Press "Enter" to skip to content

The missing leaders: leading as a teenage girl | Vivian Ng | TEDxJIS


[Applause]

this photo shows two Carl intercultural

schools 2017-2018 central student

council also known as the CSC does

anything in this photo sent out to you

there is only one female in this photo

mean and I am just his first CSC female

president in the past ten years when

people think of gists international and

progressive are often two adjectives

that come into mind yet gender disparity

and student leadership still persists

here today now this graph shows a number

of male to females CSC leaders elected

annually over the past ten years purple

is for females and green is for males on

average there is only one point eight

three females elected annually into the

CSC this means that there is only one

female to represent fifty percent of the

student body and the CSC can be seen as

a senior leadership position a council

that is in charge of organizing

school-wide events of improving student

life and overseeing grade-level councils

whereas grade-level councils can be seen

as junior leadership positions councils

only in charge of their grade level

now this next graph shows the number of

female to males

elected annually into the grade level

councils and clearly the numbers are

more equal so from this graph we can

know that girls are interested in

leadership positions but what is

stopping them from running for a higher

position what is stopping them from

running for presidency four years ago as

a freshman I was actually not about to

run for Student Council

I remember sitting amongst my two

hundred / classmates listening to our

principal mr. Clark explained what

student council is and a small part of

me always wanted to run but I was scared

and the weeks leading up to student

council applications I was doubting

myself

even more because every day at school

the Friends of male candidates would be

extremely loud and rowdy and everyday

they would shout across campus to vote

for this guy and every day they would

promote the parties that they held for

another however my friends were more

quiet my friends were more restrained

and my friends unintentionally didn’t

give me that same feeling of

encouragement I felt as if I didn’t have

supporters as if I wasn’t going to win

and in that moment my biggest setback

wasn’t my qualifications my biggest

setback was my mindset in fact girls

have been submerged into a culture that

conditions them to idealize perfection

it all first started with being the

perfect wife to our husbands then it

moved on to having the perfect body and

now we have this crazy idea of

effortless perfection that in addition

to being physically beautiful 24/7 we’re

also expected to be smart to be

successful but also feminine and

ladylike and somehow we’re supposed to

do all of this effortlessly and then we

begin equating perfection with the idea

of having it all but also note that this

is only one aspect of the lack of female

teenage leaders there are also other

factors like a community’s bias towards

male leaders however I found that

perception of failure was most prominent

around teenage girls because perception

of failure impacts confidence it impacts

risk-taking

it impacts innovation all of which are

important aspects of becoming a leader

and I want to remind everyone in this

room that perfection is not a human

quality and if you believe that it is

then you’re preventing yourself from

stepping out of your comfort zone and

trying something that might lead to

failure or great success because we

associate

failure with imperfection and that is

clearly not the case

take JK rowling for example who faced 12

rejections before becoming the first

billionaire author in 2014 or take Oprah

Winfrey whose failure inarguably

launched her on a career of TV success

or take me who failed to make the

cross-country traveling team and

freshman year but because I failed to

make the cross-country team it made me

train harder over the summer train

harder over the next season and become

so dedicated to the sport that I became

captain of the girls cross-country team

and senior year you see failure doesn’t

hinder you instead it shapes the type of

person that you will become and we’re so

obsessed with this idea of perfection

that we’ve created the fear of failure

and studies have actually shown that

girls and boys interpret failure

differently a study found that teachers

and parents give less and fewer cues to

girls to try harder or again when they

fail boys however are encouraged to

persevere to find new strategies and

then we begin to see how these

experiences shape a person because boys

begin to see failures as a learning

experience whereas girls see it as a

threat and a study by Stanford found out

when fifth grade students were given an

incredibly hard task to solve it was the

girls who were derailed by confusion and

unable to solve it in fact it was the

highest IQ girls who couldn’t solve it

the most and a Harvard professor also

found that it was girls who are dropping

out of Economics classes when they

failed to receive aids but what I find

even more interesting is that I don’t

have to look at all of these studies to

see this disparity in mindset because

this disparity in mindset exists edges

as well last year I was taking an AP

calculus AP class

which can be seen as an honors math

route for an 11th grade student and from

this class two of my female classmates

dropped out whereas all of my male

classmates continued and when I asked

the girls why they would always say that

math is too hard I can’t do it but when

I asked the boys why they would say mass

is always hard and it’s important to

note that these were people with same if

not similar grades that their

capabilities were the same yet girls

tended to associate their failures in

two internal factors like their lack of

ability whereas boys associated it to

external factors like the subject a

building is not the problem here

but mindset is a completely different

story and there’s so many articles books

and videos on failure and overcoming it

yet it still persists here today with

teenage girls and it’s because we apply

the same mindset we have to our school

work on failure we procrastinate if you

see an opportunity that might lead to

failure if it is something that you want

to do don’t run away don’t tell yourself

I’ll do it next time

because if not now then when tomorrow

next year when you graduate university

or maybe even when you’re on your

deathbed no the answer is now and the

truth is that nobody is ready to face

their fears to face what the future

holds but the future is inevitable

so like guru nanak once said conquer

your mind and you will conquer it the

world Circe’s that internet in that

internal battle of yours to seize the

moments and your fear of rejection and

go out find your passion and don’t look

back but we also need to widen our lens

and look at ourselves because a lack of

female teenage leaders doesn’t only lie

within the individual but also by the

communities

rounding these girls and we as a

community have failed we have tried and

tried to have more females in leadership

positions by giving them the

opportunities by giving them the

resources but clearly we aren’t

successful so what can we do girls will

not step up to leadership positions if

they don’t see themselves as worthy or

capable of these positions and how they

create these perceptions of themselves

comes from the environment and the

community around them

now let’s backtrack into my freshman

year where I lacked the confidence and

feared the failure of not making it into

the student council I remember clearly

sitting at my laptop screen looking at

the application deadlines and my sister

came up to me and said not believing in

your capabilities will be one of your

biggest regrets and in that moment of

self belief and self-confidence I

applied and four years later Here I am

the president of the high school all

because one person told me to believe in

myself and while my sister said four

years ago impacted Who I am today

and what I do today will impact my best

friends and along the way more and more

people will be impacted and their

tomorrows will be affected however these

perceptions of failures applies equally

to boys but from the studies to the

statistics to this picture we can

already see that boys are already

receiving this feeling and encouragement

and I’m not telling you to go out and

neglect the male population as a whole

I’m rather I’m telling you to balance

the Equality the encouragement between

both sexes by increasing this

encouragement towards females as well

and we can all benefit from having more

female leaders and how we move towards

that is by changing how we treat women

and we can all start from today so if

you can reach under your chairs you will

find an envelope with a pen and a slip

of paper

and I want you to think of a girl any a

girl and write her a note telling her

that you believe in her and maybe you

will make a difference in her life and

then I want you to reflect on your

failures and reflect on your successes

because failure is success a trying

success at learning how to succeed and

if you didn’t try your hardest then you

failed at failure thank you

[Music] [Applause]

Please follow and like us: