Press "Enter" to skip to content

The lost tribe of childless women | Jody Day | TEDxHull


what comes to mind when you see these
words spinster career woman crazy cat
lady hag which all of these are terms
used sometimes for childless women hello
my name is Jody day and I’m a childless
woman and I’d like to introduce you to
my tribe those one in five women without
children hidden in plain sight all
around you it’s probably a larger number
than you realized isn’t it you see
because misrepresented in the media in
politics in marketing in social and
healthcare policy we don’t really
register on most people’s radar
unless you’re either one of us or very
close to one of us well maybe you’re
thinking gosh with everything that’s
going on in the world today this is
pretty trivial stuff really I’d like to
show you that it matters because my
tribe has a gift that we’d like to offer
you that if you have the courage to
accept it could play a crucial role in
creating a kinder and more sustainable
world this tribe has always been amongst
us but what’s different about it now are
the numbers one in five women like me
born in the 1960s turned 45 without
having had children that’s double what
it was for our mothers generation it’s
up to one in four as what we consider
the more family oriented cultures like
Ireland and Italy and even macho
Australia up to one in three in Germany
and Japan and if my inbox is anything to
go by it’ll be up to or in the UK for
them now whilst these numbers don’t give
us any qualitative information about why
a woman might not have children a 2010
meta-analysis by Dutch academic
professor Rentschler Kaiser would
suggest that 10% of women who are
childless are child free having chosen
not to become mothers and 10% are
childless for medical reasons including
infertility
so that leads a whopping 80% of women
without children childless by
circumstance with those circumstances
varying widely but often featuring the
absence of a willing or suitable partner
during our fertile years or even an
unsuitable partner the last time that
childlessness even stood a 1/5 or 20%
was for those women born around 1900 and
who remained childless for two main
reasons firstly because so many of them
lost their current or future partners in
the trenches and secondly because many
couples could afford to marry or have
children because of the Great Depression
when you consider that it took the war
with the greatest combat losses we’ve
known and the greatest global depression
we’ve ever seen so far to create these
numbers before can you begin to sense
the magnitude of the social change that
we’re living through but let’s just take
a step back a moment to the day that I
joined this tribe was a gloomy February
afternoon in the grotty studio flat I’ve
moved into after the stormy and
distressing breakup of my last chance to
have a baby relationship I was standing
by the window watching the rain make
dusty tracks down the glass when the
traffic in the street below seemed to go
quiet almost as if I put it on mute and
then it came to me it’s over I’m never
going to have a baby I realized that my
15 year journey towards motherhood
including spending my entire 30s
stuffing 50 pound notes into the hands
of any alternative fertility guru who
said they could help me and my gang
husband can see were over I realized
that I could no longer think of myself
as someone who was one day going to
become a mother I was childless it’s one
of those childless women this moment is
forever tattooed on my heart because it
marked the beginning into a profit
found pit of grief a pit so deep I
didn’t know if I’d make it out again it
would have helped if I’d known it was
grief or if the doctors and therapists I
consulted about my life racking distress
had known that they didn’t you see my
tribe exists in a huge cultural blind
spot and many professionals miss it too
grief is a language that this lost tribe
speaks fluently but which our society is
deaf to now perhaps you’re thinking but
it can’t really be grief because you’ll
actually lose anything this is a very
common assumption and one that many of
us share too as we trudge through years
lost decades of our lives even because
you see childlessness is a form of
disenfranchised grief a grief that we’re
not allowed to experience not allowed to
talk about well maybe you’re thinking
badly this is all a bit melodramatic
Jody surely it’s not that bad let me
just share with you just a few of things
we’ve lost but not only will we never
have children but we’ll never create our
own family we’ll never be able to
correct the wrongs of our own childhood
by doing things differently with our
kids will never watch them grow up never
hold their hot little hand in ours
never throw children’s birthday parties
never take that first day at school
photo will never see them maybe grow up
graduate get married and have their own
kids will never be grandmother’s and
never give the gift of grandchildren to
our parents when they stand shoulder to
shoulder with our siblings and watch our
children play together we’ll never be
the mother of our partners children and
hold that precious place in their heart
we’ll never be part of the community of
mothers in a society and then we
consider real woman in a society that
equates hood with womanhood and as we
grow old we can’t hope that someone will
be to support us with the emotional
practical challenges of aging there
learn someone to leave our treasured
possessions to someone to take our
lifetimes someone to visit our grave my
loss may be invisible to you but I stand
here today astonished that I survived
the initiation right it took to join
this triangle and the reason I
absolutely have to seek them out was
because bingo yeah you see because when
we do try to talk to you often what we
hear back are bingos and the reason we
call them this is because on a really
bad day you can get a full house here
are just a few of them and what we’re
really thinking as you trot them out
well you can always just adopt why
didn’t I think of that actually as a
middle-aged single self-employed woman
without savings or my own home my
chances were pretty zilch actually and
even if I had been able to today’s
adopted kids arrived from their rocky
starts in life pretty traumatized at
about as far from Little Orphan Annie as
you can imagine anyway these are the
vulnerable human lives we’re talking
about not some booby prize for
childlessness and anyway there’s the
thing that becoming an adoptive parent
was never my dream I wanted to be a
biological one just like you did well I
guess if you really wanted children you
would have tried harder coming from
someone who just got knocked up on
honeymoon
this is beyond insensitive if you’d
heard the heartbreaking stories I’d
heard of multiple miscarriages multiple
failed IVF treatments costing more than
six figures of ethically refraining from
getting whoops pregnant of long term
singleness whilst waiting for a partner
grown-up enough to even consider
Parenthood with a fertility robbed by
illnesses genetic inheritance ease and
family traumas
of failed surrogacy x’ failed adoption
stillbirths and countless other losses
that could make you weep for years there
are many ways not to become a mother and
very few of them include not trying hard
enough I read this article ok whatever
miracle baby story you read in the Daily
Mail this week could I just suggest that
the reason it’s there is because it’s
news ivf had a global failure rate of 77
percent in 2012 and most women and
couples who go into fertility treats
including those in their twenties come
out without a baby
it’s frontier science and it’s still
evolving but you’re so lucky you don’t
have kids you get to sleep in and travel
so you trade your kids in for that with
you the thing is you may look at our
lives and think that they’re like your
lives but with more freedom and cleaner
furniture but what you can’t see is our
grief and an existential dark night of
the soul that would make standing
barefoot on lego quite appealing and
anyway when I do go traveling I have to
say doesn’t seem to be holding a lot of
families back Oh kids more trouble than
they’re worth have one of mine fine beer
and on Wednesday to pick up the one we
brown hair hmm can you imagine if you
were to try to talk to someone about the
depth of your parents and they said this
parents more trouble than they’re worth
you’re lucky yours are dead exactly what
all of these bingos point to is a
refusal to accept the reality of our
situation and the pain that we’re in
that the unspoken message that we hear
is will you please shut up about your
childlessness and go away and fix what
we leave are fixable and I think in our
society we’re really uncomfortable with
unfixable things we prefer to believe
that if you have enough data make smart
decisions throw enough cash and
really positive attitude at it anything
can be solved if you take a moment to
think of all that has changed for women
in my lifetime the introduction of the
pill legalized and safe abortion women’s
access to higher education
when is access to the professions and
fertility treatments all in one
generation I call us the shock-absorber
generation for the sexual revolution
this has completely changed the dating
and mating landscape yet our social
mores have not yet caught up the
pressure on modern women to get their
ducks in a row and get an education and
income a home a stable partnership and a
kid or two by the time they’re in their
late thirties is enormous yet there is
no recognition of how hard this can be
because of societal and structural
issues whilst it is now expected that
all women will work and support
themselves we have joined a professional
workplace that grew up around the male
pattern of fertility going to university
in your teens starting your career in
your mid-20s working your ass off till
your mid-thirties before settling down
and having a family but female fertility
starts declining around 28 and falls off
a cliff at 35 just at the point when men
and couples are just about stable enough
economically to consider having a family
and that’s if you have a partner to have
children with I think the perhaps there
can be parallels between mother tribes
desire to be with society and that at
the gay liberation movement of the last
50 years whilst we still have a long way
to go in terms of record wide range of
human sexuality there are laws to
protect the rights of LGBT individuals
and no self-respecting HR department
would neglect to include them in their
diversity planning yet I don’t know of a
single organization that considers the
needs
choose of women without children in the
workplace and this is about 10% of
people identify as LGBT women without
children are double that and hiding this
invisibility shows up in the way that
organizations routinely conflate female
and Lee policies with family-friendly
policies in the way that we are expected
to uncomplainingly pick up the slack for
our colleagues on maternity leave or
with childcare issues yet if we expect
reciprocity compensation or even
recognition for this or perhaps have the
temerity suggest that maybe we do
deserve to spend Christmas with our
loved ones we are seen as unsisterly and
difficult in the way that political
rhetoric rarely strays from addressing
hard-working families entirely ignoring
the many who contribute their taxes to
sustain our civil society that
everyone’s use in the way that granny is
used as a generic term for elderly women
and the way the government keeps banging
on about how families need to do more to
support our aging population entirely
ignoring that by 2030 there will be 2
million people aged over 65 in the UK
without adult children it happens behind
closed doors too
when childless daughters are ignored in
family discussions about wills and
inheritances and you’d be surprised how
often she’s given the sofa to sleep
about it whilst her sister’s kids get
her bedroom it even happens to few you
can forget and really Dessen’s gaffe
that being a mother gave her a more
tangible stake in the future than her
childless rival to resume there are 1
and a half million women like me in our
40s and 50s in the UK without children
perhaps as many as 90% of us not by
choice
the dark night of the soul that we’ve
been through and the courage that it
takes to hold our heads up high
despite the shaming other ring and
devaluing weeks
as privately and publicly on a daily
basis has given us a gift we’d like to
offer back to you the gift of grief
grief I’ll chemically transforms the
devastation of loss into an
unsentimental ability to face reality to
accept life on its terms not ours yet we
are a grief phobic society and often see
brief as something awkward and
self-indulgent to be got over as quickly
as possible but grief is the emotion
enables us to deal with devastating loss
with irrevocable change the biggest
change that we’re collectively in denial
about right now is that our planet is
dying on our watch and with it our
cherished beliefs that we can carry on
with business as usual without feeling
are very real grief for the earth and
working through the fear pain and
sadness that are a natural part of
coming to terms with loss the
consequences could be catastrophic
after all every other civilization on
this planet and because of resource
depletion my hope is that by accepting
this gift of grief you will realize that
perhaps the reason you have banished us
from your awareness is because our loss
reminds you of your own grieved losses
and the in touch with those you would
choose to be more tender with us more
tender with yourself and with everyone
who leaves and look together we can
begin to create a more emotionally
robust society one better equipped to
face the very real challenges ahead the
challenges that everyone else’s children
except ours is going to inherit
you
Please follow and like us: