
[Music]
[Music]
today I’d like to talk to you a little
bit about your minds and in particular
the outsource mind and I want to talk to
you about challenging two assumptions
that we have when we talk about issues
of digital economies and how our minds
work the first is that we aren’t cyborgs
and I’m here to tell you that we already
are because if you’re like me most of
the telephone numbers your memory is
actually managed by your external brain
right and the only telephone number I
think I can remember offhand is my
childhood telephone number the other
thing is that if you’ve gotten here by
ways you’ve outsourced your ability to
make decisions to this app the second
assumption I’d like to challenge is that
technology makes or improves our
decisions and that is what I do all day
at MIT where I run experiments to
understand how people’s just decision
makings improve or are suffering based
on technology so I’d like to start with
an image that’s a pretty classic
representation of the human mind it’s an
iceberg and here’s the thing about the
human mind it’s incredible right and it
can do so much but at the same time it’s
limited the tip of the iceberg as you
know is the small part of the iceberg
and the human mind has the tip of the
iceberg with regard to the conscious
mind that is you can only consciously
process about as much information as
fits on a post-it note so you’re hearing
me say post-it note you’re seeing a
picture of an iceberg but really much of
the heavy lifting and the work is done
beneath the surface of the iceberg or
your subconscious mind and that’s where
your NASA supercomputer is thinking
about what you’re going to eat
processing and encoding information that
we were exposed to earlier today or
noticing things that are really not
important but that are actually
affecting how you view me like the fact
that I’m a woman or a woman of color now
here’s the thing about the human mind
although it’s the original computer and
it’s pretty fantastic it is limited and
as a result we are prone to bias because
we can only process or tend to so much
information at any given time and as a
result we outsource many decisions to
computers to improve our choice and so
this picture here of the woman deciding
between using her brain or her external
brain in the computer is a little bit of
a misrepresentation because we are
increasingly becoming more intimately of
all involved with computers and becoming
increasingly less conscious of when we
dole out tasks to artificial
intelligence or when we do them
ourselves
this Homo economicus never really
existed and perhaps exists even less now
because although we fancy ourselves
rational thinkers we know that we’re not
and we also know increasingly that
computers are not necessarily rational
either so let me show you some research
from an experiment that I’ve run at MIT
let’s imagine here that you want to
become even more intelligent than you
already are
which of course we know requires the
suspension of disbelief and if you want
to boost your cognitive ability you’ve
decided to purchase a product that
purports to do this in this particular
example you’ve purchased brain age which
is actually a real product you may have
also heard of Lumosity which sort of
does mental chemists etics to improve
your mental acuity now you’ve decided to
purchase this product it’s a digital
product and you can purchase this
product brought to you by MIT or brought
to you by the online school the
University of Phoenix now if you’re like
most people you may have an in going
preference and that preference may be
toward MIT and in fact that’s what we
sell our experiments we had people use
the product trained with it and then we
tested them with regard to their
performance here’s where the human mind
is incredible but also limited at the
same time research on that very same ice
has shown that things like brands
activate all kinds of associations in
our minds and can lead us to suboptimal
decisions so for example other
experiments have shown that people who
used a pen with the name MIT on it felt
more intelligent or in an experiment
people were given wine and in one
randomly assigned condition they
received wine bottles that said made in
France and in the other condition the
wine bottle said made in North Dakota
the identical wine was rated as less
delicious in the North Dakota condition
so you may think where I’m going with
this if you’re familiar with placebo
effects the brains or our minds
expectations play tricks on us and those
expectations can lead to different
outcomes in terms of performance so what
do you think is gonna happen when we
give people these products and we have
them trained
turns out there is a difference in
performance unfortunately for those of
us at MIT there’s a reverse placebo
effect people performed worse in the
condition when they were asked to train
and use the MIT branded product even
though it was identical so given the
fact that the research team we were all
at MIT we were a little bit confused and
potentially thought we made a huge
mistake by going to MIT so we did some
other research to figure out well maybe
the associations with this particular
brand aren’t as strong or aren’t what we
expected and in fact people do believe
that MIT has high prestige versus the
other condition and they also expected
higher efficacy so this was a little bit
of a head-scratcher why are we seeing
these results and even though the people
in the MIT condition performed worse
they were willing to pay 35% more for
this identical product so what’s
happening here you may be thinking of
some alternative explanations one of
which is that perhaps people worked less
hard in the MIT condition they figured
they had more firepower on their side so
they had to expend less effort not the
case equal across all can
and perhaps maybe you think people spent
more time or were more deliberate in the
University of Phoenix condition not true
no difference across conditions there
either so we decided to do another
experiment and this time we said ok
let’s use language learning software and
let’s use a fictional language that no
one could possibly know or have an
advantage with and we used the language
from the movie avatar which is called
Navi which my PhD postdoctoral associate
was fluent in and no judgment and he
programmed a rosetta stone type language
learning software for Navi and once
again we randomly assigned people to two
conditions MIT or the University of
Phoenix and we measured their subjective
outcomes after they used the product how
did you feel afterward in the MIT
condition people felt better prepared
mind you this is a digital product they
are using it in their homes there are no
lab influences here this is technology
that equals the playing field so to
speak in that it’s a democratic way for
people to gain access to this
educational software and when we asked
about subjective outcomes with regard to
how much they’d be willing to pay for
this wonderful product once again the
willingness to pay was higher in the MIT
condition but here’s their objective
performance
once again they performed worse in the
MIT condition what’s happening here
there’s something that goes on with
human beings called social-comparison we
can’t help it we walk into a room and we
scan the room for people who are like us
whether it be according to gender race
or other markers it’s an automatic
process that takes place with human
beings and just because we’re using
technology doesn’t mean this process is
ameliorated in fact I would argue it may
actually increase as we outsource more
of our cognitive thinking to technology
that is programmed by bias human beings
when we are in a setting where standards
are high and you expect high standards
in this context certainly that can
motivate you
but those high standards in the presence
of social comparison where you feel
psychologically close to the focal
reference group can affect your
performance in that your performance can
start to assimilate toward that goal
however in the presence of high
standards
if you feel psychologically distant van
you will experience contrast effects and
your performance will suffer accordingly
this is really important not only for
digital technology but for educational
institutions and organizations that
attempt to have inclusivity when you
have a person like me who’s the first
person in her family to go to college
from immigrants and you go to a
prestigious school certainly you worked
hard to get there and you belong there
but your mind may be telling you that
you don’t and in fact the more that you
are exposed to those high standards the
more signals you see of that achievement
and that standard the more you may
actually struggle in this reverse
placebo effect now this doesn’t just
happened in the educational realm this
happens with health behaviors where we
see the
reference or focal points and we decide
whether we’re psychologically close or
distant and that affects our behavior
and in social media this is even more
amplified you may be familiar with the
ice bucket challenge or with the it’s
get it gets better campaign for LGBT
youth or with Movember to raise
awareness for prostate cancer but what
you may not be familiar with is that all
of this that’s percolating in our
digital extended selves our social media
lives is affecting the way in which we
behave even in health for instance this
imagery here versus this imagery versus
this imagery for the identical disease
with the identical copy has very
different effects on people who would
aim to support disease research or the
patient’s themselves we did an
experiment where we had a fictional
disease called Carlson’s disease and we
randomly assigned people to either be in
the patient condition or in the
potential donor condition I should
mention that none of our participants
admitted to having Carlson’s disease so
that’s good because it’s fake and
interestingly what we found is when
these things are going virally through
social media for instance and amplified
by technology our biases are still at
play
for instance here you see low efficacy
poses these images are most effective in
getting people to donate money possibly
because of things like emotional
contagion you see someone looking sad
forlorn pitiful and you want to stop
that sad feeling and you give money take
my money make me feel better
you may also run for the remote and
change the channel when those kinds of
advertisements come on right but when
you see imagery like this power poses
you may be familiar with that term these
images are most effective in getting
patients to comply with physician advice
and in these experiments patients in the
condition were more likely if these
kinds of poses to where medical alert
jewelry that would be visible to other
people to ask people for help
to tell people at their workplaces that
they need a change in their schedule to
ask for amended recipes if they were on
a special diet these kinds of things
that have huge implications for health
are aided by the imagery that we see in
technology so is the outsourced mind
more rational I think the answer is it
depends we really only started to
understand this cyborgs existence that
we have where our memory is in our back
pocket in our phones or our phones are
telling us how to go and where to go now
when we think about the outsourced mind
what I want you to think about is that
we’re becoming less conscious in having
an outsourced mind and that’s important
because as in this case when you have
computers creating the perfect face the
perfect image of beauty this was created
by artificial intelligence what does
that reflect does that reflect what true
beauty is or what biases we hold as a
result and what does that mean if you
don’t look like this or if you do a
Google search and you may be familiar
with this for three black teenagers why
does the algorithm show you these images
but if you do the identical search for
three white teenagers you see these
images technology is amazing and can
improve our decision-making in all of
our journeys whether it be how you spend
your money how you take care of your
health or maybe even how you got here
from your home but what we need to be
careful of is to challenge the
assumption that this technology improves
our decision-making reduces our
irrational thinking and that we
consciously make a decision between our
own brains and our outsourced brains so
tonight when you go home I’d like you to
think more consciously when you make
your next decision about how much you’ve
been leaning on technology and how you
can be more conscious about thinking
about your
source spring to reduce the same biases
that we hope to reduce in the human
brain make the unconscious conscious
that’s the best way to combat bias and
if you do so my hope is not only will
you improve your performance but you’ll
also improve the happiness in your life
as well thank you
[Applause]
[Music]
today I’d like to talk to you a little
bit about your minds and in particular
the outsource mind and I want to talk to
you about challenging two assumptions
that we have when we talk about issues
of digital economies and how our minds
work the first is that we aren’t cyborgs
and I’m here to tell you that we already
are because if you’re like me most of
the telephone numbers your memory is
actually managed by your external brain
right and the only telephone number I
think I can remember offhand is my
childhood telephone number the other
thing is that if you’ve gotten here by
ways you’ve outsourced your ability to
make decisions to this app the second
assumption I’d like to challenge is that
technology makes or improves our
decisions and that is what I do all day
at MIT where I run experiments to
understand how people’s just decision
makings improve or are suffering based
on technology so I’d like to start with
an image that’s a pretty classic
representation of the human mind it’s an
iceberg and here’s the thing about the
human mind it’s incredible right and it
can do so much but at the same time it’s
limited the tip of the iceberg as you
know is the small part of the iceberg
and the human mind has the tip of the
iceberg with regard to the conscious
mind that is you can only consciously
process about as much information as
fits on a post-it note so you’re hearing
me say post-it note you’re seeing a
picture of an iceberg but really much of
the heavy lifting and the work is done
beneath the surface of the iceberg or
your subconscious mind and that’s where
your NASA supercomputer is thinking
about what you’re going to eat
processing and encoding information that
we were exposed to earlier today or
noticing things that are really not
important but that are actually
affecting how you view me like the fact
that I’m a woman or a woman of color now
here’s the thing about the human mind
although it’s the original computer and
it’s pretty fantastic it is limited and
as a result we are prone to bias because
we can only process or tend to so much
information at any given time and as a
result we outsource many decisions to
computers to improve our choice and so
this picture here of the woman deciding
between using her brain or her external
brain in the computer is a little bit of
a misrepresentation because we are
increasingly becoming more intimately of
all involved with computers and becoming
increasingly less conscious of when we
dole out tasks to artificial
intelligence or when we do them
ourselves
this Homo economicus never really
existed and perhaps exists even less now
because although we fancy ourselves
rational thinkers we know that we’re not
and we also know increasingly that
computers are not necessarily rational
either so let me show you some research
from an experiment that I’ve run at MIT
let’s imagine here that you want to
become even more intelligent than you
already are
which of course we know requires the
suspension of disbelief and if you want
to boost your cognitive ability you’ve
decided to purchase a product that
purports to do this in this particular
example you’ve purchased brain age which
is actually a real product you may have
also heard of Lumosity which sort of
does mental chemists etics to improve
your mental acuity now you’ve decided to
purchase this product it’s a digital
product and you can purchase this
product brought to you by MIT or brought
to you by the online school the
University of Phoenix now if you’re like
most people you may have an in going
preference and that preference may be
toward MIT and in fact that’s what we
sell our experiments we had people use
the product trained with it and then we
tested them with regard to their
performance here’s where the human mind
is incredible but also limited at the
same time research on that very same ice
has shown that things like brands
activate all kinds of associations in
our minds and can lead us to suboptimal
decisions so for example other
experiments have shown that people who
used a pen with the name MIT on it felt
more intelligent or in an experiment
people were given wine and in one
randomly assigned condition they
received wine bottles that said made in
France and in the other condition the
wine bottle said made in North Dakota
the identical wine was rated as less
delicious in the North Dakota condition
so you may think where I’m going with
this if you’re familiar with placebo
effects the brains or our minds
expectations play tricks on us and those
expectations can lead to different
outcomes in terms of performance so what
do you think is gonna happen when we
give people these products and we have
them trained
turns out there is a difference in
performance unfortunately for those of
us at MIT there’s a reverse placebo
effect people performed worse in the
condition when they were asked to train
and use the MIT branded product even
though it was identical so given the
fact that the research team we were all
at MIT we were a little bit confused and
potentially thought we made a huge
mistake by going to MIT so we did some
other research to figure out well maybe
the associations with this particular
brand aren’t as strong or aren’t what we
expected and in fact people do believe
that MIT has high prestige versus the
other condition and they also expected
higher efficacy so this was a little bit
of a head-scratcher why are we seeing
these results and even though the people
in the MIT condition performed worse
they were willing to pay 35% more for
this identical product so what’s
happening here you may be thinking of
some alternative explanations one of
which is that perhaps people worked less
hard in the MIT condition they figured
they had more firepower on their side so
they had to expend less effort not the
case equal across all can
and perhaps maybe you think people spent
more time or were more deliberate in the
University of Phoenix condition not true
no difference across conditions there
either so we decided to do another
experiment and this time we said ok
let’s use language learning software and
let’s use a fictional language that no
one could possibly know or have an
advantage with and we used the language
from the movie avatar which is called
Navi which my PhD postdoctoral associate
was fluent in and no judgment and he
programmed a rosetta stone type language
learning software for Navi and once
again we randomly assigned people to two
conditions MIT or the University of
Phoenix and we measured their subjective
outcomes after they used the product how
did you feel afterward in the MIT
condition people felt better prepared
mind you this is a digital product they
are using it in their homes there are no
lab influences here this is technology
that equals the playing field so to
speak in that it’s a democratic way for
people to gain access to this
educational software and when we asked
about subjective outcomes with regard to
how much they’d be willing to pay for
this wonderful product once again the
willingness to pay was higher in the MIT
condition but here’s their objective
performance
once again they performed worse in the
MIT condition what’s happening here
there’s something that goes on with
human beings called social-comparison we
can’t help it we walk into a room and we
scan the room for people who are like us
whether it be according to gender race
or other markers it’s an automatic
process that takes place with human
beings and just because we’re using
technology doesn’t mean this process is
ameliorated in fact I would argue it may
actually increase as we outsource more
of our cognitive thinking to technology
that is programmed by bias human beings
when we are in a setting where standards
are high and you expect high standards
in this context certainly that can
motivate you
but those high standards in the presence
of social comparison where you feel
psychologically close to the focal
reference group can affect your
performance in that your performance can
start to assimilate toward that goal
however in the presence of high
standards
if you feel psychologically distant van
you will experience contrast effects and
your performance will suffer accordingly
this is really important not only for
digital technology but for educational
institutions and organizations that
attempt to have inclusivity when you
have a person like me who’s the first
person in her family to go to college
from immigrants and you go to a
prestigious school certainly you worked
hard to get there and you belong there
but your mind may be telling you that
you don’t and in fact the more that you
are exposed to those high standards the
more signals you see of that achievement
and that standard the more you may
actually struggle in this reverse
placebo effect now this doesn’t just
happened in the educational realm this
happens with health behaviors where we
see the
reference or focal points and we decide
whether we’re psychologically close or
distant and that affects our behavior
and in social media this is even more
amplified you may be familiar with the
ice bucket challenge or with the it’s
get it gets better campaign for LGBT
youth or with Movember to raise
awareness for prostate cancer but what
you may not be familiar with is that all
of this that’s percolating in our
digital extended selves our social media
lives is affecting the way in which we
behave even in health for instance this
imagery here versus this imagery versus
this imagery for the identical disease
with the identical copy has very
different effects on people who would
aim to support disease research or the
patient’s themselves we did an
experiment where we had a fictional
disease called Carlson’s disease and we
randomly assigned people to either be in
the patient condition or in the
potential donor condition I should
mention that none of our participants
admitted to having Carlson’s disease so
that’s good because it’s fake and
interestingly what we found is when
these things are going virally through
social media for instance and amplified
by technology our biases are still at
play
for instance here you see low efficacy
poses these images are most effective in
getting people to donate money possibly
because of things like emotional
contagion you see someone looking sad
forlorn pitiful and you want to stop
that sad feeling and you give money take
my money make me feel better
you may also run for the remote and
change the channel when those kinds of
advertisements come on right but when
you see imagery like this power poses
you may be familiar with that term these
images are most effective in getting
patients to comply with physician advice
and in these experiments patients in the
condition were more likely if these
kinds of poses to where medical alert
jewelry that would be visible to other
people to ask people for help
to tell people at their workplaces that
they need a change in their schedule to
ask for amended recipes if they were on
a special diet these kinds of things
that have huge implications for health
are aided by the imagery that we see in
technology so is the outsourced mind
more rational I think the answer is it
depends we really only started to
understand this cyborgs existence that
we have where our memory is in our back
pocket in our phones or our phones are
telling us how to go and where to go now
when we think about the outsourced mind
what I want you to think about is that
we’re becoming less conscious in having
an outsourced mind and that’s important
because as in this case when you have
computers creating the perfect face the
perfect image of beauty this was created
by artificial intelligence what does
that reflect does that reflect what true
beauty is or what biases we hold as a
result and what does that mean if you
don’t look like this or if you do a
Google search and you may be familiar
with this for three black teenagers why
does the algorithm show you these images
but if you do the identical search for
three white teenagers you see these
images technology is amazing and can
improve our decision-making in all of
our journeys whether it be how you spend
your money how you take care of your
health or maybe even how you got here
from your home but what we need to be
careful of is to challenge the
assumption that this technology improves
our decision-making reduces our
irrational thinking and that we
consciously make a decision between our
own brains and our outsourced brains so
tonight when you go home I’d like you to
think more consciously when you make
your next decision about how much you’ve
been leaning on technology and how you
can be more conscious about thinking
about your
source spring to reduce the same biases
that we hope to reduce in the human
brain make the unconscious conscious
that’s the best way to combat bias and
if you do so my hope is not only will
you improve your performance but you’ll
also improve the happiness in your life
as well thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: