
[Applause]
when I was in the eighth grade I tried
to build a maglev train as you may know
that stands for magnetic levitation and
it’s a train that runs suspended on
magnets so there’s no friction which
means it’s incredibly energy efficient
they have these in various countries in
the world and we’ve been trying to build
one in the United States since well
before the mid 80s when I tried to build
my train I would go down to the main
branch of the New York Public Library
you know the one with the Lions out
front and for me since I lived above
96th Street as it was called at the time
this was a journey into the darkest
depths of the city and then I’d go
further down into what in my
recollection is this cavernous basement
where I read heavy hardbound books with
green covers and looked at the technical
drawings of the various approaches to
magnetic levitation and armed with these
I went with my mother the hardware store
and bought some magnets and some wood
and proceeded to construct my train the
train never worked of course major
infrastructure projects even in
miniature don’t submit that easily to
the efforts of nerdy junior high school
students from the now long since
gentrified hood but I entered the train
in the science fair project that year
and the judges and my teacher kept a
straight face as I walked up to the
front of the room with my obsessions and
my ideas and my little engine that
definitely could not and they proceeded
to award me third place for my mistakes
they valued my obsession and my attempts
now I think all the time about the
distance that separates a kid and her
ideas and her obsessions from the access
she needs to gain the experience to make
those ideas real Sujata Mitra talks
about two kinds of remoteness the
remoteness of a village
rural india and the remoteness of an
urban slum well this afternoon i’d like
to focus on a third type of remoteness
and that is the distance between the
ideas that a kid has and the access she
needs to learn to make those ideas real
now in the startup world the importance
of failure is a commonplace fail-fast
is practically a mantra in Silicon
Valley and in the world of social
ventures and nonprofits the idea of
expanding access to opportunity is
talked about all the time but what we
hear much less about is the importance
of expanding access to the opportunity
to fail we hear much less about the
narrowing of opportunities to try and
fail and learn to use one’s powers
though ironically the stories that nerdy
kids love are all about this let me get
a quick show of hands who grew up on
Harry Potter world grew up on Harry
Potter all right what about Katniss
Everdeen any fans of The Hunger Games in
the house there’s like four I remember
being an early adopter this isn’t really
part of my talk of the Hunger Games and
going to a border where I asked everyone
where this book was and it just wasn’t
in fiction until finally someone who
worked there said there’s a section
called why a butt
how about disco old school for a second
how about Luke Skywalker any fans of
Luke alright alright good and who thinks
that all of these stories are pretty
lame
alright this is this is going to be good
because this is a room of nerds each of
these stories and the superhero story of
your choice is about a kid who’s stuck
in an incredibly remote place and needs
to get access to a set of experience
where she learns to use her power now
nerdy kids love these stories because
learning to use your power or magic is a
metaphor for learning to make ideas real
you heard it here harry potter is an
entrepreneur now at not the highest
point in his career not Harry Potter but
Steve Jobs had just been fired from
Apple and you can find this really low
five video online where Jobs talks about
the most important thing the most
important thing he says is the moment
when you realize that everything around
you that you call life was made up by
people no smarter than you are and you
can change it everything around you that
you call life was made up by people no
smarter than you are and you can change
it and jobs and the others who created
the basis for the digital age
really did save well if not the world
then at least the US economy Jim Clifton
in his book The Coming jobs work Jim
Clifton is the head of Gallup argues
that at a time when I was making that
little train and there was a widespread
perception of economic decline it was
those who created the digital age that
gave us decades of economic growth so
this should be good news right because
we’re in a golden age of
entrepreneurship my grandmother who’s a
hundred one talks about Shark Tank and I
can’t turn around without being pitched
by a kid on her new app
but the data tell us that this is more
like celebrating during the decline
because entrepreneurship is on the wane
in America and it’s waning particularly
amongst the young the average business
economy-wide is getting older so that as
John Legere II testified to the Senate
last year startups as a percentage of
total business have been dropping since
the 70s till it’s about half the level
that it was now if you’ve read that
Forbes article that says
entrepreneurship is on the rise it’s
important to read the fine print because
that article is based on interviews with
high net-worth and ultra high-net-worth
individuals in English the rich and the
filthy rich and this is the problem
because if entrepreneurship and the
ability to take your ideas and turn them
into life becomes a privilege just
restrict it to the usual suspect just
for those already in the club then we’re
just going to keep solving the same
kinds of problems we’ve already solved
and I really will have to keep hearing
one more slightly different social
network or sharing economy application
if entrepreneurship becomes a luxury
then the observation of James G Marsh
the organizational theorists will come
true where he says homogeneous groups
are very good at doing what they already
do well but progressively less able to
investigate alternatives and we’re
making this worse today there are people
in power today in this country and
elsewhere in the world who are
threatened by the capacity to make ideas
real these are the kinds of people that
couldn’t create a digit of the digital
age and whose idea of innovation is to
defraud students at a fake university or
shaft as many small businesspeople as
they can get away with these are people
who are threatened by making ideas real
and the kinds of policies they create
would keep today Steve Jobs his father
who was here from Syria from being in
this country so that an innovator like
that would never be born talk about the
Lord Voldemort plan but it’s not about
those in power so much is the impetus
that got them there build a wall and
every incarnation of it around the world
is the wimpiest idea there is because it
is the principle of keeping the field to
yourself because you’re threatened by
making ideas real and build a wall leads
us to a future where we’re fighting over
pieces of the world that was made
yesterday now being good science-fiction
nerds and I realize that’s a hundred
percent in this room I counted we have a
data scientists in there in the room
who’s working on that right now being
being good science-fiction nerds we are
interested in an alternative future
aren’t we so how do we switch from that
apocalyptic future and get the
alternative well I believe that the
story’s nerdy kids love provide an
answer so let’s start with Luke
Skywalker because that’s the one I grew
up on Luke is living in a place that’s
as remote as it’s gets he lives on a
desert planet in the far side of the
galaxy and Luke before he can become a
Jedi Knight needs to learn three things
all right I’m gonna asked the audience
do you know what they are think about it
for a second all right let me give you a
cheat on that and see if you agree
the first thing Luke needs to learn is
that he has a force within him because
he doesn’t know that the first thing he
needs is knowledge of his power but
that’s not good enough the next thing he
needs to do in the second movie that
comes out is he needs to go to a place
where he can try to use the force and
make all kinds of mistakes and
notwithstanding Yoda’s injunction that
there is no try
he has to try and he has to try and fail
until he learns to harness and focus his
power but that’s not enough either the
third thing that Luke needs to do is get
access to an ecosystem of people and
infrastructure that can help him bring
his power to the galaxy which is the
Rebel Alliance so Luke needs knowledge
of the force he needs a space to make
mistakes and learn to focus his power
and he needs the Rebel Alliance now the
same thing goes for Harry Harry Potter
well he needs to know about the
Wizarding World he needs to know he’s a
wizard
he needs knowledge of his power then he
needs a space he needs to go off to
Hogwarts and sneak off to the Forbidden
Forest and go through all kinds of
mishaps as he learns to master and focus
his power and thirdly Harry needs not
just Ron and Hermione but Dumbledore’s
Army Harry needs an alliance to bring
his power to the Wizarding World
knowledge of your power a space where
you can make mistakes and learn to
harness that power and an alliance
Gandhi is often quoted and I don’t think
you can actually find proof that he said
this but he’s often quoted as saying
that you know a lot about a civilization
by the way it treats its animals well I
believe that in today’s world you know a
great deal about a society by the way it
uses its Nerds and I was lucky because I
had experiences like being able to build
that train that didn’t work and being
encouraged and then later during the
Great Recession of 2008 and 9 my first
business failed and I might not have
told you this at the time but that was
the single best experience I’ve ever had
in terms of learning to harness and
focus my powers but the access to that
experience of trying and failing is
narrowing one of my own students at
Baruch where I teach a course in digital
innovation wrote a comment on an article
I had published and
said professor you forgot the most
important thing we can’t afford to fail
this kid an immigrant who had fought her
way to getting straight A’s at the best
public Business School in our area all
due respect to stern this kid felt that
she had zero access to opportunities to
try and fail we we here in this room
must prevent a lost generation of
entrepreneurs my team is doing
experiments right now with the knowledge
the space and the Alliance last year we
brought entrepreneurs into an inner-city
school on high school where they spoke
with high school students about their
ideas for how to improve the world and
what to create and I’ve since been told
by teachers in that program that those
kids found their power to do so
some of them next month we are releasing
a new framework for the global Center
for youth employment we’ve been funded
to create a framework to help kids in
the developing world have opportunities
to try to make their ideas real and a
space where they can try and fail and
then in June we’re pitching a new mobile
platform that helps give those kids
access to an ecosystem and a set of
infrastructure opportunities and that
alliance that they need and that is
aptly called rebel base but it’s not my
experiments that matter here here at NYU
where we held our venture and social
venture competitions yesterday which
I’ve judged for years and where we have
a brand new Innovation Lab what I want
to know is what are the experiments that
you can run so that is not just the most
privileged and those who share a frame
of reference who have opportunities to
make their solutions real because if we
don’t the alternative is that future
where we’re fighting and grasping for
pieces of the world
that was made yesterday to quote one
more kids nerd series indeed today the
dark is rising and it is tempting to
look to the big people to save us from
this to look to the RRS and to look to
the men of Gondor but those with
solutions but those with solutions are
stuck on privet Drive with the Dursleys
or in district 12 or on Tatooine and
they have the magic within them to
remake the world if we give them half
the chance to learn to use it what are
we going to do for them thank you
[Applause]
when I was in the eighth grade I tried
to build a maglev train as you may know
that stands for magnetic levitation and
it’s a train that runs suspended on
magnets so there’s no friction which
means it’s incredibly energy efficient
they have these in various countries in
the world and we’ve been trying to build
one in the United States since well
before the mid 80s when I tried to build
my train I would go down to the main
branch of the New York Public Library
you know the one with the Lions out
front and for me since I lived above
96th Street as it was called at the time
this was a journey into the darkest
depths of the city and then I’d go
further down into what in my
recollection is this cavernous basement
where I read heavy hardbound books with
green covers and looked at the technical
drawings of the various approaches to
magnetic levitation and armed with these
I went with my mother the hardware store
and bought some magnets and some wood
and proceeded to construct my train the
train never worked of course major
infrastructure projects even in
miniature don’t submit that easily to
the efforts of nerdy junior high school
students from the now long since
gentrified hood but I entered the train
in the science fair project that year
and the judges and my teacher kept a
straight face as I walked up to the
front of the room with my obsessions and
my ideas and my little engine that
definitely could not and they proceeded
to award me third place for my mistakes
they valued my obsession and my attempts
now I think all the time about the
distance that separates a kid and her
ideas and her obsessions from the access
she needs to gain the experience to make
those ideas real Sujata Mitra talks
about two kinds of remoteness the
remoteness of a village
rural india and the remoteness of an
urban slum well this afternoon i’d like
to focus on a third type of remoteness
and that is the distance between the
ideas that a kid has and the access she
needs to learn to make those ideas real
now in the startup world the importance
of failure is a commonplace fail-fast
is practically a mantra in Silicon
Valley and in the world of social
ventures and nonprofits the idea of
expanding access to opportunity is
talked about all the time but what we
hear much less about is the importance
of expanding access to the opportunity
to fail we hear much less about the
narrowing of opportunities to try and
fail and learn to use one’s powers
though ironically the stories that nerdy
kids love are all about this let me get
a quick show of hands who grew up on
Harry Potter world grew up on Harry
Potter all right what about Katniss
Everdeen any fans of The Hunger Games in
the house there’s like four I remember
being an early adopter this isn’t really
part of my talk of the Hunger Games and
going to a border where I asked everyone
where this book was and it just wasn’t
in fiction until finally someone who
worked there said there’s a section
called why a butt
how about disco old school for a second
how about Luke Skywalker any fans of
Luke alright alright good and who thinks
that all of these stories are pretty
lame
alright this is this is going to be good
because this is a room of nerds each of
these stories and the superhero story of
your choice is about a kid who’s stuck
in an incredibly remote place and needs
to get access to a set of experience
where she learns to use her power now
nerdy kids love these stories because
learning to use your power or magic is a
metaphor for learning to make ideas real
you heard it here harry potter is an
entrepreneur now at not the highest
point in his career not Harry Potter but
Steve Jobs had just been fired from
Apple and you can find this really low
five video online where Jobs talks about
the most important thing the most
important thing he says is the moment
when you realize that everything around
you that you call life was made up by
people no smarter than you are and you
can change it everything around you that
you call life was made up by people no
smarter than you are and you can change
it and jobs and the others who created
the basis for the digital age
really did save well if not the world
then at least the US economy Jim Clifton
in his book The Coming jobs work Jim
Clifton is the head of Gallup argues
that at a time when I was making that
little train and there was a widespread
perception of economic decline it was
those who created the digital age that
gave us decades of economic growth so
this should be good news right because
we’re in a golden age of
entrepreneurship my grandmother who’s a
hundred one talks about Shark Tank and I
can’t turn around without being pitched
by a kid on her new app
but the data tell us that this is more
like celebrating during the decline
because entrepreneurship is on the wane
in America and it’s waning particularly
amongst the young the average business
economy-wide is getting older so that as
John Legere II testified to the Senate
last year startups as a percentage of
total business have been dropping since
the 70s till it’s about half the level
that it was now if you’ve read that
Forbes article that says
entrepreneurship is on the rise it’s
important to read the fine print because
that article is based on interviews with
high net-worth and ultra high-net-worth
individuals in English the rich and the
filthy rich and this is the problem
because if entrepreneurship and the
ability to take your ideas and turn them
into life becomes a privilege just
restrict it to the usual suspect just
for those already in the club then we’re
just going to keep solving the same
kinds of problems we’ve already solved
and I really will have to keep hearing
one more slightly different social
network or sharing economy application
if entrepreneurship becomes a luxury
then the observation of James G Marsh
the organizational theorists will come
true where he says homogeneous groups
are very good at doing what they already
do well but progressively less able to
investigate alternatives and we’re
making this worse today there are people
in power today in this country and
elsewhere in the world who are
threatened by the capacity to make ideas
real these are the kinds of people that
couldn’t create a digit of the digital
age and whose idea of innovation is to
defraud students at a fake university or
shaft as many small businesspeople as
they can get away with these are people
who are threatened by making ideas real
and the kinds of policies they create
would keep today Steve Jobs his father
who was here from Syria from being in
this country so that an innovator like
that would never be born talk about the
Lord Voldemort plan but it’s not about
those in power so much is the impetus
that got them there build a wall and
every incarnation of it around the world
is the wimpiest idea there is because it
is the principle of keeping the field to
yourself because you’re threatened by
making ideas real and build a wall leads
us to a future where we’re fighting over
pieces of the world that was made
yesterday now being good science-fiction
nerds and I realize that’s a hundred
percent in this room I counted we have a
data scientists in there in the room
who’s working on that right now being
being good science-fiction nerds we are
interested in an alternative future
aren’t we so how do we switch from that
apocalyptic future and get the
alternative well I believe that the
story’s nerdy kids love provide an
answer so let’s start with Luke
Skywalker because that’s the one I grew
up on Luke is living in a place that’s
as remote as it’s gets he lives on a
desert planet in the far side of the
galaxy and Luke before he can become a
Jedi Knight needs to learn three things
all right I’m gonna asked the audience
do you know what they are think about it
for a second all right let me give you a
cheat on that and see if you agree
the first thing Luke needs to learn is
that he has a force within him because
he doesn’t know that the first thing he
needs is knowledge of his power but
that’s not good enough the next thing he
needs to do in the second movie that
comes out is he needs to go to a place
where he can try to use the force and
make all kinds of mistakes and
notwithstanding Yoda’s injunction that
there is no try
he has to try and he has to try and fail
until he learns to harness and focus his
power but that’s not enough either the
third thing that Luke needs to do is get
access to an ecosystem of people and
infrastructure that can help him bring
his power to the galaxy which is the
Rebel Alliance so Luke needs knowledge
of the force he needs a space to make
mistakes and learn to focus his power
and he needs the Rebel Alliance now the
same thing goes for Harry Harry Potter
well he needs to know about the
Wizarding World he needs to know he’s a
wizard
he needs knowledge of his power then he
needs a space he needs to go off to
Hogwarts and sneak off to the Forbidden
Forest and go through all kinds of
mishaps as he learns to master and focus
his power and thirdly Harry needs not
just Ron and Hermione but Dumbledore’s
Army Harry needs an alliance to bring
his power to the Wizarding World
knowledge of your power a space where
you can make mistakes and learn to
harness that power and an alliance
Gandhi is often quoted and I don’t think
you can actually find proof that he said
this but he’s often quoted as saying
that you know a lot about a civilization
by the way it treats its animals well I
believe that in today’s world you know a
great deal about a society by the way it
uses its Nerds and I was lucky because I
had experiences like being able to build
that train that didn’t work and being
encouraged and then later during the
Great Recession of 2008 and 9 my first
business failed and I might not have
told you this at the time but that was
the single best experience I’ve ever had
in terms of learning to harness and
focus my powers but the access to that
experience of trying and failing is
narrowing one of my own students at
Baruch where I teach a course in digital
innovation wrote a comment on an article
I had published and
said professor you forgot the most
important thing we can’t afford to fail
this kid an immigrant who had fought her
way to getting straight A’s at the best
public Business School in our area all
due respect to stern this kid felt that
she had zero access to opportunities to
try and fail we we here in this room
must prevent a lost generation of
entrepreneurs my team is doing
experiments right now with the knowledge
the space and the Alliance last year we
brought entrepreneurs into an inner-city
school on high school where they spoke
with high school students about their
ideas for how to improve the world and
what to create and I’ve since been told
by teachers in that program that those
kids found their power to do so
some of them next month we are releasing
a new framework for the global Center
for youth employment we’ve been funded
to create a framework to help kids in
the developing world have opportunities
to try to make their ideas real and a
space where they can try and fail and
then in June we’re pitching a new mobile
platform that helps give those kids
access to an ecosystem and a set of
infrastructure opportunities and that
alliance that they need and that is
aptly called rebel base but it’s not my
experiments that matter here here at NYU
where we held our venture and social
venture competitions yesterday which
I’ve judged for years and where we have
a brand new Innovation Lab what I want
to know is what are the experiments that
you can run so that is not just the most
privileged and those who share a frame
of reference who have opportunities to
make their solutions real because if we
don’t the alternative is that future
where we’re fighting and grasping for
pieces of the world
that was made yesterday to quote one
more kids nerd series indeed today the
dark is rising and it is tempting to
look to the big people to save us from
this to look to the RRS and to look to
the men of Gondor but those with
solutions but those with solutions are
stuck on privet Drive with the Dursleys
or in district 12 or on Tatooine and
they have the magic within them to
remake the world if we give them half
the chance to learn to use it what are
we going to do for them thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: