to the
data and start to build one for a
Formula One car Yann talks to and
surveys a number of retired Formula One
engineers some industry experts and and
this is what this is an example of what
we get back take just a simple component
the second column there that’s a spark
plug there’s one connection from that to
the rest of the car it’s linked to the
engine the more typical component will
be connected to several other systems in
the car and we find we bring this to the
data that not all changes are having the
same effect this matrix allows us to
separate changes the systems that are
very
not closely connected to tires from
those that are much more closely linked
and what we find is it is only changes
to tie or elected related components
that are affecting the performance of a
team not changes to other systems and
it’s not having them the same effect in
the treatment group it’s only these
these teams that were forced to do this
change that are seeing a difference and
they are finding the more changes they
make to other components connected to
tires the fewer problems they’re having
with their car and the faster they are
in races so it really looks like when
this tire changed happens some teams are
perceiving how it flows through the
system they’re noticing the potential
problems that it introduces into the
system and then reacting they’re solving
those problems more quickly than their
competitors can so these are the
strategic integrators of Formula One and
in terms of race day performance its
decisive now we’ve looked at other
aspects and this is part of the study we
looked at other aspects of integration
and adaptation we find for instance that
Mis ability to integrate appears to end
at the edge of the organization when we
look at changes by suppliers to
components that suppliers change that
suppliers control it doesn’t have the
same effect on performance and we look
for where disability arises it’s not
teams with more human capital it’s not
teams where the leaders had more
experience in the industry it’s the more
mature teams those who had worked
together longer who are figuring out
this adaptation but I’ll have time to
delve into those other other results
more more today what I want to leave you
with is just this notion of strategic
integration it really appears that some
teams some organizations some companies
have a better idea of how the parts of
their business go together
and when some change requires that they
adapt that they figure it out more
quickly counting this back to the
cellular study I mentioned the beginning
this looks like concrete evidence for
what we thought we saw in that original
study that some that these established
players are more able to understand how
changes affect the system and take the
system apart and put it back together to
adapt and be more successful now as far
as yon he’s graduated from the the
Bacardi ph.d program with flying colors
excellent and he’s fallen his heart went
into our study so he now is a manager in
North America for a Ferrari one of the
Giants of Formula One and one of the
subject teams in our study thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: