
[Music]
[Music]
[Applause]
here’s a list of things that don’t cause
murder stiletto heel shoes mother’s
selfies broken hearts romance sex
Trump’s here’s a list of things that do
cause murder the decision to murder
someone listen bullet just came into
this house and killed this daughter and
her father it’s not myself no of course
it didn’t this 16 year old girl her
ex-boyfriend came into her house with a
loaded gun
shot and killed her shot and killed her
father and tried to kill her sister Tara
Costigan a lot of people have heard of
her her ex-partner came into her house
brutally murdered her a week after she
gave birth to their baby this is the
headline we get of course you don’t
think that bullets and axes are just
randomly going into people’s houses and
killing them because murder is a choice
and things can’t make choices but the
men who committed these murders and yes
they were all men trying to make those
headlines at all they’re invisible
does it matter does it matter that they
were all men and that they’re not in the
headlines I think it does I’m a
journalist as are all the editors and
writers and sub editors that put these
articles together and the purpose of
journalism according to our code of
ethics is to describe society to itself
in Western countries somewhere around 80
to 90% of murders are committed by men
and around 30% of those the domestic
violence
related New South Wales coroner’s Court
did a study on this a while ago they
looked at all the domestic violence
homicides over the last twelve years in
New South Wales a most populated state
so it’s a fairly robust dataset they
looked at police investigations homicide
squad findings coroner’s court inquests
and criminal trials now this is not a
group of people commonly known for their
radical feminist leanings but in that
entire 12 years over hundreds of murders
they did not find one single case not
one where an abusive woman killed her
male partner when women killed their
partners they are almost always the
victims of his violence so what does
this tell us it tells us that abusive
men can escalate to murder and abusive
women just don’t this is a story we
should be telling if we were suffering a
plague of ghosts or invisible beings
sneaking into people’s houses and
murdering families that’s definitely a
story we should be telling do great on
Netflix if shoes and selfies for
murdering innocent women that’s
definitely a story we should be telling
but that’s not what’s happening in the
overwhelming majority of cases when a
woman is killed she will be killed by a
man who claimed to love her and that’s
the story we should be telling we are
not doing our job very well
a mother made a fatal mistake the mother
of a murdered son makes a headline I
have a son I routinely expect that his
friends are not going to murder him do
you think this should make headlines I
can’t imagine what this woman is going
through it is incomprehensible but I
know that victims of crime over and over
again they go back and they read the
news articles about what happened trying
to make sense of why did this happen and
this woman what does she see every time
she goes back
she sees that her son is dead and that
it’s her fault
I mean it’s ludicrous of course it’s not
her fault her son was killed by a man
named Daniel Perry you don’t see that
until the third paragraph what you see
is that it’s a woman’s fault and that
the killer is nowhere I wish this was a
bizarre-o or rare headline it isn’t
found dead like they got home from the
theme park and just expired from all the
theme park joy know this man go home
pulled out a gun loaded it pointed it at
each of his three children and killed
them the youngest was two years old
would you know from this headline that
at the same time he shot and killed his
wife as well found dead
they weren’t found dead they were
murdered by a man who claimed to love
them yes what do you reckon this one’s
about she’s a stripper so of course she
lies it’s a boob job dispute you know
boobs are always good it’s gonna be
something funny right same case after
the verdict except what he was actually
convicted of was sexual assault what are
we telling society about itself with
this headline we’re telling them that
women lie that strippers aren’t really
people that sexual assault is just a
boob job dispute it’s not serious it
doesn’t matter this is not journalism
this is deception this is perpetuating
the myth that women caused the violence
enacted against them and then they lie
about it she didn’t lie he was convicted
do you know how hard that is to do 3% of
the sexual assaults that are reported to
police rate conviction and only about
15% of the ones that happen or
reported she didn’t why this is not
doing our job
drunk teenager so she’s 17 18 maybe 19
she’s out seeing a little skirt she’s
having a few drinks she’s flirting with
football players getting herself into
trouble right that’s what you probably
think when you see drunk teenager she
was 14 years old she was raped by a 45
year old man who used alcohol as a
weapon to incapacitate her but there she
is in the headline being a drunk
teenager and all the myths that go with
it loose young women leading innocent
footballers Australia a few months after
this rape this 14 year old girl is child
she tried to kill herself that’s in the
article – let’s write down the bottom
after you’ve already got all those ideas
in your head this is not describing
society to itself now we haven’t got
hours and hours here so I just had to
pick a few of these but these come up
every single day more than once child
sex charges that bottom one seven counts
of rape 30 counts of carnal knowledge of
a child 26 counts of indecent treatment
and one count of making child
exploitation material 79 offenses in
total all against children now to be
clear he hasn’t been to trial yet we’re
not talking about whether or not he’s
guilty we’re talking about how the
charges against him are reported child
sex charges children can do a lot of
things they can forget to put their
plates in the dishwasher they leave Lego
out on the floor for you to stand on in
the middle of the night they almost
always forget to feed the dog you know
what they cannot do
they cannot have sex with adults sex
requires consent and children by
definition they can’t give consent so
it’s not sex it’s rape it’s child abuse
it’s sexual abuse it’s any one of a
number of terms that accurately describe
a crime sex is not a crime
it can’t be charged with having sex can
only be charged if one of the people
involved does not or cannot give consent
sex and rape are not the same thing like
giraffes and spoons are not the same
thing when journalist tells society that
sex is the same as rape or child abuse
they are not describing what is
happening they’re describing what isn’t
happening and again we are failing at
our purpose would even start Wow
she’s not even a person she’s a doctor’s
daughter she’s walking monkey she’s been
drinking of course you know women do
that Jagermeister Jager bombs I always
get that one mixed in six of them if you
can believe it and where were her
friends what were they doing why were
they protecting her why didn’t they stop
this from happening to her the man who
found her took her back to his house
raped her beat her strangled her killed
her where is he with his choices his
actions all we see is her the victim her
actions and her choices and the one
thing I can tell you for sure about
people who have been raped and murdered
is they did not choose to be raped and
they did not choose to be murdered and
nothing they did caused that rape or
that murder
because there is only one thing that
causes rape and murder and that is the
decision to do it journalists are going
to do their job properly and honestly
that is the story we need to tell so why
does this happen why is this keep
happening we kept seeing these headlines
is it male-dominated newsrooms we know
that about 70% of reporters and editors
and newsrooms are men is this just how
they see violence against women so this
is how they say it is it sensationalism
it’s the audience chasing the headline
or as the headline chasing the audience
I know it all gets a bit chicken-and-egg
and honestly I don’t know if it matters
anymore just because it’s always been
like this does not mean it always has to
be like this journalists are failing at
our job and I think we are we failed
ourselves we fail our profession we fail
the society that depends upon us for the
truth and most of all we fail the
victims who have already been through
far too much but when you as the
audience see these headlines when you
click on them or even if you just ignore
them and pass over them and just accept
them that won’t change Joe must are
failing to do their job you as the
audience should tell them that you
expect more that you expect better that
you expect the truth because surely the
truth is the bare minimum you should
expect from journalism you can and you
should and you must tell journalists
that you expect better from the
profession that exists to tell your
society tell you about your society
because if we won’t fix it you can thank
you
[Applause]
[Music]
[Music]
[Applause]
here’s a list of things that don’t cause
murder stiletto heel shoes mother’s
selfies broken hearts romance sex
Trump’s here’s a list of things that do
cause murder the decision to murder
someone listen bullet just came into
this house and killed this daughter and
her father it’s not myself no of course
it didn’t this 16 year old girl her
ex-boyfriend came into her house with a
loaded gun
shot and killed her shot and killed her
father and tried to kill her sister Tara
Costigan a lot of people have heard of
her her ex-partner came into her house
brutally murdered her a week after she
gave birth to their baby this is the
headline we get of course you don’t
think that bullets and axes are just
randomly going into people’s houses and
killing them because murder is a choice
and things can’t make choices but the
men who committed these murders and yes
they were all men trying to make those
headlines at all they’re invisible
does it matter does it matter that they
were all men and that they’re not in the
headlines I think it does I’m a
journalist as are all the editors and
writers and sub editors that put these
articles together and the purpose of
journalism according to our code of
ethics is to describe society to itself
in Western countries somewhere around 80
to 90% of murders are committed by men
and around 30% of those the domestic
violence
related New South Wales coroner’s Court
did a study on this a while ago they
looked at all the domestic violence
homicides over the last twelve years in
New South Wales a most populated state
so it’s a fairly robust dataset they
looked at police investigations homicide
squad findings coroner’s court inquests
and criminal trials now this is not a
group of people commonly known for their
radical feminist leanings but in that
entire 12 years over hundreds of murders
they did not find one single case not
one where an abusive woman killed her
male partner when women killed their
partners they are almost always the
victims of his violence so what does
this tell us it tells us that abusive
men can escalate to murder and abusive
women just don’t this is a story we
should be telling if we were suffering a
plague of ghosts or invisible beings
sneaking into people’s houses and
murdering families that’s definitely a
story we should be telling do great on
Netflix if shoes and selfies for
murdering innocent women that’s
definitely a story we should be telling
but that’s not what’s happening in the
overwhelming majority of cases when a
woman is killed she will be killed by a
man who claimed to love her and that’s
the story we should be telling we are
not doing our job very well
a mother made a fatal mistake the mother
of a murdered son makes a headline I
have a son I routinely expect that his
friends are not going to murder him do
you think this should make headlines I
can’t imagine what this woman is going
through it is incomprehensible but I
know that victims of crime over and over
again they go back and they read the
news articles about what happened trying
to make sense of why did this happen and
this woman what does she see every time
she goes back
she sees that her son is dead and that
it’s her fault
I mean it’s ludicrous of course it’s not
her fault her son was killed by a man
named Daniel Perry you don’t see that
until the third paragraph what you see
is that it’s a woman’s fault and that
the killer is nowhere I wish this was a
bizarre-o or rare headline it isn’t
found dead like they got home from the
theme park and just expired from all the
theme park joy know this man go home
pulled out a gun loaded it pointed it at
each of his three children and killed
them the youngest was two years old
would you know from this headline that
at the same time he shot and killed his
wife as well found dead
they weren’t found dead they were
murdered by a man who claimed to love
them yes what do you reckon this one’s
about she’s a stripper so of course she
lies it’s a boob job dispute you know
boobs are always good it’s gonna be
something funny right same case after
the verdict except what he was actually
convicted of was sexual assault what are
we telling society about itself with
this headline we’re telling them that
women lie that strippers aren’t really
people that sexual assault is just a
boob job dispute it’s not serious it
doesn’t matter this is not journalism
this is deception this is perpetuating
the myth that women caused the violence
enacted against them and then they lie
about it she didn’t lie he was convicted
do you know how hard that is to do 3% of
the sexual assaults that are reported to
police rate conviction and only about
15% of the ones that happen or
reported she didn’t why this is not
doing our job
drunk teenager so she’s 17 18 maybe 19
she’s out seeing a little skirt she’s
having a few drinks she’s flirting with
football players getting herself into
trouble right that’s what you probably
think when you see drunk teenager she
was 14 years old she was raped by a 45
year old man who used alcohol as a
weapon to incapacitate her but there she
is in the headline being a drunk
teenager and all the myths that go with
it loose young women leading innocent
footballers Australia a few months after
this rape this 14 year old girl is child
she tried to kill herself that’s in the
article – let’s write down the bottom
after you’ve already got all those ideas
in your head this is not describing
society to itself now we haven’t got
hours and hours here so I just had to
pick a few of these but these come up
every single day more than once child
sex charges that bottom one seven counts
of rape 30 counts of carnal knowledge of
a child 26 counts of indecent treatment
and one count of making child
exploitation material 79 offenses in
total all against children now to be
clear he hasn’t been to trial yet we’re
not talking about whether or not he’s
guilty we’re talking about how the
charges against him are reported child
sex charges children can do a lot of
things they can forget to put their
plates in the dishwasher they leave Lego
out on the floor for you to stand on in
the middle of the night they almost
always forget to feed the dog you know
what they cannot do
they cannot have sex with adults sex
requires consent and children by
definition they can’t give consent so
it’s not sex it’s rape it’s child abuse
it’s sexual abuse it’s any one of a
number of terms that accurately describe
a crime sex is not a crime
it can’t be charged with having sex can
only be charged if one of the people
involved does not or cannot give consent
sex and rape are not the same thing like
giraffes and spoons are not the same
thing when journalist tells society that
sex is the same as rape or child abuse
they are not describing what is
happening they’re describing what isn’t
happening and again we are failing at
our purpose would even start Wow
she’s not even a person she’s a doctor’s
daughter she’s walking monkey she’s been
drinking of course you know women do
that Jagermeister Jager bombs I always
get that one mixed in six of them if you
can believe it and where were her
friends what were they doing why were
they protecting her why didn’t they stop
this from happening to her the man who
found her took her back to his house
raped her beat her strangled her killed
her where is he with his choices his
actions all we see is her the victim her
actions and her choices and the one
thing I can tell you for sure about
people who have been raped and murdered
is they did not choose to be raped and
they did not choose to be murdered and
nothing they did caused that rape or
that murder
because there is only one thing that
causes rape and murder and that is the
decision to do it journalists are going
to do their job properly and honestly
that is the story we need to tell so why
does this happen why is this keep
happening we kept seeing these headlines
is it male-dominated newsrooms we know
that about 70% of reporters and editors
and newsrooms are men is this just how
they see violence against women so this
is how they say it is it sensationalism
it’s the audience chasing the headline
or as the headline chasing the audience
I know it all gets a bit chicken-and-egg
and honestly I don’t know if it matters
anymore just because it’s always been
like this does not mean it always has to
be like this journalists are failing at
our job and I think we are we failed
ourselves we fail our profession we fail
the society that depends upon us for the
truth and most of all we fail the
victims who have already been through
far too much but when you as the
audience see these headlines when you
click on them or even if you just ignore
them and pass over them and just accept
them that won’t change Joe must are
failing to do their job you as the
audience should tell them that you
expect more that you expect better that
you expect the truth because surely the
truth is the bare minimum you should
expect from journalism you can and you
should and you must tell journalists
that you expect better from the
profession that exists to tell your
society tell you about your society
because if we won’t fix it you can thank
you
[Applause]
[Music]
Please follow and like us: