Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Importance of a Musical Conductor | Simeone Tartaglione | TEDxMontgomeryBlairHS


when I was invited to talk at Blair high

school I was thinking I was going back

to my memory when I was in high school

so I thought maybe it’s useful or

interesting at least to to some of you

to know how I became a conductor so I

was born in a in a small town agrigento

in Sicily in Italy and I was quite good

at school and I had my love for piano

when it was time to graduate you know

the dilemma was deciding who I was going

to be start to be in my head and you

know in my town in that time be a

musician was not really the first choice

for people especially if you were quite

talented in school you want to be a

lawyer or a doctor or some something

with a real job so I started to look

around and enquire and so since I was

not really revolutionary and it was not

clear to me actually really what I

wanted to be I decided to choose a

little safer pot in my in my opinion so

I decided to be to start in college as

an electronic engineer some of you who

play in some of my orchestras would be

shocked about that me too

so I started and went there and my

father even bought me a piano when I

moved to this easily capital Palermo and

I start to follow all the courses

chemistry math physics I kind of liked

it I was y’all was interested and I was

doing pretty just I felt I don’t know if

you ever felt that way I felt like a car

on a trailer on the highway you know the

car trailer with the car up up but you

are not driving you are moving but you

are not driving I remember my friends

having such a wonderful time talking

about the new discovering microchips of

super fast computers all the kind of

exciting thing for them I was yes it’s

exciting but my heart was not full I

didn’t really feel you know dreaming so

one day I remember I was demonstrating a

month

pilgrim about one is different from zero

and I know it was kind of exciting for a

lot of my friends but at the end of that

I found to the solution oh yes one is

different from zero

yes and then I look at my piano and I

look one is different frontier so at

that moment that was my tipping point I

went to the piano I sat down and I

finally you know was clear to myself who

are you kidding

you are a musician there is no way so

right there I immediately you know in

two days change my part was a little bit

of a scandal in the family but not that

much you know how it is

not that much but my parents told me you

know we hope to you will be a real you

know had a real job in life but we know

you really like music so at the end the

fact that you find yourself was a more

important than anything else why I tell

you that because I see a lot of you here

in high school I think it is okay to try

and it’s okay to change your party life

as long you find your bliss is wrong you

find what’s really make you alive and I

feel like it now that I really have my

dream job I feel like I’m driving a

Ferrari myself on a high speed race

course you know and that’s I think it’s

very important life is short and you can

be a wonderful masterpiece so contribute

to the society with who you really are

and not because it’s you know safer or

is a you know it’s a better choice for

the people who think around you so

besides that now why somebody will

choose to leave a real good career as an

engineer to be something so crazy over

harm waiver what kind of job is

conducting um conducting many of you

already know what the conductor does the

conductor keep the players together

through a magical thing telepathic and

miraculous to

stool is called the beat now I don’t

tell my players so and the ones of you

who play with me please almost don’t

think too much about it but the reality

is when we conduct there is an

incredible process in the mind of the

players especially the players they are

looking your arm and doing all sorts of

mathematical equations so they can

predict it’s like when you do the

trajectory they can predict when to

place the sound and how to place it so

in many ways a lot of mathematics I

throw I thought I was escaping my

engineering but I kind of in the middle

of a lot of equation no matter what so

how the beat works to my students at

Catholic University I say imagine you

have a table DBT is when you lift from

the table and come back to the table the

sound happens at least in America the

European conduct is a little different

but in America happens on the beat and

through that beat to that gesture we can

convey a lot of information it can be

soft loud it can be of course fast or

slow and of course with our left hand

involved with the beat we can convey the

most important aspect of music that is

the communication now why we don’t try I

kill you so I don’t see you but you see

me so i cue you something like softer or

louder can you say tah and respond

accordingly I would tell you that you

all can make this wonderful mathematical

equation they try that was a little soft

we look at my my my size can you please

do a little closer to that M that was

wonderful try this other one Wow oh yeah

yeah

so I guess somebody will say yeah no

wonder you want to be a conductor is

much easier than be an engineer in some

ways it is but another is not so let’s

go on to some more aspect of conducting

so let’s see imagine a conductor is

perfectly trained he is a craft with his

hands right and left and his beats is it

harmonic analysis Theory phrase analysis

all kinds of music history knows

everything so it gets a job the first

thing you need to do before you want to

do a concert this is choosing the

repertoire and somebody can say that’s

easy so the conductor is like the king

in the the conducting world you can

choose whatever it wants or if you

choose something the audience likes or

not maybe choo choo sound that the

orchestra likes yes all of these are

correct answers but actually they don’t

always happen to be true at the same

time the reality is and that one of the

first challenges for a conductor when

you decide what you want to play you

always need to keep in mind who is your

target if you conduct a college or a

Youth Orchestra your target is the

development of your players so you need

to choose a repertoire that inspires

them and at the same time give them the

most information when you conduct a

professional orchestra your target is

the audience the ticket sells the donors

the press so you need to choose a

repertoire that is targeting that now

you say about the conductor do you ever

choose what he likes yes we kind of

always do but the reality is hopefully

we have a long list of pieces we like so

that every time we choose a piece the

first goal will be the appropriate piece

for the appropriate Orchestra and then

of course if you like it makes a

difference I honest I never conducted a

piece I don’t like because when you

conduct a piece you are an advocate for

the piece you are really somebody who is

telling the truth you cannot lie so

conducting a piece you don’t like it can

be very very dangerous

besides being frustrating of course now

um once you choose your your music you

need of course confront some budget

issue as well you always have a a season

winner budget so the larger is the

orchestra especially with ocular of

course in a professional world the more

it cost the more your music is rental

the more this budget for that the more

you want to have yo-yo ma every year the

more you’re going to pay for that so as

a conductor when you plan your season

you need to have your budget and a

calculator and always go back-to-back so

to make sure never go over budget or if

you go over budget you beg better have a

big meal and her friend who is going to

say yes board I went over budget but

here here is the million dollar I went

over budget so I don’t know how long

you’re gonna last but at least for the

first time you do that you’re going to

be saved now once this is done the

conductor needs to do the rehearsal the

rehearsal is crucial and we used to say

that the first 15 minutes of the

rehearsal is the time where it is

decided if it’s the conductor who

conducts the orchestra or the orchestra

that conducts the conductor so it’s

essential the rehearsal is really

planned plant really minimal details

every five minutes of the usual two hour

and a half

you need to plan where you are going to

be and at the same time you want to make

sure that you engage with your players

what I tell my students often is and you

need to rehearse the rehearsal go over

the score and anticipate any problem you

can have now what we need to achieve in

our rehearsal

the basics are one of the ensemble

people need to play together that’s the

basic then we can go a little more into

some more details that is balanced with

instrument needs to carry the melody

more is anything to allow these anything

too soft so like a mixer person ena

sound the Box you need to do

live mixing of the sounds then of course

you need to make sure the internation

match so then you start to take apart

the few spots and try to make everybody

listen to each other but then the most

important thing is you need to convey

the message of the piece music exists

because it’s a communication between

people it doesn’t matter the past the

future you know we are listening to

Beethoven still today and the message

from the past arrived was like a

completely contemporary to us so the way

to achieve that is a lot of psychology a

lot of determination some of the

students who play with my orchestra they

know I never give up and I will repeat

until we make it and I’m a stronger

believer we always can do better and

everyone can improve

no matter the orchestra where it starts

at the end of the rear so we can be

higher now I have a couple of example of

a wonderful rehearsing let’s see the

somebody has to walk without it you know

the act is the year’s first that I think

of your cheating that I always say is a

leglock what year were here work a

little work but then he changed what I

okay okay now why these are good rear so

besides of course the personality and

God bless Blair a Bernstein I do the Mel

they’re wonderful human beings but they

are technical they tell exactly what

they want but also they add the message

about the history of the piece Dudamel

what Dudamel said when the orchestra was

a little too light and not enough

aggressive he went back to say look the

composer wrote that first allegra

ghwarri arrow warrior Allegro then it

changed to Luigi’s it means his first

thing was like a war and that gives up

your an idea of also a support of a

documentation is not making things up on

the other side he did some balance it

showed that this is more this is less

and it didn’t give up even the orchestra

was pretty good for the first rehearsal

but still he wanted just perfect until

he got it it didn’t stop so he repeated

the first two three notes a lot why

bearson is also wonderful this rehearsal

is giving a suggestion to do something

in a certain way but it’s giving the

reason and a human reason

so rehearsing is fantastic it really can

make the orchestra close to the

conductor in a way that it’s a miracle

and you feel like the energy is like

going from your arm to every single

players and from every single players it

comes to you like an incredible energy

field

now when the rehearsal process is

finished some people say why wouldn’t

the conductor they rehearsed there

perfect what you need for you really

need the conductor several things first

of all the conductor is the catalyst of

this a magical incredible energetic

field and everybody through the

conductor see like an amplification of

the meaning of the music at the same

time when you have a conductor the

conductor can manage to balance things

on the spot there is always adrenaline

in a live performance that is a

wonderful thing but adrenaline can make

some you know interesting you know

surprises some people may rush so the

conductor needs to pull you and make

sure everybody goes back on the right

tempo somebody can get afraid so the

conductor can be like the ones like a

celebrity coach who’s gonna say go for

it guys this is coming that spot go for

it yes now but in many ways the

conductor is like a general a general in

in an army now let’s see one performance

yes

[Music]

[Applause]

[Music]

hmm I agree what’s wonderful did you

feel the energy do you want to stand up

with them the joy of being alive and

tell everybody we love you that’s what

that’s what the North Korea should do

moving in a way that is alive

some of the people who play with me they

know when I see people playing like this

oh yeah that’s so romantic I am so

involved I want this piece is wonderful

yeah it’s about love and debt it’s hard

to convey the message to the audience so

that’s what they of course we cannot ask

every orchestra please stand and dance

and not every piece is of course

appropriate to do that but the energy

they irresistible urge to say people how

much is beautiful to be alive

that’s why music is in existence now let

me close to one word one phrase that

burst I said somebody asked Bernstein

myself what do you live with the most

alive and he said the thing I like the

most alive is people even more than

music that’s why I made music so it’s

been a pleasure to be with you tonight

and if you have any question please I’m

more than happy to respond you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: