
what do you do as an architect in a
shrinking city in the city with a
declining population in the city with a
struggling economy we tend to think of
cities in their material sense as a
collection of buildings streets
sidewalks homes and businesses and as
architects we think it is our right to
manipulate that environment through the
act of building but building is an
incredibly capital intensive undertaking
it’s an act associated with growth and
prosperity it’s an act associated with
expansion and it’s through the
opportunities afforded to us by
expansion that we tend to shape our
cities to reflect our contemporary needs
and values but not everywhere is
expanding and not everywhere has the
opportunities associated with growth and
so as young architects my partner
Tessa Kelly and I returned to our
hometown city of Pittsfield
Massachusetts because we believed there
was work to be done there as architects
even though it didn’t have the context
associated with building it was a
post-industrial shrinking city and the
result of that belief is a project
called the mastheads the mast-heads are
five mobile writing studios that house a
writer’s residency scholarship
educational outreach and programming
about literature in place and the
mastheads were designed to celebrate the
literary legacy of Pittsfield Herman
Melville Nathaniel Hawthorne Katharine
Maria Sedgwick w eb Du Bois Henry
Wadsworth Longfellow we’re all writing
in and around Pittsfield in the
nineteenth century and what the
mastheads do is they take that history
and re
vented extended to the present by
providing a platform for contemporary
authors to come and write about place
and at its core it is a project about
place
it’s a project about taking a narrative
of Pittsfield and making it belong to
the present this is an image of the
center of Pittsfield and I love this
image because the urban fabric tells the
history of the city you have the central
square on a north-south east-west axis
lined by robust Civic buildings but
looming in the background is the
skeleton of Industry that white building
in the background was the GE polymers
processing and development planet now GE
was the largest employer in the city
through much of the 20th century until
it all but left in the 1990s and to give
you a sense of scale in this image those
buildings in the foreground they’re
robust they’re 100 feet wide six storeys
tall but over a mile and a half away
that white building is 1,200 feet long
so you can see in this image when
industries leaves to these like Pitts
fields there’s a tangible absence of
vacancy in the landscape over 12,000
jobs were lost during Pitts fields
industrial decline 20,000 of the city
60,000 residents left and so industries
like GE and Pittsfield had a gravity not
only in the economy but in people’s
identity their sense of self in place
this is an image a photograph created by
Gregory Crutzen of North Street the Main
Street in Pittsfield and this image
captures the sense of loss that cities
like Pittsfield faced all the traffic
lights are yellow it’s a manifestation
of that limbo that sense of uncertainty
about the city’s identity and future and
so this is the context you return to
there wasn’t an economy to reinvent this
environment through building but we
wanted to find some way to make this
environment belong to the present
instead of being just a remnant of the
so we began to think of the city through
a series of different lenses we thought
of the city as a collection of memories
a series of events and happenings and as
every person understands themself
through the lens of their past
experiences we thought if there was some
narrative we could take from the city’s
history and reinvented or reimagine it
we could change our attitude about the
present so we began to look at salient
eras that shape the city’s past its
agricultural beginnings it’s industrial
rise but it’s the narrative associated
with this image that seemed most
poignant to us this is a view of Mount
Greylock and Saddleback Mountain from
the south side of Pittsfield and it’s a
view that very closely approximates the
view from Herman Melville’s study window
and the story goes when these mountains
were covered in snow they inspired the
image of the white whale that populates
Moby Dick even his neighbor Nathaniel
Hawthorne commented on this saying there
sits Melville in Pittsfield shaping his
gigantic conception of the white whale
while staring at those snow-covered
mountains in a few years earlier
Katharine Maria Sedgwick was laying some
of the foundations of our national
literature and down the road Fanny
Kemble and WBE Du Bois wrote Henry
Wadsworth Longfellow penned his most
famous poem in Pittsfield and Thoreau
passed through on the weight of his
train station so there is a whole
network of 19th century authors working
in and around Pittsfield and we saw this
narrative as poignant because the words
they used still shape our understanding
of the city we still think of Herman
Melville short story the Piazza when we
look up at the top of Mount Greylock and
see the light and wonder who is looking
back down at us and so that formed the
core idea of the mastheads we wanted to
create a small scale of architecture
that both celebrated the heritage of
writing this literary legacy and
provided a platform for new creative
output in the city and so thinking as
architects we came up with a forum a
monument a monument being a symbol that
connects the
past to the present and a user a user as
a writer someone that gives us language
to understand our contemporary
environment and what we wanted to do was
take those two and distribute them
throughout the landscape make mobile
monuments miniature writer studios by
having a mobile monument we move away
from a static conception of history and
providing a space for writer in the
landscape they can have their own point
of view from which to reflect and so
amazingly we got a grant from the
National Endowment for the Arts to
realize this project to start the
residency program and build the studios
so we began designing we started with
the writer and the goal is to give them
an intimate room a space of their own in
the landscape eight feet is an
economical construction to mention and
13-6 is the highest height you can
transport on a road and into that room
we need to create a portal a threshold a
frame of reference that was their own of
course they needed a bench in the desk
and the whole apparatus had to be on
wheels so it can move throughout the
city and for the exterior we wanted to
evoke that monumental quality so we made
them black and monolithic black to
confuse the play of light and shadow
that typically defines the form of the
building and monolithic to move away
from elements like window frames and
door handles that betray a human scale
and into these monoliths we engineered a
series of operable panels that unfolded
so they opened themselves to the
landscape when inhabited and the final
form each studio took was inspired by
where we found documentation of where
those original authors was writing
Herman Melville’s study with its pitched
roof an observation tower Thoreau stated
on the top of Mount Greylock a piece of
attic Hawthorne was obsessed with the
stairwell Longfellow wrote his famous
poem about and so these small pieces of
architecture their writer studios
they’re miniature monoliths miniature
monuments but they’re fragments of
historic domestic spaces as well here
they are again confronting that
industrial past here they are in the
landscape outside Herman Melville’s
estate
abstract forms and here when used you
see how they open themselves up here the
first season of authors working in them
and if the exteriors of the studios are
somewhat severe the interiors are warm
and wooded I think this picture gives
you a sense of how those panels allow a
tiny space to unfold to the landscape
and so it was amazing
this first last summer we had our first
group of residents and despite their
initial uncertainty about the tiny
nacinda studios some combination of the
intimacy and their privileged view on
the landscape proved to be very
effective they reported having some of
their most productive writing time in
months and because we had this new
creative energy through the writers and
a real tangible presence in the city
through these writing studios we quickly
found partners that wanted to work with
us to extend this literary legacy
through other mediums we worked with a
local poet Sarah trudging who wrote a
curriculum of poetry for third graders
and brought it to the public schools
third grades an important point in a
student’s education when they’re
shifting from learning to read to
reading to learn the program is lovingly
called mast-heads fireside after the
19th century fireside poets and we
partnered with a local artist who
painted the words of the 19th century
authors on posters and we distribute
them throughout town town to get a
walking tour of language in the city and
we partnered with a English professor
Jeffrey Lawrence who encouraged us to
think of this project in the terms of
public humanities asking how we can take
humanities scholarship and make it
useful to the present and make it useful
to our understanding of our environment
he compiled a reader that contextualized
the original work that was written in
the 19th century in the scope of the
project we are doing as well as
organized a series of lectures to keep
the conversation alive in the present
and finally we partnered with the local
newspaper to release a series of folds
so everything we are doing could become
accessible to all it documented the
lectures the writing that was being done
the designs of the studios and anything
that was happening
about the city during the program and so
it was amazing to see the support for
this program in its first year some
combination of the historical narrative
reimagined and come to life in the
present really resonated with people and
for us the mastheads were an opportunity
to respond to this narrative of loss and
breathe new life into the city through a
small scale of architecture and I think
this image is a testament to that still
looming in the background you have the
skeleton of industry but in the
foreground one of our small studios one
of these miniature monuments pushes into
the landscape to provide a new frame of
reference for the future so leave you
with one final anecdote about the
project I came and presented this
project here to a group of students
about a year ago and the project wasn’t
complete but it was well underway and at
the end of my presentation one student
raised their hand and asked what’s your
I’ve never heard the letters KPI put
together I didn’t know what it meant so
I had to ask what’s a KPI and the
student responded your key performance
indicator
what’s your key performance indicator
and of course I had no answer to that
question I never thought of a question
like that so I it and ended the
presentation but that question really
hung with me and now that as first
season has passed I do feel I have some
sort of answer to that question for me
with the mastheads the key performance
indicator is the performance itself and
I think about performance very broadly
as an act with intention through the
mastheads we had many residents of the
city acting with intention about their
urban heritage and an idea about the
future and so going back to the original
question of what you can do as an
architect in a shrinking city when we
believe you can strive to shape that
environment be it cultural historic or
material by provoking people to perform
if you can provide a platform
for people that act with intention about
their environment whether shrinking or
expanding we can make more vibrant
cities that belong to the present thank you
shrinking city in the city with a
declining population in the city with a
struggling economy we tend to think of
cities in their material sense as a
collection of buildings streets
sidewalks homes and businesses and as
architects we think it is our right to
manipulate that environment through the
act of building but building is an
incredibly capital intensive undertaking
it’s an act associated with growth and
prosperity it’s an act associated with
expansion and it’s through the
opportunities afforded to us by
expansion that we tend to shape our
cities to reflect our contemporary needs
and values but not everywhere is
expanding and not everywhere has the
opportunities associated with growth and
so as young architects my partner
Tessa Kelly and I returned to our
hometown city of Pittsfield
Massachusetts because we believed there
was work to be done there as architects
even though it didn’t have the context
associated with building it was a
post-industrial shrinking city and the
result of that belief is a project
called the mastheads the mast-heads are
five mobile writing studios that house a
writer’s residency scholarship
educational outreach and programming
about literature in place and the
mastheads were designed to celebrate the
literary legacy of Pittsfield Herman
Melville Nathaniel Hawthorne Katharine
Maria Sedgwick w eb Du Bois Henry
Wadsworth Longfellow we’re all writing
in and around Pittsfield in the
nineteenth century and what the
mastheads do is they take that history
and re
vented extended to the present by
providing a platform for contemporary
authors to come and write about place
and at its core it is a project about
place
it’s a project about taking a narrative
of Pittsfield and making it belong to
the present this is an image of the
center of Pittsfield and I love this
image because the urban fabric tells the
history of the city you have the central
square on a north-south east-west axis
lined by robust Civic buildings but
looming in the background is the
skeleton of Industry that white building
in the background was the GE polymers
processing and development planet now GE
was the largest employer in the city
through much of the 20th century until
it all but left in the 1990s and to give
you a sense of scale in this image those
buildings in the foreground they’re
robust they’re 100 feet wide six storeys
tall but over a mile and a half away
that white building is 1,200 feet long
so you can see in this image when
industries leaves to these like Pitts
fields there’s a tangible absence of
vacancy in the landscape over 12,000
jobs were lost during Pitts fields
industrial decline 20,000 of the city
60,000 residents left and so industries
like GE and Pittsfield had a gravity not
only in the economy but in people’s
identity their sense of self in place
this is an image a photograph created by
Gregory Crutzen of North Street the Main
Street in Pittsfield and this image
captures the sense of loss that cities
like Pittsfield faced all the traffic
lights are yellow it’s a manifestation
of that limbo that sense of uncertainty
about the city’s identity and future and
so this is the context you return to
there wasn’t an economy to reinvent this
environment through building but we
wanted to find some way to make this
environment belong to the present
instead of being just a remnant of the
so we began to think of the city through
a series of different lenses we thought
of the city as a collection of memories
a series of events and happenings and as
every person understands themself
through the lens of their past
experiences we thought if there was some
narrative we could take from the city’s
history and reinvented or reimagine it
we could change our attitude about the
present so we began to look at salient
eras that shape the city’s past its
agricultural beginnings it’s industrial
rise but it’s the narrative associated
with this image that seemed most
poignant to us this is a view of Mount
Greylock and Saddleback Mountain from
the south side of Pittsfield and it’s a
view that very closely approximates the
view from Herman Melville’s study window
and the story goes when these mountains
were covered in snow they inspired the
image of the white whale that populates
Moby Dick even his neighbor Nathaniel
Hawthorne commented on this saying there
sits Melville in Pittsfield shaping his
gigantic conception of the white whale
while staring at those snow-covered
mountains in a few years earlier
Katharine Maria Sedgwick was laying some
of the foundations of our national
literature and down the road Fanny
Kemble and WBE Du Bois wrote Henry
Wadsworth Longfellow penned his most
famous poem in Pittsfield and Thoreau
passed through on the weight of his
train station so there is a whole
network of 19th century authors working
in and around Pittsfield and we saw this
narrative as poignant because the words
they used still shape our understanding
of the city we still think of Herman
Melville short story the Piazza when we
look up at the top of Mount Greylock and
see the light and wonder who is looking
back down at us and so that formed the
core idea of the mastheads we wanted to
create a small scale of architecture
that both celebrated the heritage of
writing this literary legacy and
provided a platform for new creative
output in the city and so thinking as
architects we came up with a forum a
monument a monument being a symbol that
connects the
past to the present and a user a user as
a writer someone that gives us language
to understand our contemporary
environment and what we wanted to do was
take those two and distribute them
throughout the landscape make mobile
monuments miniature writer studios by
having a mobile monument we move away
from a static conception of history and
providing a space for writer in the
landscape they can have their own point
of view from which to reflect and so
amazingly we got a grant from the
National Endowment for the Arts to
realize this project to start the
residency program and build the studios
so we began designing we started with
the writer and the goal is to give them
an intimate room a space of their own in
the landscape eight feet is an
economical construction to mention and
13-6 is the highest height you can
transport on a road and into that room
we need to create a portal a threshold a
frame of reference that was their own of
course they needed a bench in the desk
and the whole apparatus had to be on
wheels so it can move throughout the
city and for the exterior we wanted to
evoke that monumental quality so we made
them black and monolithic black to
confuse the play of light and shadow
that typically defines the form of the
building and monolithic to move away
from elements like window frames and
door handles that betray a human scale
and into these monoliths we engineered a
series of operable panels that unfolded
so they opened themselves to the
landscape when inhabited and the final
form each studio took was inspired by
where we found documentation of where
those original authors was writing
Herman Melville’s study with its pitched
roof an observation tower Thoreau stated
on the top of Mount Greylock a piece of
attic Hawthorne was obsessed with the
stairwell Longfellow wrote his famous
poem about and so these small pieces of
architecture their writer studios
they’re miniature monoliths miniature
monuments but they’re fragments of
historic domestic spaces as well here
they are again confronting that
industrial past here they are in the
landscape outside Herman Melville’s
estate
abstract forms and here when used you
see how they open themselves up here the
first season of authors working in them
and if the exteriors of the studios are
somewhat severe the interiors are warm
and wooded I think this picture gives
you a sense of how those panels allow a
tiny space to unfold to the landscape
and so it was amazing
this first last summer we had our first
group of residents and despite their
initial uncertainty about the tiny
nacinda studios some combination of the
intimacy and their privileged view on
the landscape proved to be very
effective they reported having some of
their most productive writing time in
months and because we had this new
creative energy through the writers and
a real tangible presence in the city
through these writing studios we quickly
found partners that wanted to work with
us to extend this literary legacy
through other mediums we worked with a
local poet Sarah trudging who wrote a
curriculum of poetry for third graders
and brought it to the public schools
third grades an important point in a
student’s education when they’re
shifting from learning to read to
reading to learn the program is lovingly
called mast-heads fireside after the
19th century fireside poets and we
partnered with a local artist who
painted the words of the 19th century
authors on posters and we distribute
them throughout town town to get a
walking tour of language in the city and
we partnered with a English professor
Jeffrey Lawrence who encouraged us to
think of this project in the terms of
public humanities asking how we can take
humanities scholarship and make it
useful to the present and make it useful
to our understanding of our environment
he compiled a reader that contextualized
the original work that was written in
the 19th century in the scope of the
project we are doing as well as
organized a series of lectures to keep
the conversation alive in the present
and finally we partnered with the local
newspaper to release a series of folds
so everything we are doing could become
accessible to all it documented the
lectures the writing that was being done
the designs of the studios and anything
that was happening
about the city during the program and so
it was amazing to see the support for
this program in its first year some
combination of the historical narrative
reimagined and come to life in the
present really resonated with people and
for us the mastheads were an opportunity
to respond to this narrative of loss and
breathe new life into the city through a
small scale of architecture and I think
this image is a testament to that still
looming in the background you have the
skeleton of industry but in the
foreground one of our small studios one
of these miniature monuments pushes into
the landscape to provide a new frame of
reference for the future so leave you
with one final anecdote about the
project I came and presented this
project here to a group of students
about a year ago and the project wasn’t
complete but it was well underway and at
the end of my presentation one student
raised their hand and asked what’s your
I’ve never heard the letters KPI put
together I didn’t know what it meant so
I had to ask what’s a KPI and the
student responded your key performance
indicator
what’s your key performance indicator
and of course I had no answer to that
question I never thought of a question
like that so I it and ended the
presentation but that question really
hung with me and now that as first
season has passed I do feel I have some
sort of answer to that question for me
with the mastheads the key performance
indicator is the performance itself and
I think about performance very broadly
as an act with intention through the
mastheads we had many residents of the
city acting with intention about their
urban heritage and an idea about the
future and so going back to the original
question of what you can do as an
architect in a shrinking city when we
believe you can strive to shape that
environment be it cultural historic or
material by provoking people to perform
if you can provide a platform
for people that act with intention about
their environment whether shrinking or
expanding we can make more vibrant
cities that belong to the present thank you
Please follow and like us: