Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Evolution of Truth | Michael Peters | TEDxRuakura


imagine that you’ve been lied to by your
partner or closest friend it’s a hurtful
lie and you feel let down and
disappointed after all lying is a
violation of trust and it destroys
humans relationships a lie has social
and political consequences a single lie
can bring down a political party or
government Hitler coined the expression
the big lie in mine Kemp a lie so
colossal everyone would believe it
because no one could believe that the
truth could be so hideously distorted
having really held a conversation with
someone who lives in a fantasy world
where you suspect everything said is
just total exaggeration you might be
dealing with a pathological liar
typically a pathological liar is
narcissistic selfish and delusional
lying becomes compulsive and habitual
pathological liars suffer false memory
syndrome many believe they’ve
accomplished superhuman feats this kind
of compulsive lying is regarded as a
psychiatric disorder we all lie on
occasions most of us might tell a white
lie to save someone’s feelings but most
of the time we tell the truth we are
brought up in a culture which has a deep
respect for telling the truth some would
argue that in our culture we are
compelled for tell the truth about
ourselves and our feelings even when the
consequences might be painful sharing
our private lives and converting and
others actually creates intimacy and
relationships in the age of social media
there’s a fashion a fascination with the
lives of ordinary people we have become
the confessional Society reality TV
rules Western society has established
the confession as one of the main
rituals that we rely on for the
production of truth not only in the
social media but also in the courtroom
in the newsroom and in the classroom
truth is central to all our institutions
and human communication is only possible
against a background of truth and truth
telling
can you imagine a society based on
systematic lying where no speech is
reliable you couldn’t believe a stranger
giving street directions or trust the
newspaper report or a friend who
confides in you truth in is a deep
cultural practice in the West yet we
take it for granted and only question it
when we were exposed to the consequences
or the effects of a lie but truth also
takes many different forms and has
changed the shape over time the ancient
Greeks had a concept Alethea meaning
unconcealed or openness truth was seen
as a form of personal disclosure in
Greek mythology ilithyia
is the daughter of Zeus she’s the
goddess of truth and she’s pitted
against the gods of deception trickery
and lies the ancient poet Homer uses the
word Allah fear in the Iliad and the
Odyssey to mean truth where truth has to
do with the reliability of what is being
said by one person to another it
opposite for hermas liable deception
then verily my child I will tell you the
truth this is the ritual sentence that
occurs five times in the Odyssey the
word often occurs in the phrase the
whole truth to tell the whole truth in
this sense is not just to utter some
sentence which is true it is to give the
whole account to tell the whole story in
the Iliad
for example Achilles asks Phoenix to act
as umpire in a chariot race and to
report back to him the truth the
traditional oath required of a witness
in court proceedings you know to tell
the truth the whole truth and nothing
but the truth
dates from this ancient source 3,000
years ago in this ancient tradition
Alethea is a matter of being truthful
and open in one’s personal dealings with
another so what can what a said can be
taken by hearers as reliable and
trustworthy it seems like all classical
cultures have a notion like truth
Chinese philosophy uses the term vowel
which means way in the sense of path but
thou also refers to a philosophical
tradition concerned with moral education
and rightful action it functions like
truth in the Western tradition thou is
the intuitive knowing of life that
cannot be grasped theoretically or as a
concept that can only be known through
the actual living experience of one’s
every day’s existence it represents the
underlying natural order of the universe
and refers to the spiritual
enlightenment that follows from living
the proper way
in Buddhism the Four Noble Truths
comprise the issuance of the Buddha’s
teachings they include the truth of
suffering and the truth of the path that
leads to the end of suffering which can
be learned as the realities of the world
by those who have reached Nirvana
I teach suffering its origin cessation
and path that’s all I teach the Buddha
the clear two and a half thousand years
ago the Persian philosopher Avicenna in
the book of healing defines truth as
that which in the mind corresponds to
what is outside it the Islamic tradition
puts a premium on truth-telling and
avoidance of lying and deception
I will not claim that truth is universal
to all cultures but it certainly seems
to underwrite the classical
civilizations Testament now here’s an
interesting word Testament means
testimony witness evidence proof all
relating to the family of truth one
source very influential in Western
culture as you know as the New Testament
in the Gospel of John Jesus says I am
the way the truth and the life he says
to his followers you know the truth and
the truth will set you free
we analyze this we see Christianity
truth this part of the Godhead and
Christianity truth is divine and as
Augustine argues much later later lying
is a sin one historical consequence of
this is that truth is associated with
spiritual freedom later political
freedom and it’s also expressible in
language it’s the basis for the
secularization of truth in science
during the 17th century when truth
becomes a property of sentences a very
brief history of the concept of truth
reveals that it changes its meaning over
time so for example in the Middle Ages
truth shifts from a subjective concept
associated with my truth meaning my word
both into a more objective one used in
the political realm to refer to legal
documents truth comes to mean being in
accord with the law in accord with the
facts and later in accord with reality
this then is the essence of empirical
science we’re true really means an
accurate representation of the world of
reality
in 1684 a German philosopher makes a
distinction between truths of reason and
truth of fact that is between necessary
and contingent truths so truths of
reason mathematical truths like two plus
two equals four which is true by virtue
of the meaning of the sign of the plus
and the equal throughs effect by
comparison a true by virtue of being an
accurate description of reality to
describe a state of affairs in the world
so science is distinguished by a success
in describing the world by its
predictive power by its problem-solving
and explanation even though its
rationality and progress might be open
to question this is the basis for
science and scientific method when
claims to knowledge don’t meet these
standards we call them pseudoscience
really the difference between astronomy
on the one hand
and astrology on the other and the West
besides scientific and mathematical
truth we also have a tradition of truth
telling it was initiated by Socrates
revolving around four questions who was
able to tell the truth about what with
what consequences and what relation to
power these practices linked
truth-telling to the law to education to
history to the media and to ourselves in
ancient Greek and Roman culture
truth-telling was a risky business
related to the duty to help others a
truth-teller sometimes risks his life
and uses his freedom to choose frankness
and see the persuasion truth instead of
falsehood or silence criticism instead
of flattery and moral duty instead of
self-interest in moral ever fear is of
death instead of life and security and
Western philosophy following Plato we
talk of knowledge as justified true
belief there is for something to be
knowledge it must have a pull a belief
condition a truth condition and a
justification condition that must
advance reasons or evidence in the shift
to information media society these
conditions no longer apply here is no
truth belief or justification condition
there is just information and it may be
misinformation or disinformation but
today we live in a post truth era as
opposed to truth really would
the oxford dictionary named it would
the year in 2016 post truth refers to a
situation where appeals to emotion and
personal belief trump objective facts
the economists ran an article both truth
politics out of the line referring
through donald trump during his campaign
when he claimed barack obama is the
founder of islamic state along with
hillary clinton imagined that obama and
clinton the founders of the worst
terrorist movement within the west even
his close supporters were perplexed
brexit and trump’s triumph in the u.s.
election indicates a dramatic turn
against the global international order
it’s fueled by a coincidence of older
conservative social values
anti-immigration sentiments climate
change denial and some worrying trends
to do with white supremacist
working-class folk from the d
industrialized areas of the u.s. got
left behind when american manufacturing
when eastern search of cheap labor trump
style and as american first policies are
delivered by twitter it’s a form of
media that lacks all reflection in
fact-checking
post truth media is linked to the
earlier concept of sound bite and photo
opportunity it completely bypasses
public discussion and the regime of the
24-hour news cycle there’s no
opportunity for discussion or argument
just a series of empty and and
verifiable statements issued in the
deafening echo chamber
to medium now fate news is full of
hoaxes misinformation distortion it’s
published with the intent of deceiving
it takes the big lie to another level as
the postmodern art of politics where
believers where supporters believe
something only if it agrees with their
own deep-seated prejudices
welcome to the Flat Earth Society that
turns its back on truth so what are we
to make of all this well that’s entirely
up to you but I leave you with this
final thought George Orville said in the
time of deceit telling the truth is a
revolutionary act
[Applause]
you
Please follow and like us: